42 Best Italian Restaurants in North York

“I ordered the wedding soup take out. $7.99 but the paper cup they give you is minuscule. Should be at least double the size for the price they charge. What a rip off. Too bad because I like there food overall“

“We had a family event last night at their restaurant. I can't stress how great the value is here, and the food quality was top shelf. I have eaten food cooked by some of the best chefs in the world and this was every bit as good. the staff were attentive but not at all intrusive. very accommodating for our large group of 15 people. Their shrimp and calamari platter was cooked perfectly, not at all rubbery, with a divine sauce to dip. Pasta nicely al denté. Calabrese antipasto, nice bread spread. Perfect, and I do mean PERFECTLY, cooked steak, chicken, and sausages. Their pizza is simple but lovely balanced between crisp and chewy. Not too thick, not too thin. Arancini were great. I highly recommend them for your next family event, or just a quiet night out for the family! Thank you to all the staff and the chef for making our family event a success, and we look forward to seeing you again soon!“

“Great food great atmosphere 👏🍷“

“Food is always amazing!! The service is great, friendly it is like you are a part of the family with every visit! A MUST EXPERIENCE!!“

“Thank you, Chef Piotr Przykaza and your wife for phenomenal dinner and Tristian for an amazing service 😊🍷 Very highly recommend it 👍“

“Great little mum and pops restaurant that opens early and serves a great breakfast. Happened to be getting my vehicle repaired and stumbled upon this place by accident. I'm happy I stopped by. Menu is simple, coffee is good and the service is fantastic. Definitely recommend y'all to swing by if you're in the area. They also serve lunch!“

“The food is terrific - unpretentious classics, obviously passed down through generations. Ask if Albert will be there when you make reservations; trust me, he makes the entire evening just that much better.“

“Here’s a review you could consider:

"Gina at Capri Bakery is absolutely amazing! She’s friendly, attentive, and really goes above and beyond to make sure every customer has a great experience. She knows the menu inside and out and always has the best recommendations, whether you’re craving something sweet or savory. Gina’s warmth and enthusiasm bring such a positive vibe to the bakery – it’s clear she cares deeply about her customers and loves what she does. The bakery wouldn’t be the same without her!"“

“Excellent food, great atmosphere and service!“

“Enjoyed an amazing dinner on the patio Will definitely be back“

“My fiancé and I went here for our anniversary and had a fantastic time. The atmosphere was amazing and the decorations make you feel like you're transported into Italy! Real family-run feel; the gentleman that served us was kind and very friendly. The food was amazing. I would highly recommend to anyone looking for a good night out!“

“Amazing fresh pasta, staff are wonderful and helpful. so glad i found them“

“The food was absolutely amazing. My 3 daughters and I went there for dinner during Summerlicious 2022. We didn't have reaervations and the options were a 1 hour wait to sit inside or be seated right away on the patio. We chose the patio. We were served our drinks and appetizers within 1/2 hour but our main course came about an hour after but it was worth the wait. We will definitely return🍾🎉“

“I recently started going to York Mills location since it's on my way to work , I love the food here , my favorite pasta is this simple delicious pasta from York Mills location, the place is so nice and clean and the staff are so amazing!“

“I entered the restaurant and was greeted warmly by the staff. The ambiance was cozy and inviting. I ordered a classic pepperoni pizza and a side of garlic bread. The service was efficient, and my order arrived promptly. The pizza was delicious, with the perfect balance of cheese, sauce, and toppings. The garlic bread was also flavorful and satisfying. Overall, it was a great dining experience at Pizza Pizza, and I would definitely return for more tasty pizza!“

“I wouldn't look any further for great food, service and lively atmosphere! .. The best hot table spot in all of York region, lots of variety daily.. from pizza to pasta to amazing salads, somewhere to go alone or with colleagues! .. I have been a customers for years now and also use Piazza Manna for large corporate caterings which is a bonus and convenient. The owner is super friendly and so easy to work with! They are totally worth it !“

“I went with a few friends to this old-fashioned sandwich shop. It is on the corner of the plaza it’s in. You walk in and it’s themed very well with my references to Italian cinema. The menu has a decent amount of options, and specials for every weekday. I ended up getting the Philly steak sandwich with pasta, as well as the sausage on a bun. It ended up totalling $35 for all of it which is not bad for two meals worth of food. The sausage on a bun was really good, as well as the Philly steak sandwich. As an Italian with Nonnas who know how to make good pasta, the pasta was really good. The food took a while to be served but the lady was really friendly, and made us feel at home. Overall, this is a cute local spot. Good job!“

“I can't say enough good things about the management and servers at Tutto Pronto. We hosted a birthday party last weekend for 51 people. Natasha (the co-owner) was just lovely to deal with. She made everything so easy - let me bring in my own birthday cake, served it to all of our guests without a plating fee, handed out a customized menu, printed and framed our seating plan, accommodated our musicians, threw in some perks like complimentary tea and coffee for our guests. Everybody has told me that the food was outstanding, and the service on point. Everybody's meals came out at the right time, and the main courses were prepared exactly to order. The staff helped with the timing of our event. I have nothing but good things to say, and would host an event again there in a heart-beat.

Thanks Natasha for helping to make my birthday party a spectacular event.“

“Generous portions. Got pizza this time, which was good and filling (took half of it home). Last time, I had their pan-seared salmon fillet topped with a honey garlic sauce and served with roasted potatoes & vegetables, which I highly recommend. Great outdoor patio spaces too. Quiet. Parking fills up fast in their small lot but you can park on the side streets for free. Service was friendly & attentive. Ask for Mike, he's great!“

“Delicious food. Good friendly service“

“A good Pizza Pizza location. The staff is attentive and prompt in service. They follow standard preparation guidelines. I only needed a slice, which they had on the counter but the staff recommended waiting for a few minutes as they were making a new batch of pizza. That's thoughtful!

Recommended!“

“I have been here several times. One of the advantages is that you can easily find parking. They have a good selection of Italian dishes. Pizzas are great. And I like the service as well, helpful and caring staff.

Dietary restrictions: They have options for vegans or people with restricted diets.“

“"Amazing dining experience! The food was absolutely delicious, and the atmosphere was perfect for a relaxing meal. A big shoutout to David for his excellent and courteous service. He really made the experience memorable. I'll definitely be returning soon!"“

“Portions generous. Price reasonable and food tasty“

“The best Pizza Pizza location! I had an issue with a few missing pieces in my order, but not only were they super prompt and responsive, they were more than generous by giving us more replacement food. Very very friendly. Thank you always!“

“Can't beat the lunch special here! Absurdly good food for the price you pay! Not to mention the staff here are amazing. Elia is a fantastic server and the work those folks do in the kitchen is miraculous. They really go out of the way to make you feel like family here without ever sacrificing the fine dining experience. Highly, highly recommend!“

“Was there for a Sunday brunch with friends. Food is awesome and coffee is good. The workers were very nice but I felt that they were short staffed because it took very long for them to greet us and bring us water. It was over 10min before a waitress was able to take our order. The food was also slow to show up and they may have missed a couple things from the order as it didnt come out until we asked for it after waiting a while. Everybody seemed swamped and perhaps there needs to be a designated server among them.

Overall, convenient location, great food and good vibes though“

“I recently ordered the classic cheese pizza, and it was absolutely delicious! The crust was perfectly cooked, with a nice balance of crispiness and chewiness. The cheese was generous and melted to perfection, creating a gooey and satisfying experience. The flavor was spot on, with a tangy tomato sauce that complemented the cheese beautifully. If you're craving a simple yet satisfying pizza, I highly recommend giving Pizza Pizza a try!“

“Excellent customer service

Vegetarian options: A lot of options

Dietary restrictions: You get what u need

Parking: Free parking

Kid-friendliness: Always smiling

Wheelchair accessibility: Available“

“Went with my dad for a classic order a ton of things and share them type of feast. Garlic knots were amazing, so were the meatballs. Also had the shrimp and bruschetta. FYI no bad food reviews here. For mains we had the lamb ribs which were delicious in flavour and the flat iron steak with fries which was also delicious. Dessert was cannoli’s, gelato and tiramisu. I would order everything again hands down. It was kind of the manager to deliver our food, her name was Shenesa (hope I spelled that right.) she stayed and had a conversation with us and really brought the whole experience together. A really good manager can make or break an experience and Shenesa is the type to make it. Well come back for the food and the service!“

“This is my Favour pizza location, I always order there because the customer service Mary is a very nice lady and excellent service, she also speaks a little mandarin, she always positive and made sure my order is complete before I check out. and I love the pizza and chicken wings, they are so fresh and delicious!“

“Amazing location! I ordered online (stupidly) and for some reason they gave me boneless bites instead of wings. I can’t eat boneless bites. I called and after some discussion. Even after closing the manager came and personally delivered wings to make my order right. Very happy with the service and he went up and beyond the call of duty! Good people I really appreciate you making it right. Thank you!“

“Have been a customer for decades. The best homemade authentic Italian sauces and pastas in the city and a great selection of fresh and frozen and different sizes. Now also a good selection of dairy free options. Bring cheques or cash as no debit or credit options. The owner and staff are lovely. Prices have increased since Covid but then again they have everywhere!“

“Friendly staff! They have great customer service skills and took my order in a timely and efficient manner. The food was also really good and tasted super fresh which I appreciate greatly. As for the restaurant itself, it was very clean and neat--I always go back to dining in because I enjoy the atmosphere every time. Would definitely recommend anyone to this location as they always hit the nail on the head every time!“

“Great bar which offers delicious food. Family owned restaurant where you can feel that they care about their customers. Probably the only place in Toronto where you could watch a Montreal Canadians game and a Leafs game at the same time. Will officially come back. - Thank you from a montreal fan“

“Really good pizza, appetizers yummy too“

“The owner was so friendly when we walked in the door. He gave us lots of time to look ofer the extensive menu and gave us a great education lesson on his fancy pizza oven. The pizza was fast and delicious and the garlic dipping sauce I could eat on its own!“

“Sandra she's the best“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

I’m thrilled to see Mammas Pizza back in action after a year-long hiatus! Their return has been well worth the wait. The customer service is incredibly warm and welcoming, making every visit feel special. The pizza is served hot and fresh, with a perfect balance of flavors. Their pasta dishes are equally delightful, bursting with taste and cooked to perfection. Mammas Pizza truly knows how to create a memorable experience. Welcome back, Mammas!
PS:- There special walk-in offers are really so lucrative☺️“

“I found a great pizza hut location and ordered in store Supreme lover pizza. Wow the staff member Mr. Vishal was so nice to talk too and have a very friendly attitude. The Pizza was great and I highly recommend to everyone to try their craving pizza from this location. Keep it up the hard work Vishal. I'll certainly coming back to this location.
Thank you once again“

“Great pizza! I come here regularly for their pizza slices and their sandwiches, and once in a while I get a margarita pizza from them. Very nice atmosphere in the store with great workers. And amazing food! Always go the extra mile with their service. Definitely check them out“