13 Best American Restaurants in Gary

“Great Food friendly atmosphere“

“Best pizza ever since I was little“

“This was my 3rd experience and I usually carryout. This time we decided to dine in. The pancakes and grits are definitely worth the drive. The salmon cakes are one item you want to get while you're there. Despite having great and affordable food, the dining area and dead insects in the window sills need to be addressed. Can't wait to continue the support.“

“Flamingos has been in town for a long time. Nice little cozy place. A good perch dinner. We like a thin crust pepperoni pizza. The flavor of the pizza dough reminds me of Onos which was one of the Best pizza places, that has a Great flavor to it that you can not find anywhere. The cheese is stretchy when hot. Good flavor! Thumbs up?for Flamingos!“

“Our first visit to this steakhouse was exceptional from start to finish. The hostesses were warm and welcoming, and we appreciated being able to choose our preferred seating.
Our server, Melissa, was friendly, knowledgeable, and her recommendations were excellent. Most of all she was thoughtful. When she saw my camera come out she offered to take pictures and after I told her I wasn’t going to order a cocktail due to a headache, she checked in on it later on. She made for a great experience.
The Chilean sea bass was perfectly cooked with a delicate texture and delicious sweet sauce, while the ribeye was cooked to a perfect medium and was juicy, tender, and full of flavor.
Chef Arthur stopped by our table and we were able to personally compliment him on the incredible lobster and shrimp dumpling appetizer, which was absolutely delicious.
The combination of exceptional service, outstanding food, and genuine hospitality made for a memorable evening. We look forward to returning and trying other dishes although it’ll be hard not to order the Chilean sea bass and ribeye again because they were that good!“

“Disappointing..the chili/koney sauce was very salty to the point it was nesrly inedible. ..I think since it was late afternoon, it simmered to the point where it became concentrated due to evaporation and it needed some liquid to even out the extreme salt content... the dogs were good, the chili cheeseburger was almost impossible to eat..so messy. Fries were.probably the highlight of my visit the lady behind the counter was excellent though 👍👍 Great service I probably would try them again though....possibly the saltiness was an anomaly“

“They have some of the best Catfish in town period…..“

“Love my tavern family always😎🥰🥳✨“

“If you’re a real hookah smoker, this is the place. The hookah is incredibly smooth, high quality, and definitely the real deal. The atmosphere is classy, relaxing, and not getto at all!! Even the crowd is respectful and classy, which really adds to the experience. Everything is always clean, the staff is friendly and welcoming, and the service is consistently great. I come here a couple of times a week, and every visit has been amazing. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a premium hookah spot with great vibes and top-tier hookah!“

“Great cheese steak !!!! Gotta try u s steal sandwiches 😂😂yummy!!“

“Everything was so delicious. I'm not cooking anymore on Sunday.“

“Was looking for a good buffet after the Horshoe's buffet in Hammond closed (never re opened since Covid).

Maaaaan this place is prettttty good! One major downside is there are no restrooms in the buffet area, which makes it awkward if you wanna use it between your meal, since you lose your access once you step outside.

Realistically I think the team is pretty understanding about all that but still, it is an inconvenience.

Otherwise it's all great. About 50 bucks per person if you don't got any special or membership or nothing. So pricy but I'd say worth it.“