9 Best American Restaurants in Montello

“Our experience here, both camping and enjoying the restaurant and amenities has been truly great. Wouldn’t think of having Friday fish fry any where else!“

“The food is great!! staff is super friendly! delivery within10 miles. our favorite place to eat in Montello.“

“We drive from Oshkosh and camp up the road in Montello. I love this place, best burgers ever! All the food we have had has been amazing. We love the atmosphere, Jeff is so funny, rest of staff is very friendly. Highly recommend this place.“

“Excellent homemade pizza. Cozy, inviting and friendly. Highly recommend for burgers, steak sandwiches and the pizza!!!!“

“Vicki is the best! Service is great. Food is excellent for lunch and dinner. Highly recomend the Fish Fry!“

“Our daughter's wedding at The Rustic Saloon on October 10, 2025, was truly an exceptional and memorable night, thanks to the entire team. They went above and beyond to make the evening perfect, and we couldn't recommend them more highly. Exceptional Food and Service The meal for our 85 guests was the talk of the night! The fish, shrimp, and chicken were all absolutely amazing and perfectly prepared. Thank you cook’s! The entire staff, especially the servers, were fabulous to work with and spot on throughout the evening. Dave the bartender was great, keeping the night fun and flowing with his accommodating service. A Perfect Venue A special thank you to Kricket and Paul for their incredible accommodation and commitment. Shutting down the restaurant to the public on a Friday night to host our elegant and amazing wedding was a generous gesture that made the night feel incredibly personal and exclusive. We highly recommend the establishment, the food, and the entire personal (staff) at The Rustic Saloon!“

“Good tasty food, glad breakfast is avaliable all day. Staff was very welcoming and attenative.“

“Came in today with a large group for our family cousin’s weekend and everything was excellent from service to food. Everyone raved how good their meal was! We will be back again!“

“stopped in while enjoying our seasonal campsite, the belly buster pizza and bang bang shrimp, was so, freaking good. the pizza was well seasoned, and had the best sausage I've ever tasted! and Destiny waited on us and helped us feel welcomed, She was a delight, "hell yea!" she was!!!This will be a regular stop for us when we come to town, thank you!“