Sandwich Shops near Fitchburg

Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop •
6291 McKee Rd Suite E, Fitchburg

“First time at this new Fitchburg Jersey Mike's location and it was busy! I ordered ahead with the app and my sub was ready (so nice to be able to skip the line!). I ordered the #8 Club Sub without the red vinegar and olive oil. But last second I added the Hot Chopped Pepper Relish (free topping) and it was great! Not as hot as jalapeños, but soon much flavor. It reminded me of giardiniera. I really enjoyed this sub!Ordering through the Jersey Mike's app was easy and gave me choices to customize that I wasn't aware of. Plus you earn loyalty points towards a free sub!“

4.8 Superb10 Reviews

2
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
5957 McKee Rd, Fitchburg

“It's a subway. Everyone's had it before and it's routinely decent at least. Sometimes you don't get the ratios of toppings you want but this one has always gotten it right for me. I love a subway that has friendly people who know how to make a good sub. If you want a subway that doesn't skimp on your food, then this is the one for you“

3 Average19 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
2839 Fish Hatchery Rd Suite 3, Fitchburg

Customers` Favorites

Bread Baked

“This Saturday night crew was top notch. They were ready to serve right when I got in the door and got My sandwiches made fast, made right and delicious. They were friendly, helpful, provided great conversation and just all around good people that made me feel really welcome.I saw the person after me got their sandwich super fast too!Not sure why the reviews aren't higher, I was almost even expecting less cause of the rating, but I was pleasantly surprised to see this crew definitely gives it their all to make this a really good Jimmy John's!Thanks for your hard work and great vibes!“

3 Average31 Reviews
Jimmy John's Sandwich Shop • $
6231 McKee Rd f, Fitchburg

“I grew up in IL, so I'm fully on the JJ train.I'm still sad that the cut out the sprouts years ago, but this spot is everything you'd expect: fast and on-point.My only disappointments have been that they have run out of iced tea and the jalapeño chips on a couple of occasions. And since COVID, it seems like they never anticipate that anyone will actually sit down to eat (which I'm sure is often true). There's sometimes things like napkin inventory out on the customer tables.Either way, go JJ!“

2.7 Average33 Reviews
Saigon Sandwich Sandwich Shop • $
257-299 N Charter St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Special Combo

“Eating on campus is you know... don't get me wrong, that's any campus, institutional food is just soul-crushing on most days. So to have something like this around, a stone's throw from most buildings on the UW, fresh, consistent, flavorful, and balancing between crunchy, spicy, satisfying and wholesome, and always quick, is just bliss. The menu is very limited but there is a vegetarian option and thus might just be the best Bahn Mi-like sandwich in this our town of Madison. Perfectly complemented with a packet of simple Lays I hope this place doesn't go away any time soon and that this review doesn't make it crowded and spoil my fun. He does accept EatStreet orders so you could pre-order rush in from class or work. My favorite is the Vietnamese Meatball but you mostly can't go wrong with any of them.“

4.7 Superb78 Reviews
Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
1601 Deming Way, Middleton

Customers` Favorites

Turkey and Provolone on Wheat
Roast Beef and Provolone
The Number Four
Tuna Fish
Big Kahuna
Chips

“This location is the best! Filled with kind and welcoming employees. They were all smiling and so happy to be there and thanked every customer who gave a tip. They prepared my gluten free sandwich in the back to minimize cross contamination. They all deserve a raise! Great experience, I had to write a review.“

4.3 Superb163 Reviews
Rock'N Rollz Sandwich Co Sandwich Shop • $
5208 Farwell St, McFarland

Customers` Favorites

Turkey and Ham Sub
Squeal 'N Gobbler
blt

“I ordered 4 subs for dinner. Each sub had its own different toppings and everything was perfect. The bread was awesome and I would recommend this place anytime. I ordered the subs for pickup. I sent the order around 11am but didn't want to pick it up until 4pm. The order was ready, fresh and great!“

4.1 Good89 Reviews

8
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
8315 Murphy Dr, Middleton

“Great customer service at this location in recent weeks. Clean store, and a sense of awareness that slow sandwich turnover makes a difference. In the past 3-4 weeks I've been to 3 area Subways. Two were commendable. One failed. The Stoughton Rd. store. Slow and inept. The food appeared fresh, but the young lady seemingly the senior staff of the two, couldn't grasp the Club sandwich concept. Because the company dropped the roast beef, The Club, no longer was listed on the menu. So I'm her view, it couldn't be made. All three other stores I'm mentioning made the sandwich effortlessly adding bacon. Which traditionally is and has been a default item. Since forever. Except in Subway speak. When this worker wrapped her head around this alteration, she pulled it together. This store isn't on my map moving forward. The mazomanie store gets kudos. I've been there 5-6 times just since early last week. In fact I took a chance and gave the steak and cheese a try. Ages ago I didn't like this at all. But when built with a decidedly proper array of items, adding the chipotle mayo, OMG. I Returned that evening for a foot long version. This is the same sandwich today I'm referring to which I picked up earlier (yesterday actually) that I'm following up on. The build: meat and pepper jack cheese. Toasted. Jalapeño, red onion, pepperoncini, pickles,black olives, black pepper and the chipotle Mayo. Stellar. Tomatoes were tried once, didn't work any magic. Perhaps super fresh ones could've performed well. I want to give five stars, but can't. The subway bread isn't up to snuff. Maybe before, but either it's changed or my expectations are too high. I still hold the coveted top rank for the new kid. That Jersey Mike punk being my current top sub stop.“

4 Good67 Reviews
Crostini Sandwiches Sandwich Shop • $
231 North St, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Chicago Style Italian Beef Sandwich

“We had the French dip and gyros sandwiches, which were both quite good. A nice lunch. The restaurant interior is less funky than dumpy. We suggest a paint job, new furniture and clean up the terrazzo floor. The food is more important though. Very good!“

4.1 Good48 Reviews

10
Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
2813 N Sherman Ave, Madison

Customers` Favorites

Meatball Marinara Melt
Steak and Cheese Sub
Cookies

“I’ve been a regular customer at this subway for over 17 years. No matter how busy this shop is, the staff here make the highest quality sandwiches just the way you crave them every single time. Amanda the manager is by far the best sandwich artist subway has ever seen. Her staff are amazing, friendly and have the best work ethic compared to any other sandwich shop I’ve been to in Madison. I look forward to getting my lunch here every day I work. I hope the staff here know how much their customers appreciate them.#bestsubwayever“

4.2 Good35 Reviews
Loading...

Enjoy More Tastes In Fitchburg

map Map