34 Best Pizza Restaurants in Amarillo

“Great staff, always fantastic food. Do yourself a favor go try it out, but also make sure you go to one of their tastings!“

“DELISH pizza I randomly found and so glad I did! I honestly couldn’t believe how empty it was when I visited. It made me wonder if people just don’t know this place exists because it definitely deserves more attention. It’s tucked away on the back side of a strip center, so it’s easy to miss if you aren’t looking for it.

I ordered one of the specialty pizzas and customized it with a couple of extra toppings, and it was absolutely fantastic. The crust was delicious, the ingredients tasted fresh, and everything was cooked perfectly. I couldn’t leave without trying the blackberry bread pudding for dessert, and I’m so glad I did. It was the perfect sweet ending to an already great meal.

If you’re in Amarillo and love pizza, don’t let the hidden location fool you. Fire Slice is absolutely worth seeking out, and I’ll definitely be back the next time I’m in town!“

“Hands Down The Fudging BEST They Be Looking Out For Folks Like I Got Home And I Realize I Forgot To Order Ranch For My Wings As Well As Ketchup For My Fries. It Was A Complete Vibe Kill Until I Open Up My Fry Box And Bam 2 Ketchup Packets And A Ranch Cup.🥹🙏🏾🤗 And Everything I Ordered Was Cooked To Perfection
#NOONEOUTPIZZASTHEHUT“

“Simply the one of the best and coolest places in town. Creative and delicious seasonal pizzas (The Gobbler!!) and superb beer selection. They do great things for the community, as well. Cannot say enough about them. Give it a go. We are fans for life.“

“Great tasteful pizzas very affordable prices“

“Just had my second pizza and it reminded me of East Coast Style. Then I heard the owner say they were East Coast Style. Delicious Pizza! Go now!“

“This place was great. Great service and food. Fun place!“

“Best pizza ever! Always eat here when we are passing through!!!“

“The food was delicious and the service was great!“

“m mx,,x,exmmzmz,xm,mxmx mdm,m“

“I really love your gyros! I wish you had a food truck and would come to lake Meredith and Borger/Fritch/Stinnett“

“😍I love love their salads and when they messed up an order the manager on bell was so accommodating and replaced my order and redelivered.“

“Best pizza ever! Always eat here when we are passing through!!!“

“Valore is hands down one of our favorite places to eat! If you love Italian food, this spot is an absolute gem. The dishes are always flavorful, fresh, and beautifully presented—it’s clear the chefs take real pride in what they do. What really sets Valore apart, though, is the staff. Every time we visit, we're greeted with warm smiles and friendly, attentive service that makes us feel genuinely welcome. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy amazing food, and leave already looking forward to your next visit. Highly recommend to anyone looking for top-quality Italian cuisine in a cozy, inviting atmosphere!“

“Love labella’s pizza , I eat here at least a few times a week , they got great service and even better pizza 🍕“

“fresh food all the time. it's the best tasting pizza I have ever had in Texas. so I recommend you come down 6th and try it. trust me you won't be disappointed.“

“This restaurant is fantastic. Their service is excellent, the food is delicious, and everyone who works there is friendly. The owner goes above and beyond to see that customers are treated correctly. I will make it a point to continue to eat here every time I am in Amarillo.“

“We had the Lunch Buffet 07/29 and the experience deserves more than the 5 Stars we can give. From the moment we stepped foot inside, the cleanliness and customer service set the tone. The food was hot and fresh with a great rotation with nothing sitting empty or for too long. The staff kept up with drink refills and updates on when items were coming out. The entire staff from the front of house to the kitchen should all be recognized. Thank you for a great dining experience and we will definitely be back. Side note, they were playing some cool jams. Lol“

“I love eating here. Been eating at the other locations for years. They have an awesome menu with a great variety of meals to choose from. Definitely a place to keep going and enjoying meals.“

“OMG! My gluten/ dairy free pizza was the best I have ever had!!!!This is a great reason to come back to Amarillo, Tx“

“Tried OVR-EZE and had a really good experience. The service was smooth and efficient, and everything was handled professionally from start to finish.

The overall experience felt easy and hassle-free, with staff being friendly and straightforward. Solid spot if you’re looking for reliable service“

“Friendliest People & Always Amazing Food..Not "Stingy" on toppings like other places...They SHARE THE LOVE❤🍕 SOMEHOW Reminds Me Of The Drive-In Pizza From The 80's!! Thumbs-Up!!!“

“This is one of the greatest cicis I've ever been to try were friendly thy accommodated my daughter who is lactose intolerant and made her her own pizza on flatbread no cheese no butter the pizza was super hot and fresh they kept up on it never had an empty spot always had hot pizza stayed there for an hour with games and everything it was a greattl experience here in Amarillo thank you“

“Pizza stayed fresh, the salad bar was stocked and clean , Christina was great hostess and kept the place clean.“

“Our go-to pizza place for delivery, however this time I felt like the ham & pineapple pizza I ordered was so overloaded with pineapple (I love pineapple, but even I have my limits) that it completely overwhelmed the pizza. It was as if they tipped the container over and said "oops." I'll still eat it (even though I don't enjoy it this time) and I'll still order from them, but I hope this won't happen again.“

“Staff was nice and helpful from the first reservation questions to the end of the baby shower. We had a whole family event with about 20. Loved how we were able to decorate the room and everything went perfectly. Our guests had a good time choosing food on the buffet. Enjoyed everything from salad, pizza sticks, pizza and ice cream. Best party place around! Thank you!“

“😍I love love their salads and when they messed up an order the manager on bell was so accommodating and replaced my order and redelivered.“

“The Best Pizza Hut in Town! Thank You For The Best Service. Awesome ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Ordered two pizzas tonight and they were easily the best I’ve had from a Pizza Hut in a long time—plus I scored a great deal on both. The food was prepared quickly, delivered fast, and arrived hot and fresh. Huge kudos to the team at this location 👏🏼🍕 01/26/26 @ 7pm“

“Best damn pizza in Amarillo!! Lexi is the best!! She made my pizza and cooked it (well done) to perfection. Undercarriage was perfect top golden brown and cheesy!! Delivery was fast thanks Nash you rock!! I've ordered from many pizza places in Amarillo and been disappointed who knew good ol Domino's can make a brick oven pie without a brick oven..GREAT JOB!!“

“I picked up a meat lovers pizza yesterday. The pizza was so fresh and delicious. I wish there was a Godfathers Pizza near grand prairie. Our pizza was the best pizza I have had in a long time. Nice staff and clean dining area. Now we wish I had bought 2 pizzas.“

“So your pizza is still good, but I am so sad that you changed your sauces! Please got back to the pesto. It's what made you stand out. Thank you! 😊“

“Great staff! Delicious fast quality food!!“

“excellent delivery and service“