39 Best Pizza Restaurants near Penngrove

“Delicious sauce, amazing dough and fresh quality ingredients. Having been raised in Chicago, I am kind of a pizza snob. So when I say this is the best pizza I've had in my 30 yrs in Sonoma County, you should take notice. Brava!!“

“We arrived in Glen Ellen after a long car ride. I chose to crash at the hotel, but my husband wasn't going to miss a chance to eat at Glen Ellen Star. A week later I am still hearing about the other-worldly bananas foster he had for dessert! :-) We love this place so much that when we plan a weekend getaway we stay in Glen Ellen and drive over the hills to visit Napa and St. Helena just to be near our favorite restaurant, the Glen Ellen Star.“

“Excellent resturant would recommend highly and will be back again.“

“had meatballs. garlic knots. salad. wings and pizza. everyone loved each item. wow. its new in petaluma next to whole foods“

“Excellent pizza and the owner and son are really nice people. I’ll be back!“

“Sat 11/11 was my first time dining here. Epic dinner and dessert, highly recommend!!. My daughter and her boyfriend have been dining here for a while, they love this place so much they're regulars..now add me to that list!“

“Update 1 Feb2024 Came in for a date night. Jeff helped with any questions that we had and checked in here and there despite how busy things were. Water refills were good tho infrequent. I'm surprised I haven't come back for so long. The pizza was a mainstay for the place which I told my partner about but we would venture to other places of habit during those occasions. We had gotten a 12 inch omni and a couple of beers to round things. The omni was solid, crust had good bite to it. I liked that they had a hazy on the menu as well which finished things off nicely. Will definitely be back sometime for more pizza now that we've broached the place for a night out.“

“Stellina is probably the only place in Petaluma with international quality standards. The price is moderate but the products that are received for it justify it. I've been going to this place for a couple of weeks and it really doesn't disappoint at all .5 Stars.“

“Go to this spot asap! Everything about this place is amazing! Full Bar, cocktail menu with lots of options, tvs, music playing, casual dinning area, lots of menu options! French dip, pesto ravioli & Margaritas are amazing! Chicken wings were great too! The owners & managers are super nice & giving. This is a family run restaurant that you need to visit and support. They've got great service, awesome food & causal vibes! 5 stars all around! great for large groups also!“

“Hubby and I love the Pizza. The Pizza was huge, yummy, and it's not greasy. We will come back again soon.“

“This is a favorite for most Petaluma residents I know! Great location and in the summer there is free live music on Sunday near the bar. They have great pizzas and cheese plates. The wine is diverse and usually ( I'm picky!) good! The owner is knowledgeable and so so nice!!“

“my daughter and I drive 3 hours to eat here. it doesn't disappoint! even when we have to take it to go and eat on the corner bench :)“

“The food is almost as stinkin awesome as the owner and his staff! :) Ha ha... Great place to eat. Unique choices in pizza, and delicious desserts.“

“definitely unprofessional not ok to tell a customer that even though the person taking your order over the phone messed up your order then you call then rude employee female at 6:30 pm answer the phone saying they can resend it out but charge me delivery fee again which is not ok or how it works I worked for domino's for a few years now and we don't do bussiness like that at all its unprofessional to lie to a customer then when the customer ask for a manger you don't put them on hold for 15 minutes and you over hear the person on the phone say just great saying not professional things about the customer completely rude and employee needs written up an reprimanded for this type of behavior but the manager is going to make it right but no customer should ever have to wait 45 minutes more to get there correct order completely not ok hopefully the GM and the district manager will look into the store off bear valley in apple valley to train there employees in proper procedures and professional way to handle customer service we order all the time never have these type of issues very disappointed“

“Great farm to table fresh meals! Im hopelessly addicted to the Chicken Faro Salad. Great, friendly staff. I highly recommend eating here.“

“Okay, folks, I've found it – the holy grail of pizza places! ? This mom-and-pop shop doesn't just serve pizza; they serve what might just be the best pizza in town. Walking in, you're greeted by those cozy red walls that just scream, 'Welcome, let's have a great time.' It's the perfect spot to chill with friends, grab some drinks, and dive into some seriously delicious pizza. For me, it gives NYC vibes! Pizza is thin with a crunchy crust! Hot Hawaiian and shrimp gamba are the BEST!But here's the cherry on top: the owners. They're the nicest people you'll ever meet, making you feel like part of the family from the get-go. Trust me, this place isn't just good; it's the best. Do yourself a favor and stop by. You'll see exactly what I'm raving about!“

“Great service. Great food. We will be back. Please put braised short ribs back on the menu.“

“We order from here often. Since living in a different city we usually order through doordash. Something changed in the menu where we couldn't add any special instructions. Very challenging because my daughter only likes a few foods and one specifically from this restaurant. After calling and talking to Sandra, she took the time to figure out the glitch through doordash, and now we are able to order this special meal again. Huge thank you to Sandra for caring enough to spend several days and endless hours figuring this out. I can't thank you enough!! Customer service like I haven't felt in a very long time.“

“After soccer or little league many many years ago, I remember always heading to a local pizza joint with the team, hanging out to celebrate a win or commiserate over a loss, all while enjoying pizza, soda, and some arcade games. Pinky's is nostalgia for me because it reminds me of that local pizza joint in many ways. Is it the very best pizza in town? I'm not sure - pizza is so varied these days and everyone has a different taste. The pizza has always been solid and very reasonably priced compared to other options closer to downtown. Our go-to is the combination with anchovies and it's a big, dense pizza - there must be just as much weight in toppings as dough! All of the staff are incredibly friendly and the service is very efficient. There's also plenty of street parking in the area. So, can you find a slightly better pizza in town? Sure, you probably can, but Pinky's is about more than pizza. It's about creating memories and nostalgia as a family, or a team, or as friends.“

“I LOVED both the chicken/waffle sandwich with coleslaw & the Mac and Cheese. I'm not usually one to order these but was encouraged to try them here. Best food I've had for awhile. The service was friendly and prompt. You have to try this place!“

“My absolute favorite pizza, possibly of all time! If you're wanting a kinda thin pie like you get in NYC, then you will love this pizza.After COVID hit, we lost this gem of a place. Luckily it's back and as great as ever, Thank you❤️“

“What a great place, our bartender Kelly was fantastic. Very attentive, always had my drink full and had great recommendations for the menu. Very enjoyable to talk to. Had a really great time. plan on coming here again. A great menu, you can get a burger and a shake, or a pizza, tacos, sandwiches. Very full menu with all a good variety. one of my new favorite places to go!!!!!! Fun Time!!! Thanks Kelly!!!“

“The wild goat is a phenomenal restaurant on petaluma's riverfront.What's 60s and 70s music ebbing and it has a warm atmosphere.The staff are professional and amazing.It's a little pricier but the food is delicious and very well worth it for a special occasion ?And it's okay to share and split a meal that they're not against that and the bathroom is in the mail part it's not in the restaurant itself but you just let them know you need to use the restroom they'll give you the code“

“I go to Petaluma and work on weekends. The gentlemen that work there when I call to place an order. They already know what I normally order, and when I go there to pick up the food they always say nice to see you again. They are very friendly ☺️“

“Great food service? Everything!“

“Yummy pizza. Handmade dough❤️“

“Just went over to get a pizza. 4pm May 26 2026. Guy behind counter was working on one. Guess he didn’t like chatting or his job. Told him take his time…sat down to wait. Another woman and daughter came in and the pizza guy went right up to them and took care of their order first. Waved at him wondering what’s up and he just shrugged his shoulders. felt like age discrimination… I left.“

“We had a fantastic dinner at Rosso last night! The food was amazing, our food server was excellent!“

“Hubby and I love the Pizza. The Pizza was huge, yummy, and it's not greasy. We will come back again soon.“

“Truly one of THE BEST pizzerias EVER. Crust is FABULOUS, folds just right, like a good pizza should! AMAZINGLY DELECTABLE sauce and pepperoni- better than ANYTHING you’ve had before!!! I’m the kind of person that could eat pizza 365 days a year but if I had my way- this would be the ONLY place I’d get my pies from!!! Truly outta this world flavors and always cooked just right!“

“Food is incredible! Bacon Alfredo break sticks are insanely amazing.“

“Pizza is decent to really good... it all depends. 4 Stars because it's not consistent. Thin crust is great but the amount of cheese they put on a cheese pizza isn't enough. Last time I ordered it was covered in cheese and a thin layer of red sauce which is the best way. Each slice was covered with lots of cheese. This time each slice was halfway covered with cheese (very little) and the rest was just sauce. Acre you are good pizza but please don't cheap out and ruin the experience of your customers.“

“Staff, 10/10! Environment, 10/10! Food, 11/10! I do not know how to put into words how great this place is! The staff is super friendly, willing to answer all questions you have. The food is scrumptious! I’ve had the breaded chicken sandwich with fries as well as the pizza. If you make your way onto base please come here and support! Also do your self a favor and get a side of two rock sauce!!!!“

“BEST PIZZAAAAA!!! Have been getting this pizza forever. It is so good. Always good fresh but if you take some to go and cook it extra well done in a toaster over it is the best! Definitely give it a try. Also this is the best location they always put the perfect amount of cheese.“

“I'm a regular customer. I keep going back! For me, the pizza always comes out piping hot and with fresh ingredients. I can see where some lady brought her pizza home with her. Maybe she lives 2 hours away. She should have had it fresh, because when this pizza is fresh, it's my favorite. If you're a basic person, I'm sure you could get an amazing pepperoni or cheese pizza and really enjoy it fresh. But if you want to try something a little bit out of the box, try one of the unique flavors. You can get a pizza with a Thai influence. You can get barbecue pork pizza. There are plenty of pizzas with fresh veggies packing flavor. Even if I didn't work in the area, Extreme Pizza would still be my craving.“

“Pizza is good quality. Other food items are good as well. Prices are reasonable and service is pretty fast. I usually order ther curbside delivery. If they don't bring out your food within 2 minutes of the order being ready and after checking in via text or the link in the confirmation email your next pizza is free. They always beat the 2 minutes, at least for me“

“It wouldn't feel like Rohnert Park without Mary's. This place has been through thick and thin and prevails as a community staple. The owners are genuinely great people and very actively involved in Rohnert Park. Mary's has some basic staples like gnocchi and the house salad. Their blue cheese dressing is hard to beat. Service has always been friendly and they have some great long time staff.“

“I didn't catch her name but the lady working the register today that helped my girlfriend and I was awesome. Super friendly, gave us a huge slice of pepperoni, and the food came out really fast. Customer service and the quality of the pizza were both 5/5, will definitely be swinging by here again at some point.“

“Recently went there for a cousins birthday it was great. The whole atmosphere had a good vibe and the service was excellent. The only thing that I can't really rate is the food because the only thing I ate there was pizza but that by itself was pretty good. Overall good games, good service and a good atmosphere. Would definitely come back“