30 Best Mexican Restaurants near New Palestine

El Toro Bravo New Palestine Mexican • $
7242 US-52, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Ceviche and Queso Fundido
Mexican Street Tacos
Chicken Chimichanga
Cheese with Spinach
Flautas Mexicanas
Fajitas Chipotle
Chicken Fajitas
Acapulco Special
Steak Ranchero
Mexican Tacos

“It seems that they were not satisfied with the shrimp ceviche they ordered for takeout the previous night. They found that it did not appear to be shrimp or taste like shrimp. When they ordered takeout again the next day, they willingly exchanged the shrimp ceviche for another entree, just paying the difference in price. The restaurant allowed them to exchange the dish without any issues.“

4.2 Good72 Reviews
The Nopal Mexican • $
38 W Main St, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Fajitas
Steak Fajitas
Taco Salad
Burrito
Nachos

“We had a good experience at The Nopal. It was my first time to visit since they changed hands. The food was typical to other Mexican restaurants in our area, but slightly above average and the service was exceptional. Only took off one star because no margaritas! It seems they have no liquor license at this time, but they're working on it! I hope they get it before summer because they have a nice patio seating area and I would love to come back and enjoy another meal outside accompanied by a margarita.“

3.9 Good43 Reviews
Taco Bell Fast Food •
4045 S 600 W, New Palestine

Customers` Favorites

Cinnabon Delights 12-Pack
Burrito Supreme
Cheesy Roll Up

“Better then other Tacobells around they actually use normal portions where some TBs put very little. I still have issues with bigger orders. Last visit I was missing one item and another item was made incorrectly. They are fast to fix and replace any issues “

3.7 Good39 Reviews
Burrito Express Mexican • $
9355 E Washington St, Indianapolis - 7.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Extra Chips and Salsa
Chimichanga Dinner
Enchiladas Verdes
Lunch Chimichanga
Chicken Fajitas
Chicken Tostada
Burrito Express
Carnitas Tacos
Steak Burrito
Burrito Loco

“I’ve been here a few times and the food doesn’t disappoint. I did have a disappointing experience today with our bill however. There was an extra meal charged on our bill which I brought to our servers attention. When she returned, I found that instead of voiding and printing a corrected bill, she ran a credit charge for the overage. This meant I had to pay the higher incorrect charge and wait (from what I understand) a couple 3-4 days for the credit to return to my card. I don’t feel it appropriate that the customer pay for the billing error then have to wait for a refund. I did let them know I wasn’t happy about it. I will be watching that I do receive this credit. It also put a bad taste in my mouth about returning anytime soon.“

4.5 Superb62 Reviews
Red Cactus Mexican Restaurant & Bar Mexican • $
8142 E Southport Rd, Indianapolis - 7.86 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steak Fajita Chimichanga
Strawberry Margarita
Chips and Salsa
Arroz Con Pollo
Cheese Dip
Taco Salad
Guacamole
Burrito
Nachos

“I go to this restaurant all the time when I’m on that side of town. Quite a few of my friends live right around it. One of my favorite dishes is their hot and spicy chicken. Overall the experience is very pleasant and the food is excellent.“

4.4 Superb72 Reviews
Cessar Tacos Mexican • $
2107 N Post Rd, Indianapolis - 8.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Barbacoa Beef Barbacoa
Birria Tacos
Braised Beef
Asada Steak
Steak Taco
Al Pastor
Burrito

“This place is has some good Birria Tacos. I have yet to try more items on the menu, but I will soon. The prices are average, compared to most other places and taco trunks I visited. But the portion sizes is nothing close to the west coast or southern region.“

4.3 Superb95 Reviews
Guadalajara Grill Mexican • $
9918 E Washington St, Indianapolis - 6.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mexican White Cheese Quesadilla with Guacamole Beans Rice and Mild Mexican Salsa
Burritos Mexicans That's the Name
Enchiladas Guadalajara
Seafood Taco Salad
Caldo De Camaron
Chips and Salsa
Chicken Fajitas
Shrimp Fajitas
Seafood Nachos
Texas Fajitas

“I've been to a lot of different Mexican restaurants in the Indy metro area, and this is hands-down one of the BEST. Got the camarones a la diabla and they were wonderfully spicy (not too supremely spicy either). Choriqueso was very well seasoned and delicious as well. Service was immaculate too. This will not be our last time here either!“

4.2 Good107 Reviews
Caribe Marisqueria Seafood • $$
8855 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Langosta Rellena de Mariscos
Camarones Empanizados
Caldo De Mariscos
Empanadas De Camar
Seafood Molcajete
Caldo De Camaron
Fajitas Texanas
Flan Napolitano
Fried Mojarra
Mixed Ceviche

“Wow this place is fantastic. Unique menu with many things I’ve never seen at an Indianapolis restaurant. Not for people who fear flavor or new foods they are not catering to the American palette. Great atmosphere with music and decor that is on point. Clean bathrooms always and most importantly the best staff. Customer service is through the roof these folks take pride in their work, tip em extra cause I already know they deserve it.“

4.3 Superb68 Reviews
Costa's Grill Greek • $
1020 W Main St, Greenfield - 7.03 miles

Customers` Favorites

Athenian Salad with Chicken
Gyro with Greek Fries
Tenderloin Sandwich
Mashed Potatoes
Chicken Kabobs
Greek Chicken
Greek Burger
Greek Salad
Gyros Plate
Falafel Gyro

“This is the first time I have visited this restaurant since they changed to Mexican and Greek Restaurant from Greek and American, my husband has been and liked it, so we went today, had the deep fried chicken chimichanga, warm fresh tortilla chips and homemade salsa were served almost as soon as we were seated, also ordered the cheese dip appetizer, everything was delicious, chimichanga was loaded with tender chicken!“

4.2 Good85 Reviews
Taqueria Los Potrillos Food Trucks •
8925 42nd St, Indianapolis - 10.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Served with Cheese
Arroz Y Frijoles
Street Tacos

“The food was hot and delicious. Reasonably priced for 2 tacos and a drink. It was raining at the time so I sat in the car until my food was ready. The food truck is near the new justice center I think off of justice way. You won't be disappointed.“

4.5 Superb38 Reviews
La Iguana Mexican restaurant Mexican • $
8895 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.58 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pescado Frito Mojarra Fried Fish Mojarra
Mini Hamburguesas Mini Cheeseburgers
Deditos De Pollo Chicken Fingers
Mojarra Al Chile Limon
Caldo De Camaron
Lengua Tongue
Carne Asada

“The new server is very polite and patient and presented herself with etiquette. She smiled alot and was very attentive! The food was on point (I'm a certified chicken and steak tacologist). Everything was well seasoned! The chips and salsa aren't the typical chips and salsa style, but better! The restaurant was very clean and the music complimented my margarita ?... it was like an extra shot of tequila in my cup. I didn't expect so much swag and atmosphere before I walked in. I am definitely glad I did, and I appreciate having places like La Iguana I can go to when I need great food!“

4.7 Superb27 Reviews
Terramar Mariscos y Carnes Seafood • $$
8143 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Botana Camarones A la Diabla
Fajitas de Camarones
Molcajete De Carnes
Orden de Tostadas
Filete Empanizado
Ceviche Camaron
Aguachile Mix
Refried Beans
Salsa
Chips

“Not the Mexican you're used to. Focuses on seafood. You won't get lovely, spicy, chunky salsa with your chips. You get mayo and ceviche. Can't even ask for salsa, you know like Chi-Chi's, On The Border, or Pace. Nice people, good staff. My wife likes seafood so I go. Drinks seem very watered down (not just my opinion) so stick to beer.“

4.3 Superb53 Reviews
Don Rigo Mexican Bar & Grill Bar & Grill • $
1336 N State St, Greenfield - 8.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Enchiladas Rancheras
Guacamole Mexicano
Mexican Guacamole
Pablo's Burrito
Nachos Supreme
Fajita Burrito
Beans and Rice
Chicken Fajitas
Mexican Salad
Burrito Loco

“Don Rigo never disappoints. The food comes out quickly and always tastes great. The shrimp chimichanga is delicious. So are the QuesaBurria tacos. The 88 ounce margarita tower is fun for a group!We do try to avoid going during peak hours because the restaurant is rather small and can be very crowded during busy times. The layout feels cramped and it can be difficult to get around because of how narrow the paths are between the tables. When we do go at busier times, the wait time is usually fast. The bar side is the restaurant offers a bit more room than the main room. We usually try and sit in there.“

4.1 Good79 Reviews
Los Vaqueros Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $$
301 E Main St, Greenfield - 7.85 miles

Customers` Favorites

Two Beef Tacos Rice and Beans
Grilled Chicken & Steak
Lunch Chimichanga
Chicken Fajitas
Beans and Rice
Burrito Carbon
Lunch Fajitas
Carne Asada
Chilaquiles
Taco Salad

“Really enjoy going to this restaurant. The service is always great and the food is awesome. My wife gets the Pollo Ranchero and I got the Texas taco salad this time (delicious). Always amazed with waiters, they look like they are almost running to take care of orders. Have had a great experience every time we've ate here.“

4.1 Good75 Reviews
Valle Grill and Cantina Mexican • $
1550 N State St, Greenfield - 8.52 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chorizo Beans & Cheese Nachos
Beef Burrito Rice and Beans
Grilled Chicken or Steak
Chimichanda Texana
Burrito Carbon
Fajita Nachos
Tecate Bottle
Tossed Salad
Texas Fajitas
Molcajete

“We ordered the alambre and it was delicious. We also had the children's nachos which is a more than generous size and will last for two meals. We had a tamale that was slightly undercooked on one side but the staff was very humble and gracious and quickly offered to make up for it with a new one, but my mother was quite full at that point. For dessert My son and mom had the had a flan which was amazing.Portion sizes were over generous and we are able to take home leftovers for a second meal. They even gave us some salsa to take home as well.The entire restaurant, including the bathrooms were exceptionally clean. We highly recommend and wish that they were closer to us so we could frequent here more often.Dietary restrictions: I do not eat anything that comes from a cow. They were very accommodating of this. My mother does not eat anything spicy and they made sure that her sauces came on the side.Kid-friendliness: The wait staff was very friendly and kind to my 5-year-old child listened and spoke to him directly.“

4.3 Superb37 Reviews
Ranchera Bar & Grill Mexican •
2806 N 600 W, Greenfield - 7.2 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Enchilada
Chicken Fajitas
Burrito Texano
Shrimp Fajitas
Guacamole Dip
Chimichanga
Cheese Dip
Taco Salad
Enchiladas
Queso Dip

“Great chips and salsa. Prices and portions were great. We ordered a burrito Loco and house beef soup. The soup was surprisingly good and the burrito was fire. They mix chicken and beef in the burrito. It was so good I forgot to take pictures. Lol.“

4 Good94 Reviews
El Mariachi LLC Mexican • $
826 S State St, Greenfield - 7.4 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ground Beef or Chicken Quesadilla
Two Tacos Rice and Beans
Shrimp Chimichanga
Steak El Mariachi
Quesadilla Shrimp
Chile Colorado
Shrimp Fajitas
Rice & Beans
Enchilada
Pollo Loco

“Best Mexican cuisine in all of town, I've been going here for a good minute and the food is always top quality for Mexican food in the Greenfield area? Staff are friendly, food is decently priced, and the portions are perfection. Keep doing it right El MariachiParking: Large number of spaces, in a rarely used strip mall.Kid-friendliness: Has a kids menu!“

4.4 Superb29 Reviews
EL Jaripeo Mexican • $
30 Washington Pointe Dr, Indianapolis - 6.12 miles

Customers` Favorites

Texas Fajitas with a Lime Margarita Steak and Chicken Burrito
Mushrooms and White Sauce with Beans and Rice
Steak Chimichanga Dinner
Nachos with Only Cheese
El Jaripeo Taco Salad
Chips and Salsa Verde
Mexican Chilaquiles
Lunch Steak Fajita
Tacos De Carnitas
Fajita Taco Salad

“I had the steak fajita and my husband, the Texas fajita.The portion sizes were enormous!!! Gordon Ramsay would complain that half the profits are walking out the door. Ha ha! But we've got another meal later, so it helped our pocketbook.The waiter was nice. He could have been a little more attentive.We will definitely be going back.“

3.9 Good102 Reviews
The Latin Flavor - Food Truck Mexican • $
9130 E 38th St, Indianapolis - 9.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Carne Asada Mexican Taco
Homemade Fruit Water
Nachos

“I love their food! Even though they have multiple items on their menu, there aren't so many that you feel overwhelmed. They also list all the ingredients in English and Spanish so you know exactly what you're getting. The food is fresh, always hot and made to order. And I can't say enough about their fresh squeezed juice. The papaya, and the passion fruit juice are amazing. I come at least one so a week, and I would definitely come more if I lived closer lol.“

4.1 Good32 Reviews
La Hacienda #13 Mexican Restaurant Mexican • $
9920 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Queso Chipotle Dip
Carnitas Dinner
Guacamole Salad
Nachos Locos
Chimichanga
Carne Asada
Fajitas

“Food was a great a nice staff for a great price. Our awesome server gave us a bag of chips and salsa to go for no additional cost. Called my kid champion I thought that was nice. Our server gave us a to go bag for our food. We ordered the Texas nachos and the Chile verde both were amazing! Overall great place we will definitely come here again!!“

4 Good37 Reviews
Taco Express Mexican • $
8626 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.69 miles

Customers` Favorites

3 Birria Tacos De Carne Asada
Authentic Tacos
Soft Taco
Burrito
Nachos

“This truck was at a church event that they had. I've never eaten at a taco truck before, but I didn't want anything else they had. These guys gave the BEST customer service I've ever had, AND the food was amazing! If I see them at another event, they'll definitely be my go to!“

3.8 Good32 Reviews
Mi casita Mexican •
8345 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.68 miles
4.3 Superb7 Reviews
Margarita Factory Mexican Cuisine Mexican • $
11135 Pendleton Pike Suite 400, Indianapolis - 10.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Teak Chimichanga Dinners
Burrito Carnitas
Chips and Salsa
Burrito Loco

“Great everything! Went for the first time today and didnt have to wait at all. Immediately our drink orders were taken and margaritas served. I got a blueberry margarita which i have never seen in a mexican restaurant, and I loved it. My mom got a marg flight and loves every single drink. The food was great with a pretty diverse menu, the service was great. Will definitely be making the trip again.“

3.6 Good88 Reviews
El Rincón Catracho Lupita Family • $$
8150 Pendleton Pike, Lawrence - 10.77 miles
4.1 Good9 Reviews
El Tacotorro Mexican • $
4240 N Franklin Rd, Indianapolis - 10.68 miles

Customers` Favorites

Carne Asada with Rice and Beans
Pollo Taco

“Authentic TEX MEX , all the patrons and staff were Latino except me , but I was served promptly and welcomed warmly. I ordered two shrimp tacos delux and they were delicious and quickly brought out by a beautiful friendly waitress. This restaurant is adjacent to a small Latino grocery store . I think this is a common practice and I believe it promotes fresh food and family atmosphere. Try it you will like it!“

3.7 Good29 Reviews
Tacos A La Diabla Mexican • $
8315 E Washington St, Indianapolis - 7.81 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tacos De Carne Asada Y Tacos De Carnitas
Burrito a La Diabla
Tacos Al Pastor
Chips and Salsa
Chicken Fajitas
Fajitas Nachos
Fried Burrito
Salsa Verde
Steak Taco

“Always a pleasure, the ladies are beautiful the men are polite and good cooks.They make sure it's exactly what you ask for, they attend to you without being over bearing (my preference is watch my drinks and check with me frequently but don't hang around too long) and they do just that take care of you without interrupting the flow of your conversation.The food has been 8-10/10 everytime and I'm a regular not once have I had a " mid meal" they also have unique cocktails and margaritas. The vibe is welcoming the food is great big fan.If I had to think of a negative critique............idk maybe a tv or two would be a nice addition, just something more to look at I guess. Get the corn tortilla street tacos with cilantro and lime for a reliably good meal and throw a cactus margarita to share with your date!“

3.6 Good50 Reviews
Carnicería Mi Mexico Mexican • $$
4240 N Franklin Rd # 101, Indianapolis - 10.68 miles

“This establishment offers a wide variety of products, especially those familiar to Latinos, such as condiments, spices, and certain types of meats that might be hard to find in a typical American supermarket. However, the main drawback is the limited space; the place quickly becomes crowded, causing discomfort when there are around six people. My recommendation is to plan ahead and avoid peak hours to steer clear of crowds and long lines at the cashier.Despite this space limitation, a standout feature is the availability of pre-prepared foods, ideal for those with limited time who want to enjoy something traditional from Mexico. In summary, this place is a solid choice for meeting specific needs for Latin American products, but careful planning is crucial to avoid inconveniences due to the confined space.This establishment offers a wide variety of products, especially those that Latinos are accustomed to, such as condiments, spices, and certain types of meats that are difficult to find in a conventional supermarket in the United States. However, the main drawback lies in the limited space; The place fills up quickly, causing discomfort when there are around six people. My recommendation is to plan ahead and avoid rush hours to avoid crowds and long lines at the ATM.Despite this space limitation, a standout feature is the availability of ready-made food, ideal for those short on time who want to enjoy something traditional from Mexico. In short, this location is a solid option for meeting specific needs for Latin American products, but careful planning is key to avoid inconveniences due to limited space.“

3.8 Good11 Reviews
Polleria los 2 hermanos Mexican • $
8990 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken and Rib Plate
Chicharron

“Tik tok made me find this place. A guy called the Crawfish king eats these huge Chicharrons and they look so delicious i had to find them. Idk why but my soul felt like i would find them him. I went to google maps and searched Chicharron and this name popped up i went to the pics and there they were. I went today and purchased some. They run about a lil over 5$ a piece. I don't speak Spanish so there was a language barrier but we made it through. They also take cards. Im excited to try more things.“

3.6 Good30 Reviews
Don Marcos Restaurant Y Taqueria Mexican • $
4779 N Post Rd, Indianapolis - 10.56 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steak Tacos Carne Asada with Avocado Slices
Tacos Al Pastor
Guacamole

“I've always come to this restaurant due to being so close to where I live plus getting good food service, the staff is friendly, attentive and the rare times I had small issues with the food, they do you right by fixing the error. Just gotta love their tacos de asada & al pastor, the orchata drink is quite good, It's an easy recommendation from me to this business place to my friends & to everyone looking for a good Mexican food location.On the weekends at late hours I can say that it gets a little bit loud for my taste due to they turn into full bar mode with their karaoke nights and the drunks, lol, so if that's not your thing then coming here in early before 10pm would be the best to enjoy your meal time.“

3.7 Good15 Reviews
TAQUERIA LOS POTRILLOS Mexican •
8601 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis - 10.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steak
3.7 Good15 Reviews
Loading...
map Map