21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Mount Pleasant

“The service is always fantastic and the pizza is the best we’ve found!“

“I went for the first time and it was awesome. I saw that they had amoroso rolls and had to have the meatball sandwich. It helps to take the crave away if your from the Philadelphia area.“

“I don’t even know where to begin to describe how amazing Ty’s was… my fiancé and I stopped in here with my parents on day 1 of our trip to the area and it did not disappoint whatsoever. From the apps to the dessert, all of our choices were a 10/10!! Our waiter Scott was the best, he alone deserves 5 gold stars! ⭐️ we were even lucky enough to meet Ty and found out we were at the “magic table” that earned us dessert on the house!! Now whether you’re lucky enough to get the magic table or not, you CANNOT pass on the churros!!“

“First time here. It was great. Food and service were top notch. Sue took great care of us. We will be back.“

“Fantastic food with personal service“

“If I could give this place 1000/10 I would. Pizza is authentic, the flavors, the sauce, just top tier. The service was amazing as well, very personable. I couldn’t recommend this place more!! My family and I will definitely be back.“

“The food and service were great. Thank you for the welcoming and friendly atmosphere...AND a delicious dinner!“

“My family and I had Paisano's while on vacation last week. I can tell you that it was some of the best pizza and sandwiches we have ever had! We will definitely be back!“

“Amazing crust that keeps us coming back… that and the absolutely kind owner. It is the kind of small business you want people to give a try. It won’t disappoint.“

“I have been to numerous Italian restaurants in my life. Out of every Italian restaurant this one is the absolute best, everything was so outstanding. Everything was made from scratch it had tons of flavor. Great service great atmosphere. I cannot highly recommend this place enough, today was my first day going there and I will be a regular there multiple times a month because it was that good. I can no longer hold other Italian restaurants that I’ve been to at such a high standard because this place was so outstanding and delicious.“

“Fantastic food and great service. Well worth the price. Highly recommend!“

“The food is absolutely delicious, and the staff is incredibly friendly—it’s always a joy to chat with them while dining in. The owners are warm and welcoming, which makes the experience even better. Gillian, Greer, Greta, Jarrod, Jada, and the rest of the team are truly amazing! Everyone works so hard and consistently delivers outstanding service. I highly recommend this restaurant!“

“Absolutely best Italian combo sandwich ever! The ciabatta is out of this world. Crispy and fresh. You have to try this one!“

“Amazing experience! My husband and I heard this restaurant was coming to North Mt Pleasant. Decided to head that way tonight and we were pleasantly surprised!!! We had the whipped cheese with honey and rosemary focaccia, pizza special and the chicken gnocchi. All were amazing! And a delicious bottle of Cabernet! Perfect date night!“

“Being from NY, it has a hometown feel with excellent food, good sized portions and the best waiter ever in Joel.“

“I have to say Sarah the general manager is a class act. She and her staff are very personable and helpful. The product they put out has care behind it. Just an example last Tuesday (buy one get one free pizza day) I ordered a large pepperoni magnifico pizza and added onions and green peppers. Vegetables were fresh and noticeable on the pizza and other items with that fresh aroma when you get the pizza. The crust was nice and soft like a fresh loaf of bread coming out of the oven. Then I had a garlic crust. When I open the box it was like art with the colors and the wonderful smell. The tast. Well try it you won't be disappointed.

Thank you,

Your loyal customer,

Jeff“

“Good food and service. Lots of fun pizza options, and a nice selection of drinks both alcoholic and non-alcoholic. Fun and creative environment with lots of cool art and statues. Seems like they have done a good job in keeping it clean and up to date over the years.“

“First time and promised repeat customer!!!“

“If you are looking for New York pizza This is the place!! Delicious sauce. Fresh mozzarella and real pizza dough ! We are so happy we found this Restaurant. Can’t wait to try other items on the menu!!“

“Food was good- pepperoni and basil on gluten free crust & another pepperoni on regular crust. Pizza is wood fired and has that thin crust, rustic, floury thing going on. The kids tried the hot honey on theirs and loved it! The meat and cheese board was good as well. We went on a weekend and there was competing music between here and the bar across the street, lots of people, lots of kids playing on the playground in the seating area.

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust available“

“You know what to expect - for a quick 'upscale' dominos pie - sure. Is it a classic pizza for a purest, no. But it sure hit the spot with a cold Yuengling! Staff was super nice, place was immaculate - I see no reason not to go back.“