14 Best American Restaurants near New Glarus

“Kristi's Restaurant offers a welcoming atmosphere, great food, and unique dishes. The menu features outstanding options like Salmon, Wiener Schnitzel, Lobster Bisque, and Lemon Ginger Cheesecake. The service is friendly and professional, and the location is great. Guests praise the excellent food and service, recommending dishes like Chipotle Salmon and Seared Ahi Tuna, as well as delicious desserts and cocktails.“

“Glarner Stube is a popular restaurant known for its excellent cheese fondue and exceptional steak dinners. The service staff are attentive and fast, and the owner is actively involved, working alongside the team. The cheese fondue is praised as amazing, while the vegetable add-on could use some improvement. Overall, Glarner Stube offers a friendly atmosphere and an incredible dining experience worth every penny.“

“Kennedy's Ice Cream And Grill in New Glarus is a must-visit spot with delicious burgers, sandwiches, and ice cream. The BLT is a standout, loaded with perfectly cooked bacon. The cheeseburger is another favorite, with a soft bun and fresh toppings. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the service is top-notch, with Kennedy herself often greeting guests. The milkshake special, like the peach cobbler, is a must-try. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or a sweet treat, Kennedy's is a definite recommendation for a satisfying meal in a friendly setting.“

“Sportsman's Bar & Grill is a welcoming establishment, ideal for bikers and visitors to New Glarus. The kitchen serves a variety of food, including onion rings, pizza, sandwiches, burgers, and fish fry on Fridays. Friendly staff like Ashley and Shane contribute to a pleasant atmosphere. The restaurant has an outdoorsman theme with game mounts and fishing lures. Located centrally, it offers a chance to explore nearby attractions. Stop by for good food, great service, and a unique experience.“

“Fat Cat Coffee Works is a pleasant place to visit, offering private seating areas upstairs and excellent medium roast coffee. The quiche specials are a hit, and the staff provides great service. The atmosphere is inviting, with cozy spots to eat and a variety of delicious treats for dessert. With free parking available, it's a great spot to stop in for coffee or lunch.“

“Kleeman's Bar & Grill in New Glarus is the go-to spot for drinks and a good time. With a friendly atmosphere and attentive staff, it's the perfect place to unwind. They offer well-made bar food, with amazing cheese curds and burgers that hit the spot. Enjoy a cold Spotted Cow and some tasty fries in their cozy outdoor dining area. The bar exudes a fun vibe, with hardworking servers and a bartender who cooks up delicious heart attack burgers. Don't miss out on this gem for a great time with friends and some tasty bar favorites.“

“Tofflers Pub & Grill offers a variety of delicious meals, with highlights including a tasty bloody mary, truffle fries, Indiana Pork, and grasshopper cocktail. The outdoor patio is perfect for watching games or bringing your furry friends. While desserts like the Chocolate Chip Cookie can be hit or miss, the efficient staff ensures a relaxing dining experience. Perfect for a worry-free cocktail and meal outing.“

“Culver’s offers tasty food like chicken tenders, veggie burgers, grilled cheese, and salads. Despite occasional mistakes, the place has friendly service. The rueben is recommended, but it can be messy. They have gluten-free options for those with restrictions. The cleanliness could use improvement, but overall, it's a good spot to revisit if in the area.“

“Paoli Schoolhouse American Bistro is a charming and classy restaurant, offering a delightful ambiance for special occasions. The menu features intricate and well-blended flavors, with options ranging from brunch favorites like omelettes, pancakes, and huevos rancheros, to dinner entrees priced between $30-$50. Generous portions and excellent service from staff members like Aiden and Forest contribute to a memorable dining experience. The shaded patio is perfect for outdoor dining in the summer. Located near local shops, it's an ideal spot for lunch or brunch.“

“River Ville Bar and Grill offers amazing homemade food made with fresh, quality ingredients. The friendly and helpful staff provide excellent service, creating a cheerful atmosphere. Customers highly recommend the menu, including dishes like chocolate pancakes, and praise the great value for the delicious food.“

“J & M Bar, located in Belleville, is a popular local spot known for its friendly atmosphere and delicious food. The menu offers a variety of options, with customers particularly praising the burgers, Reuben sandwich, Thursday night nachos, and Wednesday spaghetti. The bar's biscuits and gravy dish is also a standout, capable of impressing even those from the Southern states. While the establishment does not accept credit cards, it does have an ATM on-site. Although there was a mix-up with some provided drink vouchers in one instance, the overall pricing is reasonable. Food portions are generous and fresh, with high-quality ingredients used in dishes like the bar burger and fries. The bar features a selection of alcoholic beverages as well.“

“Sugar River Lanes has new friendly owners, Marsha and Rob, who have brought positive changes to the place. The staff are polite, helpful, and remember customer preferences. The atmosphere is clean, fun, and welcoming. The prices are reasonable, making it a popular choice for bowling. Rob and Marcia are passionate about bowling and building a community, as seen in their roles as youth and high school coaches. The wood lanes, good food, and drinks make it an ideal spot for a night out. Updates to the venue are ongoing, enhancing the overall experience. It is highly recommended for a community-oriented bowling experience.“

“Paoli Pub & Grill offers great bar food with fresh ingredients. The homemade cheese curds and Jalapeno Wontons are popular appetizers. The Catfish Po'boy is a must-try and the pickle vodka adds a unique twist to their Bloody Mary. The atmosphere is great, especially the outdoor patio. The service is good, even during busy lunch hours. Prices are surprisingly cheap, making it a fantastic dining option.“