46 Best American Restaurants in Nantucket

“Very homey, love this place“

“Awesome service. Great tasting lobster 🦞 roll and panini“

“I came here last night for the first time in four years. I use to live this restaurant but in 2021 we had a few bad experiences and decided not to return.
But I returned last night and was happy I did. Service was great from
Both the hostess and our waitress. We shared everything and I was thrilled to find that the fire broccoli was great as always and I enjoyed the salad which had delicious chunks of halloumi cheese on it. Also enjoyed the two pastas we ordered and my uncle enjoyed his trout. They had an amazing burger on the menu in 2020. I wish they'd bring that back. Otherwise, it was wonderful to
Be back and I'll definitely return.“

“We recently had dinner at Nantucket Tap Room, and overall, it was a mixed experience. The restaurant itself has a cozy, charming atmosphere and the service was polite, though not especially attentive. We came in hoping for a solid meal, and while some things stood out in a good way, others really missed the mark. The wings were probably the best part of the meal. They had a great flavor and were served hot and fresh. That said, they were a little too crispy for my taste and slightly burnt around the edges—not enough to ruin them, but enough to notice. They could’ve been pulled from the fryer just a little sooner. Still, they were definitely enjoyable. For the main course, I had the swordfish. It was okay—not bad, but not particularly memorable either. It was cooked through and plated nicely, but lacked the kind of seasoning or bold flavor you’d expect at a place like this. It felt like it needed just one more element to bring it to life. Unfortunately, dessert was where the meal really fell flat. We tried a couple different options and none of them were great. The texture and flavors were off and felt like an afterthought rather than something crafted with care. For a place that clearly puts effort into its mains and apps, the dessert felt like a letdown. Overall, Nantucket Tap Room has potential and seems to do certain dishes well (especially the wings, with just a little tweaking), but there’s definitely room for improvement, especially in the dessert department. I wouldn’t go out of my way to eat here again, but I wouldn’t completely write it off either. Maybe with a few updates, it could be a more consistent dining experience.“

“I just had the best 70th birthday dinner here! Chef Joseph created a delicious menu and paired wines. The Company Popovers accompanied a crisp Caesar salad, Wagyu beef and a lobster tail with smashed potatoes & broccolini was the entree, rounded out with “The Marriage of Crème Brûlée + Chocolate Mousse” and Dows Fine Sherry Port. The service was spectacular (thank you Johnny) and the intimate and cozy atmosphere made for a wonderful experience for my party of 10. I recommend this place for a singular and memorable experience!“

“Love it there! Fun atmosphere“

“Went for Dinner during Christmas Stroll weekend, Both the meal and service were exceptional.“

“With beautiful heated outdoor seating, fabulous creative drinks, delicious food, and excellent service, we’ve added this to our summer list—one of my favorite dining experiences on Nantucket.“

“The bartender tonight was awesome and introduced us to new wine!!!!“

“We love the food and the vibe at Slip 14! It’s so nice to have an excellent but casual restaurant on the water. Teddy makes the BEST Bloody Mary’s we have ever had! The energy is so great with Teddy’s personal playlist on Spotify, football or golf on the TV. Between Teddy, Brennan and Timmy they are a fun tag team welcoming everyone that walks in. Between the 3 of them at lunch on Sunday Funday you can’t miss having a great time. We loved the scallop roll which is so unique, smash burger and the fish tacos. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“This is hands down our favorite restaurant on the island. Food is spectacular. They need to get some of the service kinks out. But lately, one of the owners has been on hand to quickly rectify any issues- which goes a long way. Thank you, Cheryl! We will always be back.“

“Group of 6. Main dining room, very nice vibe. Food was outstanding - best in Nantucket. Service was solid. Only mild disappointment was the unexpectedly large bill at the end. They include an auto 22% gratuity on groups of 6 or more. Thats fine and we’d have gotten there anyway but would have preferred to be told that, either by the waitress or on the menu. The charge slip includes the all inclusive bill plus an additional line for more tip, which i find bad form. Its a great restaurant- just be up front.“

“Great food and cocktails!“

“Wonderful food & location“

“Our waitress was fantastic, the food was great, but the hostess couldn’t have been any worse, she was downright nasty and unaccommodating.“

“As someone who takes pride in choosing thoughtful, high-quality accommodations when traveling, I can confidently say that Greydon House in Nantucket exceeded expectations. Located right in the heart of downtown, it was the perfect choice for a weekend stay. I specifically wanted to be close to the Steamship Authority ferry, great restaurants, and downtown shopping—and this location delivered on all fronts.

From the moment we checked in, we were warmly welcomed by friendly staff and a personable, attentive manager who set the tone for a relaxed and enjoyable stay. The location couldn’t be more convenient: a three-minute walk to one of the best lobster rolls you’ll ever have at Walter’s, a charming coffee and pastry shop directly across the street, and the Whaling Museum just steps away.

Given the unbeatable location, we weren’t expecting much from the room itself—but we were genuinely impressed. Our room was cozy and well-appointed, with high-end toiletries, beautiful shower tile, and an exceptionally comfortable bed. Harney & Sons tea and quality coffee were available all day, which was a much-appreciated touch.

One of the highlights of our stay was Via Mare, the on-site restaurant. Although we enjoyed every meal during our visit to Nantucket, this restaurant stood out. The oysters were among the best I’ve ever had, and the cocktails were both creative and delicious.

Despite the cool weather, we found ourselves drawn again and again to the charming side porch. Whether we were reading, chatting, watching the Memorial Day parade, or enjoying takeout meals, it became a favorite spot throughout our stay.

Greydon House offers a rare combination of location, charm, and service—and we’ll absolutely be returning.“

“Best place,best atmosphere,best workers,excellent food and staff! My favorite place always, everyday and any day 🥰🥰🍋‍🟩🥂🍸“

“I have been going to Nantucket for 30 years and this place has always had great food, friendly service and I always look forward to the piano player.“

“By happenstance, my fiancé and I stopped in for dinner earlier this week! The phenomenal service we received paired with the exquisite halibut and bolognese dishes brought us back a total of three times during our five-day stay on the island.“

“The food here was good but let me tell you about this salad!

Don’t miss out on the best dish you’ll ever put in your mouth. The kale and cabbage salad! Despite the very unassuming name, it was the best salad I’ve ever had in my whole life and I would go back to Nantucket just for this (I wouldn’t split with my husband next time). Just trust me and get it! Still thinking about it days later.“

“A lot of investors are confused and go into deep research for a trusted and legit platform to trade and invest in. I was also looking for the best one until I read good reviews and recommendations about Mrs kathrine lucas, With her great skill of trading and mining made a good profit for so many in their trade account. I was amazed how happy many investors wrote good comments about her. I contacted her and invested with her with believe and trust just as the way she replied m“

“Awesome We always happy with everything“

“I have been going to Nantucket for years and finally found Island Kitchen this past August; one of the best meals to be had on the island. We ate outside by the bar and despite a bit of rainy weather; we throughly enjoyed the atmosphere and cuisine; the service was excellent and we have earmarked a return visit this August.“

“We sat with some locals on the ferry over to Nantucket and they told us we had to stop by for their Acai bowl and other breakfast/baked good items. The pumpkin bread was delicious and I went back every day for another piece to go with my Chai which they made with steamed milk and it was delicious. I opted for the almond milk b/c they make it fresh in house. They seem to make a lot of items in house, as well as the granola and even the dog cookies for the pup cups (I overheard them talking about it). The ice cream selection was great too and one day I tried the Pumpkin- YUM! My husbands favorite was sea salt caramel on a chocolate waffle cone which we had never had before, but glad we did. The outdoor patio was also a good place to take a break and people watch.“

“Such a friendly and great place for reasonable food. And it’s always good!! Try the turkey reuben or the chicken nachos. It’s a great sports bar kind of place.“

“Always glad to have Millie’s down the road“

“New chef and there during Christmas stroll which means exceptional volume of people. Friendly staff but slightly overwhelmed by the non stop grind of Stroll weekend. Limited menu for stroll. Food was tasty but not exceptional like the previous chef. Example, lobster bisque didn't have the one large piece of lobster I would have expected. Would go back during non stroll to see the what the restaurant is really capable of.“

“It was quick- i ordered 2 burritos. They make them how you want them. Then you pay and you're on your way bing, bang boom- i don't know what would happen if I would have ordered like a cheeseburger or something. I may have to circle back sometime-no Montucky Cold Snacks- and I don't think there were any drinks- except like, yeah, water, iced tea, cokes-
None of the fun stuff, but the staff was great. Very helpful. Fantastic burritos way to be Boat House!“

“Always fast and always delicious! 45 is my go to place before busy work days. I love the icy surfside and dirty chai for my drink order. Any sandwich here is a 120/10. I especially love the spinach croissant! Highly recommend and friendly staff, thanks especially to Shea for always taking care of me!“

“Such a kind and welcoming energy! Incredible food and amazing crew! Always love seeing Danique ! She remembers my order each time I walk up and is so quick and efficient and is amazing with going above and beyond !!“

“Visited Nantucket Friday. Checked menu at several places before selecting Walter's Deli. Had the corn beef/pastrami Reuben. My favorite sandwich and I am a seafood guy. Fantastic and delicious!!! Generous portions and priced right. My wife had the roast beef sandwich. It was a hit as well. Person that made the sandwiches was a nice guy to boot.

Sat on a bench in front of a realtor's office. Realtor asked me where I bought the Reuben because it looked so good.“

“I Do think is the best restaurant in Nantucket soooo good !!! Everyone are nice and food and drinks are amazing“

“👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍“

“Best Irish pub certainly in Nantucket. More accurately the Cape. Food is exceptional, service is warm and goes the extra mile and the Guinness is without a doubt the best on island. The atmosphere is local strong but welcome to all. This is Nantucket.“

“We enjoyed my wife's birthday at Oran Mor. The service was excellent, as was the food. We shared the Kale salad and the ‘Recelet' cheese starter. I had the Veniaon which was so good. My wife had the seafood tagine, and my daughter had the black truffle pasta. The portion size was perfect. The venison was cooked to perfection. We shared the coffee doughnut dessert - incredible - definitely will go back. Noise level was a bit loud.“

“I’ve been enjoying visits to Something Natural for over 35 years since being an intern on Nantucket. Looking forward to seeing friends and family on their visit next week!“

“We had a great breakfast here. Of course, it’s Nantucket pricing, but that’s the whole island. I got the corned beef hash and it was unlike any other I’ve had. The corned beef was sooo tender and instead of using diced potatoes, they were almost mashed potatoes. Very good. Hubby got the huevos rancheros which had a really good sauce. He added an extra pancake too. The staff was very warm and kind. Seating was crowded but we really enjoyed our morning there.“

“Stopped in before our ferry ride for a snack. A solid beer selection, including some tasty Ciscos hit the spot. We also had the nachos, which came loaded with cheese and pulled pork. We left with full bellies and a smile on our faces. Definitely a great place to seek out while spending the day on Nantucket.“

“I frequent this place on my day off just for little odds and ends, sometimes a slice of pizza here and there. First time ordering a burger and some fries and honestly, pretty decent foe the price out here. The stuff they have in the warmer around lunch ain't half bad too (decent pepper chicken with some fried rice) I appreciate this little place.“

“We sat in the dining room that was off for the bar. The bar looked very ruckus and like everyone was having a good time was relatively quiet enough to eat anyway, and the staff from Croatia and couldn’t have been any nicer! Great experience“

“Nice place for outdoor dining for lunch“

“Huge portions of delicious fresh seafood! It's casual and informal counter service. If you are in town and love seafood, head here!“

“Some of the best sandwiches 🥪 on island a must stop for every visit“

“Always have such a great time. Buck for a shuck is in full effect. Great raw oysters by the dozen. Always my first stop when I get to Nantucket“

“The service was great and the food was delicious.“

“A must go to while on Nantucket!“