15 Best Sandwich Shops in Appleton

“We were in the area and decided to pick up a couple of subs to take home. The service was very friendly and professional. Our sandwiches came out promptly and were very good! We will definitely return.“

“So glad we still have this place. Thier sandwiches are still the best and its a shame we dont have more shops. Some places have one sandwich I like but this place has a few and they always bring limited time sandwiches worth trying. They have great soups, chicken wild rice is my goto but beer cheese and cheddar broccoli soup are great when I'm in the mood for it. That soft and tasty piece of bread you get on top of your sandwich is always great to dip in your soup or just eat by itself. This will always be my goto for subs.“

“Great sandwich! Excellent service!“

“I always like eating at a Jersey Mike’s when I donate a sub. They have good options and have great ingredients. I was particular struck by the amazing customer service and kindness in this staff at the Appleton location. I rarely take the time to leave reviews, but 5 stars all around d for this crew.“

“glenn fresh bread and heaping meats and cheese are delicious“

“Do the subway rewards and have yet to offer reception of my rewards at this location...other locations kindly give me my $2.00 rewards toward purchase???
Remember only till 8 pm Saturday and Sunday the young worker had to kick someone out that tried to get service at 7:59:59pm...“

“Jimmy John’s is pretty much the standard sub place that most people go to. Their subs are good, but the competition is really starting to pick up with other sub places that are catching up to Jimmy John’s with quality and speed. Jimmy John’s is ‘good’, but not great, but I do like their bread.“

“My goodness, I've never seen someone work so fast and still get things right! Sandwich artist was working alone during the lunch hour; people in line, someone with a huge order, plus called-in orders. She was just amazing. 10/25 11:35 a.m.“

“Could not decide for the life of me what to eat. Glad I stopped here! Clean store, friendly staff, and most importantly GOOD SUBS. The New York Steamer was a flavorful sandwich! They didn’t have White bread because I came in late but the wheat was very soft and tasted good! Will be coming back :D“

“First n foremost I would like to recognize Manager Andrew for the upmost professionalism in our recent visit we are regular customers at your location I'm proud to give great comments to the employees that earned it you have an excellent employee here Jimmy John's I just wish there were more employeees like Andrew in the fast food industry that made me feel that I meant something to them as a customer I felt right at home like we were family I will be back regularly this makes for a rating of 100% guest satisfaction with 110% recommendation thank you Andrew your the best !!“

“I’m consistently amazed by the positive customer service at this location. I realize it’s not easy to service hungry mall customers all day, but this location does so with price, friendliness, and efficiency. Kudos to them. The young man, whose name escapes me, even struck up a conversation with me while serving his line. This location does a great job!“

“Jimmy John’s has become my go-to spot for a quick, satisfying meal. Their sandwiches are consistently fresh, with high-quality meats, crisp veggies, and that perfectly soft-yet-crusty bread that makes every bite worth it. I especially love the #12 Beach Club – the avocado spread is a game-changer!

What really sets Jimmy John’s apart is their speed. Whether I’m ordering in-store, online, or through delivery, my food is always ready fast and made just the way I like it. The staff is friendly and efficient, and the locations are always clean and well-kept.

If you’re looking for a reliable, no-fuss sandwich place with great taste and unbeatable speed, Jimmy John’s delivers—literally and figuratively.“

“The store was completely void of people. As with most of the subways, that I have been to, they are always pushing you with questions on what you want. When you haven't been in a store for a while, it takes time to review the rather large menu boards up behind the counter, as they have changed their appearance and corporate must have had some idea what they were going for, with all the colors and sizes of letters, and I just makes it harder to find and identify what you want or might like to try. I much prefer the KISS principle. That's why I usually go to Jimmy John's, you give them a number and you can get the heck out of there.“

“Got 12 " to share w/ the wife. When I asked her how it was, She asked what I ordered. I aid "all Meats." She looked and there were NO MEATS!!! Complained to the staff, the manager and no results . TERRIBLE EXPERIENCE! DO Not Patronize them~~~~

Parking: Iy sucks!“

“Definitely one of the better subway experiences I've had in a long time but i guess i normally frequent one of the worst ones in the area 💀 did some research on nearby subways and this is definitely one of the better ones and the one in Walmart in Darboy is the lower end. Didn't look into all of them though“