10 Best Coffee Shops in Bainbridge Island

“Excellent coffee and service! Give them a try“

“A cute little coffee shop off the main strip. Pegasus is clearly a local favorite by how busy it was midday on a Thursday!

I could see them getting so busy the line would snake out the door, so we were lucky to sneak in before the crowd and order one of their specialty drinks, a cardamom latte!

The drink tasted authentic, not using artificial syrups or sugar. We would have loved to stay and enjoy the cozy ambiance, but we had more of the island to explore.“

“The perfect tiny cafe enjoyed by neighbors and visitors alike.“

“OMG. It's Amazing!! We went to the Witch's Haunted High Tea Service and it was EXTRAORDINARY! Do not miss this. We do afternoon tea service all over. I have a three sisters and it's our fun thing to find unique and eclectic places to have a proper tea service. The food was incredible and the tea was spot on. One side note i would change is the only way to make reservations is you have to call but they squeezed us in.“

“We love our local market! Town & Country has grown and updated their interior beautifully! We love it. If I have ever had a question or an issue with a product I have spoken with the appropriate department person and have always had a speedy and positive response. Many changes to products have happened over the last year, with occasional hiccups as new things are tried. But, we have found that ultimately it has all been for the better. The store may be sleeker, but the heart is still there in spades. I am amazed how they came through for us during COVID and still are! Kudos, Bainbridge Island T&C!“

“An Island Gem!
This charming spot is one of my favorite island finds. Their sandwiches and quiches are always delicious—thoughtfully made and full of flavor. The bakery case is consistently stocked with homemade, freshly baked, tempting treats that are hard to resist. There’s plenty of easy parking, and the outdoor seating is just lovely: sweet little iron tables nestled among potted flowers, perfect for soaking up the sunshine and relaxing with something tasty. 🌸☀️ Highly recommended!“

“a wonderful bustling place full of courteous able people!“

“very nice staff! i enjoy going there.“

“I often stop by The Marketplace during my work lunch breaks or on a Saturday afternoon, and it’s always a treat. Their chicken pita dish is delicious, and the side of baklava makes for the perfect sweet finish. The atmosphere is warm, friendly, and inviting — a wonderful place to relax and enjoy a meal or a bottle of wine. I highly recommend spending some time in this delightful establishment. A special thank you to Nikos and Alexis for their outstanding hospitality!“

“Loved the panini I ordered today, it was very tasty & the staff member was super nice.“