21 Best Italian Restaurants near Whitchurch Stouffville

“East Side Mario's never disappoints! I recently had the pleasure of installing a flag for them through my I Love Stouffville initiative, and it’s easy to see why they are such a popular spot. The food is always delicious, and the atmosphere is warm and inviting. The staff go above and beyond to ensure you have a great dining experience. Whether you’re there for a family meal or a night out with friends, East Side Mario’s is a fantastic choice!“

“Great food and friendly staff!“

“Our server was courteous and cheerful. I give her full marks in dealing with our group of 14 people.
The food on the other hand was not as impressive. It may be me but I did see anything eye-catching on the menu and ended up ordering the spaghetti and meatballs. I remember BPs pasta dishes to be much better (I really liked their big lasagna which is no longer on the menu), but the sauce lacked flavour and the cheddar cheese made it seem like some weird Italian-Canadian fusion cuisine that did not work.
We sat in the dining room and there were a lot of TVs playing the Raptors game, so I could look in any direction and see the score. Our section was tight but it was a large group and we would not normally be there with that many people. I am impressed that they were able to accommodate a large group in their regular dining room.
Overall I would go back to watch the game with some buds and have some appies and pops, but I don't think I will go back for the mains.
Hope this review helps. Happy dining!!!“

“Fod and service excellent but it is so noisy it is impossible to relax and enjoy conversation with friends. I constantly had to ask my friends to repeat and I ended up with a sore back from spending the entire time learning forward at the edge of my seat to try to hear the people across the table. Why don't restaurants understand that when you go out for dinner with friends you want to talk to them? You don't want a restaurant that's quiet as a tomb, but there needs to be a happy medium so you can carry on a conversation.“

“Food is great and reasonably priced ,great drinks and the staff are excellent ,well trained and have a laugh with you .The manager made me a Caesar (cocktail) and converted me …. Will definitely be back“

“Amazing Italian food highly recommended“

“Best pizza 2014 so many pepperonis loved it. No one even comes close i love the 3 topping special. Risapan did a good job mama mia pizza. Judy is a very nice man.“

“Very good food and excellent service, I would recommend Everyone is friendly“

“This restaurant attached to Monte Carlos Inn serves Western dishes with a touch of Hong Kong style. Their food is excellent and honey mustard pork chop is a must try and I consider it best in town. Price is reasonable for the quality and generous portion. If you intended to spend a romantic evening with your other half, there are excellent choices of "dinner for two" during weekdays. Highly recommended.“

“I went to this place for the first time and was delighted to the customers and their taste .odour of the good and well behaved staff. Had vega and non veg menus very prompt service.“

“The atmosphere was great, and the food was awesome. All fresh pasta. If I’m back in the area I’ll be going back!“

“Great food & service. I always go there“

“Food was amazing!

Mattarello gave my friends and I top notch service. All the dishes were delicious and seasoned.

The atmosphere was very chic and good lighting. The service they were friendly and so helpful. Anything with truffle was very mouth watering delicious.“

“I just had to leave a review for this place! The service was outstanding. My husband and I accidentally ordered the wrong pizza, and even though they had already made it fresh, they kindly swapped it for the one we wanted—at no extra charge. I’m so grateful for their generosity, and they handled it all with such kindness. Thank you so much!“

“Thank you Sonia for an awesome pizza and fixing our delivery! It’s delicious!

Dietary restrictions: Delicious options

Kid-friendliness: Super friendly staff and owner

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy to get in“

“I had a great experience with my recent Pizza Hut takeout order. The process was smooth, and my food was ready on time. The pizza was hot, fresh, and loaded with toppings. The staff was friendly and efficient. I’ll definitely be ordering again!“

“The food was poor, chicken parmesan $22 tasted like microwave TV dinner, with Greek salad that had 1 olive, really?? Fettuccine Alfredo had no flavour. Pizza was good. Service not bad. I can’t understand why any one would serve food like that if they wanted any one to come back? The food here used to be great! Long time Markham Res“

“Maravilhoso restaurante Deliciosa comida Atendimento excelente“

“Our team had a great time doing the Celebrity Servers Fundraiser. The servers were so helpful and friendly. It was so much fun!“

“Lovely family Resturant. Beautifully done steak exactly what I asked for medium rare leaning more to the rare side. Shrimp pasta was delicious the shrimp was done perfectly and not overly cooked. Nice family style smash potatoes and butter grilled veggies as a side. The garlic bread and soup of the day remind me of grandmama’s cooking.“

“Here’s a sample review for Pizza Pizza:

“I recently tried Pizza Pizza, and it was a pretty satisfying experience overall. The pizza options are extensive, with a variety of toppings, crusts, and styles to choose from. I appreciate that they cater to different dietary needs with gluten-free, keto, and plant-based options. The crust was nice and crispy, and the toppings tasted fresh, which is always a plus.

The delivery was fairly quick, and my order arrived hot. However, I did feel that the sauce could use a bit more flavor; it was a bit bland for my taste. Also, the prices are reasonable for standard pizzas, though the specialty options can add up quickly.

Overall, I’d say Pizza Pizza is a solid choice if you’re looking for reliable pizza with plenty of options to customize. It’s“