27 Best Seafood Restaurants in Islamorada

Ziggie & Mad Dog's Seafood • $$$
83000 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Coach Shula's Barbeque Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Lobster Tail and White Truffle Mac & Cheese
Ziggie's Classic Lobster Bisque
Hot Molten Lava Birfday Cake
Phyllo Encrusted Escargot
Garlic Salted Onion Rings
Cowboy Cut Bone-In Ribeye
Crabmeat Stuffed Snapper
Phyllo Crusted Escargot
Ziggie's Lobster Bisque

“It was good but not worth the wait, they will sit you outside with infested mosquitos. The wait was ridiculous. Server hardly even checked on us. Will not visit again!“

4.2 Good281 Reviews
Twisted Shrimp Seafood • $
87745 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

1 2 Pound Fried Shrimp Basket
Shrimp \u0026 Fry Basket
Twisted Shrimp PO’Boy
Blackened Shrimp Tacos
Mahi & Shrimp Platter
Twisted Shrimp Tacos
Island Shrimp Tacos
Shrimp & Fry Basket
Sweet Potato Fries
Island Shrimp Wrap

“Very friendly staff and the food was delicious! The owner came out and spoke and was a genuinely really nice guy! Thanks for a great time!“

4.9 Superb438 Reviews
Island Grill Seafood • $$
85501 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Island Grill Seafood Pasta
The Original Tuna Nachos
Homemade Key Lime Pie
Famous Tuna Nachos
Crispy Whole Fish
Fried Cheesecake
Huevos Rancheros
Spicy Tuna Roll
Tuna Poke Bowl
Coconut Shrimp

“I always love coming to the Island grill! Today is the BEST day I’ve had here meeting Brandon at the bar! He is SO warm, helpful, provides THE BEST service, and just gave me the best keys vibes on my day off. What a breath of fresh air! Jessica was also so incredibly friendly and added to one of the most relaxing days I’ve had in a long time. The food was excellent, all around just a great experience!“

4.7 Superb649 Reviews
Wahoo's Seafood Bar and Grill Restaurant Seafood • $$
83413 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

The Wahoo's Fried Seafood Platter
House's Signature Wahoo blt Club
Key's Local Whole Fried Snapper
Wahoo's Signature Seafood Rice
Locals Favorite Wahoo Bites
Classic Keys Fish Sandwich
Oysters on the Half Shell
Key Lime Pie in the Keys
Killer Conch Fritters
Key Lime Shrimp Bowl

“One of our favorite restaurants in Islamorada! The views are amazing, the food is so fresh and delicious and the people are warm and welcoming. Host Brian always sets us up with a great table! This week Mr. Nike was our server and took great care of us. We'll be back again and again, fantastic restaurant overall!!“

4.5 Superb482 Reviews
Green Turtle Inn Seafood • $$
81219 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Our Famous Turtle Sticky Bun
Captain's French Toast
Lobster Mac N Cheese
The Turtle Breakfast
Meatloaf Sandwich
Shrimp and Grits
Lobster Benedict
Turtle Chowder
Conch Fritters
Bacon Wrapped

“First night in Islamorada,too tired from the days traveling,so we ordered a Turtle Inn salad with grilled chicken to split. Super fresh produce,homemade dressing. It brought us back for a second visit.“

4.6 Superb180 Reviews
Islamorada Shrimp Shack Seafood • $$
81901 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Our Famous Shrimp Fritters
Great Key Lime Pie
Shrimp and Grits
Shrimp Jambalaya
She Crab Soup
Coconut Shrimp
Shrimp Tacos
Clam Chowder
Combo Basket
Fried Shrimp

“We were on a family vacation and tried the Shrimp Shack after a suggestion from Capt Jake who took us offshore fishing. We took the Mahi we caught to the Shrimp Shack and they prepare the most delicious dishes you will find in the Keys. We actually came back a second night as well. They prepared the fish 7 or 8 different ways for us and each way was phenomenal. Not only was the fish good, the service was excellent. The food arrived quickly and we really felt taken care of…. like family. The restaurant is not crowded so there is no wait time. There was no water view but if you can get past that, you will have the best food around. We tried several other restaurants in the area but none were as good. The photo was just the first visit. The second visit we had the fish prepared completely different. Check out the portion of the menu labeled “Hook and Cook” for all of your options.“

4.6 Superb165 Reviews
Whale Harbor Seafood Buffet Seafood • $$
83413 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Hand Shucked Oysters on the Half Shell
Variedad de Camarones A la Mantequilla
Ceviche Crab Salad and Octopus Salad
Key's Local Whole Fried Snapper
Wahoo's Signature Seafood Rice
Pan Seared Caribbean Wahoo
Portofino Shrimp Linguini
Alaska Snow Crab Legs
Steamed Mussels Clams
Crispy Whole Snapper

“Nos encantó el lugar , variedad y servicio exelente.“

4.4 Superb543 Reviews
Hungry Tarpon Restaurant Seafood • $$
77522 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Conch Ceviche with Crispy Tortilla Chips
Trailer Trash Bloody Mary
House Made Key Lime Pie
Whole Fried Local Catch
Beer Battered Fish
Blackened Mahi Mahi
Hog Fish Sandwich
Sweet Potato Fries
Chicken Sandwich
Fish N’ Chips

“De passage à islamorada durant notre séjour dans les keys nous nous sommes arrêté chez Robbie’s,nous sommes tombé sous le charme de cet endroit. Déjeuner au Hungry tarpon,tellement délicieux que nous y avons à nouveau déjeuné au retour de key west. Endroit magnifique au bord de l’eau,personnel très chaleureux,notre serveur John très sympa. Vivement notre prochain séjour en Floride et particulièrement dans les keys 🥰🇺🇸“

4.4 Superb445 Reviews
Lazy Days Seafood • $$
79867 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Broiled Seafood Platter
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Il Pescato Del Giorno
Ensalada de Cangrejo
Key Lime Pie Slice
Coconut Shrimp
Key West Salad
Seafood Bisque
Stuffed Shrimp

“FANTASTIC Food, atmosphere, clean restrooms and staff!!! We had Snow Crab Legs and Shrimp Scampi Pasta that were fantastic! HUGE portions so think before you order as you will miss dessert!! Club Kelly, Jim and Melanie Kelly, Winter Garden, FL love Lazy Days!! We will be back!! Well done Randy!“

4.3 Superb566 Reviews
ReelCatch Restaurant Seafood • $$
80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Calamari Rings with Sweet Peppers
Chilled Pink Shrimp Cocktail
Blackened Lobster Tacos
Black & Blue Burger
Chicken Quesadilla
Ceviche De Camaron
Belgian Waffle
Key Lime Pie
Mahi Tacos

“We stayed at this resort while diving next-door at the sister resort love this place. It was very clean. Food was amazing. Beach was clean and the pool and tiki bar was a plus will definitely come back.“

4.3 Superb95 Reviews
Lobster Shack Seafood • $
86700 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Key Lime Pie
Lobster Roll
Salad

“It was a delicious sandwich (roll) lobster 🦞, very simple, small area, prices same as other places that serve lobster rolls, ❣️ but excellent, including very cute quaint curio shops, we go in and enjoy lobster rolls every chance we get to head to the Florida Keys. ❣️try it ‼️ it's always an adventure ❣️“

4.3 Superb61 Reviews
Chef Michael's Seafood • $$$
81671 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Lobster- Juliette with Shrimp and Scallops
Seafood Pasta Shrimp Scallops & Lobster
Catch of the Day Fried Lion Fish
Seafood Pasta Shrimp Scallops
Triple Tail in Adriatic Sauce
Conch & Rock Shrimp Fritters
Shrimp and Lobster Ceviche
Fried Hog Fish Dinner
Hogfish \u0026 Eggs
Grilled Triple Tail

“We took our daughters and their friends here for a special dinner. The chef let each daughter and her friend split the huge 16oz steak which then was perfect.“

4.2 Good147 Reviews
Lobster Shack Seafood • $
86700 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Breast Sandwich
Conch Fritters
Key Lime Pie
Lobster Roll
Salad

“It was a delicious sandwich (roll) lobster 🦞, very simple, small area, prices same as other places that serve lobster rolls, ❣️ but excellent, including very cute quaint curio shops, we go in and enjoy lobster rolls every chance we get to head to the Florida Keys. ❣️try it ‼️ it's always an adventure ❣️“

4.2 Good61 Reviews
Caribbean royale Seafood •
82775 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada
5 Superb1 Reviews
Tides Beachside Bar & Grill Seafood • $
82100 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Mango Shrimp Tacos
Islander Burger
Conch Fritters
Key Lime Pie
Tuna Nicoise

“Einfach Wunderbar 🌴💚 I'm freien sitzen und auf das Meer schauen, essen lecker, leider alles in Plastik serviert“

3.8 Good22 Reviews
Marker 88 Seafood • $$
88000 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Famous Homemade Key Lime Pie
Old Man and the Sea Tacos
Islamorada Fish Sandwich
Cheeseburger in Paradise
Yellowtail Meuniere
Hot Blue Crab Dip
Key Lime Seafood
Shrimp -N- Grits
Seafood Platter
Lobster Bisque

“They kept the charm of the old Marker 88 in little details like keep the 2 GREEN covered table and benches almost in the same location as before... a iconic scene was shot in one of them on a episode of BLOODLINE. Food is as good if not better than before if that is possible.... service is excellent too. Friendly staff including hostess/host and waitresses/waiters very impressed with the new dock and WOW EVERY table has a GREAT view to take in LOTS of selfies were being taken during my visit, I celebrated my 78th Birthday 1 day before and had Fresh Mahi Mahi Tacos for Lunch. So happy they did a complete do over after the destruction from the hurricane that so much damage to the beautiful Keys. Welcome Back Marker 88! Happy to see you there....“

4 Good471 Reviews
Papa Joe's Waterfront, Islamorada Seafood • $$
79786 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

10oz Burger Sweet Potatoe Fries Triple Tail
Chicken Brussels Sprouts and Mac and Cheese
Watermelon and Burrata Salad
Key West Pink Shrimp Curry
Everglades Style Grouper
Pork Belly Burnt Ends
Sweet Potato Fries
Crispy Gator Bites
Chicken Sandwich
Conch Fritters

“great food and atmosphere“

4.5 Superb291 Reviews
Green Turtle Wine & Spirits Bar • $
81219 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie

“First night in Islamorada,too tired from the days traveling,so we ordered a Turtle Inn salad with grilled chicken to split. Super fresh produce,homemade dressing. It brought us back for a second visit.“

4.5 Superb84 Reviews
Whale Harbor Marina Seafood
83413 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

“The best place to do everything the keys has to offer!!“

4.4 Superb91 Reviews
20

SandBar

SandBar Bar & Grill • $$
83413 Overseas Hwy #1, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Marinated Ceviche on Tostones
Smoked Fish Dip with Tostones
Blackened Fish Tacos
Shrimp \u0026 Crab
Octopus Salad
Ahi Tuna Poke
Crab Dip
Seafood

“If you're looking for one of the best ocean views in Islamorada, The Sandbar is a must visit! The atmosphere is perfect — not too crowded, and the live music adds a great touch without being overwhelming. The real standout, though, is bartender Carlos. He’s an absolute gem — friendly, attentive, and always makes you feel right at home. Highly recommend this spot for a relaxing, enjoyable time by the water!“

4.5 Superb33 Reviews
Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar Bar • $$
96 Madeira Rd, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Lorelei World Famous Madeira Bay Fish Sandwich
Frozen Key Lime Pie with Mango Sauce
Peppercorn Crusted Yellowfin Tuna
Alaskan Snow Crab Platter
Tropical Coconut Shrimp
Bayside Grilled Chiken
Sunset Conch Fritters
Captain's Quesadilla
Bacon Wrapped Shrimp
Stone Crab Chowder

“The very best Key Lime Colada in the Keys! Amazing prices and food! Beautiful outdoor setting for watching the sunset.“

4.2 Good499 Reviews
Kaiyo Grill & Sushi Sushi • $$$
81701 Old Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Scallops and Lobster Mash Potatoes
Candied Brussel Sprouts
Macadamia Hogfish Roll
Yellowtail Tiradito
Yellowtail Sashimi
Yellowtail Snapper
Steamed Dumplings
California Roll
Stuffed Avocado
Eggplant Chips

“I can’t speak highly enough of our experience. Party of 6 with fresh catch prepared by Chef Michael. He prepared our Wahoo 3 ways; sashimi and two hot preparations served with rice. All being self proclaimed foodies, not one person at the table denied it was one of the best meals of our lives! We did enjoy two of their sushi rolls and they were also fantastic! Chef Michael and our server were so friendly and made our experience a definite 10! Everyone needs to visit them! Thank you for a very memorable evening, we will return every chance we get!“

4.2 Good79 Reviews

Customers` Favorites

Brisket Sandwich with Fries and Collards
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Creamy Coleslaw
Mac and Cheese
Baked Beans
Pulled Pork
Cornbread
Sauce
Ribs
Wings

“Best bbq I’ve had in years!!!!! Worth the visit 100%“

4.1 Good77 Reviews
Islamorada Fish Company Seafood Markets • $$
81532 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

World Famous Islamorada Sandwich
Oysters on the Half Shell Dozen
Fried Seafood Combo Basket
Islamorada Fish and Chips
Whole Yellowtail Snapper
Key Lime Pie in a Cup
Stone Crab Claws
Smoked Fish Dip
Conch Fritters
Coconut Shrimp

“Love this restaurant! 10/10. We had the fish and chip-best I have ever had! We also had the key lime pie because you have to when you are in the Keys! Soooo good! Then there is the atmosphere-tarpons swimming by, pelicans floating, and the view-wow! To add to that there was great music from a singer (didn’t catch his name) and a wonderful waitress! Definitely will be back!“

4 Good361 Reviews
MM 88 Tiki Bar Bar • $$
88 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Key Lime Pie
Crab Cake

“Marker 88 is an absolute gem in Islamorada! The atmosphere is relaxed and beautiful, with unbeatable waterfront views, but the highlight of my visit was the blackened hogfish with Tabasco butter sauce. Perfectly seasoned, cooked just right, and the sauce was incredible — rich, flavorful, and with just the right amount of kick. It’s one of those dishes you’ll be thinking about long after the meal. The service was friendly and attentive, making the whole experience even better. If you’re in the Keys, Marker 88 is a must-visit for both the food and the setting. Highly recommend!“

3.8 Good110 Reviews
Puerto Vallarta Mexican Bar & Grill Mexican • $
86701 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Carne Asada A la Tampiqueña
Chicken or Steak Fajitas
Vallarta Mahi Tacos
Chips & Salsa to Go
Quesadillas Vallarta
Whole Red Snapper
Rice and Beans
Shrimp Tacos
Seafood Soup
Wet Burrito

“Nice atmosphere, good food, a great drinks.“

3.6 Good107 Reviews
Atlantic's Edge Restaurant Fine Dining • $$$
81801 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Grilled Cheese with Fries
Key Lime Pie of the Day
Mahi Mahi Sandwich
Whole Snapper
Fried Snapper
Avocado Toast
Crab Cakes
Sushi
Poke

“What and exceptional meal. Our server was possibly the sweetest human we gave met on our vacation. The staff is so courteous and professional. Our meal was a special treat and we were given top star service. The meal itself was a showstopper. Our daughter is a picky eater and was treated with such care. The Mahi Mahi is absolutely one of the most exquisite dishes. I was able to pair it with a side reserved for the specials (coconut rice) and honestly it should be served as such. My husband got a rib and shrimp meal and loved every bite. Our desserts were equally incredible. If you want a family friendly meal (that's a treat) you HAVE to check out Atlantics edge.“

3.8 Good272 Reviews

You May Also Like