Sandwich Shops near Middleton

“The manager was one of the nicest people I met while in Middleton, visiting the area for a high school hockey championship. I was immediately greeted, treated courteously and respectfully, and was overall very impressed! I know he was the manager as another individual came in to ask for a manager and he introduced himself as such. Plus, my sandwich was very good!“

“On the way back from a trip and came here for subway. Been to couple subways and know it really depends on the people who own it to give you a good experience. Amazing personality from the guy behind the counter and the sandwich was beyond expectations too. Recommended!“

“I thought Superbowl Sunday would be a perfect day for the $5 footlong cookie, but they didn't have any. Thank goodness for the amazing service, and plethora of coupons that come in the mail. We didn't need the extra calories anyway. :)“

“To Mike, the manager at Jimmy Johns in Middleton Wisconsin. Thank you for your amazing service and delicious food.I recently catered two different conferences using Jimmy Johns in Middleton. The customer service Mike offered was amazing. It was clear he wanted to get my order correct and he took the time to assure that. At both events, the food arrived on time, it was accurate and delicious!!I'm very happy I decided to reach out to Jimmy John's for our catering needs.Very satisfied.Karen SBaha’i Faith conference team.“

“This was my first time ordering from this Jersey Mike's. I arrived on a busy Sunday around lunch time. I want to give a special shoutout to Sara who took and made my family's order. With a long line from a busy lunch rush Sara was flawless. Her fantastic attitude instantly improved my mood! She was talking, laughing and carrying on with customers while we waited and all the while diligently making multiple orders from memory . I have to say as a person who works in customer service myself (GM at a hotel group) this was some of the best customer service I have witnessed in quite some time even when faced with a large task of orders and quite a few people. Sara you keep rocking that awesome outlook on life, I want you to know it certainly did not go unnoticed!! This location is lucky to have Sara and because of her I will certainly be back. Thank you for the warm smile and good laughs Sunday, your customer service really stuck with me and I believe it should be recognized. If I could give you an award I would!“

“Jen and Matt are awesome! They always get my special order correct and make me smile every time I am in there. They work hard and are very friendly. Seeing them before work makes my day better!“

“$4.75 for an 8 inch sub with everything on it. Yum!“

“Stopped in here for the first time after an appointment for my daughter. She is on the spectrum and went straight for the cookies before we in. The cashier (very tall guy with shorter hair I wish I got his name) was SO polite about it and was very attentive to our order especially when it came to my kiddo. The food was great. They also gave us a side of just plain grilled chicken for her for under $2 no questions asked. Highly recommended in all areas.

Vegetarian options: Very good variety and quality of veg options.“

“This is a very good subway. The staff is excellent. The food is always fresh and you can either sit inside and or it’s quick if you want takeout.

Parking: There’s plenty of parking and there is handicap parking

Kid-friendliness: It is kid friendly and they will find something they like to eat and it has comfortable seating. It’s very clean inside.

Wheelchair accessibility: You could park right in front there’s handicap parking and you can easily use a wheelchair“

“Being a big fan of Jimmy John’s has made me not venture to trying new sandwiches places, but this sandwich shop will not disappoint! The service was super fast and the sandwich was amazing! I tried the focaccia bread and I hope it sticks around! It’s amazing! I may have found my new go-to sandwich place!“