12 Best American Restaurants in Gary

Arman's Restaurant American • $
5875 Melton Rd, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Chili Dog and Fries with Onion Rings
Chili Cheese Polish
Cheeseburger
Taco Special
Chicago Dog
Cheese Dog
Hamburger
Cheese Cup
Brownies
Hot Dog

“We just ate at the last Armans Hot Dog stand....totally delicious!The building isn't big inside or out, small parking (also, because it is crowed inside), but it is clean and the owner and his staff are very friendly.To us, better than Pops & Nick's in Crown Point.Also, it's right across from the Miller Train Station .... which looks like it is pretty close to opening....wahoooo!Parking: It's a small parking lot... and it is filled most of the time.“

4.5 Superb57 Reviews
Miller Pizza Co. American • $
622 1/2 S Lake St, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Mushroom Deep Dish
Italian Beef Sandwiches
Garlic Cheese Bread
Hot or Mild Wings
Mozzarella Sticks
Thin Crust Pizza
Order of Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Stuffed Pizza
French Fries

“The guy that waited on me was really nice, however when I came back to pick up my pizza, that young lady showed me she did not want to be bothered, I told the guy she should be in the back with that attitude. Still gave 5 because pizza never disappoint, However if I go in again and she gives me that attitude, good pizza want matter.Parking: You park in back which not alot of space, or you can park in the next business lot, some people park on side that taking a chance you can get side swiped.“

4.2 Good97 Reviews
Balkan Grill Company American • $
3101 Grant St, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Wrapped Chicken
Chicken & Mushrooms
Balkan Mixed Meat
Side of Cabbage
Gourmet Burger
Stuffed Burger
Chicken Kabob
Cabbage Salad
Cevapi Large
Bean Soup

“Second time here. Got the mixed meat. Phenomenal! Fresh meats perfectly cooked. Fresh homemade bread and the spreads, especially the white one are delicious. Truckers take my word on this. Great portion size and healthy macros. Going back before I head back to Texas. 10/10“

4.4 Superb40 Reviews
Flamingo Pizza of Miller Pizza • $
8341 Locust Ave, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Nperch & Shrimp Basket
Calzone with Cheese
Buffalo Chicken
Flamingo Pizza
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wrap
Supreme Pizza
Cheeseburger
Italian Beef
Cheese Pizza

“If you're bothered by smoke, you're not going to like it here, although there is non smoking dining in the back. If that doesn't bother you, this is one of THE best bars in NW Indiana. Diverse crowd, awesome bartenders, good bar food, music during the summer. Great neighborhood bar.Reasonable prices, especially for drinks.Parking: Parking can get tight on weekends during prime time.Kid-friendliness: No kids. Period. Smoking bar.“

4.2 Good89 Reviews
Council Oak Steaks and Seafood Steak House • $$$
5400 W 29th Ave, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Council Seafood Medley Soup
Ceaser Salad with Anchovies
Duck Fat Potato Hashbrown
Duck Butter Fried Heaven
Raw Bar Sampler for Two
Bread Rolls and Butter
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Anniversary Dessert
Loaded Baked Potato
Dry Aged Meatballs

“Great place for a family celebration. Eugene was well beyond service expectations! Make sure to request him. Friendly, extremely attentive to the details, and will make your experience the best. Menu changes based on what events are happening in the casino. Come hungry and enjoy an appetizer (that can be a meal in itself) and any entree cooked to perfection.“

4 Good87 Reviews
Ques Lounge Lounges • $
4469 Broadway, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Wings

“I want to personally thank the owner and ALL of the staff at Que's Lounge..They made sure my sister's 60th birthday party was a success.. They were professional, friendly, and made sure we got everything we needed.. Excellent!!!Count it all Joy...Thank you so much ❤️“

4.6 Superb22 Reviews
Tavern of the Oaks Bar • $$
6201 W 25th Ave, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Jumbo Chili Cheese Dog
Grilled Ham & Cheese
Toast & Hash Browns
Double Cheeseburger
Mac N Cheese Bites
Buffalo Tenders
Cheese Sticks
Side of Toast
Egg Omelet W

“Tavern of the Oaks has great food. I highly recommend the wings and pizza. A community bar....reminds me of CHEERS! The owner Maria is cool and the bartenders are great-Frank,Amy,Sammy,Steve,Nichole and Shannon. Let's not forget Nila, the cook!! She can throw down in the morning. Great spot to stop after work. Right by the casino. Breakfast menu is fire, grits, eggs and bacon, hash browns and pancakes“

4.2 Good28 Reviews
Koney King Restaurant American • $
4601 Broadway, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Chili Cheese Fry Small
Chili Cheeseburgers
Grilled Bologna
Chicken Tenders
Bowl of Chili
Onion Rings
Chili Sauce
Koney Dog

“I worked there when I was a Junior in high school at Lee Wallace 1974.I rode my bicycle to & from work. Happy to see that Koney King is still open and providing wonderful chili, chili dogs and burgers to the community. I also remember Flamingo pizza, and Geno’s pizza on Broadway.“

4.1 Good39 Reviews
D & K Gourmet Salads and Soul Food Bowls American • $
625 S Lake St, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Soul Bowl with Jerk Chicken Yellow Rice with Herbs and Green Beans
Soul Bowl Fried Chicken Greens and Mac N Cheese
Pound Cake by the 1 Pound Cake Man
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Teriyaki Chicken Noodle Bowl
Kendalls Turkey Express
Homemade Peach Cobbler
Mac & Cheese Egg Rolls
Jerk Chicken Egg Rolls
Homemade Pound Cake

“My family and friend love this place we traveled a distance to get here and was just as we expected the food was great the people were polite ? ?Kid-friendliness: My grandchildren is never a problem when we go out so of course it didn't matter they were treated with respect“

4 Good67 Reviews
SteelCity CheeseSteaks Cheesesteaks • $
3101 W 5th Ave, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Double Bacon Cheeseburger
Philly Cheese Steak
5 PC Chicken Wing
Chicken Wings
Steak Fries
Burger
Catfish

“We're new to Gary, so we are constantly trying new places. We chose SteelCity based off of the pictures. Then looking at their menu, the options were endless and it was hard to decide.THE SERVICE: I ordered online and wasn't able to pick the time I needed to pickup our food. So I called. Let me tell you...the lady that answered the phone was great. She was patient with me and answered my questions. When I told her it was our first time trying the restaurant, she gave me some of the back story. When I was at the restaurant everybody was great. Not too often I see EVERYONE at an establishment enjoying what they do.THE FOOD: We decided we'd try burgers and 2 different styles of fries. The SteelCity Steak Fries were hands down an amazing experience and plentiful. The burgers were smash burger style and if you're like me, you love the crispy edges.LOCATION: The only issue I had was finding the restaurant. I pass it twice day and had NO IDEA it was there. The Marathon station it shares the space with definitely hides it. BUT...now that we know it's there, we will definitely be going back.Thank you for the great meal and awesome experience.“

4 Good65 Reviews
Charlie's Coney Island American • $
2490 Broadway, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Toast with Jelly Butter
Choice of Meat Omelets
Chili Cheese Fries
One Meat Sandwich
Hamburger Combo
Big Breakfast
Egg Sandwich
Grits Large
Sausage

“There’s something about the way the young lady takes my order that keeps me coming back for more. She’s soo nice, my order is always correct and fresh, and when I come to pick up she always greats me with a smile. She provided TOP TIER customer service everytime ?“

4.2 Good20 Reviews
Kings Wings & Things East Side NOT THE BROADWAY LOCATION Chicken Wings • $
800 E 21st Ave, Gary

Customers` Favorites

King Mozzarella Stick SM
Bacon Cheeseburger
10 Whole Wings
Crispy Chicken
Turkey Burger
Party Wings
Pizza Puff
Catfish

“Fried shrimp and deep fried wraps are REALLY good. Buffalo chicken sandwich is AMAZING and they have great daily and lunch specials. Keep in consideration their sign “we don’t serve fast food we serve good food” so be prepared for AT LEAST a 30 minute wait“

3.8 Good46 Reviews
Loading...
map Map