Sandwich Shops near Middleton

“The manager was one of the nicest people I met while in Middleton, visiting the area for a high school hockey championship. I was immediately greeted, treated courteously and respectfully, and was overall very impressed! I know he was the manager as another individual came in to ask for a manager and he introduced himself as such. Plus, my sandwich was very good!“

“Julio is fantastic. He deserves a RAISE - do whatever it takes to KEEP him! Patient. Helpful/accommodating. Seamlessly balanced call-in orders and customers at the counter. He greeted everyone and listened to each person’s requests. Everyone we saw enter and leave appeared to be very satisfied and “seen.” (About 20 people while we ate.) He even took time to help someone with questions about the Subway app.“

“I thought Superbowl Sunday would be a perfect day for the $5 footlong cookie, but they didn't have any. Thank goodness for the amazing service, and plethora of coupons that come in the mail. We didn't need the extra calories anyway. :)“

“Chebs Hut in three ( 3 ) blunts. White Widow - all the flavors and textures especially with garlic bread, just an amazing sandwich! Magic Mushroom - yo, portobello and Asian flavors on that garlic bread, hell yeah!! Dank - pizza sub. Perfect cheese n pepperoni, lots but so yummy and perfect! Had fun at the bar, great vibe from the staff and patrons. My kinda joint 😀“

“Jen and Matt are awesome! They always get my special order correct and make me smile every time I am in there. They work hard and are very friendly. Seeing them before work makes my day better!“

“Being a big fan of Jimmy John’s has made me not venture to trying new sandwiches places, but this sandwich shop will not disappoint! The service was super fast and the sandwich was amazing! I tried the focaccia bread and I hope it sticks around! It’s amazing! I may have found my new go-to sandwich place!“

“Came to this Subway because of the positive reviews and I can confirm! I have food allergies and so I usually ask a couple kind of specific things to be done (change gloves, paper wrapping away from the cookies) to ensure my safety. They were not only happy to oblige but made me a new sandwich after a moment of miscommunication (which was completely my doing!).“

“Super friendly and great business. They also sponsored my United Asian Club event from the kindnesses of their hearts without us asking them. Thank you Saigon Sandwich for your love and support!“

“This was my first time ordering from this Jersey Mike's. I arrived on a busy Sunday around lunch time. I want to give a special shoutout to Sara who took and made my family's order. With a long line from a busy lunch rush Sara was flawless. Her fantastic attitude instantly improved my mood! She was talking, laughing and carrying on with customers while we waited and all the while diligently making multiple orders from memory . I have to say as a person who works in customer service myself (GM at a hotel group) this was some of the best customer service I have witnessed in quite some time even when faced with a large task of orders and quite a few people. Sara you keep rocking that awesome outlook on life, I want you to know it certainly did not go unnoticed!! This location is lucky to have Sara and because of her I will certainly be back. Thank you for the warm smile and good laughs Sunday, your customer service really stuck with me and I believe it should be recognized. If I could give you an award I would!“

“if you had higher than 5 stars for your employees that stick up for Jesus and love and acceptance, I would have gone higher!!!! great job!“

“This place has been such a blessing to my family I love the bread basket and Amy is the SWEETEST PERSON IN THE WORLD!! , all the volunteers are amazing people we love you guys!! Thank you for all you do!!“

“Didn't get to my break 'till after they had closed - instead of locking it up in the store or throwing it they left it outside for me. Thank you kind milios person!
Also their sandwiches are always pretty good and priced alright. 👍“

“Might be common knowledge but Jersey Mike’s has consistently been the best sandwich chain by a mile; just brought my girlfriend with celiac today and was greeted with very kindly and they made sure her allergy was well accomodated. And of course, our sandwiches were delicious as well!“

“I will NEVER EVER support this company again thanks to this location- it's "manager" and "workers" they cannot make food correct. Will not fix it. manager avoids customers to resolve issues. been 2 weeks. still waiting. not only is she/he avoiding me but the whole company is now it appears. nobody wants to take responsibility? thats how you operate? well. we shall see. AVOID AVOID AVOID AVOID AVOID BAD BUSINESS BAD BUSINESS BAD BUSINESS SICKENING!“

“Fast friendly and fresh bread. Can’t beat it.“

“Stopped here on our way from Milwaukee to Iowa. 1st time at a Milio’s.
Sandwiches were delicious! We got an Italian Sandwich & Turkey Sandwich. Our kids loved the bread!
Facilities were clean. SUPER friendly staff!
Highly recommend!
Will definitely e stopping there again in our way back.“

“Wow - what a pleasant dining option at the Memorial Union! It offers both made to order sandwiches and salads as well as grab and go items. I was totally impressed with the quinoa black salad I ordered for lunch - excellent mix of textures and the flavors of the components complimented each other. There are no tables at Carte to dine-in, but its not difficult to find a table elsewhere in the Union (Strada, the Rathskeller, the Terrace).“

“I am allergic to soy and can’t have the bread. He recommended a salad. OMG! Even if I could have soy, the salad was fantastic! It was so fresh and made so well! Thanks!“

“Get the Long Steer on a jalapeno wrap. It's delicious“

“Great Subway
Employees working here on Saturdays are awesome and very friendly.
The interior/seating area is clean.
The restrooms were clean.
The sandwiches prepared here are very good
I Will be back if I’m ever walking around the area.
Overall a great location located near camp Randall and UW Madison campus.“

“Always fast, fresh, and friendly at Jimmy John’s! The sandwiches are delicious, the service is quick, and the team works hard to keep everything running smoothly. Extra shoutout to my daughter, who works there on weekends — proud of the great job she and her coworkers do!“

“I had a wonderful visit to this location today! A girl named Sahr was working, and she was so welcoming, greeting everyone with a warm smile. She is incredibly hardworking, attentive, and does complete justice to her role. Between her amazing customer service and the great food quality, it was an excellent experience with also the clean and calm atmosphere. I will definitely recommend this place to everyone! 👍👍“

“We used to eat at Subway regularly. The prices have gone up so much that we only eat once in a blue moon but 1 main guy that works@ Northport dr.&Sherman ave.- in Sherman plaza is the reason why we will be back . His friendly & professional manner was refreshing. The food was pretty good , we had ham & turkey footlongs w/cheese, lettuce & tomatoes ... On artisan Italian - I think that's what it was called?“

“Me and my family came in ten minutes before close (SORRY QUEENS!!!) and the employees were so efficient and friendly anyway. I know from experience how hard it is sometimes to not be grumpy when customers come in and order stuff right before close, so I was SO grateful and impressed that the employees were so nice to us!!!“

“Everyone who works here is extremely nice! And I can earn rewards back on my gas with Moocho. #Winning“

“Just have to tell you that, for the first time, I visited Cousins on Park Street. My experience was outstanding. The person who waited on me was Sam, very friendly and courteous. I had never been to any Cousins before, and I commented to him that you even sell grilled sandwiches. He then offered to grill my ham and cheese sub, and to heat up my cookie. Both very delicious. It was a great first visit.“

“The bread is so fresh and perfectly sized. My sandwich included alfalfa sprouts and the were plentiful and fresh, when I came home I was able to give some to my cat and she loved them. Everything was fresh, Sorry to repeat myself but it's the truth. Staff went out of their way to make sure I was greeted and taken care of.“

“I recently gave Jimmy John’s a try for the first time and the sandwich that I ordered was very good.
I visited this location on 4/26/26 to try the Little John #4 the sandwich was prepared very well + I enjoyed the fresh bread and fresh veggies.I also gave the brownie a try which was also good.Employees were friendly.

This location is kind of small from the interior since it’s between other businesses there is some tables available but it’s best just to take it for carryout.
This location is conveniently located along State St.
Will definitely have to try other variety of other sandwiches available here.
Overall a good experience.“

“This is "THE" best Jimmy John's! Love going here! All of the guys that work here are all amazing! Mike, Ray, Juvann, and Jeff are all so very nice, genuine and very kind. They are extremely efficient, helpful, fast and the nicest guys you'll ever meet. Everything is always perfect, from the sandwiches to the chips, pickles & cookies. This is the Jimmy John's for us! Check it out! I know you'll love this location, too! Thanks guys! :)“

“It's a subway. Everyone's had it before and it's routinely decent at least. Sometimes you don't get the ratios of toppings you want but this one has always gotten it right for me. I love a subway that has friendly people who know how to make a good sub. If you want a subway that doesn't skimp on your food, then this is the one for you“

“Hot, fresh, more than normally flavorful ingredients, friendly, helpful--and one of the very be$t deal$ on State Street!“

“Great experience!!!! Food was great-and even though they ran out of bread- and clearly in a stressful night, Tessa and Murphy handled everything professionally, and with a smile and a laugh. I absolutely loved chatting with them! They are hard workers and clearly care about their jobs! Will be back! :)“

“Best Jimmy John's in Madison!!! Always been so helpful to our student organization, and Coach and Gabe were especially helpful tonight as we ran into a little issue before our big meeting! They saved us and were so kind about everything. Coach and Gabe are the best, plus they make incredible sandwiches :)“