16 Best American Restaurants in New Shoreham

“Overall good spot for take out! Super good street corn but the chips were stale. Also got a handheld that was supposed to come with potato salad but didn’t which was a lil disappointing, but the handheld itself was super good. Quality of the food we got minus the chips though was great!“

“Fabulous date night destination! Fantastic service! Reliably delicious!“

“The best gourmet burger I’ve ever had!!“

“I’m usually extremely hesitant about any restaurants in touristy areas. I’ve had so many bad experiences over the past more than 30 years — overpriced and bad food, total tourist traps. But this place really restored my faith! Big thumbs up for the absolutely delicious burger — WOW! And the chicken pesto pasta was a dream!“

“We went to The Spring House for our 25th wedding anniversary. This was the best vacation we have ever had. The hotel is amazing. We had a corner room facing the ocean and the view was perfect. We loved sitting on the lawn in the white Adirondack chairs. The view was spectacular, the live piano music was wonderful and it was great that you could order drinks and food from your chair. The food and staff was also great. We had the same waitress for two of our dinners and she was amazing her name is Kacey. She made our dining experience very enjoyable. We highly recommended The Spring House and we plan on going again.“

“Just lovely. Can’t wait to get back“

“I go with my eleven year old daughter. We enjoy being served lunch on the beach by the fabulous servers. The food is delicious! So much fun to hear the music in the background while enjoying swimming and building sandcastles.“

“We tried the casual outdoor part of the restaurant. All outdoor seating no table service and a limited menu. But they do have lobster rolls. Quite casual. The food was ordinary but OK. Service was reasonably quick and friendly. The price was very high but that is common in the very touristy part of Block Island.“

“You come here for the good times and to cut bait from the influencer crowds and social butterflies looking for a backdrop. Good food, good for kids good for good times, music, entertainment, off the grid, locals experience. Flipz, tanks, shorts, shoes, shirts, no problem, just smile and have fun with others. You'll be glad you stopped by. Great wings, Nara on Tap. And a nice list of other things.

Kid-friendliness: Kids are welcome, although it can get a little wild at times later in the evenings, but typically all safe and fun.

Wheelchair accessibility: First floor entrance, wide doors,“

“Always a great time at Payne’s . Love the Painkillers with Meyers Rum floater. Extra shoutout to our server Caitlin Wrobo for bringing us the tots! Best tots ever and the most adorable server ever. Always the best when visiting Big Mike & Stacey on Full Cuckoo.“

“One one of the best meals I’ve ever had. The oysters Thermidor were to die for. Wasn’t as hungry as I wish I had been given how good the food was but I ordered the Sicilian clams with a side of pasta and that was also perfection. Service also outstanding. Two hours to get there and two hours back and totally worth it. Don’t miss this one.“

“Love Kimberly’s! Seafood Fra Diavlo is one of the best I have had. Highly recommend:)“

“Great chowders enjoyed both enjoyed lunch“

“A great old- fashioned breakfast place. Delicious home- made pastries and friendly service. Eggs, pancakes, the works. The locals eat here.“

“We had dinner on the porch which was very pleasant and the views were great. They also have indoor and what the call patio dining. Patio dining is on the lawn so it's in the sun, if you want outdoor but not in the sun reserve the porch.
I had the mussels and the scallops. The mussels are spectacular. They are served in soup rather than just a broth. The mussels themselves were plump and fresh but it's the soup that sets this dish apart, I wanted to lick the plate.
For the main course I had the scallops. They were fine, fresh but otherwise not outstanding.“

“Good place for drinks and conversation with other visitors and bartenders“