27 Best Seafood Restaurants near Key Colony Beach

“Outstanding service, food and drinks! Went there for my birthday dinner and it was great! We will be back soon!“

“AMAZING!!!! Had dinner as a last minute decision, and we were completely impressed with Barracuda Grill. We all had the special, lobster scallop and shrimp linguini. Salads were great, entrees were top notch, and the staff were really friendly. Highly recommended.“

“Great vibes- great food!!!“

“Oh my goodness! Everything is so good! Excellent service. We tried the blackened Hogfish, smoked fish dip, grouper, tuna, stone crab legs, Mac and Cheese hamburger, stone crab chowder, crunchy peanut butter pie and Iguana Bait on draft. Yum! Highly recommend!“

“I really wish I had the black bean salad recipe! It was great and will be missed“

“Happy 25th anniversary! 👏🏻👏🏻“

“Love this place! We’ve been coming here many times throughout the years and enjoy the atmosphere and delicious food! Our ONLY issue here has been one specific, rude waitress. Today was the 2nd time we’ve had her as our waitress. First time (last year) she attended our families, we noticed she was rude, but gave her the benefit of the doubt, figuring she was having a bad day. But today, she was being extremely rude, unprofessional and seemed annoyed. She treated our kids poorly and treated the adults like kids. I’d still recommend this place, but please be aware not to have TANIA as your waitress!“

“We had a delicious dinner- lovely restaurant and great service -every course was freshly made and wonderful! Pricey but worth every penny . Fresh muddled mango mojito- the best 👍👍“

“I got the smoked fish dip and it was a 10 , delicious“

“The Cracked Conch has, without a doubt, the very BEST Conch Chowder in the Keys... I bought extra to-go to have later when I'm far from the keys!“

“Relaxing, chill tiki bar right on the water. It’s behind the Bluegreen Vacations Resort and open to the public. We had the Friday night all you can eat Mahi fish fry and it was delicious. Best fish we had while in the Keys. Highly recommend the Mahi fried fish.“

“Fun place for families, with lawn games in the beautiful outdoor eating area. Local live music. Kids enjoyed the BBQ options. Conch and clam chowders were great. Good kids menu.

Kid-friendliness: Kid menu, backyard games and live music.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

I recently had the pleasure of dining at The Plaza Grill, and it was nothing short of phenomenal! We stumbled upon this hidden gem while attending a show at the theater next door, and I’m so glad we did.
🍽️
The baked brie was an absolute standout, and the calamari paired with their incredible red sauce immediately set the tone for a fantastic meal. Once we tasted that sauce, we knew we were in for a treat!
🍽️
The service was impeccable, making our experience even more enjoyable. The atmosphere was inviting, and I loved the charm of the place from the outside.
🍽️
Being Italian and from New York, I have high standards for Chicken Parmesan, and The Plaza Grill did not disappoint. The chicken was perfectly crispy, with just the right amount of sauce, and they generously served pasta on the side, which was equally amazing and enough for two to share.
🍽️
We will definitely be back! If you're looking for a delightful dining experience, I highly recommend The Plaza Grill.
The only downside is that we were so enjoying the company, ambience and food. I forgot to take pictures.📸“

“Been coming here for the last 3 years and we love this place the food is awesome and our server Kris is the best we ask for him every time we come“

“Great view of the races,cold beer @ beautiful bartenders“

“Hidden Gem. Great food, good service, awesome atmosphere. The grouper cheeks are insanely good.“

“A group of 6 of us had a fabulous dinner here last night. Had reservations and were seated immediately when we got there. Linda our server was witty and clever, but never too familiar. She did an excellent job, of talking us through the specials. 5 out of the 6 of us ordered specials. Everything was delicious. A few of us ordered desserts. Not sure why, we were so stuffed by the portions. There were plenty of to go boxes. 😂“

“Great food chilled atmosphere, fab spot for breakfast or lunch“

“another awesome dinner, tonight we sat at the bar. did was great as usual, and the service was awesome. thank you“

“We are Canadians and been to the Panda House a number of times. Fresh food and friendly staff. Missed it last year as you were closed for renos.....Hope to get back and see the new Panda House.................“

“Blue Waters Grill is an amazing place to hang out. I come here once a month. Yadi, Yeni and Roberto are the best! They make you feel like family as soon as you come to the bar. They are the reason I come back once a month and stay here. Of you are coming to Marathon, you have to stop by Blue Waters Grill.“

“Great food! Great atmosphere! Catch your fish and get it prepared right here! Real nice Clark!“

“It was our first time eating there,,service was lacking a lot,,we had to ask for refills, she did leave a pitcher of water then. We ordered the lasagna dinner that comes with a side salad so we ordered another regular salad since we were splitting the meal. The side salad was pitiful, it came on a coffee saucer it looked like,the regular salad was a good size. For $24 the side salad should have been the same size as the extra salad. She brought our food and we sat there waiting on the bread,,,she comes back by and informed us bread was extra,,,really, I’ve never had a meal at any restaurant where you had to pay extra for bread, most will bring you more if you eat what they served you the first time. The upside was the lasagna was good.“

“Best seafood restaurant in the keys!“

“There are LOT of good food choices down in The Keys, but this was easily our best meal. The Cuban elements were ridiculously good. Wonderfully seasoned and every bite felt like home cooking. Their Key Lime Pie was basically a religious experience. Pretty sure the pastry chef's hands were anointed by The Lord. Thanks again, Stephen!“

“This is the best place to be, the best place to spend your SUNDAY and make it a FUNDAY, absolutely the best with an Epic and captivating Sunset 🥰😊“