11 Best Italian Restaurants in Petaluma

“Was drawn in by weekend specialty pasta - so delicious and comforting Pork Bolognese - nice wine choices to pair; friendly & attentive service.“

“Excellent food, drinks and service“

“The food was absolutely amazing. We shared a house salad, a pistachio pizza, a creamy truffle white sauce pasta, and finally an awesome tiramisu. Also had a great selection of drinks and wines available and have a cork fee if you want to bring your own. It is a very popular and tightly packed place so I recommend reservations and you will be very close to others.
The only negative items we had were that we had to wait a while after our reservation time. And that the service speed is sometimes inconsistent. Table seated later and behind us, and with a different waiter, had ordered and received their drinks and appetizers before we could even order our drinks. Our waiter would disappear for a long while and had to waive down others to help us. Just bad luck of the draw for us that night. But the food is still so good that I’d go back!“

“A great place in Petaluma, CA. Love this place. The food is great and there are always some specials in the menu. Love the wild boar gnocchi but everything is great!“

“I have been going to hectors pizza for about 30 years now recipe workers everybody there are still the same will continue being my favorite pizza“

“Great service. Great food. We will be back. Please put braised short ribs back on the menu.“

“Legendary Italian. Family Style. Enough said.“

“Decades in business, the New Yorker is long standing Petaluma staple with exceptional food!!!!! And Rosalia!! She serves up some seriously solid pizza, amazing pastas and homemade sauces plus very generous salads- you can't go wrong with anything you order!
While you wait for a to go meal or dine in, enjoy the eclectic decor and postcards from all of the world. Such a gem ofa locally owned old school pizza joint.
One of my favorite restaurants of all time! ☆☆☆☆☆☆
♡ a fan since 2001!“

“Loved my time there the food was so tasty. 💕“

“Ralph (the owner) is an absolutely wonderful human being. We grew up on Fergene’s and it’s my first meal in California every time we’re in town to see family. Specifically the Chipotle Chicken pizza,“

“Good pizza and great service.“