18 Best Bakeries in Newmarket

Baker's Crush Bakery • $
1100 Davis Drive Suite 24, Newmarket

“We can't recommend Baker's Crush enough! She made two custom cakes for our daughter's birthday celebrations—a beautiful unicorn cake for her actual birthday and an adorable Winnie the Pooh cake for her birthday party—and they were absolutely phenomenal.

The unicorn cake made our daughter's birthday so special for our little family celebration. Even our fur baby (dog) got to enjoy a tiny taste and loved it too! The Winnie the Pooh cake was the star of her birthday party. It was not only absolutely stunning, but also incredibly delicious. Our guests couldn't stop talking about how amazing it looked and tasted too.

Her attention to detail, creativity, and talent are truly exceptional. She brought our vision to life perfectly, was so kind and easy to work with, and helped make our daughter's birthday unforgettable. It's rare to find someone who creates cakes that are just as delicious as they are beautiful, and Baker's Crush absolutely does both. We’ll definitely be ordering from her again and highly recommend her to anyone looking for gorgeous, delicious custom cakes!“

4.9 Superb188 Reviews
Nutmeg Bakeshop Bakery • $
256 Main Street South, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Croissant Cronut Cheese Biscuit Almond Pastry Pain Au Chocolat
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
Stuffed Cheddar Cheese Bread
Cronut and Cheese Biscuits
Pain Au Chocolat and More
Runny Butter Tarts
Assorted Cruffins
Assorted Pastries
Nutella Cruffin
Cinnamon Cruffin

“Great sour dough bread and croissants 😋“

4.9 Superb166 Reviews
Goodman's Fine Foods Bakery • $
Located in the Event Space within Vince’s Market, 19103 Leslie Street, Sharon

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Buns by 1 2 Dozen

“Just enjoyed a wonderful roast beef dinner! The beef was cooked perfectly—tender, juicy, and full of flavor. The creamy mashed potatoes with rich gravy were delicious, and the fresh green beans and pickled onions added a great balance to the meal. The Yorkshire puddings were light, golden, and absolutely outstanding. Everything on the plate was prepared with care and tasted fantastic. A comforting, satisfying meal that I would gladly have again. Highly recommended. @heatherstable.ca
Located in the event space at Vince’s in Sharon. Worth the price. Great for a date as the Chef cooks the meal in front of you and explains every step.“

4.9 Superb67 Reviews
Molisana Bakery Bakery • $
16635 Yonge Street Suite 5, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

Bruschetta Pizza Slice
Prosciutto Sandwich
Roasted Red Peppers
Chicken on a Bun
Sausage on a Bun
Chicken Dinner
Sausage Dinner
Veal Sandwich
Cheese Pizza
Veal Dinner

“i’ve been going here since they first opened! I don’t have a negative thing to say - i do however wish they had delivery service so i could order their pizzas for delivery 😀 as they are in the other end of town for us.

We really enjoy their pizzas but our all time favourite is their veal sandwich’s and the chicken greek salad. Soooooo good! I sometimes order a side of their hot peppers to throw on my salad.

The veal is tender and it’s very filling, the bun is fresh and soft and it pairs so well with their tomato sauce.
i do wish though that they would also do eggplant as an add on but they’re a successful business so i’m sure they have there reasons not too.

My son absolutely loves their rose sauce so we do often buy their jarred sauce to go. It’s one of our favourite italian bakery’s. The staff are so kind and it’s always a busy place to go so you know it’s great food when you see tons of people there at lunchtime!!!“

4.5 Superb242 Reviews
COBS Bread Bakery Bakery • $
18289 Yonge Street, East Gwillimbury

Customers` Favorites

Raspberry \u0026 Custard Danish
Spinach \u0026 Feta Croissant
Sourdough Vienna
Sourdough Bun
Pastries

“Cobs Bread is my absolute go-to for fresh bread. Their traditional sourdough loaf is incredible—it has the perfect crusty exterior with a soft, airy, and beautifully tangy center. It toasts up amazingly well and is perfect for sandwiches. Everything they bake is top-tier, but that sourdough is a must-buy!“

4.5 Superb106 Reviews
Pablo Cheese Tart Newmarket Bakery • $
57 Harry Walker Parkway South Unit 4-6, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

White Chocolate Raspberry Mini
Earl Grey Cheese Cake
Mini Cheesecake Tart
Creme Brulee
Cheese Tart
Strawberry
Mochi
Mango

“I've been here so many times and only now do I think to write a review :) For hot drinks, the matcha latte is terrific, and for cold, the mango slushy and melon matcha tea are repeat favourites. The little tarts are of course the star of the show, so delicious. I find myself ordering the strawberry daifuku, mango and peach tarts; my SO really misses the chestnut tart now that it's gone. And, those really big cheese tarts have been great when we are having company over.
Just a few tables and chairs, a quiet spot for a chat and very friendly owners.“

4.4 Superb115 Reviews
Paris Baguette Bakery • $
47 Harry Walker Parkway South Suite 12, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Cream Cheese Pastry
Premium Individual Lunch Box
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad
Strawberry Croissant
Sugar Mochi Donut
Almond Croissant
Soft Cream Bread
Caprese Baguette
King Cream Donut
Twisted Donut

“Thank you for your kindness in helping the local community. we appreciate your support.“

4.2 Good264 Reviews
The Dapper Doughnut Bakery • $
17600 Yonge Street, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

Old Fashioned Donuts
Strawberry Donuts
Fruity Pebbles
Ice Cream Cone
Smores Cookie
Mini Donuts

“This is the best place I've ever been to (food wise of course). The donuts are the best donuts I have ever had and the woman working was incredible. I really wish I knew her name so I could put it here but I ordered 6 donuts and she gave us a seventh free of charge, it was amazing. I also got a milkshake (which also comes with a donut mind you) and it was the best milkshake I've had in my life and my sister works at Kawartha dairy so I have milkshakes pretty often. Absolute 10/10 in everything I will be coming back here next time I come to Newmarket.“

4.4 Superb71 Reviews
Bagel World Newmarket Bakery • $
16995 Yonge Street, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

Egg Benedict with Smoked Salmon
Eggs Benedict Smoked Salmon
Bagels \u0026 Cream Cheese
Bagels & Cream Cheese
Cream Cheese and Lox
Toasted Western San
Sweet Cheese Crepes
Eggs and Sausage
Assorted Bagels
Bagel World

“Excellent service, excellent food!!“

4.2 Good251 Reviews
Mercato on Main Bakery • $
47 Main St S Units 3 & 4, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

Penned Rośe Pasta Carbonara
Penne with Tomato Sauce
Chocolate Croissant
Italian Pastries
Tiramisu Cake
Cheesecake
Lemon Cake
Meatballs
Arancini
Cannoli

“Authentic Italian perfection. From the porchetta with all the fixings to the rapini rotolo, eggplant parmigiana, arancini, and pistachio ricotta cannoli—every bite tasted like home. My 15 guests couldn’t stop raving. Delivered hot, on time, and full of heart. Truly outstanding. 🇮🇹🍷Thank you Mercato 🙏“

4.2 Good245 Reviews
The Maids Cottage Gluten-Free • $
223 Main Street South, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

Old Fashion Plain Butter Tarts
Pecan and Raisin Butter Tart
Raspberry Coconut Butter Tart
Home Fries Toast & 2 Eggs
Old Fashioned Butter Tart
Mixed Butter Tarts
mmmm Buttertarts
Quiche & Salad
Breakfast Wrap

“No photos to share, I ate all the evidence 😅 Just amazing! These butter tarts are TO-DIE-FOR and I will 10000% be back very soon!! • Homestyle Plain - Was still warm! pastry was perfect and the filling was the right amount of sweetness • Raspberry Coconut butter tart - My favorite tart!! (so far) Again, pastry was perfect, and the filling was exactly what you would expect and just the right amount of each flavor. • Don't even get me started on the Caramel Apple Cookies!✋️ (Okay you talked me into it) SO SOFT and just the right amount of chewy, Caramel isn't over powering and you get a nice amount of apple flavor. As for the service, Such a pleasant experience from the moment I walked in, to the moment I left. Very welcoming staff who are happy to answer any questions you have, a few jokes passed around, and didn't hurt the wallet. 10/10 highly recommended!“

4.6 Superb205 Reviews
Simply Sweet Bakery • $$$
17817 Leslie Street Suite 34, Newmarket

“Picked up a Date Square today and they are just as delicious as ever. Would highly recommend.“

5 Superb44 Reviews
The Little Red Bake Shop Bakery • $$
200 Mulock Dr Unit 4, Newmarket

“Absolutely delicious cookies!!! My mother-in-law surprised us with treats for Valentine's Day - so good! Thank you!!“

5 Superb22 Reviews
Mr Pretzels Upper Canada Mall Bakery • $
17600 Yonge St, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

Salted Pretzels Catering Order
Pretzel Cheesestick Combo
Freshly Baked Pretzels
Sugar Cinnamon Combo
Pretzel Dog Combo
Napolitano Combo
Parmesan Combo
Nutella Combo
Vanilla Combo
Toscana Combo

“I tried all pretzels ‘ flavors, there were really great, fresh and delicious, the staff was very friendly and respectful, and I really like 🥨 or pretzel bites especially sugar & cinnamon and toscana , hot dog bites and everything 🤤🤤🤤 🤤“

4.1 Good81 Reviews
Pascals' Tarts Bakery • $
160 Pony Drive Unit 1B, Newmarket

“The most amazing butter tarts for such a great price too.

The tarts are $6 per pack of 6 regular sized ones or $6 for 12 mini butter tarts. Have not seen prices like this in a long time.

The butter tarts are also my kinda style. Not into the runny filling. This was bit thicker and creamier which is how I like them.

The tart itself was nice and buttery enhancing the whole buttery taste.

Person helping me out was very nice and friendly. She was on break and as she saw me entering, without hesitation, she came right back in to help me out. It operates almost like a takeout counter. You order fro
Them through a window and they give it to you after you put payment through in the same window.

Parking is extremely easy. This place is in an industrial area and had my choice of parking spots coming here.

They are also on roof good to go so if you get a chance to do that, the price is gonna be crazy good for the amount of food you’d get.

Definitely one of my top recos for butter tarts.

Great job overall“

4.5 Superb17 Reviews
Home Slice Bakery Bakery • $$
269 Rogers Road, Newmarket

“We ordered a chocolate butter cream cake with sunflower decorations for our daughter's wedding. It exceeded our expectations. It looked great and the flavor was wonderful.“

3 Average5 Reviews
AVA Super Bakery & Pastry Bakery • $
16925 Yonge Street Suite 9, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

نان تافتون

“The bread called Barbari mashhadi was AWESOME!!!!! The best bread we’ve ever eaten in canada! There are some herbs on the bread that smells soooo good. I highly recommend their sangak and barbari . You’ll love it. 😍“

3.8 Good86 Reviews
Saint Germain Bakery Bakery • $
17600 Yonge St, Newmarket

Customers` Favorites

6 Portuguese Style Egg Tarts 葡撻半打 6s

“Honestly, my favourite bakery! We live out of town and no stop to Newmarket is complete without a trip to Saint Germain’s. Same for my parents who also always stop here when in Newmarket. The service/staff are fantastic and the food is phenomenal. Prices are very reasonable and it’s extremely clean. I would give more than 5 stars if I could!“

3.8 Good129 Reviews