15 Best Italian Restaurants in Amarillo

“Amazing food and great customer service. Highly recommend!!“

“Valore is hands down one of our favorite places to eat! If you love Italian food, this spot is an absolute gem. The dishes are always flavorful, fresh, and beautifully presented—it’s clear the chefs take real pride in what they do. What really sets Valore apart, though, is the staff. Every time we visit, we're greeted with warm smiles and friendly, attentive service that makes us feel genuinely welcome. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy amazing food, and leave already looking forward to your next visit. Highly recommend to anyone looking for top-quality Italian cuisine in a cozy, inviting atmosphere!“

“m mx,,x,exmmzmz,xm,mxmx mdm,m“

“Excellent dining experience, in Amarillo it is second only to Cellar 55 in dining experience. I believe they are both from the same owner. We had dinner with traveling friends. They loved the experience as did my wife and I. Thank you very much. Mike“

“This restaurant is fantastic. Their service is excellent, the food is delicious, and everyone who works there is friendly. The owner goes above and beyond to see that customers are treated correctly. I will make it a point to continue to eat here every time I am in Amarillo.“

“Pescaraz is such a great restaurant operated by such wonderful people! The food is delicious, authentic Italian food. Thank you!“

“I wanted to take the time to leave this review because the staff at this location deserve nothing but the best.

I have been on the road traveling for three days, and by the time I made it to Amarillo yesterday, I was completely exhausted and starving. I checked into my hotel and noticed there was an Olive Garden nearby. I hadn't had Olive Garden in a while, so I was really hoping to grab some dinner. 🥹

I realized they closed at 10:00 p.m., and it was already 9:30, so I called to ask if it was still okay to place an order. I honestly felt bad calling so close to closing because I know everyone wants to go home after a long shift. 🥺

The woman who answered the phone was incredibly kind. I wish I had asked for her name because she truly deserves recognition. She let me know that as long as we arrived before 10:00, they would be happy to prepare my order. She was so friendly and understanding, and I really appreciated it.

We made it there just in time, and the Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo was absolutely delicious. 🤤

I especially wanted to thank the entire staff for taking my order even though it was so close to closing. They didn't have to, but they did. When they heard me mention that I had been driving all day and was tired and hungry, they showed genuine kindness. That simple act meant more than they probably realize.

After such a long and difficult day, they turned my night around. Great food is always nice, but great people are what make a place memorable. Thank you all so much. ❤“

“Great atmosphere and vibe. Solid selection of wine and beers with good local representation. Food was fantastic and the kids menu was greatly appreciated. This is the kind of place you can grab a quick lunch or sit around for awhile at the it show. Service was superb.“

“fresh food all the time. it's the best tasting pizza I have ever had in Texas. so I recommend you come down 6th and try it. trust me you won't be disappointed.“

“3 of us girls celebrated women's time. We had the best experience. One lady had never been there, she loved it and felt very special. Another lady had only had drinks in the bar. She had a marvelous time. I made the reservations, I've been there many times. My husband who passed in January 2025 used to take me for it anniversary. It's also where I said YES to the marriage in 2007. I enjoyed every minute of all of it off course. But missed my husband presence and laughter.“

“Muy rico los elotes 😋 con maíz blanco.. Aun queda mucho por probar.“

“The food was delicious and the service was great!“

“Love labella’s pizza , I eat here at least a few times a week , they got great service and even better pizza 🍕“

“Will be dining/taking out once a week now. We support you #LGB“

“Hayley and the team did an excellent job upstairs, and the food was delicious. Went down to the speakeasy where Evelyn and the team made sure we were well taken care of with drinks in a fun environment. So glad we stay here every time we go through town.“