50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Yellow Springs

“Great calzone and lasagna. ♤“

“great food and customer service. good prices +++++“

“Ok so we’ve dined at Old Scratch Troy location about 6 times since it’s opened. Waited a bit to give them time to really get in their groove. While I do recommend the place. Pizza is good, staff is nice (especially Amanda at the bar) and shareables are tasty. That said I would like to see the food’s taste be a little more consistent. My favorite dish is the fire roasted cauliflower but sadly it hasn’t been prepared the same way twice with the last two times it was barely seasoned at all once it was almost raw. Hopefully as training continues they will fix that issue.“

“Great Pizza!! We will travel from Grove City to eat at Colonial Pizza.“

“The new owners and customer service is great. They are not cheap when they put topping or cheese or anything on your pizza. Love the new changes in there.“

“had the Sunday buffet today, first time. everything was great! excellent food, especially the pizza. service by Chrissy was awesome. we will definitely be back!“

“Haven’t ate at Fazolli’s in years! Miss the one in Altoona, Pennsylvania“

“Pizza n Wings are a must We get light sauce on pizza, Good eats!!“

“Nothing but good things to say!!! Food is amazing and staff feels like family. Enjoying the Ohio State Michigan Game today and won a jersey for my son in a raffle! Support this small Business!!!“

“Our server was very polite and the food was delicious! I would recommend the fettuccine Alfredo or the lasagne.“

“Always good pizza! The staff are always friendly also!“

“BEST PIZZA IN TOWN. Customer service is great.. friendly, courteous and welcoming. Downside is they are not always open which is frustrating when you want one of their awesome pizza. Establishment has a lot to be desired but the customer and staff make up for that.“

“Food has been amazing and the delivery time has been outstanding the last couple times we have ordered from dominos. Best delivery time I’ve seen from other places 🍕“

“This place defines community! What beautiful energy! And the food NEVER disappoint!“

“Hickory Inn knocked it out of the park! Au ju roast beef sub, mushroom and Swiss burger with real mayo was literally top 3 in my life. We had a slice or two of a double pepperoni and extra cheese pizza as an appetizer and I wanted to eat the whole thing 😋. I resisted so I can enjoy it for lunch tomorrow, in the airfryer.“

“Food is always great. Just not sure what to think of online ordering. 3rd time in a row I ordered online and was given 30 mins, got there in 20, paid & still waited another 30 mins.Watched people place pizza orders, get it and leave while I was still waiting. 2 times.“

“very unprofessional! no care for disabled children or special needs children very poor service! very rude employees!“

“My family loves this pizza. We did a pizza taste test with pizzas from other highly recommended pizza places in the area and my whole family agreed Slice of Heaven was hands down the best!“

“The Cassano’s pizza on south limestone in Springfield is the best! We have never been disappointed with a pizza we got from there! We switched to that store after several disappointing pizzas from other Springfield locations! Good job guys keep it up!“

“While on work travel, me and my friend stumbled onto Station 1. What a cool spot...the area is nice, food is excellent, and the people are great!! If you listen to any review, listen to mine. Stop in, and really experience how cool this place is...especially in the summer.✌🏽“

“Let’s start this 5 star review by stating: they gave half of my order to the wrong person!!!

So why 5 stars?!

Because mistakes happen, and it’s what businesses do after a mistake that matters. This establishment apologized, had already started remaking the order before they finished figuring out what happened (to reduce the time to replace my order), then gave me an extra pizza and breadsticks as an apology.

Best we pieced together is someone accidentally loaded half of our order in the wrong pizza portal and someone else got it (that person gets 1 star for lack of honesty). This place took care of business getting me the corrected order, plus a little for the 10 minute wait. Awesome Customer service.“

“Pizza has been very good and ready when they say it will be. The only questionable thing is that the TV-advertised “any pizza, any size for $9.99” — you have to ask for that when you call. Otherwise their recorded message gives pizza specials starting at $12.99 and up.“

“I ordered pizza for delivery tonight with the bad winds and rain from hurricane helene. My delivery was driver was so nice! If i could rate this 1,000 stars solely because of him I would. I requested the pizza to be left on the step, and he went out of his way to leave it there while making sure the box didn’t get ruined. Pizza is fresh and amazing, and bless delivery drivers! Especially the one I had tonight!“

“This dominos has some of the best drivers and customer service. They had a few large delivery order come in this morning right ahead of mine and they called me almost right away and explained the situation and that the delivery may take longer than expected, which was no problem but I appreciate the call. Fast forward to a little over an hour after I placed my order and the delivery driver (Ben?) called to let me know he was on his way and that they had given me a discount because of the wait I had, which again didn’t bother me at all. I really didn’t not need a discount on my bill but I greatly appreciated it and appreciated being kept in the loop about my wait time on my order. Thank you Dominos I’m Enon for your great customer service!“

“I absolutely recommend this place! Local very friendly staff! Treat you like Family. I love to get their bucket 🪣 ☕️ coffee! The food is all made in house! Delicious! Better crazy bread than Lil C…. 😉 Thank you!“

“One of the best tavern pizzas you can find in the Dayton area, for real. Perfect crust, plenty of toppings, taste was on point! Joes Pizzeria in Riverside gets all the pizza fame in the area but to me this tastes better and I never thought I'd say that because Joe's is really good. Jen was our bartender and did a phenomenal job. We'll definitely be back for more. 🍕“

“I just wanted to give a huge shout out to Fairborn, OH tj chumps. We had my sons birthday there in their private room and everyone was so friendly and welcoming and the service was amazing and they were so friendly with the kids and loved including my daughter to be as if she was working. We are so thankful!!“

“Excellent food! Affordable prices :)“

“The food was very good, as was the customer service. The only issue I have is with the drinks. Apparently, they discontinued their fountain drinks. As a result, if you are dining in and order a Coke/Pepsi, you get a bottled drink. What this really means is that there are no refills on drinks because they don't have the fountain for that anymore.“

“We tried it for the first time tonight and it did not disappoint! SO good!“

“The meat lovers pizza was delicious and full of toppings (not skimpy at all) my steak hoagie was good except the bread was not done enough for me... I like it alittle more toasted... the service was fast and the price was not bad at all... Will eat here again“

“Just excellent pizza. I was so wonderfully surprised. And it was van great for lunch the next day. Great ingredients but it’s always about the sauce and thus is just off the charts. Got a medium deluxe with extra cheese but it didn’t need extra. Love itChristine Vlasic“

“Who ever made pizzas tonight, you rock! Best pizza from your store in a long time!!“

“Everytime I eat there they never fail me it’s absolutely delicious 😋“

“The Cassano’s pizza on south limestone in Springfield is the best! We have never been disappointed with a pizza we got from there! We switched to that store after several disappointing pizzas from other Springfield locations! Good job guys keep it up!“

“The food was great and it was served very quickly and efficiently! We’ve wanted to stop for a long time since it’s on our route between home and Cincinnati. Always wondered how it could possibly have that many cars in the parking lot! Despite lots of cars in the parking lot, we were seated quickly, served quickly, and our food was excellent! Highly recommend the shrimp cocktail, the fried veggies, and the fish and chips.“

“Open up your dining room, please! When asked if the dining room was closed, your employee here told us to ask the lady behind the counter, then he sat in the closed dining room the entire time we waited for our carryout order“

“Best bar in xenia hands down.“

“amazing people and food! give it a try!“

“THANK YOU SHIRLEY! YOURE THE REAL MVP <3“

“We have discovered the Italian subs at Domino's. We have ordered them several times recently. We ordered online and it is the best way to get an order ready fast. We love these subs and the Domino's on E Main St, in Springfield, Ohio is great.“

“Food was delicious but occasionally mistakes happen. Pizza and bread were under cooked and slightly doughy. Ate a couple pieces and put the rest out for the racoons in the back yard
Won't stop me from ordering again but hopefully this will be constructive criticism.“

“amazing food great service“

“When they built the new restaurant we went there couple times in a row and felt a pizza was burnt. We was really craving Cassano's this last couple weeks and we return to order it from the restaurant hoping maybe there was some improvement.... There is a young manager working there and if she makes your pizza it is great I wish I knew her name cuz I would sure give her a shout out. We We now feel confident that if we want Cassano's East main's a place we're going to go!“

“Awesome service and tasty food! I ordered a large pepperoni, sausage, banana pepper pizza and it was cooked to perfection. Highly recommend!“

“love this pizza since 1980“

“I’ve been purchasing from Cheetos for about a year now my wife was getting surgery at Ohio Valley. I came to chido’s and as I go to pay for my order, he says it’s on him. It wasn’t a regular order. It was a very large order and I just wanna show my appreciation. Thank you very much from the hole family we love the food 😮‍💨🔥 Thank you again brother god bless 🙏😏“

“I loved it!! But your survey kept freezing. I tried to do survey and it kept freezing. Tried to start over a few times now I can't do it for a week. My receipt is from 5/14/2016, 317236. Phone 937 450 1111“

“If you're searching for the perfect spot to enjoy some thrilling Ohio sports action, look no further than Legends Pub and Grille! This place is an absolute gem for fans of all our beloved local teams. Whether it's the Buckeyes, the Browns, or the Cavaliers, you can always count on catching all the games here. The atmosphere is electric, creating an exciting vibe that makes every game feel even more exhilarating.

But it's not just about the sports! The food at Legends is truly impressive. From mouthwatering wings to hearty burgers and delicious appetizers, every bite is a delight. Each dish is crafted with care, and you can really taste the quality and passion that goes into the cooking. Don’t forget to check out their daily specials!

Now, let’s talk about the bartenders! They are phenomenal—supportive, friendly, and knowledgeable about their craft. They mix up some fantastic drinks, keep the atmosphere lively, and always make sure you're taken care of. Their service is fast and with a smile, making you feel right at home.

And last but definitely not least, the owners Maryann and Jerry are two of the kindest people you’ll ever meet. They truly care about their customers and create a welcoming environment that feels like family. Their passion for the pub shines through, and it shows in the attention to detail throughout the place.

Overall, Legends Pub and Grille is the perfect combination of great food, top-notch service, and a fantastic place to cheer on your favorite Ohio teams. I can’t recommend it enough! Whether you’re a die-hard fan or just looking for a fun night out, you won’t be disappointed. Cheers to a legendary experience! 🍻🏈🏀“