29 Best Italian Restaurants near Cayce

“Highly recommend this place if you love authentic Greek food! It’s so many great choices so I will give you my top 3 picks! 1.The meat lovers pizza 2. The spaghetti meat sauce with the homemade meatballs, so good and delicious! 3. Spaghetti Caruso made with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, pepperoni, Italian, sausage, and ham covered with meat sauce!“

“Pizza was ready upon pickup and still hot and delicious. Great pizza!“

“Was excellent service and alot of food for the price, love it! 😊“

“Absolutely fantastic. Loved the decor. Great staff. The food was so great! The only thing I would say is maybe add a little something out of the ordinary for dessert. Will definitely be back!“

“The food and service were impeccable!“

“My absolute favorite Italian restaurant in the Columbia area. Always wonderful food and great service!“

“Wonderful service! Ashley, you were a wonderful waitress! The food and drinks..yum!! Chef's kiss! 5 Stars!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We come here for every celebration/anniversary. Every time it is great. The past time we went we had CJ as a waitress and she was AMAZING. Felt like she knew us and got every detail perfect. She was so bubbly and easy to talk to. Will definitely come back and ask for her directly!!!“

“Nice chicken cutlet. Rainbow cookies were like from home. Wife bit into the cannoli and I swear I saw a tear. Will go back!“

“The place was hopping at 6:30 on a Thursday. The waitstaff was exemplary! As quick as they could, telling us about timing, and great suggestions. And the food! Top. Notch. Salmon, chicken parm, and Italian sausage mains were delectable. The lemoncello, tuxedo, and cheesecake were decadent. Many choices at the bar. Truly a wonderful experience! Thank you!“

“Great staff who take pride in great customer service. Fetticuni Alfredo with shrimp off the chain. Best homemade I have tasted. Pizza was fantastic. definitely recommend and I will be back!“

“I’ve lived in Lexington my whole and for some reason, I just went to dinner here for the first time the other night. I should not have waited so long! The food was delicious! I had the chicken parm and my husband had a Stromboli. Our server Ellis was fantastic! Very personable and polite! We would request him to be our server next time! I will be back many, many more times!“

“Offers dine in, carryout, and delivery. We chose to dine in. Seems to be a family run business. They offer pizza by the slice as well as whole pizzas, sandwiches, appetizers, and entrees. Carryout was pretty busy but we decided to dine in. Both the regular and gluten-free pizzas were great. I ordered a medium, probably should have gone with a small, as it was a lot of food. Definitely one of the better pizzas we have had in Columbia. We will be back.“

“We had the Spinach Artichoke pizza and a cannoli - both were delicious! I'll def go back! The staff was great and service was fast.“

“The Best Place to Eat. Great Food, Wonderful Staff and Very Good Prices.“

“Been coming here for 2 yrs, food is always decent. No complaints. I gave 4 stars cause last night I ordered to go and I caught hell in the RR!! Ik it was what I ordered cause that was all I had eaten that day (hadn’t eaten last night, so nothing from the night before). Just saying, I’m not sure what that was about but don’t let it happen again.“

“The food was good, the service was excellent, and prices were fair. This place is open for breakfast and lunch. There were vegetarian options. I had a grilled portobello sandwich with coleslaw and a slice of pecan pie for dessert.“

“Fast and delicious and a friendly staff.“

“Delicious sandwiches and the sweet wheat bread is the best!“

“The “FRIED CATFISH” SPECIAL was absolutely DELICIOUS and the portion serving was awesome…two large filets..Should b on the menu permanently!!“

“I used to be a Danos girl… but Za’s pizza takes the cake for best pizza in Columbia!“

“Fazoli’s is a solid option when you want quick, affordable pasta 🍝 The food comes out fast, and it’s an easy go-to for a filling meal without spending much.

The breadsticks are definitely a highlight - warm, soft, and consistently good 🥖

It’s best to stick with the pasta though, since the pizza is just okay in comparison. Overall, it’s a dependable choice for fast, budget-friendly comfort food 👍“

“Wow! The special pizza was ESPECIALLY delicious!“

“I preordered a weeks worth of meals and drove from Aiken to pick up. It was well worth the drive. The food is not only appealing to they eyes, but everything I ordered tasted fabulous! You can taste the love in this food!“

“We planned to do something for our wedding anniversary today but something came up and we had to stay home. We decided to have JR Cash’s tonight as take out because we haven’t had them in a while due to our busy schedules and boy it did not disappoint!! We had the ribeye, prime rib..sides and house salad..croissants. Our girls wanted grilled cheese and a burger and we were all soo satisfied!! Food was delicious, fresh, and it was as good as if we were in the restaurant!! Thanks for making our anniversary dinner a great one 💕“

“There pizza is delicious made with perfection and affordable they always have a special going on that is very affordable as well, although there was a hiccup with my last order but they didn't make it right the next round, thank you Marco's“

“The BEST pizza in town“

“Great food and great staff..“

“Always Awesome food and CS and NEVER disappointed 🥰🙏🇺🇸 #REBTD 😇“