25 Best Ice Cream Shops in Tallahassee

“A Tallahassee must-visit! Tried my first snowball here and I’m officially a fan. The Tiger's Blood/Mango Lemonade combo is a game-changer. The location is adorable, right by the park, making it the perfect spot for a sweet treat and a walk. I'll definitely be back!
Ciao 🌸“

“The employees quickly served a line of happy customers! I require sugar~free options and the SF tangerine Italian ice was delicious!!“

“The ice cream and the service was really good. It gets kinda loud so be sure to make your voice a little louder. Atmosphere is okay. There’s some flies and the place is small but can’t help it when the door is consistently being opened. Overall really cute Icecream date idea“

“We love Jeremiah's! My daughter and I go at least once a month to grab a sweet treat here or one of their other locations. Staff is always friendly. You also get a nice amount of serving. We usually get the small they run around $6.I would say the tables outside sometimes may need a little cleaning.All you have to do is mention it to an employee and they will get right to it. 🙂“

“The employees quickly served a line of happy customers! I require sugar~free options and the SF tangerine Italian ice was delicious!!“

“We adore Nuberri! Whenever we come to town my kids always want to go, we’ve never found any better froyo anywhere else!“

“So I just took my kids for an end of the school year treat and I will be back! We walked in and I told the guy it was our first time in and he was so sweet and helpful. He welcomed us in and explained the menu as we looked it over and then we all chose what we wanted. One of my boys got bubble gum with sour spray and the other got blue raspberry with sour spray...they LOVED them! My 2 year old got whatever blue they had and I got the unicorn and let me tell you....it was absolutely amazing! I can't wait to go back and try something else. 10 out of 10!!“

“I had to bring my dog and the owner working stood outside and held his leash for me while I got my ice cream. Even with a store full of people she was very kind and helpful towards me!“

“just had Barb's chocolate sunflower ice cream! Voted #1 ice cream by the Food Network in the state of Florida! Just delicious! what a treat you have to try it!“

“Went in today for a 4 pack and this location does not disappoint. The cookies were amazing and warm. The staff was so kind and helped me pick my cookies, Layla, Jayla, and Alejandro were amazing super friendly and quick with my order. Definitely will be coming back!“

“We had a team bonding event at Peterbrook. It was fantastic! We learned so many things about the history of chocolate and had some good laughs as we made our treats. I highly recommend this local store! You won’t be disappointed ❤️“

“Aw man, is it good! The quality of the ice cream here is top-tier, and I love that they always have something new to try with their rotating menu. The staff is friendly, competent, and straightforward, and I really appreciate how clean and well-kept the location is. Highly recommend!“

“Wish more people came to the reviews to give good workers their props by name so they can get paid more…. I watched a lady come by complaining she got the wrong flavor a WEEK AGO and demanding a free shake while calling the worker “stupid“ for mixing up the cake batter and birthday cake flavors that are right next to each other and are basically the same. Luckily the workers kept their cool while being able to manage the busyness of the store. Couldn’t have been me… happy the workers didn’t quit or beat her up, it takes a lot of self control. And she still walked off satisfied after cursing out the workers who help her. Most of them are usually nice people and easy to talk to , a lot of them still in COLLEGE.“

“I love the food, it’s fast and simple, great ppl running it. Way to go Chewbees 👍“

“My fav place to go for Poke in town! The food is perfect and the portions are exact! I really like getting the create your own poke bowl, and the sweet chili sauce is my favorite. The staff are sweet and attentive and make sure I'm well taken care of!“

“Good coffee. Big windows. Semi-rustic decor with some industrial elements like exposed ducts, polished concrete floor. Visited on a Friday, got a decaf drip...tasty....nicely allowed a refill for free (like at Starbucks). However, came back the next day. Ordered a ham-egg croissant and a drip decaf. Was given an Americano decaf (like the day before, since they don't make decaf drip) and charged for it, not for drip as the day before. No apologies. Plus their payment processor added an automatic 2 dollar tip which should not be set to tip at 20 percent by default. The ham-egg-cheese croissant was flattened and not very good. Plus if you want half and half you have to ask a barista, like its a big deal. All in all my opinion dropped. It's a Starbucks knockoff chain local to Florida with ice cream (at the one I went to) but not always as good or generous as Starbucks. This felt slightly less generic than most Starbucks due to the fancier rustic/industrial decor, but it's also small inside so tends to feel cramped.“

“I love this place so much. Every staff member I’ve met has been incredibly nice and efficient, even when there were a few more customers in the store. The space is very clean and cute and every boba and mochi I’ve tried has been delicious. 10/10 recommend them and I will continue to recommend them lol.“

“5 Stars ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had an incredible experience at Culver’s that went far beyond great food. I accidentally threw away my phone with my tray and was honestly panicking. When I told the staff, they immediately jumped into action and went through their trash—without hesitation—to help me find it. Their kindness and willingness to help meant the world to me. That level of customer service is rare and so appreciated. On top of that, the food was absolutely delicious and made fresh. You can tell they take pride in both what they serve and how they treat people. Thank you to the amazing team at Culver’s—you truly went above and beyond!“

“It would sure be nice if you guys would start accepting cash again definitely a a pretty messed up thing to do not accept the number one form of currency in our country“

“delicious and very nice staff“

“We traveled 2 1/2 hours from Alabama to Tallahassee. We found things to do downtown to add to our day. However, the main purpose of our trip was to visit this restaurant. The pizza was amazing. We went that far based on the recommendation of 2 of my Italian 🇮🇹 Army flight students at Fort Novosel (Rucker). They told us your restaurant had the most authentic Italian 🇮🇹 style pizza they had found within 3 hours of Fort Novosel. I fully agree with their assessment. The pizza was nearly identical to what we ate in Naples, Italy 🇮🇹 6 years ago. We look forward to visiting again in the future. Maybe when we go back, it will be warmer so we can enjoy more of Tallahassee. BTW, for those in other reviews that complained about the crust being nearly paper thin, that is how it is in Italy 🇮🇹. This restaurant aims to make authentic Italian pizzas. If that is not what you are looking for, you need to find an American 🇺🇸 style pizza restaurant.“

“Love the friendly staff ~~ and Pumpkin Pie Blizzards!! 🥰“

“great food and atmosphere!“

“I was traveling from Gainesville and needed food in a pinch. I hesitated coming because I hadn't been to a dairy queen in yearsss. I am so happy I chose this over mcdonalds down the road. It was the best fast food burger i have had in a while! It was so hot and delicious. The staff was great 10/10“

“Much better location than certain other locations especially ones on Capital circle East or west. The manager has made sure that there's no drips on the cones and the cup was cleaned off so there is nothing to worry about getting on your clothes very nice“