13 Best Pizza Restaurants near Cross Plains

PJ's Pizza Pizza • $
1830 Main St, Cross Plains

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Calzone
Pizza

“I can't spread the word fast enough about how much we love ordering from PJs. Our boys love getting their own All Mine pizza's and of course breadsticks. The hubby and I love the Calzones. They are huge! And who could say no to the pepperoni rolls? Thanks PJs for being our go to on pizza night!“

4.5 Superb43 Reviews
Novanta Pizza • $
8452 Old Sauk Rd, Middleton - 6.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Truffle Gelato
Build Your Own Pizza
Graham Cracker Cake
Vegetarian Pizza
Mozzarella Ball
Salsiccia Pizza
Gorgonzola Salad
Diavola Pizza
Lemon Sorbeto
Pizza Nutella

“Really good pizza at a fair price. We got the Salsiccia and the Lombarda. The Salsiccia was definitely the better pizza but both were very tasty in different ways. The tomato sauce shines through! Novanta is a great option when you want something different than the greasy standard pizza.“

4.6 Superb79 Reviews
On the Rox Pizza • $
8901 County Hwy Y, Sauk City - 9.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Loaded Italian Beef Sandwich
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Philly Cheese Steak
Rox Supreme Pizza
Bavarian Pretzel
Pickle Pizza
Meat Lovers
Taco Salad
Meat Pizza
Beef Taco

“we ate pizza and had beer on Dec 2..pizza was amazing! Beer was good, too. But enough about that..I'm an elderly lady prone to forgetfulness..and I inadvertantly left my purse that had a wallet given to me by my daughter and which means the world to me .I searched our house and called every place I thought I had left it. Finally texted The Rox and they had it! My gratitude to this wonderful restaurant!“

4.6 Superb45 Reviews
Wall Street Gallery & Bistro Italian • $$
14 Brodhead St, Mazomanie - 8.2 miles

“I have been to this place a few times with my boyfriend. We love the martinis and wine selection. The specials are amazing, the pizza is always hot fresh and tastefully done and the decor is always warm, inviting and fun. It's a wonderful drive out there on Highway 14 from Madison - and the couple that runs the place are hardworking, beautiful and amazing individuals who provide the most wonderful tasting dishes in the area. It's a gem - and the food is always tasty. My boyfriend is obsessed with the stroganoff sauce and the Beef Tenderloin - and I had the beautiful medley special of vegetables, green pasta and alfredo sauce. They also freshly bake the loaf of bread to order so it is always hot and fresh when it is received at your table. The dessert is always amazing as well - if you aren't too full from your meal to enjoy it! I highly recommend and love this place - and I hope you will too!“

5 Superb13 Reviews
Villa Dolce Italian • $$
1828 Parmenter St, Middleton - 7.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp & Scallops Linguine
Goat Cheese Bruschetta
Wild Mushroom Ravioli
Gelato Experience
Crispy Calamari
Truffle Fries
Salmon Salad
Meat Lovers
Bolognese
Tiramisu

“Villa Dolce is a consistently wonderful experience. No matter what day of week, or week of year, the service is impeccable, the bartenders are talented, the food is amazing, and the overall experience is absolutely worth it. Highly recommend!!“

4.3 Superb85 Reviews
Good Co. at Pioneer Pointe Cocktail Bar • $$
3730 Manistee Way, Verona - 5.37 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cedar Grove Cheese Curds with Choice of Ranch or Bacon Aioli
Everything Bagel with Lox
Build Your Own Pizza
Good Co Harvest Salad
Spicy Fried Chicken
Bacon Cheeseburger
Clam Chowder Soup
Eggs Benedict
Wedge Salad
Hamburger

“We love everything about this restaurant!! Great staff, food and decor!! Emily was so friendly at the bar! Make sure to check out the facade under the counter at the bar! It was handmade with individually painted golf balls— very cool look! We were super lucky to have Kyle, who normally bartends, as our server— he’s absolutely hilarious and we had a ton of fun with him!! And the calzones are so good, as are their salads and fries w/ aioli!! Keep up the great work everyone! We appreciate you!!!Vegetarian options: Vegetarian options are yummy: soups, salads, mushroom cheese & spinach calzonesParking: Plenty of free parking“

4 Good58 Reviews
Brix Cider Cideries • $
119 S 2nd St, Mt Horeb - 8.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Weekly Burger Special Blue Cheese and Pear
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Flight of Ciders
Cookies
Salad
Soup

“Brix cider offers a wide variety of ciders served in a relaxed atmosphere. The flights are a great way to sample the breadth of their offerings at a reasonable price. Nearly all their ciders are available to take home as well if you find a couple you like. The staff was friendly, and the service was prompt. The bathroom was clean and well stocked, also.“

4.2 Good55 Reviews
Papa Murphy's | Take 'N' Bake Pizza Pizza • $
1021 N Edge Trail, Verona - 10 miles

Customers` Favorites

Herb Chicken Mediterranean Pizza Baking Required

“I love Papa Murphy's but the atmosphere needs to change the atmosphere needs to be looking like in the jungle you know something look like nature and flowers and leaves hanging them from the roof and it's look like that when you walk into the front desk it should look like that or Hawaii treesVegetarian options: They got salads and stuff if you don't want no pizza and it got the keto Pizza we just put in a bowlKid-friendliness: Oh yes kid friendly I need to have like a little playground for them to play if they're going to order pizza oh it's cooking they should have like a little playset but I can just play for a little bit like McDonald's or theme park in the building“

4.3 Superb10 Reviews
PipPop Pizza Mt. Horeb Pizza • $$
1213 Springdale St, Mt Horeb - 8.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Poppy Cheese Pizza

“First time having the food here. My wife loved the tandoori and the pizza is very tasty. The gentleman who helped us Jacob I believe was his name was very friendly and made our first visit very enjoyable. Will definitely try again when in town and looking for good pizza and Indian food.Parking: Parking right in front very convenient“

4.1 Good27 Reviews
Wiscow Pizza - Middleton Pizza Delivery •
8313 Murphy Dr, Middleton - 6.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Create-Your-Own Pizza
3.6 Good9 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery •
7468 Mineral Point Rd, Madison - 8.12 miles

“?????Customer Ser,?? is A1? here! I thought there kindness & compassion is Awesome.? Food Always Hot & Ready?? to dig in man because im not waiting till i get home u ?know u always gotta have a 1 appetizer pulled out da box ?b4 leaving out ur vehicle to go inside to ur kitchen table to eat it.??‍♀️??‍♀️ ???""Pizza Pizza""???????? ??????????ALWAYS A 10 ?? Thanks Guy's!!i gotta start remembering yalls name . ✌?✌?✌?“

3.5 Good13 Reviews
Pizza Hut Pizza Delivery • $
1848 US-18, Mt Horeb - 7.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Breaded Boneless Wings
Breadsticks

“Until now, the last time I had a great Pizza Hut experience was my grade school "Book It" days. I am really not a fan of the Pizza Hut red sauce and I LOVE pizza. Needing a quick dinner, I decided to give Pizza Hut a go. I ordered the thin and crispy pizza with an Alfred sauce base (instead of red sauce), sausage, green peppers, and bacon. I usually opt for a pan crust, but the crust absolutely did not disappoint! The edges were especially delightful. I grabbed a cold piece leftover piece for breakfast and enjoyed it immensely.My husband loved his wings and we were both incredibly happy for $20.“

3.6 Good19 Reviews
Toppers Pizza Pizza • $
7850 Mineral Point Rd, Madison - 7.82 miles

Customers` Favorites

Toppers Classic Handtossed Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Topper Pizza
Ragin Pepperoni Pizza
Parmesan Garlic Wings
Original Topperstix
Smoky BBQ Chicken
Boneless Wings
Loaded Tot-Zza
Cinnamonstix
Birthday Stix

“Amazing service. Today I picked up 6 pizzas for my daughter’s birthday party. Some of the pizzas had varying needs to accommodate food allergies. One of our sons has severe food allergies and some of our guests kids had other allergies. When I picked up the pizzas, the gentleman who handed me the pizzas let me know how they were prepared; to keep us informed of what was done for the pizzas. I was very appreciative of this and so was my wife when I told her what he told me. I’ve been to this location a number of times and it’s been great service and food every time. Highly recommend!“

3.6 Good72 Reviews