33 Best Pizza Restaurants near West Middlesex

“So good!!! we love this place“

“We went to Jimmy Neno's for the first time yesterday. The Wings were the best I've ever had. The service was Excellent. Great atmosphere. We will be back“

“Absolutely one of the top thin crust pizzas in the area!! Closet pie to a traditional New York thin crust and I would put it in the same class. This is one of my new go to!“

“Try the Sharon steel sausage sandwich. You won’t be disappointed!“

“I’ve had scottos since they were in the mall when I was a child! Their food is amazing and brings me back to my childhood. My husband and I now take trips to the restaurant (we live almost 40 mins away) to have it every now and then. So worth it!“

“highly recommend. We stupid in there monday and really enjoyed it. Best pizza we had in a long. The Employees were very friendly.“

“I was just passing through town and honestly didn’t expect to find a spot like this. Seeing a big Southern Italian last name on the sign immediately caught my attention, so I had to stop in, and I’m glad I did.
This is a genuinely authentic Italian-American place with that warm feel that makes you feel at home the moment you walk in. I ordered a capocollo-ham sandwich with provolone, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing. Fresh ingredients, well made, and very satisfying. I also tried the garlic knots, something I always judge Italian places by, and they were very good. Fresh, soft, and flavorful. If I had one tiny suggestion, I’d say a little extra garlic wouldn’t hurt, but that’s just personal preference.
The spinach stromboli was excellent. Fresh, clearly house made dough, and exactly what you hope for. I finished with cannoli, and they were absolutely on point. Small, authentic, and delicious.
I also loved that they had all the little extras that make a place feel real. Cookies, jars of pickled garlic and peppers. specialty items, packaged pasta to take home. The whole atmosphere just felt welcoming and genuine.
A really pleasant surprise in a town where I wasn’t expecting much. Definitely worth stopping if you appreciate authentic Italian-American food.

One fun suggestion: add a Nutella stromboli to the menu. If you do, naming it “The Stefano” would only be fair. 😄“

“I remember when they were in the Kmart mall in Meadville. We happened to be in Sharon today and when I made the connection, I knew we had to stop! It’s exactly like I remembered it. Pizza by the slice in every combination you could think of and absolutely delicious. She even pointed out the signage from their Meadville spot and joked about still having a freezer from Montgomery Wards. I’m so happy we stopped and we will be back.“

“Food is always exceptional. Doesn’t matter what you order. The steak bomb is definitely one of my go to’s! I would highly recommend for your next meal!“

“fast courteous service, food was great!! and beer was cold!“

“My family has eaten Luigi's pizza since it opened in Farrell. The best pizza we have ever eaten!“

“Best pies around like no one else“

“Wonderful place to fill up on the pizza is incredible delicious fresh ingredients buttery cheese and crust it starts with an local with an dream and that dream of preparing and delivering the best pizza in town I’m Palmer and I go there as much as I can I’m an local that loves the real quality and freshness I find at only homemade hometown pizzas“

“Our favorite pizza in the valley“

“We took a day trip on 8-14-26 to the greater Youngstown area and found this little pizza shop. Very nice people and very good pizza. We enjoyed ours at the Yellow Creek park nearby. Perfect end to our day. Thank you Brier Hill for the great experience. We'll worth the trip!!!“

“Great pizza! Sauce was very good and the pizza baked perfectly. Only downfall was the size of the pies. We're a family of 4 (two which are teens) and we had just enough ordering 2 pies. My fault was not asking the size. Also note, to get in to the pizza pickup spot, go to the bar entrance, ring the bell and when the door opens, go into the kitchen located on the left just as you walk in.“

“🍕 Just gotta give credit where it’s due… This small mom & pop spot absolutely delivers. The crust? really good, The cheesy bread? reminds me of my childhood I’ve lived in 10 different states, and I don’t say this lightly you’re 1 of only 2 pizza places in the Youngstown area that I genuinely enjoy. Keep doing what you’re doing 👏 Support local!“

“I love pizza joes. Never have had any issues at all!!! But ordered a stromboli last night. Wasnt the same ! Top had slits in it and the inside was not done!“

“Stopped here on a Friday afternoon after playing 18 holes and before playing another 18 holes. A group of 10 of us sat in the bar section and put a few tables together. Service was fantastic. Can't remember the guy's name but was super friendly and quick. Pizza was phenomenal and great prices. Super happy without experience and would absolutely visit again when we play nearby!“

“The pizza was good and so were the Parm bread bites but I spent almost 18$ on 16 wings and they were the smallest wings I've ever seen in my life!!! Not only that but they were also very soggy. I will never order wings from dominos again. Don't bother wasting your money on the wings !“

“Best homemade lasagna in the Pa. /Ohio area.....all good food and the pasta sauce is homemade fresh daily. This place is a diamond in the rough...older style atmosphere with delicious choices. Prices are very reasonable too!“

“I love their food, it's the best but I'll never purchase any of their fountain drinks. Twice I've purchased drinks and debris of some sort was in my drinking cup. I think that the lines aren't cleaned of flushed on a regular basis. Should you get a fountain drink, open the lid and check for debris.“

“hmmmm YUM sloop good. love the sauce. usually me and Tonya pick off the cheese then lick the sauce right off the bread. After we dunk the bread in French or Catalina dressing or feed it to our dog Grover Cleveland name him after the pres. I would eat sauce if they sold in stores with a spoon... good stuff nuff said“

“Food was great, as were the staff; and live music :-) :-) :-)“

“Miss coming there and time to come back“

“Pizza and wings were very good, I'm a Jersey transplant so I've been trying all the local pizza places! Great flavor! Very good sauce and cheese ratio on the particular pie I ordered 9 in round I think, very doughy in a great way! Not New York or Jersey style but very very good! Will be back again and again!“

“toppings were left off and Stromboli came with the smallest amount of filling I've ever seen...6 pepperoni..literally I could count them..on a lg deluxe Stromboli...never ever again..I've never thrown away so much food in my life...0 stars not 4 stars 🤢🤮“

“My Son Dale, his girlfriend Allie and my nephew Brady took me there today, for an early Mother’s Day Dinner, the food was excellent. We all had a wonderful time. Our Server was right on target.“

“Very nice waitress!!! Food was great and brought out perfectly timed!! The place was clean and very nicely decorated....did not see one bug in the place or in the food! Actually had a great experience! Thank you it's been a while dining out where people actually cared about their jobs!! IT SHOWS!!“

“Never really had a bad experience from Marcos. Friendly & efficient. Shocked at all the bad reviews.“

“I really enjoy how convenient and reliable this place is when I am craving something quick and easy. The pizza always arrives piping hot and the crust has just the right texture, which makes it a solid go-to for a casual dinner. I have always had a friendly experience with the delivery drivers as well, and it is nice to be able to track my order so easily on my phone.“

“What a Great Experience! I always know my order is different so I go in already nervous for places by order anywhere I go. The young man who took my order was wonderful, her repeated my order twice to make sure he had it correct, I didn't even ask. I had no question to worry about my order my being correct. I get my order and take it to the car. I do double check before I leave because more often than not its wrong, again by everywhere most times. Not only was the order correct, it was the best pizza I have ever received! I appreciate both of the men that worked tonight, more than you will ever know! I wish I had got their names. I ordered my pizza at 5:52pm and received it at 6:10pm 8/15/26. Please give them the appreciation they deserve! When I see then again I will ask their names.“