37 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Carlisle

“We had to wait a bit, but it was manageable. The starters were fantastic! We tried the ‘chorizo, chips & chorizo’ and ‘cheese curds’, and they were both surprisingly delicious. The flavors were unexpected, and the sauces were perfectly balanced.

Now, let’s talk about the main course - the burgers! Oh my goodness, these burgers were incredible! They were incredibly generous in size, and the one I ordered, The Duke, was so big that I had to cut it into smaller portions. It was still a bit much for me!

Overall, the food was exquisite and the service was amazing. I’m definitely planning to return here with a group of friends sometime soon.
- some parts of this review have been reviewed by an AI“

“Always good pizza! The staff are always friendly also!“

“I ordered pizza for delivery tonight with the bad winds and rain from hurricane helene. My delivery was driver was so nice! If i could rate this 1,000 stars solely because of him I would. I requested the pizza to be left on the step, and he went out of his way to leave it there while making sure the box didn’t get ruined. Pizza is fresh and amazing, and bless delivery drivers! Especially the one I had tonight!“

“AWESOME pizza, subs, and atmosphere!“

“Just excellent pizza. I was so wonderfully surprised. And it was van great for lunch the next day. Great ingredients but it’s always about the sauce and thus is just off the charts. Got a medium deluxe with extra cheese but it didn’t need extra. Love itChristine Vlasic“

“Every time I come through the drive-through they get to me right away and they are really nice and always make sure I’m happy.Food is really good and when I get the food it’s hot and fresh . I really do injoy coming through the drive-through“

“Who ever made pizzas tonight, you rock! Best pizza from your store in a long time!!“

“Great calzone and lasagna. ♤“

“I love this place! I’ve only tried the chili chicken and tandoori chicken pizzas so far, but both are excellent. If you are a fan of Indian food and pizza, this is the place to go.“

“Every time I have been here (a lot), I have been impressed. The food is excellent & the service is great. I would & have recommended this place. My very favorite!!!“

“My favorite pizza in Dayton!“

“I drove out to Dayton from Columbus to have a little fun day. While looking for a good place to eat I came across Godfather’s Pizza. We were NOT disappointed! The girls at the counter were amazing, and provided the sweetest and best service! Everything was very clean! The food? INCREDIBLE! I ordered a large pep, medium Humble Pie and 2 orders of garlic bread with cheese. I’m used to garlic bread with cheese being a sliced sub bun. We were all very excited to see that it was thick cut garlic butter and cheese toast! for a group of 7, one order would have been plenty. The pizza sauce blew us all away! Shortly after our pizzas came! The cheese pull was BEAUTIFUL! 7 people and we had the large pizza box stuffed with leftovers! We are all very picky about pizza and Godfather’s did NOT disappoint! Even after the pizza had sat for a little it still had a picture worth cheese pull! Not an easy thing to find anymore! Keep doing what you’re doing!“

“We had the buffalo chicken roll, the supreme calzone w/out sausage and the fried dough with powdered sugar and cinnamon. All of it was great. Our service was great. This was our first time, we will definitely be back.“

“The pizza was superb. Every bite of our mushroom pizza melted in your mouth. It was well worth the price. We have leftovers for dinner tomorrow. I recommend Jet's Pizza to anyone who has never tried theirs'.“

“I’ve been away from my life long home of Enon for the past year and my first order of business upon returning was to order from my “go to” favorite, Pizza and Company. We’ve been back home for 5 weeks and gotten dinner from them 3 times and whether it was the pizza, sub or hoagies, the food and service has been exceptional. Edge to edge ingredients, plenty of delicious sauce and cooked to perfection every time. The service and delivery personnel are top notch, courteous and friendly. Do yourself and our town a favor by supporting this locally owned business and enjoy some great food.“

“Me and my wife ate inside. The two girls up front were both very friendly and helpful. Brought our food out to the table and brought us extra bread sticks. And even delayed bringing the cheesecake out so we could eat it cold. I wish I had a picture of the food but is was so hot and good I didn't think of it at the time. Everything was on point. Only thing I will say is the floors near the counter and in the restroom both smell like they were mopped with dirty water. There was a mild odor. But once you got to the dining room the odor didn't follow.“

“The best delivery I've had in 6 years and it came from the Huber store on Old Troy pike . On time hot and almost edge 2 edge....keep it up . 05-17-2022“

“great food and customer service. good prices +++++“

“Pizza has been very good and ready when they say it will be. The only questionable thing is that the TV-advertised “any pizza, any size for $9.99” — you have to ask for that when you call. Otherwise their recorded message gives pizza specials starting at $12.99 and up.“

“Karen has the best pizza in the land! She has a nice local business that serves fine pizza and related food. Buy local and buy from Karens Pizzaria!“

“My family loves this pizza. We did a pizza taste test with pizzas from other highly recommended pizza places in the area and my whole family agreed Slice of Heaven was hands down the best!“

“It was good. I would have probably gave 5 stars if they had more of a personal size pizza. Their small pizza is way to big for just me bug with no other options that's what i had to get if i wanted pizza (and i did) I didnt even have room to eat half of it. Wish I liked cold pizza or day old reheated pizza but it just never tastes the same. At least I got a delicious meal! Owner was friendly and super chatty. It's nice to be greeted with good conversation. If I'm in the area again I will definitely eat here again.“

“Tried Old Dayton Pizza for the first time today and it was AMAZING! You can tell the ingredients are fresh. The margarita pizza and pepperoni pizza were 10/10. Beth the bartender was extremely friendly and informative (and great drinks). We’ve been looking for a pizza to compare to Western New York and this is it. As a Dayton girl, it’s a sad day to say this beats Marion’s. But SO good.“

“I want to start off by saying my food and service have always been great! I understand every once in a while quality may be a little off. I order from this location I would like to say at least 4-5x's a month. Two weeks ago I ordered my pizza at 10 in the morning before this location was open with an 1130 delivery. When I received my food it was cold. Now I could've taking the whole order back because its normally pipping hot. Well I called and spoke with a guy told him about my order and his promise was a $10 credit. Well, I ordered again either that day or the next and I was told you can't use the credit on a delivery. I understood that I didn't feel like driving so I paid full price. Today, as usual on Friday I call to place my order and I was even going to pick it up. I talked to Brandon and he stated that I didn't have a credit. Not to mention my account is flagged for abusing credits. Now I have bank/credit card statements that I ALWAYS pay FULL PRICE for my food. At this point its not about the credit but the service. Why promise something if your not going to follow through. To say he talked to his GM about my number and he's not going to do anything is a bit much.“

“This dominos has some of the best drivers and customer service. They had a few large delivery order come in this morning right ahead of mine and they called me almost right away and explained the situation and that the delivery may take longer than expected, which was no problem but I appreciate the call. Fast forward to a little over an hour after I placed my order and the delivery driver (Ben?) called to let me know he was on his way and that they had given me a discount because of the wait I had, which again didn’t bother me at all. I really didn’t not need a discount on my bill but I greatly appreciated it and appreciated being kept in the loop about my wait time on my order. Thank you Dominos I’m Enon for your great customer service!“

“This Noble Romans is located in a Service Station. The owners are husband and wife and very nice people. This is a hidden gem as they offer a variety of foods to include their famous breadsticks with dipping sauces. I had the pleasure of trying the chicken burrito which was excellent with a fresh OJ from the store. They offer a variety of pizzas from 7", 10", and 12" all are excellent. If you are in the Dayton aera or stopping for gas this is a must stop.

Vegetarian options: Breadsticks with marinara sauce

Parking: Service Station with parking“

“The best bar and grill this side of the Mississippi. Their pizza is exceptionally delicious and very well priced. I personally recommend the hot chicken pizza. The family who owns this establishment is top-notch and goes out of their way to support the local community and other organizations! Check their website for many events, including bike night, karaoke, and other amazing get-togethers!“

“I love dominos especially the filly cheese steak it has the best flavor with the ranch to the best it’s not that expensive like $15-35$ it’s not that expensive highly recommended & no diss is not a ad! !MUST TRY NOOWW!

Parking: There is a lot of space for the parking lots nobody parks there there is plenty of parking“

“Always enjoy stopping by on Saturday afternoons! Holly is great and that guy Tim always makes me feel welcome. Cool place.“

“Nice atmosphere with great food and drinks“

“good pizza but drivers need to make change for a hundred“

“😍Always Amazing! Great food, people and service! Who could ask for more?“

“Love this place. Staff is awesome,food always good and you can tell everyone has a good time there“

“I probably consider myself an occasional regular, because I try to meet a couple friends for a cold beer on Wednesdays. Ray is the stable force currently, and I’m very concerned if he ever leaves our nice little sports bar may not make it. We have a hidden gem (potentially), but things seem to be trending in the wrong direction. Not quite ready for Bar Rescue to come in yet ?, but definitely has too much upside to not make a better effort to do what is needed to be run more efficiently.“

“So I just ordered the Detroit style pizza, not wild about it. I think at then end of the day I just prefer stuffed crust. The real reason I am giving this review is because of my delivery driver! 5 stars, followed my directions to a T! Very impressed. Pizza Hut give that guy a raise! Delivery was 9/23 at 9pm!“

“House Pizza is good. No complaints. I ordered online and went to pickup. I was told it would be 5- 10 minutes. Okay. 10 minutes later, someone comes out and asks what I ordered. I tell them. They apologize and now need to make a new pizza for me.....I know stuff happens. Seems like the ball got dropped a few times. I'll be back!“

“So I ordered an Italian papadia and they had made it wrong so when I called to let them know…. they were so kind to me and said they would replace that. So I went in the next day to pick it up and it was the best Papadia I’ve ever got from them. They went above and beyond to fix it for me. Awesome staff. The one delivery guy recognized me and told me that he put the stickers my daughter gave him last time he delivered our pizza to our house in his truck, which made my six-year-olds day when I told her that he kept the stickers she gave him“