12 Best Seafood Restaurants in Orange Park

Shrimp Shack Seafood Kitchen Seafood • $
646 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

30pc Fried Shrimp Dinner w 2 Sides Cheese Grits and Baked Potato
Senior Butterfly Shrimp
Catfish & Shrimp Fried
30 Piece Shrimp Dinner
Bang Bang Shrimp
Fish and Shrimp
Fried Mushrooms
Shrimp and Grits
Shrimp & Grits
Popcorn Shrimp

“I want to give a shout out to Amy, the general manager and her crew at The Shrimp Shack on December 17, 2024. I took my Momma there for a birthday lunch, (she’s turning 74 on December 18th), and while eating, my Momma had a seizure. Amy came over to our table and helped my Momma and keep me calm. Another employee called 911 while I was busy caring for her. Amy even told us to come back and eat at a later date and it would be no charge. I’m not sure if she’s a member of this group but thank you, ma’am for being there for my Momma and I. God put us in the right place at the right time. You’re a gem and I pray that God truly blesses you! ❤️“

4.6 Superb148 Reviews
Oyster Co-Op Seafood Market Seafood Markets • $$$
922-5 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp and Scallops
Live Crabs

“Sorry it has taken this long. I have been in a Crawfish coma since Father’s Day! You all are so amazing not only did they let me know live crawfish was coming in and revered me 10 pounds but totally hooked me up with a few more than what I ordered! Absolutely amazing customer service!! 10 out of 10 review for me!!“

4.8 Superb55 Reviews
Two Sisters and A Deviled Crab Seafood • $
1910 Wells Rd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Potato Fries w Cinnamon Butter
Lobster Mac -N- Cheese Balls
Tampa-Style Deviled Crab
Chicken & Waffle - Half
Whole Snapper Special
Sweet Fried Plantains
Big Strips with Fries
Strawberry Milkshake
Whistle Stop Special
Fried Green Tomatoes

“This is a hidden gem in the mall! I highly, highly recommend it and we will be back. PS the lobster mac-n- cheese balls are a MUST try. 🤤“

4.5 Superb93 Reviews
OP Fish House and Oyster Bar Seafood • $$
636 Kingsley Ave, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Captain's Platter Combination
Local Mayport Flounder Basket
Mama Shaw's Conch Fritters
Fresh Fried Clam Strip
Chef Jason's Brussels
Fried Green Tomatoes
Virginia Clam Strips
Homemade Hushpuppies
Oysters Rockefeller
Sweet Potato Fries

“Good food good service but they don’t know how to play music to their crowd. I love Guns N’ Roses and ZZ Top but it’s not there typical crowd for dining“

4.3 Superb287 Reviews
Crafty Crab Seafood • $$
950 Blanding Blvd #1, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Boil w Snowcrab Headless Shrimp and Side of Sausage
Lobster Snow Crab Legs and Shrimp Boil
Extremely Steamed Oysters
Crab and Shrimp Boil
Fried Shrimp Basket
Sweet Potato Fries
Chicken Fingers
Corn on the Cob
Lobster Tail
Raw Oysters

“The food is always fixed to perfection; however, I ordered the appetizer of oysters and for the price they were extremely small otherwise no other complaints. Will still go back.“

4.3 Superb105 Reviews
Tunis Seafood Wings Subs Seafood • $
290 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Burger and Seasoned Fries
Wings and Chicken Gizzards Combo
Fried Mushrooms Fried Oysters
Fried Calamari Combo
Gyro & Fries Combo
Fries with Sauce
Seafood Platter
Wings & Gizzards
Chicken Tenders
Tender Basket

“OP Tunis is so good. worth the wait for food cooked to order. friendly. ..always... and the cheesecake is YUMMY!“

3.8 Good84 Reviews
Irie Diner Caribbean Restaurant Caribbean • $
1177 Park Ave, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Jerk Chicken Served with Rice and Beans and Sweet Plantains
Homemade Pineapple Lemonade Per Gallon
Ackee and Salt Fish with Festival
Di Bahamas Conch Fritters
Barbadian Combo Platter
Dominica Veggie Station
Jamaican Style Oxtails
Tobago Coconut Shrimp
Jerk Pork Tenderlion
Jamaican Jerk Chicken

“First time dining today, it was delicious! Had the conch fritters and coconut shrimp, definitely recommend. Hubby had curry chicken and loved it. We will be going back again soon!! Owner and server were awesome as well💕“

4.6 Superb144 Reviews
Lola's Filipino Cafe & Mini Store Asian • $
1241-21 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Combo Meal 'Side' Choice
Fried or Paksiw Fish
Philippine Adobo
Pork Pata Paksiw
Chicken Inasal
Bistek Tagalog
Lechon Kawali
Cassava Cake
Fruit Salad
Leche Flan

“Everything is made with love. When you walk in, your nose will tell you you're in the right place. it is a warm and friendly atmosphere. Thanks for the wonderful food and memories!“

4.5 Superb88 Reviews
The Hilltop Restaurant American • $$
Recommended
2030 Wells Rd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Served with Mushroom Bordelaise Sauce and Horseradish Sauce
Chicken Marsala Florentine
Mashed Sweet Potatoes
Crab and Spinach Dip
Fried Green Tomatoes
Chicken Caesar Salad
Mini Pork Osso Buco
Pumpkin Cheesecake
French Onion Soup
Mixed Green Salad

“The Hilltop just hosted a surprise birthday party I put together for my wife and we couldn't have been more pleased. We ended up with over 70 guests enjoying an hour's worth of awesome appetizers and then serving stations offering 3 choices plus a carving station. Each of our family and friends were super complimentary of the food, and I would whole-heartedly agree with them. I have enjoyed meals there before so I already knew that would be great. Everyone loved the venue as well, and the kitchen, wait and bar staff were amazing to work with to get things setup just right. I checked out many other places in town, but The Hilltop came in as the best overall in value for per-person cost as well as everything that goes into selecting the best venue for an event like this. The guests that had been there before echoed the same, and the ones that hadn't dined there yet couldn't say enough good things about the food and the facility. This will by my go-to for any future events.“

4.4 Superb70 Reviews
El Pegao Restaurant Latin American • $
2177 Kingsley Ave #13, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Fried Pork Chops Rice and Beans and Fried Sweet Plantain
Sorullitos Salsa Lelolay Corn Sticks with Lelolay Sauce
Chicken Breast with Salad & Fried Plantains
Tenders with Fries or White Rice and Beans
Mofongo Camarones Al Ajillo O Salsa Criolla
Fried Pork Chops White Rice and Beans
Carne Frita Con Ensalada Y Tostones
Chicken Chicharrón and Mofongo
Mofongo and Steak with Onions
Mofongo Churrasco - Steak

“The food was so flavorful, you can tell the chef puts love into his dishes. I had the arroz con pollo, the pernil dish, and the porkchops and they were all delicious“

4.2 Good100 Reviews
Captain D's Seafood • $
318 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

2 Piece Fish & 2 Piece Chicken Meal
Sampler Platter
Hush Puppies
French Fries
Mac & Cheese
White Fish
Butterfly
Coleslaw
Sandwich
Seafood

“some people should really be ashamed of themselves i just witnessed a woman coming in the restaurant and claiming she is sick from the shrimp that she just ate and she want her money to be refunded. she claimed to feel so sick and nauseous that she maid have food poisoning and she will be going to the ER ... she was literally in the restaurant for 50 min and making a big deal out of everything... she got her money refunded and walks out to her car and puts a CIGAR in her mouth... lady if you are really that sick you wouldn't even feel like smoking... shame on you... I'm sorry for the girls in the restaurant working that had to deal with this person.. and thumbs up for staying calm... because just listening to that woman's BS made even me upset.“

3.2 Average78 Reviews
Red Lobster Seafood • $$
Across From Orange Park Mall, 32 Blanding Blvd, Orange Park

Customers` Favorites

Endless Chowder Salad & Cheddar Bay Biscuits
Half Dozen Cheddar Bay Biscuits
Walt's Favorite Shrimp Platter
The Ultimate Seafood Platter
Main Deck Margarita Flight
Salmon New Orleans Full
Classic Caesar Salad
Steak and Lobster
Brownie Overboard
Side House Salad

“it's not bad..My mom loves the place but nothing blows me away..“

3.5 Good168 Reviews

You May Also Like