50 Best Bakeries near Wallingford

“Fresh, delicious, creative choices.“

“Alyssa’s Cakery absolutely knocked it out of the park! They created the most incredible gluten and dairy-free wedding cake for us, and it truly exceeded every expectation we had. The flavor was unreal - rich, moist, and absolutely delicious. You would never know it was allergen-friendly. Every guest who tried it was blown away. The presentation was perfection. The cake was beyond anything we could have imagined for our wedding day… elegant, beautifully detailed, and crafted with so much care. It looked like something out of a magazine. From start to finish, Alyssa’s Cakery delivered quality, artistry, and heart. We couldn’t be more grateful and will be recommending them to everyone we know!“

“Owner is very nice, protein cookies are the best I've ever had. Honestly, they'd be good for a regular cookie, you completely forget they're protein they're so good, and that means a lot because I've tried quest, foodies, my cookie dealer, and redcon brand protein cookies and they all pale in comparison in my opinion.“

“Cupcakes are very good. Not too much topping and cake is moist. Friendly and helpful staff. Highly recommend!“

“Elizabeth's Bakery now has some GF items. Today I tried their GF blueberry muffin & brownie. The muffin is amazing! It didn't taste GF at all. Lots of blueberries, not overly sweet like some GF baked goods; great texture -not gummy at all; and a wonderfully big muffin like it's gluten containing counterpart. The brownie is soooo fudge! It is not gummy at all. Tastes just like a gluten containing brownie (well at least what I remember them tasting like). These are so much better than any GF brownie mix & better than any recipe I have made at home. It's been years since I have been able to purchase a great tasting GF item at a bakery. Thanks Elizabeth's Bakery for including a few GF items on your menu.“

“This bakery is a must try! I have celiac disease, and it's so hard to find any good gluten-free pastry, so when they said they had gluten-free cheesecake,I had to try it!.. it was so good 👍 😋 next time I'm in Wallingford Ct I will definitely stop!“

“Absolutely out of this world donuts and coffee!!!!“

“I got this cake for my daughter’s birthday, and it was a showstopper! The guests couldn’t stop raving about it, many even asked where I got it. The pineapple and coconut frosting perfectly creamy, and the texture was spot-on. It was a hit with everyone and made the celebration even more special! absolutely unforgettable!“

“everything from gas to shopping“

“The bakery offers a big variety of cookies, and pastries which are very tasty! The apple cider donuts are among the best I have ever had. The cupcakes are good, however the cupcake frostings are flat and lack flavor. Everything else is so tasty at this bakery - I think the bakers definitely have the talent to improve their frosting recipe.“

“We had an assortment of cupcakes.. and they were delicious…like home made delicious… .. they were very moist, and not too sugary on the frosting… everyone at the party loved them too.. thanks!!“

“The employees at the North Haven store are always friendly, helpful and fast. I've never had an issue or mix-up with my order and the cookies, as always, are scrumptious. I particularly like their rewards program . Points add up fast and you get frequent and substantial discounts without being constantly bombarded by texts and emails or having to buy a million cookies first.“

“Absolutely love their cakes, and completely blown away with their designs, I tell them what i want or idea and they make it come to reality, its a great feeling to be able to not only trust them with designs and beauty but the taste of their cakes are delicious!!. Definitely a place I will continue going back to ..Thank You JCakes for making my past few parties a success with you amazing 🎂“

“I ordered a few trays of cookies for a party I was hosting. I called, a little flustered because I was feeling very last minute. I explained how many people I was hosting and that I didn’t know what or how many to order. They were unbelievably patient with me and told me they would take care of it. And did they ever!!!! Freshly baked, beautifully presented, and SO DELICIOUS! I was thrilled. Guests impressed. Delightful variety. I will be back and I highly recommend you check them out!!!“

“Tried the frozen Mac n cheese and it was absolutely delish! My son who is very picky had three helpings. Probably the best we’ve had. We miss the seafood newburg. We were told it was not a good seller. It is a must try if they put it out again. You don’t know what you are missing. The flavors are unbelievable!“

“My husband surprised me with a Princess cake. I mentioned I’d love to try one after seeing it in a baking show. He searched online and Marjolaine’s was the only place he could find. He drove over an hour to pick it up and it was well worth the drive! We just picked up a Dacquoise. This one was a request from our daughter. We tried a smaller version that was in the case. It was absolutely delicious! So light and airy and the flavor was divine! We are driving this cake all the way to NC and are 100% certain that our daughter will be thrilled ! We are heading back in the beginning of April for a Marjolaine for our daughter in law. It is well worth the trip!!!“

“Great wait staff Food was delish“

“Had the best Italian cream pie for Easter! So good!!“

“I needed a last minute birthday cake for my wife’s birthday. I called Maria at 6pm the night before and she had it ready no problem by the next day. She was extremely friendly and allowed me to customize the cake.

The cake was delicious and enjoyed by everyone at the party! Would definitely recommend“

“First time ordering a cake here and it was beautiful AND tasted amazing!! We will definitely be back!“

“Just stopped by for the first time and I am so glad I did! their bacon egg and cheese sandwich is the best I have ever had, the apple cinnamon muffin is delicious, and the staff was so kind and helpful. I ordered a dozen muffins for an event on Monday and I am so excited to share them with others. highly recommend. I will for sure be back.“

“Milani's did cookie boxes for my daughter's communion. Such beautiful presentations.“

“I love their large variety of cakes, each one is so beautiful and delicious you want to buy them all!! The cookies are awesome. Pumpkin Cheesecake was decadent! 👍🏻“

“Steve did our wedding cake on 10/11/25 and it was delicious ! From our first meeting with him he was very attentive, and drew up exactly the type of cake we were looking for. He literally made my Pinterest cake photo into reality. The cake not only looked stunning but it tasted so good too. The cake was so fresh and flavorful. The frosting was delicious. Our guests were raving about it ! We are so happy we chose DiSorbo’s for our wedding cake! 11/10 would recommend DiSorbo’s for your wedding cake or any cake you need ! Thank you Steve!“

“An Artist Beyond Talented & Delicious Cakes as well❤️“

“LBs sweet treats offers a variety of specialty cupcakes and I asked for egg free and she was able to oblige. the cupcakes were delicious and she made them just as her and I discussed. I would totally recommend her for cupcakes and probably cake and cookies and cake pops too!!! thanks so much Lauren“

“My girlfriend and I are bakery fanatics and haven’t found one in the area that we really like, until today! Their breakfast sandwiches are amazing and the pastry’s are to die for! And the prices are unbeatable. Definitely our new regular breakfast spot!!!!“

“Great food authentic and the service is even better my wife and I go there for some of the things that remind her of home Mexico that is so if you're looking for great food stop in and check out there selections also great breads all different kinds great with that morning coffee“

“Ok if you’re looking for some bougie patisserie this isn’t it HOWEVER, this place has the character, charm and personal touch that has been all but destroyed in our culture. Andrew is the best. His baked goods are a lost art and so is the feel of his shop. It is as unique and retro as he is and that is a GOOD thing. He’s one of the few left that knows his customers by name as they walk in and strive to make sure everyone is treated well sure he takes weirdly long vacations and leaves hilarious messages on his phone. But that’s the appeal of this bakery. They make Swedish pastries and bread that you can’t find anywhere. But above all it’s Andrew and his family run bakery. If you want Impersonal Dunkin baked goods baked in a factory in who knows where this ain’t it. Bread and Basket is like visiting Main Street USA that my grandparents reminisced about.Give them a try!!!“

“I have nothing but good things to say about Confections by Betsy. Professional and great service & you get exactly what you order! I will be ordering from her again! ❤️“

“I got a cake from here 2 years and it was exactly what I wanted (the heart cake). My husband loved the taste and kept mentioning it when it got closer to his birthday this year so I, of course, had to get another one. It was AMAZING! Everyone loved it and a few said it was the best cake they’d ever had. Yellow cake with cheesecake filling and buttercream- highly recommend. Steve was also great with communicating and working through my indecisiveness about the design.“

“Incredible coffee and pastries!“

“It was very good !!! Going again tomorrow“

“Great wait staff Food was delish“

“Visited Sue Stones. Did you know she was often voted Connecticut's Cake Lady? Saw so many examples of exquisite and imaginative cake designs created for display that are truly ingenious and often based on the clients most treasured experiences. She created my own wedding cake for my first wedding and it went on to win awards for that design as well. For those who are Cinderella or Elizabethan devotees, her created castles far outweigh those found in your favorite fairy tales.“

“I moved 4 years ago, but I know it’s still THE BEST! I started coming her at 16 every Friday to get bread. I’m 51. Meet the family and find out how good they are! You won’t be disappointed.

Dietary restrictions: Always“

“Cute little coffeeshop with very good coffee“

“I feel honored to be apart of the wonderful history of Chestnut. Patty and staff’s warmth, delicious and quality food, and reasonable prices relative to what you get, make this place a staple in New Haven. Sad to see it go, especially considering the genuine community surrounding it. You are loved, Chestnut!

Thank you for everything, Patty ❤️“

“I discovered this store when I was High School, around 1977. Graduated 1978 from Wibur Cross. They were on Edgewood Avenue and Platt Street. Then they moved to Whalley Avenue. I still tell people about this store. Always love it. 🥰“

“I celebrated my birthday yesterday at Foodology and what a blast! Even more fun than I had hoped. Everything was clean and organized and Christina was amazing to work with. Definitely plan an event or attend one of their super fun public ones. We will definitely be back!“

“We stopped in for some stuffed breads and tried some italian pastry.They where all excellant and be back for sure.“

“Fabulous Greek Salad!!!!!“

“Awesome empanadas and great food“

“I first saw Moon Rocks Gourmet Cookies at a craft show at the High Plains Community Center. I tried a sampler of six (out of the eight available) flavors: • Traditional chocolate chip • Salted caramel • S'mores • Cannoli • Blueberry lemon • Orange creamsicle The other flavors were oatmeal raisin walnut and peanut butter chocolate chip. The six flavors I had were absolutely amazing. The cookies were light and flavorful, absolutely delicious. They make gift baskets too, so you can share the goodness. Highly recommended.“

“Everyone talks about Sally's or Frank Pepe's apizza here and there but frankly the best pizza I've had in New Haven so far is from this spot. They do take forever to make your pizza on busy days, regardless it is well worth waiting for. I'm assuming the pizza would be less expensive if they didn't charge so much for toppings. The pizzas are huge, plan accordingly with a group of buddies instead of ordering a whole pie for yourself. Would say the same of the calzone, which a friend got“

“Our yearly apple picking spot and favorite place to pick up local honey!“

“If anyone went to Jepson school in the 90s this is Cheryl from Carol’s classes place!! The food is so good!! it’s made with love and tastes like it’s made from your mom’s kitchen. It’s definitely a go to breakfast/lunch spot in New Haven! <3“

“Avvetura is becoming my go to Deli. And the bakery is awesome as well. The food is always so delicious. I love the variety of sandwiches, meals and baked goods. I never leave hungry!!!“

“Awesome Bagels and Croissants, I try to stop when I can, I highly recommend this place,give them a try“

“la comida y atención muy buena“