50 Best Seafood Restaurants near Stock Island

“Rachel has amazing service. Overall she’s the best.“

“Payed a visit today!! Location is beautiful. I had the special of the day. Shrimp Alfredo! It was delicious. My husband had the fish and chips. Very good as well. The French fries were homemade. Ashley was awesome getting everyone waited on. Small and cozy atmosphere, beautiful setting, great food and fun music. We will definitely return!!“

“Lovely anniversary dinner. Excellent service and meal. They had a sign on our table wishing us a happy Anniversary and we had the best view of the sunset!!“

“A wonderful atmosphere and the staff are very friendly and make you feel a part of the family. The food is top notch and has an inviting appearance. Had never eaten there before but went as a birthday dinner and was not disappointed. Next time we are in town, Red Shoe is on top of the list to return too. We love this restaurant!“

“Awesome restaurant and menu. Very, very friendly service!“

“Excellent service and food.“

“the lobster roll was fantastic!! highly recommended this place“

“Great dining experience, excellent service, great food and drinks!!! Highly recommended“

“The Grouper sandwich is the bomb!!!! Bread is super fresh and the Grouper is just as fresh, deep fried to perfection with a light coating. The eatery is as Key Westie as you can get and the employees are nice, friendly and polite!! A must on everyone’s trip!!“

“This is the second time we have come in less than 4 months. It's a perfect view. The port offers drinks, meals and snacks to accompany it. Also on some occasions they bring live musicians and DJs to give the last touch to this incredible place. If you are in Key West, you can't miss this view!“

“We stayed right down the street at the Palms Hotel we were told we would get a discount at this food truck which we did not but ???? My wife had the fish and french fries and I had the chicken burrito with french fries and the food was great. The burrito was so huge. It was enough for three people, a little pricey for a food truck but I guess that’s what happens when you’re in Key West overall great rating great food really really good burrito“

“Very Friendly! Great roll!“

“Amazing restaurant, every last detail thought about when it comes to service, ambience, food, flavor! This place is awesome!! They are certainly aiming to please! We had the lobster risotto, the grouper oscar, escargot and stonecrab appetizer and lobster bisque, dirty martinis!! Finished with some key lime pie!! Ask for the love Nick from Georgia!! ??“

“It was recommended to us by some locals. The atmosphere is elegant, very clean and friendly staff. We had the Hogg fish which they are known for. Absolutely excellent dinner. Reasonably priced for where you are and what we ate. If you're ever in Key West I highly recommend dining here. We didn't call ahead and got right in at opening time. It would probably be a good idea to make a reservation, as we saw many people wait outside when we left. 5 stars ☆☆☆☆☆“

“Great food experience - plus Eric behind the bar is exceptional!! A should not be missed Key West place if you want a refined night out!!“

“Great service! Great food!“

“We had the best food and service while visiting Key West in June. Can wait to go back on our visit next weekend!“

“The bowls, tacos and poor boy’s are all amazing! Love this food truck!“

“The service and food was excellent! 5 out 5 stars. Have to go to morning happy hour! All of the food was wonderful….and the key lime pie was THE best!“

“Coldest Beer and best happy hour in Key West!! Best Irish bartender Annette. Her wit and attentive service makes it a relaxing and enjoyable place to have cold drinks and happy hour appetizers!! Highly recommend!!“

“tasty brunch followed by relaxing on the beach. Kids loved it here“

“I had the 1 pound Shrimp with potatoes and corn, cooked in the bag with butter and old bay season. It was super good ,price was better than most, food was cooked perfectly. service was spot on. Restaurant was clean and AC for a hot day. 5 star would definitely come again.“

“Love the happy hours. Delicious and generous appetizers and excellent drinks.“

“Stayed here for a 3 night weekend and I was not disappointed. Great location, price and ambiance. The breakfast buffet was always warm and tasty with sufficient options for the discerning pallette. The Pulled Pork, rice and beans with fried plantains was beautifully prepared and presented.“

“Great service. Unfortunately my yellow tail snapper was very over cooked and tough to eat.“

“Lobster rolls were Amazing!!! Best we have ever had because of the buttery rolls and tons of lobster.“

“Turtle Kraals is a coastal paradise that effortlessly earns a well-deserved 5-star rating! From the moment you step in, the vibrant and lively atmosphere welcomes you to a true island getaway. The menu is a delightful celebration of flavors, offering a wide array of mouthwatering dishes. From the fresh seafood to the flavorful Caribbean specialties, every bite is a culinary delight. The attentive staff adds to the overall enjoyment, making you feel like a cherished guest. For an unforgettable island dining experience, Turtle Kraals is an absolute must-visit!

Parking: safe“

“Very good food! The béer is good, I like this restaurant.“

“Came into Key Weat for our first time and came across this gem of a restaurant. Our waitress Sandy had just started a week ago and amazed our entire group with her energy and beautiful personality. Food was delicious and I really mean Delicious. Hope to return in the future and hope to see Sandy.“

“One of the best hotel and cafe restaurants in key west“

“I stopped by for a quick lunch and the experience was excellent. This restaurant has single oysters, which is perfect if you - like me - have never tried them before and don't want to commit to half a dozen. My server was really helpful with instructions on how to eat an oyster successfully, which was great because I was really nervous about it haha. Turns out, they're not that bad! Maybe even good..? I also tried the conch fritters and the Tito's hard lemonade, both of which were tasty as well.“

“Romantic dining with the most creative entrees . Such a memorable experience“

“Frita’s is our MUST have every year on our annual Key West vacation! Food is amazing and service is incredible!!“

“This place was phenomenal all around. The owner greeted us, management all greeted us, and staff was attentive all around. Lobster pizza and the street corn pizza were phenomenal. I loved the Pina colada key lime pie. It is by far the best key lime I have tried. The view, the chickens, all of it!!“

“Impressed and Amazed....that's how I'm starting off this post. Didn't know what to expect. I honestly hadn't heard to much, but I have heard it was all positive. We went there for my wife's birthday and a friend. We started off with cocktails which were just amazing. My wife had the Island expresso...OMG...she's not a coffee drinker, but I think this might have changed her mind. They made an impressive Coconut Bubble...you got to go there to see what I mean. I had the 1865 Smoked Old Fashioned...best one I have every had and our friend had the purple Cucumber Collins and she was so excited and happy with the flavor and presentation. For the food...first...everything on the menu looked good. We started with Appetizers that included the Cornbread Madeleines that were so good followed by the Pietro's Calamari...OMG...Best on the island...I'm serious when I say that...absolutely the best! and our friend ordered the Ahi Tuna Tartare Tostada with a mango yolk and the Stuffed Avocado with Lump Crab. The outside of the avocado looked just like the outside of an avocado, but it was black lime which was so good and genius. We decided to have the Prime Rib for two, which actually fed all 3 of us and a lobster tail. All perfectly cooked. Let me also say our waiter, Veli, was just the best. So friendly and helpful and very, very knowledgeable about the menu and the offerings. Just expanded on the experience we had. By dessert time we were so full, but since it was my wife's birthday she got to choose and her selections was the Smoked Chocolate & Cherries...WOW...is all I can say. All the staff from setting up the reservation to those filling our water and delivering our food were just so friendly and professional. This is a wonderful atmosphere, where you can sit inside with wonderful views or sit out side and enjoy the water and for us the sunset. We island dressed up for this, but we saw people who came in to dine in just relaxing attire. We'll be back...especially at happy hour as they have a really nice offering. Put this place on your must go restaurant. I know we have!“

“Great fish tacos and pasta salad!“

“It was great! Thanks Lenny for the good help, the good cocktails and the good food! �“

“Many friends recommended! Glad we listened, fantastic food and laidback chill feel.“

“Amazing service, food and atmosphere! Definitely a hidden gem within Key West. A must try if you are in the area“

“All I can say is check this place out! The food is amazing!“

“Lovely place for breakfast! Me and my family ate eggs, pancakes, bacon and bread for a really reasonable price. The coffee was really good as well! The two people who ran it were really friendly and were happy to talk to us about Key West after we ate. It is also in a beautiful courtyard with seats both outside and inside.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly“

“The best place in the keys to hang out before sundown!“

“Have been there twice. Last year was amazing. Everything perfect. This year, the special was prawn (not gulf coast shrimp as specified) and the prawn had the seafood stank, unlike typical fresh seafood. Didn’t want to cause a stink. Way overpaid IMO, we’ll be back about a 50:50 shot. Wasn’t busy? Perhaps off season? Idk.“

“Excellent staff and owner who cares about everyone.“

“Oh my goodness, what a wonderful experience we had when dining with you on November 30th! The food was incredible and service was outstanding! If you like martinis, they have many to choose from. We celebrated my husband’s birthday with a beautiful sunset view. (Thank you to the staff for making it extra special!)Seriously, a perfect dining experience! When in Key West, definitely dine here!“

“Food was spectacular; service low key (pun intended) and great limeades“

“Great food and drinks-Enjoy.“

“Always a fun time & loved the veggie quesadilla“

“Best dinner on the island! Four of us luckily got a late reservation on a rainy Christmas evening (2023). Food was fabulous! Service top-notch. Great atmosphere. Nice specials were offered for a holiday dinner.“

“Amazing food! Very friendly and attentive staff. Did I mention amazing food! Thank you for a great time!“