11 Best American Restaurants in Crested Butte

“We had a fantastic dinner at this new addition to the Crested Butte dining scene. The nachos were delicious and the vegetarian bahn mi had incredible flavor. Definitely get an assortment of the sauces to dip fries in and to add to any sandwich. Our waiter made great recommendations and we would certainly go again. Plus, how can you possibly a $2 Genesee can?“

“Friendly, quality, homey, fun. We’re lucky to have The Wooden Spoon in our CB South community. Can’t beat grill master Evan!“

“THE best meal we had in Crested Butte this trip! Grounded in the owner’s great-grandmother’s sourdough starter (named “Trisha”, because OF COURSE), this woman-owned gem is deliciousness at every turn. From the sourdough with black garlic butter to the house-made pasta to the flatbreads and finally bread pudding, everything was PERFECTION - well balanced, indulgent, DELICIOUS. And the wait staff were awesome too (thanks, Abby!). Don’t miss this spot!“

“What an incredible experience. We loved the ability to ski and ski out. The people were all really nice and the food was great. A hidden gem. We recommend definitely a bucket list item you should do. Compare to experiences at some of the other restaurants, we found the prices reasonable.“

“Just my unbiased opinion. Absolutely delicious!“

“Without a doubt, the best food and service I have experienced. Thier Tasting Menu was superb.“

“In Crested Butte a have to stop; however, have a reservation! Service food atmosphere makes you feel you are in your families dinning room having food cooked with love for you! Be prepared for family style dinning with two courses and dessert. Full bar with amazing drinks!

Each course allows for seconds or thirds… hahaha and you have to enjoy the amazing biscuits! Save room for the dessert! When we were there, chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwich was a perfect closer!

We had four in our party, and all of us tried fried chicken, AMAZING! You have the choice of a variety of entrees. When we go back it will be a mix of chicken and beef!

Amazing for two o. That special night but also family friendly!

Parking is a challenge. We would park at the visitor center, walk the shops, have dinner and walk the ice cream cookie off back to the car!“

“I’d go back but, first I’d have to tryout some of the other breakfast places in town. On the plus side the food was tasty and fresh. On the negative side, the service was slow, my food wasn’t hot and the restaurant was stuffy. My gf’s food was hot so maybe their timing off this time.“

“We have been on vacation in Crested Butte and checked online to see if there were any available public tee times. I spoke to one of the pros a few weeks ago and he said that there was a member / guest tournament on 7/23/22 and to check back when we were in town because some public tee times would usually open up. There was a spot open for 3 players at 2:30pm. So we called the club and Maddie was very helpful and reserved the time for us. Once we got to the club we walked into the pro shop and one of the other staff members went to get the lady who was running the pro shop. As soon as Erin walked in she was confused as to why we were there as non members and how we were able to get a tee time today. Keep in mind the 2:30pm slot was listed as a public tee time on their website. She said we could still play but kept reiterating that it was a mistake that we were able to book a tee time. She did this at least 4 to 5 times making a scene in the pro shop. Erin was clearly trying to make us feel not welcome which she did a great job at! We finally just decided to cancel the tee time and leave. We have played at many other resort town golf courses such as Keystone, EagleVail, Beaver Creek and NEVER had this awful of an experience. Every other course we have played was so hospitable and welcoming as every course should be. We were very disappointed with how poorly we were treated by Erin. People with that kind of attitude should not be in the hospitality business. Every other staff member we came in contact with was extremely kind and helpful, that’s the way it should be. It’s sad how one under qualified staff member can ruin someone’s experience! As a small business owner myself, I would never treat any customer or potential customer the way Erin treated our group. It was extremely unprofessional and rude.“

“Glad ... so glad ur in south CB!! Always enjoy!!!“

“We stopped in at 8:30pm on October 5th tired and weary from a long day of hiking. Even though they were closing at 9pm they treated us like we were the first customers of the day. Highly recommend and next fall we will definitely return. PS. The food is outstanding.“