31 Best Pizza Restaurants near Felton

“I’ve tried many pizza and sub restaurants in York/South Central PA and this place is by far the greatest when it comes to quality and pricing. My work gets their food at least once a week from here and makes a great lunch with your friends! We’ve gotten it so much that we’ve made friends with the delivery guy! 10/10“

“Went there last week. Prices were cheap for what you get and will get you full. Our food came in around 10 minutes and was hot. I recommend the Pizza Hoagie for anybody coming here. There is biking parking in the front, for anybody wondering.“

“We have shied away from this place primarily because of the generic name. Kinda like avoiding a business named Joe's Brain Surgery Center or something similar to that. Curiosity finally got the best of us and we stopped in here at Vincent's Deli for lunch. Upon walking in we noticed dirty dishes piled atop multiple tables, and the interior of the place is quite cramped. We had sat down at a table and waited almost 10 minutes for a server, but none showed up. We then noticed a couple of ladies come in to the restaurant, one sat down at a table while the other lady placed their order at the counter, and then she brought 2 drink glasses to her friends table. So we then placed our orders at the counter, filled our drink glasses at the dispenser in the hallway, and waited for our food to be delivered to our table. My beef panini was very good quality shaved medium rare roast beef which was very tasteful, and the cheddar cheese had a good bold taste to it. Howsumbutever, the quantity of that shaved roast beef was on the scant side, not nearly filling the bread it was served on. My wifes tuna salad panini was perfectly grilled with a generous amount of tasteful tuna that was very moist and delicious. I was pretty much irritated that I had to pay a 20% tip when I used my Mastercard to pay the bill. At a full service restaurant or grille it is not uncommon for us to pay a 50% tip to our server for good service. But here at Vincent's Deli we had to pay a tip, even though the only table service we received was when the employee delivered our sandwiches to our table.“

“We were in York for a Volleyball tournament this wknd and decided on pizza last minute. Glad we did. Definitely a hidden gem. We are from the Philadelphia area and have our fair share of pizza places(every corner) and with that being said, one of the BEST I’ve ever had. No doubt will be hitting the JAWN up every time we are in the area! It was perfect.“

“I stumbled into this place because I had some time to kill. So cute inside. Warm and cozy. Everyone was friendly. Really liked the atmosphere. It’s a pizza place you want to hang out in. Food good too!! Everything well stocked and it was clean!!“

“I'm not a person that does reviews. I have researched alot of pizza places in York, pa over the years. Memory lane pizza had amazing reviews and now i see why! I ordered a 16" bacon, and 16" buffalo chicken pizza. I now know I have found my place to order pizza from here on out! My wife and I are very picky and im glad we found this place! Do your taste buds a favor and order!“

“Holy smokes this place is amazing!!! First time here and it didn't disappoint! The staff is super attentive and polite and the home made bread....WOW !!!I ordered the ham boat and fries...the sub was neatly made and full of meat and toasted to perfection.The fries were the best I've ever had at a sub shop.Other places need to take step their game WAY up after eating here. Fabulous.“

“MOD pizza Mega dough crust with non-dairy cheese and loads of veggies is a vegan's dream. The amount of toppings makes for seemingly endless opportunities. The staff is upbeat and it feels like you're dropping in on friends.Dietary restrictions: Dairy free cheese!!! Plant based meat option, too. You can get a vegan custom pizza.“

“Just ordered their large 2 topping special (bacon and sausage) ... DELICIOUS! I usually just get the cheese teak sub when my other half orders from here but thought I'd try the pizza. Haven't had a good slice of pizza since moving to this state and just gave up on trying... very impressed!“

“Grab takeout from here all the time! Good food that's worth the price!Parking: A small parking lot that fills up quickly, but usually has spots available.Wheelchair accessibility: They have a wheelchair accessible entrance and parking spots.“

“This is a ma & pa kind of place that just makes you feel at home when you enter. All of the staff are wonderful and struck me as people who are just genuinely kind hearted. The inside is kept clean and neat, homemade cookies are displayed perfectly through an old school diner case which complimented the atmosphere well. The food was absolutely delicious. The personal Stromboli was baked to perfection and was a huge portion for such a low price. The cheesesteak sub is a new favorite and easily one of the best I have ever had. The meat was deliciously seasoned, the sub was well packed, the cheese melty, the fried onions blended perfectly. Even the BLT was done well. The pumpkin rolls were mouth watering and a sweet savory finish to top off a delicious dinner. I cannot say enough good things about this unexpected gem. From its atmosphere and people to its seemingly homemade recipes and prices, I can see why this shop has been around for so long. I only wish we had known about it sooner. I highly recommend a stop in for some food and good conversation if you're in the area.Kid-friendliness: Kids menu options available and the staff was so kind to kiddoWheelchair accessibility: Easily Accessible“

“I love this place. Their food is delicious and huge portion size. I grew up with the owner. And I love her like a sister Maybe more. But I understand that she has recently sold this business. So if you want to experience her delicious food. You better get in there quick. I would suggest the 3-ft stromboli. And if you're dining in, definitely get the French fries.Kid-friendliness: They treat everyone like their favorite neighbor.Wheelchair accessibility: Nothing to worry about if you're in a wheelchair. Although if you're alone they do not have automatic doors.“

“Ordered 2 6in subs: meatball parm and tuna w/ breaded cauliflower/mushrooms. LOVED the food! They make their bread in house from pizza dough, one of the few places that I've found that still do :)Saw staff using gloves, which is reassuring!Accidentally left my purse there and retrieved it with no concerns.It's nice to find a family friendly, honest business.Lost a star cause the restrooms don't use hot water in the sink and one of the restrooms didn't have a working hand dryer, nor anything in the restroom to dry your hands.BUT; overall a nice, clean establishment with polite and honest staff.“

“I continue to be impressed with the consistency of this MOD Pizza location! Since moving to the area, this is our go-to pizza spot. The pizza is always delicious and prepared nicely. We get takeout and it’s usually finished before the estimated pick up time.Parking: Can be difficult to get into the parking lot“

“We been here for cheese and pepperoni pizza several times.Pizza is very good.Service is great. Nice workers at counter.Atmosphere of this restaurant is really nice. Lots of tables and spacious.I never had anything but pizza here so can't rate other food on menu.I had dropped in with a large group of kids after our baseball game and seating was awesome.“

“It was semi busy and a little noisy, but our server was still excellent.I didn't find any crab in the Maryland crab soup, or clams in my clam strips, but it was all still good. We didn't leave hungry, but that was probably due to the abundance of fries.Their other food was pretty good. So all in all a good place to eat.“

“Good food. I may have been overly tired from a long week of work. Had a mixed ravioli dinner. Sauce was fantastic, cheese raviolis were good, the meat raviolis were MEH( they had an odd taste to them.)My soup, salad, and garlic bread were fantastica!“

“Mamma’s Pizza is a great place to stop for food while in the Loganville/Seven Valleys area. Everything it always hot, and tastes good. Staff is friendly, and it is clean. It can be pricey sometimes. French fries, and subs are delicious. Love this place, and where it sits is very convenient!Parking: Parking can be limited sometimes if all spots are full.Kid-friendliness: Friendly to kids“

“I've been coming here for years and the owner and I have been friends since high school! The food, drink menu, and atmosphere are superb! I usually get the Italian Stromboli and my husband loves their cheeseburger sub. I've had lots the other items on the menu and you can't go wrong! Friendly service, clean bathrooms, this is a 5 star experience! Thanks Vinny and the rest of the crew at Golden Crust! You guys rock!❤️“

“Yum! Visiting town for business and had to try this. Very good. Quality of food is excellent! Variety of pizza hot and fresh. They’ll make one if they don’t already have the variety. Bread sticks are delicious, everything was! Customer Service was top notch, all employees friendly and smiling. Troy was very friendly and informative when I checked in for a table. Price was a value. Would visit again when in the area. Give it a try you’ll be glad you did!Kid-friendliness: There were many kids here. Very kid friendly.Wheelchair accessibility: Open spaces between tables.“

“This place was really good. The pizza and service was good. However, the lasting impression that I came away with was the quality of the workers and staff there. They weren't overly bubbly but they seemed happy to be there and happy to serve us.“

“We always enjoy Nino's Pizza it is the best in York PA!!! recently ordered pizza and it was not as I wanted but they quickly responded and brought me what I wanted I feel bad cuz I don't want to complain but they made it right immediately“

“This place is a great lunch spot in a place with a ton of fast food options. The food is so fresh, always. They have a half sub and fries for $6.50 or something like that at lunchtime and it's a heck of a deal. I've eaten several of their subs, right now I'm enjoying a top tier Italian sub and it's outstanding. The customer service on the phone is wonderful and the gentleman who answers speaks so clearly and kindly without making you feel like he's being slow with you. Just an all around great lunch spot!“

“We moved into our home going on 3 years ago and as we tried different options to find a favorite pizza place, Bubba D's Shrewsbury location was the obvious winner. We've been ordering exclusively from them ever since! We have not eaten in but we have done both take out and delivery. Both these options we have had exclusively awesome experiences with. Now this place does get busy especially on the weekend evenings but even with that factor, I don't think we've ever ordered and not had our food within 45 minutes. Plus we're 10 minutes away. The fact that the food is always blistering, burn your mouth hot like it just came out of the oven is crazy to us but the quality is evident and the food is just great! Take out is just as easy, the staff is always friendly and pickup time is always so quick! Definitely try this place!“

“I can't comment on the atmosphere because I've never actually been there yet, but delivery is great and they are honest when they are running a little behind. However, it is worth waiting for, because the food has always been delicious. I love their chicken quesadilla because it has a great flavor. We just tried their meatball sub and it is legit one of the most amazing subs I've had. You can tell they put a lot of dedication into preparing this food to share with the community!!“

“Took both my granddaughters here for their birthday, the pizza was good. The kids had fun playing the games and riding on the rides ...Parking: It was raining so parking couldn't park near the businessWheelchair accessibility: Yes it is wheelchair accessible“

“So, this has been our go-toplace for the last six months. Their fried mushrooms are out of this world, and their salads are delcious. Pizza are great as well.We always get delivery, and the gentleman that has delivered has been the same and is nice, professional, and nothing but polite when he delivers.This place is running on all cylinders and a must!“

“Only had Sal's twice in the last 2 weeks. Daughter just moved into town. Got subs from there the first time the steak and cheese with onions and mushrooms ordered them without the marinara sauce, they came with the marinara sauce but you know what, they were really good! Got a slice of pizza to try and it was very good! So the second time we went we got a whole pizza! It will be my go-to pizza place anytime I visit my daughter!“

“As a lifetime fan of OIP, I can't recommend them enough when I'm in town or know people traveling through town. Joe and his family have always been the nicest and welcoming folks ever. The pizza is great, their sub rolls are fantastic too!“

“We ordered an xlarge 1/2 cheese and 1/2 pepperoni mushroom, green pepper, it was still warm upon arrival, friendly deliver guy and the lady who took the order was friendly as well. Toppings were plentiful, taste was great. We have nothing but good things to say.“

“Pizza is amazing!! Wings are probably the best in the area!! The Stromboli is absolutely a waste of money though.....not enough to even fill the ends and when I asked the staff about it they said if infant more meat is have to pay $4 extra so I did and got maybe 1/4 cup extra. Overall good food just don't waste your money on the boli!!!“