50 Best American Restaurants near Butler

“We were visiting Milwaukee and were seeking something close to our hotel on the search for pub food. Our expectations were surpassed. Great atmosphere, service and food. My daughter and I recommend the baked French onion soup and burgers. You won't be disappointed!“

“Last two times I have gone here I have had bad food. Fried chicken livers way over done, and beef shank was dry and tough, variable were under cooked to he point of being raw. And last time I went somehow my bill came out to $168. I had drinks and bought cocktails mix to go, but just seemed like too much after I thought about it. Not sure if I trust restaurant manger, seemed to be playing around with the bill.“

“We had an amazing time last night at McCoco’s! Miguel, the owner came and greeted us and checked on our table many times and is very friendly and kind. We will definitely be coming back in the future and will recommend friends and family to enjoy a meal or two there as well!“

“Arrived around 9:15am, we only had to wait for 15 minutes which was good. My partner and I both ordered the corned been hash which was also good! We weren’t a fan of the poached egg that was on top, but that was more of a preference thing. It had a sweet taste to it, so it was just different, not bad. Our waiter Jose was great! I had ordered an iced coffee which was coffee pour over ice (I was expecting creamer with it) Jose had no problem bringing over creamer for me which made it so much better! Only spent $44 (w/o tip) which was fair. We would not mind returning when visiting Milwaukee again!“

“Burgers & Bloody Marys were great. I had the Loser burger. Fries nice and crispy. Service was very good despite being busy & they gave us a free choice of a sugar cookie or chocolate chip cookie to all in party when check was received. Nice surprise. A bit of a wait initially & parking not always the easiest but worth it!“

“Fantastic burgers at any price, but for $10.75 you get the Big O, or a little less for the other burgers. Sides are great. Service is great (and usually pretty fast). Have yet to have a bad experience, and I don’t expect I will. I go out of my way to come here for lunch. Truly a hidden gem, although probably not for much longer.Parking: There’s a significant curb to get over to get into the parking lot. If you drive a low car, park on the street.Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“A group of seven of us went there on Monday night. The overall experience left us with mixed feelings. Scallop Specials: Introduced by the staff serviced our table. It's too Salty, also it's more expensive compared to other main dishes on the dinner menu. Chicken & Mushroom Risotto: it tasted fine, but not to my standard. Tip Calculated Automatically One aspect that caught us off guard was the automatic tip calculation. Without asking, the restaurant included the tip in our total bill. While we appreciate the convenience, it would have been nice to have the option to adjust the tip based on our experience. Warmth of Service Unfortunately, we didn't feel particularly well-treated during our visit. The staff efficiently took our orders and delivered the food promptly, but there was a lack of warmth or personal touch. A smile or a friendly chat can go a long way in enhancing the dining experience.“

“We celebrated our dad’s 80th birthday here, the second big milestone our family has celebrated at Parkside 23. The food was absolutely delicious and our server, Aaron, did a phenomenal job! The private room was perfect for us with just over twenty guests. It was a great space and beautiful ambiance. Our event coordinator, Brittany, was very helpful and responsive! Highly recommend it!“

“This is truly a neighborhood diner that is a local favorite spot. We went on a Saturday mid-morning for brunch, and trust me . . . We were not alone. That joint was packed. We had about a 25 minute wait which was cool. Once we got seated, we were greeted by our waitress. The wait staff is not like an ordinary staff. They are a group of people that look like they just put on whatever is clean and come to work. You really don’t know who works there as the restaurant staff look like the average customer. . , it’s kinda weird, but it works. Our waitress was awesome!We had the Buffalo chicken BLT wrap with hand cut fries and creamy coleslaw and the spicy chicken quesadilla with tortilla chips w/salsa and sour cream. The food was soooo flavorful and seasoned to perfection.It’s a very busy dish place where everyone minds their own business. Loved it!!! I will be back. This restaurant should be featured on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives.“

“The BEST part of our visits is the exemplary customer service. The WELCOME door mat, the warmest ever. Aside from the delicious soups, pot roast and fish frys', it's folks like the ever loyal and longtime server, Dana, Lindsey, Tricia, Christina, Darcy, Tanya and then there's the funny, and patient gentleman greeter who coordinates and makes sure that the people flow is smooth and effortless. These folks are valuable assets to the Sluggo's dining room table and the community that chooses to gather here on a weekly basis.Vegetarian options: Salads with or without your choices of grilled meats.Parking: Plenty of parking behind the main building, and to the sides to include the area by the main entrance, furthermore easy access to two handicap spaces.Kid-friendliness: When my family visits from Texas, we often break bread here with the family to include our young grandchildren during the flexible dinner hours. The Sluggo ladies warmly welcome all youngsters who they gladly spoil as their own.“

“I have never had such amazing food like this before, freshly made and quickly prepared. Everything is cooked to order. The staff is so friendly, accommodating and welcoming. the tacos I ordered were SO good and the chips and salsa had great flavor. I’d recommend this to anyone who’s looking for a new place to try. This will be my new favorite place to stop at Every time I’m in the area. The staff here goes above and beyond to make sure you’re satisfied. Thank you for an amazing experience.“

“Love this place!! Great food, great service, great atmosphere! (Sorry no pictures).. but have had some really good salads, wraps, soups and a grilled cheese (today) that was other-worldly! You can also enjoy a beverage or good cup of coffee/latte from their bar. Highly recommend!“

“My wife and I love coming here when we're waiting for our dog to be groomed down the road. The chicken dumpling soup is awesome and I had a patty melt today. That was as good as I've had in many years. What I liked most is the service we received from Debbie. She was amazing. Debbie anticipated our needs constantly, even though they were very busy. Extremely impressed!“

“Came with a group of friends. Some have been here before. This was my first time.Had reservations, and got seated right away. Our server did a great job of getting us settled in. Super friendly, and really helpful with offering menu advice. (Thanks Matt).Had a few of the appetizers. All were hot and delicious. We especially enjoyed the bacon wrapped watermelon rinds. To us it tasted like pineapple instead of watermelon. How do they do that! So yummy.For dinner, we all got different entrees, ranging from Chicken & Waffle Salad, to the Salt Roasted Beet Salad (mine). Everyone was raving about their selections.We didn't have room for dessert, but because it was a birthday, they offered a complimentary Creme Brulee. I have had plenty of CBs, but one seemed especially good. Was there some spice/seasoning along with the caramelized sugar?What a great restaurant find! We will be back.My only "small" complaint is that the open dining room could be a bit loud at time. (Lots of people have good times)“

“Someone in the reviews prior was talking about how this place is a hidden job with such wonderful food so I had to try it out. Wow. The Philly cheese is sooo delicious! Wings were hands down the best I’ve had yet in this area. Such fair prices too with large portions. Many spots in the area cost more, have less quality, and up charge using inflation excuses. This is not one of them. I can’t wait to go back.“

“The wings, the drinks, the DJ, the staff and the weekly specials is what brings me to a new spot and keeps me coming back. This place has all of that and more. We are always greeted right away even though I see some regulars. We don’t get treated any different, the food is always hot so when I wait I know it’s because the chef is cooking it the right way.they have weekly specials like margarita Mondays, wing Wednesdays, tenderoni (chicken tenders)Thursdays, fish fry Fridays, and Saturday and Sundays are specials on micheladas and mimosas.“

“We love Cooper's Hawk. It is always a treat to eat there. The staff, ambiance, and food are outstanding. There were three of us and we all had the medallions of beef. It came with mashed potatoes and asparagus. It was just delicious and I would recommend it. It is noisy and that would be my only complaint. However, it won't keep us from returning soon.“

“"the" Kitchen in Sussex, is a hidden gem. I am hesitant to review it publicly because it may lose its small town diner feel.I have been here 2x, both times for breakfast. Fast service, friendly service, quick coffee and good. My first time I had an omelette - nothing wrong with it. The second time I had the Corned Beef with two eggs over easy - nothing wrong with it. And, a side of ham - moist and not dryed out. The wheat bread both times were good.A nice, small town diner that for me does it right.I will be back (at least) 1x per week.“

“This was with out a doubt the best meal of my life. Everything was perfect. We had scallops, halibut, venison, all cooked and seasoned to perfection. The service and ambience was top notch. For dessert we had an almond roasted pear .. incredible ! The evening was so great I took a copy of the menu to remind me how special of a night this was. From now on every time I am in Milwaukee I will arrange my schedule to make sure Lagniappe is a part of it. Just plain phenomenal. Thank you to chef Andy and all his employees for a remarkable experience.“

“This was literally the best experience we’ve had somewhere. We came in and our toddler just started screaming. We were about to leave when the manager came over and offered him a cookie to calm him down. Amazing. We asked if we could order his food before ours, so another server got his order, and his food was out within two minutes. It made us so happy that we were treated like that. We just wanted to be able to go out and eat, and you all made it happen. Thank you to our server Jayden, the other server, the manager, and kitchen for making our toddler(and us) happy!“

“My husband and I have been coming to this eatery since it reopened under new ownership with Carlos who had formerly been the cook at the North Avenue Grill for several years. Though we will not be returning customers to this eatery, it's no reason for me/us to discourage others from eating here. The food is delicious. It's served hot and fresh. And we also prefer to do business with small businesses such as the Midtown Grill. But on our last recent visit, and this was not the first mishap, my food was not served as I had ordered, but I didn't complain. On this last visit, I didn't complain either, but I did exclaim to our wait person that I was unhappy with my platter. The Huevo Ranchero eggs were, and I had asked for two, instead of the three, overcooked, and it was too salty for me to enjoy. Well, as I watched the wait person walk away, I noted that the server engaged the cooks re: my food and from their body language it was obvious that my constructive critique was not received in good form. Shoulders were shrugged, and this implied to me that they didn't care. This behavior told me everything I needed to know re: my customer satisfaction. This is unfortunate because we enjoyed coming to this laid back eatery. We were provided a discount of which I DID NOT ask for, and I tried to explain to the server that it wasn't necessary, but I was left speaking to their back as they chose to walk away. This behavior towards me was rude and disrespectful. If an establishment does not want need or want your business, the wait staff can certainly help to make or break a customer's spirit.“

“Cafe Hollander Mequon was wonderful! I had Easter lunch there with my family; the food was delicious and the service was excellent! Shout out to our server Monica who was fantastic! She was super attentive and handled our sassy table with style and grace! ^_^Dietary restrictions: Great gluten-free menu! ^_^“

“Mandi is an amazing server/bartender. Our drinks and food were served quickly and we didn't wait too long for any refills. She always has a smile on her face and communicates with every single customer. She is friendly and an asset to Liquid Johnny's. We will definitely be coming back!“

“My husband agrees that the duck fat burger is one of the best he’s ever had! I love the vegetarian fat noodles they’ve had on the menu during the winter season, seriously mouth watering.. but pretty spicy (the Thai chilis they put in there are no joke and last time I was crying at the table for a good 25mins because I accidentally ate one), I wish there was a warning about that. The cocktails are good, but not anything fabulous or fancy. We’ve been back once since our first time there a couple months ago!“

“Surprisingly good food, Much better than you expect! The bartenders are super professional and really know their stuff. The result is a fantastic bar to hang out at and get a bite. Give it a visit, you'll be impressed.Parking: Parking is a bit tight, come early if you want a good spot.“

“Our first time here, and we loved it ! As soon as we walked in, we were surprised . Quick service, friendly smiles and the food was really good ! It's about 15$ a person for breakfast . The only downside was 3$ for a soda with ONE refill only. We will be back when in Milwaukee!“

“The atmosphere is clean and fun. The service is great. The menu has many options and the food is delicious. Pricing is justified with the quality and quantity of the food served. I can't wait to come back to enjoy another very pleasant experience.“

“Went here for a Marquette Big East Tournament game during lent on a Friday. Lots of TVs, packed house, our servers seemed cool under pressure though and the upstairs had the game volume on.Food was good, tried a lot of different things and bartender was a little hammered but he seemed like he was still on top of his game lol.“

“I have been coming to Nicky Migz for the better part of two years.I have to say, the staff has always been there for me and my family, I have two daughters that love the family friendly and inclusive atmosphere.Yes the GM has had some demons and over my interactions I am confident to say he and their family have shown me nothing but to be a honest and thoughtful family.althoughthere has been instances of delayed service and wait times it has always been made correct. I willContinue to support Nicky migz bar and grill as long long as they continue to accept and support every single person who enters their establishment.“

“Nice place to drink after a long day at work. The service is very fast even on busy days. The food is your typical bar type food. Nothing special. A local place the coworkers go after work because it is close by. The enter and exit is confusing because driveway is hidden. So because very caution.“

“I've been to First Watch a few times, and I'm always very impressed at how nice their staff is to customers. My go to meal is the half salad and sandwich. They have a very good Cobb salad, fresh tasting ingredients. I also like how you can join the waitlist online.“

“this was my first visit to Ivee's! the food was very good and the staff was attentive. I have been a customer for a good many years to the Sawmill and Odyssey restaurants and Ivee's by far exceeds their standards! I hope they take their business away as they deserve it! Thank you!“

“I was concerned about how one could "dress up" macaroni and cheese.....Mac's did it fantastically! I actually ordered 3 different skillets/plates because I could not make my mind up. The original mac and cheese was very creamy and tasted pretty good. I enjoyed the toasted cheese on top.The second dish was the Buffalo Mac and Cheese. It came with a celery stick and a little toasted bread slice. I really could have used a few more celery sticks as one was definitely not enough. The crumbled blue cheese was a nice flavor touch, though a dressing would have been nice to cute the spicyness of the sauce. The Buffalo chicken was a nice add-in to the Mac and cheese. Again, spicy Buffalo chicken, which was wonderful.The third skillet was the Carnitas Mac and Cheese. This skillet was awesome! The different ingredients did not make if feel like a Mac and cheese add-on topping, but a wonderful dish! I loved the black beans and corn with the tortilla chips sprinkled on top. The seasoned shredded pork was seasoned very nicely. I actually did not finish all the dishes because I was eating too much, but the Carnitas Mac and Cheese was the one I wanted to bring home as a leftover. That was the overall winner of the three!The associate, Josh, who took our order, was very personable and pleasant. His smile definitely made me feel like I was not bothering him when I went back to order dessert...the chocolate cake. When we go back in the future, it would be nice to have Josh serve us again.Very pleased with our overall experience.“

“The 4 patty build-yer-own Angus burger with American cheese slices in the middle of each patty was unbelievably amazing. Very juicy with just the perfect amount of grease oozing.It was so good, I ordered another one 20 min later.Kaitlan, our server, did a fantastic job with our party of 4.Milwaukee water was clear and refreshing.We got done eating and went straight to Saz's circle bar and had a few more rounds.Looking forward to another visit to Saz's State House“

“I have been going to brass key for 13 years! We've had birthday parties, parties after both my mother in law and my daughter passed. We go there for fish fry Fridays, or to just go for their amazing breakfast and lunch options. Not had a bad experience, no complaints here. The staff recognizes all their loyal customers, they greet, treat you with respect, courtesy each time you visit. I enjoy their great food, company, and overall hope they don't go out of business“

“It was recommended to us from a local business that we made a stop at first as we live an hour away and wanted to get lunch before our drive back. FANTASTIC recommendation, great atmosphere, excellent food, waitress was wonderful. Thought it was going to take a bit to get our order, it did not, it was out within 15 minutes, our full order. I purchased the BBQ sauce to go to use on my own ribs this weekend. Ecstatic, as this is the best homemade BBQ sauce I have ever tasted.Crispy brussel Sprouts ✔️Cheese curds ✔️Smokin' Annie ✔️Candied Whiskey Bacon Burger ✔️Fries ✔️You will not be disappointed whatever you order off this menu!!“

“Easily a hidden gem. The food is outstanding. Excellent tacos, fried chicken sandwiches, quesadillas. A must try. Easily some of the best food in the area.Dietary restrictions: They do have gluten free things on the menu. My wife has Celiac's and she is safe to eat there.“

“First time here and we’ll surely be back. Appetizers were delicious, we ordered the French onion dip and Brussels. Ended up splitting the Buffalo chicken sandwich which was nice and crispy. Service was 10/10. All around a great experience. Amazing drink menu too!“

“I gave them 5 Stars for Atmosphere but don’t expect a 5 Star restaurant this is a quant small town bar/ restaurant. We go for the Friday Fish Fry, they take your order when you arrive and seated when food is ready. I had the Baked Cod I have a big appetite and was very satisfied with the LARGE portion at a reasonable price. They are always packed but with their efficient system you get served in a reasonable time.Dietary restrictions: I had the Baked Cod with Butter no sides .Parking: Parking lot can get full when busy but there is street parking adjacent to restaurant.“

“When I first walked in I thought; ‘Crap, almost no wait staff.’ BUT, glad I stayed! Great service, great chow and very affordable. I went in because I was nearby and wanted breakfast. Next time it will be because I PLANNED to have breakfast here!“

“Two brothers with my cousins. So, let me get into it! The food at two brothers is very diner like from back in the 90’s. It was okay defiantly a breakfast kind of meal for sure! The service was amazing! Our waitress checked in often and also waters and coffees filled up. The atmosphere was Nostalgic the pictures and the décor really took me back and it was a very pleasant feeling of home. For a good meal and nostalgic feeling check out two brothers!“

“lovely local diner with good food and good service [cash only]I tried this place out for the first time this past weekend after being recommended by a friend and was not disappointed.It's a small restaurant that physically is showing signs of its age, but the good food and friendly staff more than make up for it in my opinion.They're a cash only business and only open breakfast-lunch, but prices are absolutely reasonable and I would definitely recommend stopping here if you're in the area and looking for a bite to eat.Parking: parking next to the restaurant is limited to a few street spots in front, the next door liquor store does have a parking lot and there is free street parking nearby if you're willing to walk a block“

“You won't be disappointed in the food, its really good. I just can't get over the beer prices.. 10 dollars for a beer is insane. 7-10 dollars for craft/local beer.. shooo. The food is worth checking out though. ??? Get the Half-Chicken if you want something fried and fantastic.“

“This is a great local restaurant/bar. The people were friendly, even though I wasn't a regular. We ate at the bar, the bartender was nice, with a little sass.I had the Rib Special. Everything about it was good, the ribs fell off the bone, pretty good BBQ flavor.I will definitely go back.“

“Went with a group of 8. My small sirloin with a side of garlic creamed spinach was excellent, but I was told the ribs were lackluster. The servers were friendly and competent. Food and drinks are both a bargain here, with a huge array of cocktails offered at $8, and steak about 30% cheaper than on average. It's a working man's steak house, small, intimate, with good food without pretensions. Dress up, dress down, nobody cares. Desserts were delicious, too.Wheelchair accessibility: Ramp and single level. They will accommodate.“

“under new management - chicken aren't as good as they used to be... but still good.- fried whole wings - deliciously golden, not too salty. They are whole wings, in 3 sections, which is nice if you like the wing tip area like I do.- potato wedges - these are more expensive than regular fries, but there's no Merrit in paying the extra. Regular fries are pretty good, and the wedges are subpar.Oh, and don't get lost. They are located right on the corner of Teutonia and Good Hope, inside the gas station. (and don't get gas here - it's cheaper just down the street)“

“Definitely a little hole in the wall kind of place, a few tables to sit and eat. Typical kind of ma and pa sandwich shop. The service was good and fast, nice and easy to place an order. The price was fair for what you get. And finally the Reuben was pretty solid. I'm sure you can get it made how you want if you ask. It was a little heavy on the sauerkraut for me, but I can see how others may like more of it. The meat was nice and juicy and really soaked in the bread. I also had a Chicago dog and it was alright It was just a little cold. I'll definitely be back to try some other things. Overall I'd suggest anyone to try it.“

“I came at prime brunch time and was welcomed warmly by both the barista behind the counter and also a waitress when I transitioned into the dining area. The person I was with and I had a lot to chat about and our waitress came back like three times before we finally ordered our drinks; she was so kind and didn't pressure us to keep it moving. My Bloody Mary was good: it included a huge pickle and a chaser. I got the spicy chorizo hash and it was huge; the potatoes aren't crispy though--that's the only thing I wished were different. The sourdough toast was perfect and I'd come back again because everything on the menu looked really good!“

“This "hole in the wall" bar is a must stop. I love visiting bars like this because of the community they provide. I was welcomed by the locals and had great conversation through my visit.The area is out in the country and can be tricky to find. Once I arrived, there was plenty of street parking as well as a lot in the back The inside was charming with a vintage vibe. Drinks were strong and their menu is lengthy. I ordered a cup of the soup which was styled after the Reuben sandwich. The corned beef was excellent. The soup is creamy and flavorful. I have tried to stop by again but they are only open Tuesday through Thursday. I wish I had checked the menu it because the reviews online show a fish fry but I'm not sure if that's available daily since they're closed on Friday? I hope you find out soon!“

“I just want to Thank Libby Montanna's for accommodating our reservation for 18 people . Our waitress staff were amazing , the food was delish and was delivered by multiple people to make sure is was delivered hot and all together I can't say enough how awesome this resturaunt is. Once the food was delivered our waitress asked how our food was and how everything was in general....which was good follow thru. Afterwards we saw Joe 2.0 which was exceptional..what a great night and thanks Libby Montanna for being q part of it.“