50 Best Sandwich Shops near Millcreek

“Came in for a quick bite tonight and the store was absolutely slammed. The lady that was in charge was great. She had a great attitude while helping train someone new, making sandwiches and helping customers. Well done. Give this lady a raise. Oh, the sandwiches were good too.“

“I had ordered my lunch for delivery a couple weeks ago and was disappointed because when I got my order, I didn't get anything that I ordered. I emailed the store, expecting just a quick apology and a free sandwich. What I got met and exceeded my expectations. I went in to get my sandwich and the manager was apologetic and quickly got my lunch prepared. I went to pay for the chips and drink that I ordered and was told that everything was good and I didn't owe a thing. The sandwich was delicious and made my lunch. Thank you!“

“so i don’t typically leave reviews for places but the experience i had today was so positive that i had to share. i ordered lunch for pickup this afternoon and was late with arriving due to personal instances (relevant i promise) and i received a phone call from a very kind person letting me know my order was ready. i was flustered in the moment due to my situation and quickly made up that i was lost getting to their downtown slc location and he immediately went into assistance mode, giving me directions while assuring my order will be kept until i arrived and it was exactly the human interaction from a kind stranger i didn’t know i needed until it happened. i arrived quickly thereafter and i presume it was the same person who handed me my order was the one who called me and his in person kindness matched his over the phone kindness. every time i’ve come here its been nothing short of exceptional customer service and if not most importantly - the food is ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS. the buffalo chicken and turkey bacon wraps are to die for and breakfast sandwiches slap too i swear it. also i’m just now remembering i ordered 2 sandwiches for 2 people but i didn’t order 2 bags of chips cause i’m trying to save money and before leaving out the door with my order, he added ANOTHER bag of chips in to my bag because there was already chips in my bag (crying) thank you for being such wonderful people and for being part of our wonderful salt lake city community!“

“Excellent! that cookie oh my. I am obsessed“

“Went in to the store around 2:50pm today, and the entire crew was so friendly and their service was incredible. My girlfriend ordered a veggie, and one of the Lady’s wiped down the slicer for us without even asking. The whole crew was social and amazing, and it made my birthday even better :)“

“I come in a couple times week to either there yummy asiago Bagel with cream cheese, or their tuscan chicken sandwhich with fries. I just tried their Chipotle pepper jack cheese burger, and was so delicious, and my work had their clam chowder that was also so delicious. Highly recommend!!“

“This is everything you want in a breakfast sandwich! The brioche bun is the perfect texture. The bacon and sausage are unreal - so full of flavor. We drove 30 minutes for this sandwich and plan to make the drive many more times because it is that good!“

“Porn the subs is so good I wish they had one out here in Jordan landing“

“I just love the tuna sandwich!!! love you guys!!“

“Love this store the service is great“

“Absolutely exceptional sandwiches with extreme care and home-style comfort - but make no mistake, not something you can replicate at home.

Focaccia is remarkable soft and crunch at the same time. Ambiance is bodega meets farmers market.

I want to go again and again.“

“My hubby and I stopped in for the first time ever to use a gift card. OMG, it was amazing! Hubby said his chopped cheese sandwich was unlike anything he’s ever had before, in a good way, and the potato salad was a surprise treat. I had the turkey which looked exactly like the menu picture- that doesn’t happen very often and tasted really good . Katy was super helpful and informative. Definitely worth a repeat.“

“We went into the Saratoga springs location and saw the magnificent looking cinnamon rolls. Much to our dismay there were no raisins and we are always on the lookout for raisins in our cinnamon rolls. Carl, the owner, said he’d make a pan with raisins for just for us. We took 10 huge cinnamon rolls home and the family indulged in the best rolls ever! Thanks Carl!“

“I love Knockerbockers in South Jordan! Courtney is the best! My orders are always perfect and on time. The food is great! The price is right and the service is excellent. I highly recommend and use them to cater breakfasts and lunches every week because I know I can count on Courtney to take care of everything she’s so reliable. Knickerbockers is my secret weapon for keeping my clients well fed and happy!“

“Great Food Friendly Service & Atmosphere“

“Hands down the best subs ever. Everyone is always happy friendly and smilin. ❤❤“

“This was the best experience at any Jersey mikes ever. Kiersten recommended my family and I the best sandwiches we’ve probably ever had. She was very helpful and nice, and held a conversation with us. This place was also pretty clean, even during the lunch rush they kept it nice.“

“This place is a freakin gem! I can find no faults in the cheese steak, it is perfection in a bun and has no equal in Salt Lake County. I ordered to go online. I had to modify the pickup time in order to run another errand. They answered the phone promptly, understood my requests and asked clarifying questions. My food was hot and delicious when I got home. We need to continue to support small independent businesses such as this one or face the doom of soulless chain restaurants that treat you as a number they desire to extract as much money as they can out of.“

“Awesome food and the owners are great!“

“The Robin’s Nest is easily my favorite sandwich shop in Utah. The sandwiches are fantastic, but the service is what really sets this place apart. By my third visit, the cashier—who I think might also be the owner—recognized me, handed me a punch card, and even credited my previous visits. Despite how busy they get, the team moves quickly and keeps things running smoothly.
My only real complaint is that their hours are limited, and they only have the one downtown location. Then again, that might be a blessing for my health.“

“Curtis is the best guy. Freshest ingredients. Best subs hands down, regardless of what you choose on the menu.“

“I’ve been to this location at least once a week this past month. I’ve been SO IMPRESSED with the general manager, Peter. Every time I come in he is actively engaging with customers, even when it is busy. He truly is setting the example for his team. The customer service he provides is outstanding and I hope the company knows how lucky they are to have him.“

“Not your average sandwich shop. The food is so good it's almost ridiculous. These guys get it. I don't know who the chef is behind this menu but it is perfectly curated.
The flavors - the quality ingredients - I love it!
Generous portions and fair prices. Great addition to the SLC food scene.“

“Dillion made our experience memorable. He greeted us with enthusiasm and amazing customer service. The Philly steak sandwich was the best we have ever had. The Italian was crisp and fresh. We are so grateful our area gets an amazing and affordable restaurant. Dillion was impressive with not even a wasted movement. His speed and precision had our food ready so quick that I was shocked. We were first timers to this place and can’t wait to return. I liked the options for their sodas and chips.“

“It was a bit tricky to find (it is on the second floor #421) but once I did wow!!! Where to start? The staff and owner are extremely friendly and inviting, the food quality and portion sizes are out of this world. Especially if you're comparing to a similarly priced lunch at a different restaurant! Even the half size portions are enough for 2 meals which is so appreciated in this current economy! Thank you Jeff and the rest of the Knickerbockers crew for always making my visits an amazing experience ❤️“

“Love this store the service is great“

“The staff were very friendly! I came into the store to pick up my mobile order from the app and the worker noted that they hadn’t received it. Odd because it’s the right location and time. I confirmed the order was for the correct store and provided an email receipt. We come to find out someone stole our bag at the pick up. This was over $100 worth of sandwiches. Thankfully the employees honored our receipt and remade our sandwiches. From a family who is exhausted and just finished moving, thanks for turning the situation around!“

“Dudes. I thought Quiznos was gone. Was so stoked when I found this location. Chicken carbonara sandwhich was just like I remembered. So friggin’ good.
It’s not close to my house but I’ll be going out of my way from time to time for a great lunch!“

“Rico y abundante definitivamente muy recomendable“

“The food here was absolutely delicious! We had turkey subs and they were high quality. Stuffed with ingredients and fresh! We got the mini cookies and they were so good! The service was awesome. The guy making our sandwiches was very nice and conversed with us while making our food! Wish I could go back but I’m in Montana! Definitely recommend eating here!“

“Eaten here twice now and will be back. Both times I had the vegetarian potato with a side of soup. A family member said the French dip sandwich was great. Husband enjoyed the Italian sandwich. The staff is very friendly and helpful as well.“

“Best Sandwhich In slc! The bread is so fresh and delicious. Always a great experience. Family shop, nice people. Huge sandwiches. Highly recommend 💕👍👌“

“I love going to Oh Mai. One of the best dishes to enjoy. I have been a customer with them for many many years and often go to their locations in South Salt Lake and Salt Lake City. I went in to their South Jordan location and ordered their P.5 - Ribeye & Brisket Pho and on the menu board behind the cash register they have the prices listed as $12.99. I ordered it and was charged $15.46 after tax (before tax $14.25) on my receipt. I thought maybe they made a mistake on the charge so I asked the sweet lady who charged me about the price error. Her reply was that the prices on the menu board are 10 years old and the prices of things have increased. I felt bamboozled by the false advertisement of the price on the menu board.

I hope they can have one of their employees take some time to help place new price tags on the menu board soon or perhaps letting their customers know that the prices are incorrect on the menu board and relay them verbally the new price or hand them an up to date menu with correct prices. Oh Mai thank you so much for being a part of Utah and making delicious food!“

“Always a great experience going to this location. Best people! If you go at noon be prepared to wait for a moment... But if you order online for no extra fee you can skip the line and get your food! Always have a wonderful experience going here, will definitely return and recommend!!“

“Curtis is the best guy. Freshest ingredients. Best subs hands down, regardless of what you choose on the menu.“

“I LOVED the girl that tended to my father and I for our order. Super bubbly, super sweet, and just had an amazing overall personality of working there. I also work in a restaurant setting kind of like this place, and it’s people like her that just keep the atmosphere positive and alive. I wish I got her name! Would’ve LOVED to have been friends with her! Thanks you guys! 07/10/2025 @2:10pm-2:30pm“

“Quick service, the sandwich was fresh and delicious!!“

“Two thumbs up and 5 stars! How is that for ya!“

“Love Jersey Mike’s but if you have a bogo coupon for a 6” and one of them ends up being a foot long (which is more than the coupon asks you to spend, you won’t get the other 6” for free. Dumbest policy I’ve ever heard of.“

“I love subway.It's so good.I wish that some of the employee would take time to make this sandwiches.Look a little better when they put it together. Some of them just throw all the veggies and stuff, and like a big pile, whatever, I guess it comes out.The same“

“Best service with a great attitude. These guys were great! Jessi and his coworker were so nice and polite. I feel like it’s hard to find good customer service these days- and both of these gentleman were just the best- even on a busy day during the holidays 😊. Thank you!“

“I had an awesome experience at this Subway! Mykol and Jared were both incredibly friendly and made my whole visit way better than I expected. The place was clean, the ingredients were fresh, and the service was top-tier. Definitely one of the best Subway visits I’ve had!“

“Pasta was delish and kids meal was awesome for my kid too. Love the refillable coffee. Went here after visiting the Natural Museum and stayed till the weather outside was less than 90 degrees. it was conveniently close. Made our SLC visit memorable. Would highly recommend 👍 Can’t wait to visit the branch near us in San Diego next. 😊“

“We had a small family gathering with a lot of food sensitivity and allergy issues. Cadan’s expertise in the cross contamination and safety protocols has been a life saver for our family. We are grateful to be so fortunate to receive such valuable support and care. Give that man a raise!“

“I love Jimmy John's! Always good, always the correct order and best of all, super freaky fast!! Keep up the good work. :)“

“Stopped in a had a sandwich for lunch. It was great. The German chocolate chocolate chip cookies was amazing.“

“I work nearby so I've come by very often in the past year. The food is good but the place gets 5 stars for the stellar costumer service I receive from the amazing ladies that work here. Every visit without failure I'm greeted kindly, spoken to with patience, and when it's busy, I've seen them work extremely efficiently and fast. Just wow. 10/10“

“As someone who's worked at subway for years before, Alejandro is an incredible sandwich maker. I hope a manager sees this, as this person deserves immense praise. At the end of a long 10 hour shift, they still gave incredible customer service, held conversation and were very kind, and had the best sandwich making I've seen from dozens of subways. I will be returning because of this incredible person.“

“By far the best Jimmy Johns experience I have ever had in my life! Only seconds after I paid, I had an 8 inch pepe and a bag of chips in my hands. Justin was super quick and even gave me a high five, making me feel special. Give that guy a raise! I will definitely be returning.“

“Love it! tiene las mejores tortas que eh probado =)“