21 Best American Restaurants near Wellsville

“Forry's is the best! The food is absolutely delicious. The cheeseburger sub is arguably the best around. Definitely, sit out back in the grass on the picnic tables. You can't come to Forry's without getting some ice cream, though. It's the best! All the soft serve flavors are fantastic.They don't make restaurants like Forry's anymore, that's for sure.“

“We arrived just past 11am on a Sunday. They offer a brunch buffet, not want we wanted. We were given lunch menus. I asked if breakfast was still available, yes for an extra dollar was the reply. Ok. I can live with that. We ordered eggs with sausage patty (extra charge started on the menu) and eggs with scrapple. The food was good! But then came the bill. We were each charged 1.50 for rye bread. Staff never mentioned the upcharge. And charged for tea and coffee even though the menu stated included with the eggs breakfast. But apparently does not apply after 11. Ask about upcharges before ordering.“

“I’ve had a chance to go to the Fresh Start Restaurant and I can’t say enough positive things about it. The food is always good, the staff is always friendly and I know I’m getting quality ingredients in a clean environment. I highly recommend you plan a day to stop in for a good meal. They’re not open 7-days a week, so plan accordingly. I hope you enjoy.“

“Great place to stop for ice cream and food. And the serving sizes are huge and the cost ain't bad at all. Good luck eating all the ice cream. It's delicious.Parking: Big stone lotKid-friendliness: Mini golf right down the road. Great food and plenty of room aroundWheelchair accessibility: Flat, no steps.“

“Stopped by Wolfe’s today as I just happened to be passing through the area on an alternate, non interstate highway route from Maine to FL. This place is an absolute, authentic gem of an old school diner, inside and out. Completely iconic right down to the table side jukeboxes. Super friendly staff, smiling customers and great food. 10/10“

“What a lucky find! We stopped en route to Maryland and they could not have been nicer. The service was fantastic, and they were able to accommodate the disabled members of my family without question or hesitation, even opening a different section of the restaurant for us to all be able to sit at a table together. The food was brought out quickly, our drink refills were ready before we even asked, and I had the best diner burger I've had in years. I highly recommend this place!!“

“Food was excellent and attractively presented. Drinks were generous if just a bit overpriced. Pet peeve on staff training. Servers reached in across to pace items and plates were cleared before everyone at the table was finished. Servers though were courteous and efficient.“

“One of my favorite local restaurants as far as quality goes. Don't be in a hurry to eat when you come here. Enjoy the food, enjoy the atmosphere, and enjoy your company. It's hard to get past the appetizers. They are so deliciously awesome. I would recommend the polenta with bolognese. I had the best cheeseburger that I have ever eaten here. The sweet and spicy burger, although it's not spicy, it's very delicious. Try it.“

“The pork was tender and the amount was generous for the pork BBQ sandwich. I enjoyed each of the offered BBQ sauces with the mild BBQ being my favorite for this sandwich. Hushpuppies were perfectly crispy without being dense inside and the baked beans were a flavorful blend of beans. This was a lunch stop during a brief roadtrip. If you're in the Harrisburg area you need to stop at Road Hawg BBQ.“

“I've been coming to the Pickle Nickel since 2016 when I started a summer job back in college. The burgers and shakes are amazing! The staff is always friendly and it's such a unique dining experience.Since college I've moved to the area, and I'm so excited to be able to eat here more often! I only wish they were open more during the week, but that's just wishful, hungry thinking!“

“I went with family for Easter dinner. Reservations only. There were 15 in our group. When we arrived we were seated immediately, table was ready, no waiting. Limited menu for Easter. All entrees included baked potato & salad. I chose broiled scallops for my entrees. A dozen jumbo scallops cooked to perfection. I had to take half home. Service was outstanding. Restaurant was packed, even with the reservation only policy service was great. Food terrific.“

“Wow…. So glad we found this place. Was told an hour wait when we arrived but the kind ladies opened the lower deck and seated us immediately. Vanessa our waitress was on point from the start with great service with a smile. We will diffently be back. We had a variety of different foods and all of our party enjoyed there meals. The views from the there decks is absolutely breath taking. Try it you won’t be disappointed.!!!Kid-friendliness: Our kiddos loved the deck and watching the fish.“

“Always delicious ice cream and a friendly experience! My kids love this place and it's a total bonus that there is a mini golf place right next door so you can just walk over! I love that they always top the ice cream with a little hard pretzel because it gives you that sweet & salty experience!! Thank you Bill Mack!“

“My husband and I visited The Old Farmhouse Tea room this past Saturday 2/10/2024. It was just the 2 of us out on a date. Our server Katelyn (not sure if that's how her name is spelled) wad VERY NICE and professional and walked us through everything. The food was great, the service was FANTASTIC, and she was kind enough to take a picture of us. We hope to visit again, and next time we'll try the dinner option? And try and bring some friends with us. THANK YOU for making our date a memorable one. ?“

“If you just looking for a normal 2 egg breakfast with coffee you can't go wrong here. The food is consistent and good usually. I go here often enough and I have had days where things where off but then again I've had that happen everywhere . The food here is good , good price, and the staff is friendly and fast.“

“Stopped in on a Sunday afternoon with 5 friends. I can tell you this is good eating.I ordered the Hog Wild Platter. Great flavor on the pulled pork; lightly sweet, smokey and moist. The pit beef was sliced thin and very good. The baked beans were plenty and the slaw cold and crisp. The grilled roll made the perfect foundation for a sandwich. Everything was served as expected; hot hot and cold cold.Parking is on the street and there is plenty of room.Staff along with the owner very all very welcoming.All seating is outdoors. Our weather was perfect but the afternoon sun was a bit in my face the entire time; there are tables with umbrellas, but it would be better if there were more shaded tables. There were also plenty of yellow jackets looking to eat your food and drink your drink.You order at the window, there are only a few menus to go around so get in line. From ordering to delivery was about 20 minutes. Each platter was served in the order received. Don't drink too much while you wait as I will warn you, there are no facilities here for use by the customers; not even a hose bib.After my meal, I asked for a sink and i was given wet wipes. You might know them they are the ones grandmom used to carry.Overall, this is very good BBQ so use the toilet before you get here and do your best not to get messy eating or order aheadand take it to the local park to go eat. Enjoy the food.“

“Big portions (we have plenty of left overs even after stuffing our faces), amazing price (especially these days) and great people. My fiancé and I will be ordering food from this truck anytime it’s close to us or at an event we’re at. Thank you for setting up shop at our go to beer distributor today!!“

“"Serendipity" refers to the occurrence of fortunate or unexpected events by chance, often leading to a pleasant or beneficial outcome. It's often used to describe the experience of finding something valuable or delightful without actively seeking it.“

“We had the one of the best experiences in a restaurant here (and we consider ourselves foodies and eat out at least once a week). Everything from starters, cocktails, dinner and dessert was on point. Was our first time but certainly not our last, highly recommend.“

“Parking: In order to make room for more warehouses, the township re-routed the road which used to be directly in front of the Summit. So, picking out the entrance lane is a little tricky, but well worth it. We have long enjoyed eating at the Summit. They have friendly staff, good food, and plenty of it.“

“Wonderful family style bar and grill. Food is great, service is super. Only thing is not having brewed iced tea. But I survived with bottled tea. We live in York and it was a rainy day and we wanted somewhere to go. We definitely will go again. The ribs they serve on Sunday (??) are fantastic. Stop by and enjoy. You won't regret or forget the stop.Parking: Plenty of free parking and if necessary there is an empty car lot across the street. Probably parking for 100 vehicles.“