28 Best Italian Restaurants near Bethlehem

“I forgot to mention on my last review that we always get a vegan pizza to go with our dinners. It is really great crispy pizza with vegetables on top but no cheese. I'm sure all the other pizzas are equally delicious. Lasts for days in the fridge and can be reheated in oven- not microwave because that makes the crust mushy! Really good place!“

“My first visit was last February for my birthday. My friend had pre-arranged for the 5 course tasting menu/pairing. It was the perfect introduction to the restaurant and the culinary talents of Chef David. When a close friend had a milestone birthday I knew this would be the perfect locale given his Italian heritage. He’s picky on bread since he makes his own - he couldn’t get enough of it and was excited to find out it was made on site! Recently, when I saw the braised rabbit filled buttons I knew I had to return. Since it was just me and a last minute decision I was thrilled to get a spot at the bar. I can tell you the attention was exactly the same as if I were in the main dining room. First time visitors should splurge on the tasting menu! Grazie mille Chef David and the entire friendly team.“

“We are very impressed. Lauren and I had lunch today. They got us in without a reservation. We were treated "compliments of the chef"with an antipasto salad and lemon cello shots. We ordered a late lunch of Tramonti salad and chicken wings. We were so impressed with the atmosphere and the food. There was so much food we had to bring some home. We ended up talking with our neighbors who are up from Brooklyn, New York and Milford, Connecticut visiting because they had heard such good things about the restaurant . I recommend I recommend you get a reservation.“

“Buffet style office Christmas party. 2023 was our 4 time hosting the event at Verdi's. Plenty of well lit parking. Staff was great. The food; chicken marsala, sirloin, vegetable medley, salmon and salad was okay. Not great and not bad.“

“Amazing!!! I stopped in Sat. 3/9/24. I ordered a breakfast sandwich with ham & cheese in Gluten Free bread. They toasted the bread and the egg was cooked to perfection! Such helpful staff and so grateful for the GF bread. I will be back.????“

“Finally got to enjoy Roma tonight. Lots of great choices. Veal parmigiana was about as good as it gets. Escarole, beans and sausage, long hot peppers in a marinara sauce, and a huge meatball for our appetizers were all amazing. Must plan ahead as reservations are the only way to get in on a Friday or Saturday night. Understandable given the high quality of their food and service.“

“We went for dinner tonight. My parents love it and took us for my husbands birthday. Food was great! Such big portions and so many shrimp in my Nana’s dish, and it was delish! But what I really want to comment on is that I informed the waitress my son had a peanut allergy. She said they didn’t have anything with peanuts but would inform them. She came back with a picture of the back of the bread wrapper to show me the ingredients to make sure his grilled cheese was safe. I appreciated that more than they know. As a new mom who is also new to the allergy world I’m just learning and the fact that they thought to show me the ingredients says so much. Usually people think if there are no peanuts it’s safe, but you knew enough to look at the ingredients in the bread and go the step further to show me, and I thank you for that!“

“After walking around on a cold, windy day hot, delicious pizza was perfect! We live supporting small businesses, and this family-owned place fit the bill. You can tell a lot of care and pride go into the preparation of the food. The tables were clean and well cared for, too, which is always appreciated. Great service and prompt delivery of the food. The pizza is delicious! Love the sauce and every part of the pizza was flavorful and piping hot when we got it. Keep up the great work, we will be back!“

“Wasn't sure about this place when we pulled in to the parking lot but so glad we gave it a try . I ordered the Zuppa di pesce ( one of my favorite hard to find meals ) absolutely everything I was hoping it would be and more . Very extensive menu if you can't find something here to tickle your taste buds maybe your not human . The service was awesome. The restaurant itself ain't very fancy but a steady flow of traffic of people picking up and calling in for orders . They are definitely doing something right . Me and the wife was in from out of town for a funeral. And we was very satisfied with our meals and service . So if your in the area this place is definitely worth the stop .“

“So despite the name, Big Daddys does have eat-in service, and also appears to be part of a gas station? The location is a bit off the beaten path, but plenty of parking. I found a certificate on Restaurants.com for the pizzeria, and it was a good deal. Lunch and dinner at a discount! The burgers were pretty large, as were the fries if you ordered them as a side. The pizza had more of a tomato-acidy sauce than sweet, but a good amount of cheese. You could order by the slice inside. There is also ice cream, onion rings in the hot food area, and baked goods wrapped for desserts. There's both Coke and Pepsi in the coolers, and chips behind the window side booths. They also have a bar area and sell on Slice! Big Daddys also does local delivery on certain days in the evening. Goodness, there's a lot going on. Plus, a good flow of pick up orders. The gentlemen at the register seemed to have a good handle on things though.“

“Got take out from Aldo’s tonight and it was incredible. Calamari was fresh and crispy. The lobster ravioli was incredible too. Big chucks of lobster in a delicious sauce. This place turns out magnificent dishes and is a must visit! Well done!“

“Incredible food and service. We have called ahead and used them for several large family parties. The food is hot and delicious. The service is impeccable. I would highly recommend anyone to try this restaurant. You’ll be very surprised, The ingredients are delicious and of high-quality.“

“They are located behind a gas station in Litchfield, CT. They rank up there with Bigfoot and UFO's in terms of things you might randomly find while driving. That being said, make the effort. Their pizza is awesome, with perhaps the most perfect crust I've had. Everything else on their menu is well done, too. Why does all the magic happen behind a gas station?“

“So Google says I came here a week ago, but that's not true. It's been almost 2 years i last Came here with my husband, who's sinced passed away we used to go here all the time and the food service, an atmosphere was always great. The meatball Grinder was his favorite.“

“I just had surgery and Tom the owner just deliver my pizza. Through my ring camera he offered to bring pizza inside and put on counter for me. With my permission he did just that. I’m a grateful for not only a great meal every time we order from Martino’s but the excellent service. Tom exceeds customer expectations and so does his staff. Thank you again for the kind gesture…“

“I had it delivered but the delivery guy was so amazingly sweet and the pizza delicious . I’ve lived in Woodbury over 10 years and complain there are no good pizza places first time trying , now I’m wrong !! So good !Vegetarian options: Yum“

“Our chicken dish was described on the menu as being atop pasta. What we received was just chicken on a plate. I feel like every time we try to eat here there's an event going on. They should close the restaurant portion of their business during events so paying customers don't get neglected.“

“Middlebury pizza is just that good ole family owned restaurant that works carefully on the details of the dishes they create, while always managing to stick to the basics perfect them.Whoever made my chicken parmigiana wrap deserves an award because it was one of the best I’ve ever eaten! Food is excellent every damn time and they’re effortlessly consistent!“

“The food is absolutely amazing and so is the staff. They did the catering for our engagement party and it food was amazing. Ordering the food was a breeze. It was the only stress free process about planning the party and having zero doubts that the food order would be perfect. Weather ordering for a large party or just getting take out, you will never be disappointed.“

“Was looking for a place open on a Monday. Popped in for a late lunch. Was very happy with the peppered pork loin panini. So tender and flavorful. Staff checked in on us and the place was very clean and inviting. I'd recommend trying it out“

“We have been coming here for years now as our favorite date night out restaurant and were a little worried when we learned of a new chef. What a spectacular meal! A refreshing take on some of our favorites. Omar, our server was incredibly attentive and didn’t rush our night out, which with two littles at home was appreciated. Everything from the drinks, appetizers, main course, and dessert was top notch.“

“A wonderful atmosphere, warm & welcoming. The service was excellent. Our waitress was the chefs daughter who was very knowledgable about the menu. The main course was delicious as was the dessert. I'm looking forward to going back soon.“

“Love the pizza, it's all we order from here but will definitely be trying other things. Extra cheese is extra cheese for real lol not like other places that say extra but you get nothing different than what you always get. If ur in the area give them a try. My only got to for pizza ?“

“Went out to dinner here on Friday night. The parking lot was packed. And I know why. This is an old style Italian restaurant. Not fancy but absolutely delicious. I had chicken cacciatore. My wife had a bowl of pasta. My friends had the seafood dishes.the seafood dishes were outstanding. The owner came to our table. They were very friendly. Prices were reasonable, not inexpensive, but not extravagant either. I will definitely come back.“

“I’ve been going here many years and I’m not sure how to give this review, because the quality of the food changes every time they have a new owner. When they first opened this place the food was incredible, and then it was below average, and now it changed again. Last I went it was just average, nothing like it was when it first opened. But by no means was the food bad!2nd experience: I believe there are new owners, the food is significantly more bland, and the drink I ordered was way too bitter.“

“We stopped here for a quick late lunch. Onion soup was very good. The restaurant is very clean, and decorated very nice. It made me feel as though I was in PA in Amish country! I ordered a wonderful, delicious salad as I am gluten-free. Very satisfying. My daughter ordered the Reuben. I would eat here again if I was in the area.“

“First time here, thought the atmosphere was great and so was the food. We had the potstickers and jalapeño popper egg rolls for apps. I had buffalo cauliflower tacos and my husband had blacken chicken pasta. Everything was awesome. Others in our party enjoyed their food also. Our waiter was great! Will be going back.“

“Do t know why the stars are low in this. Husband had meat rav I had chicken Marsala good bread for dessert husband had the special berry cake and j had chocolate mouse cake both very good. Waitress was good as well. The only thing that wasn't so good was the iced tea maybe it was old but yea that's was it“