15 Best Italian Restaurants in Amarillo

“Amazing food and great customer service. Highly recommend!!“

“Valore is hands down one of our favorite places to eat! If you love Italian food, this spot is an absolute gem. The dishes are always flavorful, fresh, and beautifully presented—it’s clear the chefs take real pride in what they do. What really sets Valore apart, though, is the staff. Every time we visit, we're greeted with warm smiles and friendly, attentive service that makes us feel genuinely welcome. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy amazing food, and leave already looking forward to your next visit. Highly recommend to anyone looking for top-quality Italian cuisine in a cozy, inviting atmosphere!“

“Excellent dining experience, in Amarillo it is second only to Cellar 55 in dining experience. I believe they are both from the same owner. We had dinner with traveling friends. They loved the experience as did my wife and I. Thank you very much. Mike“

“This restaurant is fantastic. Their service is excellent, the food is delicious, and everyone who works there is friendly. The owner goes above and beyond to see that customers are treated correctly. I will make it a point to continue to eat here every time I am in Amarillo.“

“m mx,,x,exmmzmz,xm,mxmx mdm,m“

“Pescaraz is such a great restaurant operated by such wonderful people! The food is delicious, authentic Italian food. Thank you!“

“First time to Fire Slice; in town for a RC airplane event. The food was amazing! We had cheese curds and pepperoni, hamburger, smoked ham and jalapeno pizza. We will definitely visit again. Staff were very helpful and courteous. Also draft beer prices - Amazing!“

“fresh food all the time. it's the best tasting pizza I have ever had in Texas. so I recommend you come down 6th and try it. trust me you won't be disappointed.“

“The food was delicious and the service was great!“

“Muy rico los elotes 😋 con maíz blanco.. Aun queda mucho por probar.“

“Great food, great service. The only reason the food didn't get a five-star rating is because of the Short Rib Cheese Puffs appetizer being significantly overcooked. Our server was worried about them arriving too cool, so she asked the kitchen to make them piping hot. In the process, the outside of the appetizer was way overcooked...still a good appetizer and I would order again with the hopes they would arrive properly cooked. For my entree, I had the Blackened Bayou with chicken. Outstanding!“

“Didn't really expect anything more than a normal good meal. What we got was a gourmet meal, nothing could have been better. Our waitress, a young lady named Kaylee was even awsome. I wish all our experiences were this good. Worth every penny.“

“Love labella’s pizza , I eat here at least a few times a week , they got great service and even better pizza 🍕“

“😍I love love their salads and when they messed up an order the manager on bell was so accommodating and replaced my order and redelivered.“

“We always enjoy visiting Toscana Italian Steakhouse, but our experience last night was truly exceptional. We were celebrating our wedding anniversary and were seated in the perfect place to relax and enjoy our time together. Our waitress was attentive without ever being overbearing, and everything—from the appetizer to our entrées and dessert—was absolutely delicious. The staff's thoughtful attention to detail, including an anniversary card and an extra-special dessert, made the evening even more memorable. Thank you for helping make our anniversary celebration so special!“