35 Best American Restaurants in Plymouth

“This place is hands down, without a doubt, one of the best, if not THE best restaurant in Plymouth. Every single thing we got was incredible and portion sizes were perfect. We ordered a grilled Caesar salad with chicken (psst! they grill the romaine and it adds an extra layer of unbelievable flavor). For entrees, we ordered the NY Strip Frites with chimichurri, smoked garlic butter, and Parmesan fries AND (on special) the Pistachio and sesame encrusted blue fin tuna with coconut rice, black garlic kimchi, passion fruit gastrique and fried yucca! We were worried that the steak wouldn’t be as tender as the more expensive options on the menu, but it was SUPER tender and had so much flavor from the garlic butter! The tuna is our new favorite dish! The crunchy texture of the kimchi and yucca really complimented the melt-in-your-mouth tuna, and the coconut rice had amazing flavor. The portion sizes were perfect (not small at all, but not overly huge), which allowed us to save room for dessert. Yes, we ate more! We split the Mississippi mud pie. Sadly, it was the only time in the meal that we remembered to take photos. I wish I had more photos to share, but here’s a shot of our mud pie. TJ was our server - he was incredibly knowledgeable, very attentive and provided great recommendations. The place isn’t very big, so definitely plan on making a reservation if you visit on a weekend. Definitely check this place out! I can’t recommend them enough. It’s our new favorite spot!“

“Delicious salmon and cod dinners!! Great ambiance!! Amazing espresso martinis!“

“I popped in last Saturday and instantly fell in love with everything (white noise cocktal=HELL YES) to the totally lovely staff that took care of us during a hasty retreat out (boooooo!). NeverMIND how dope the food was. My reason to come down to Plymouth went up in smoke, but I WILL BE BACK ❤️“

“Friendly staff, good food, and good drinks! Their outside seating is dog friendly which is a big plus for me.

I got the Cape Cod Reuben which is now something I am shocked that I’ve never had before because it’s such a great match up. My husband got the fried fish sandwich which he really liked. Crispy fries too!

We both got the shanty pale ale which is an exclusive collab beer they have with Stellwagen. Love local supporting local!“

“Holly was our friendly and attentive waitress when I visited this restaurant for the first time with my dad the other day. Things oftentimes get heated when my dad and I discuss things, and Holly was very good at giving us the space we needed when we needed it without sacrificing the proper amount of attention and service. ???
The food at Kevin's was surprisingly good, especially for the fact that I hadn't heard that before! I built my own omelet with jalapeños, feta, and onions. The home fries on the side were among the very best I've ever has! And Holly kept our coffee ☕️ filled to the brim!
I would have preferred the outdoor seating, but my dad doesn't really like sitting in the sun, so we ate indoors where I wasn't super-crazy about our spot only because it's such a quiet restaurant, and my dad gets angry with me and doesn't realize how loud he speaks when that happens.
I would definitely return to Kevin's fit a quiet, relaxing, very reasonably-priced meal. Next time with my wife, so there won't be any heated discussion! ?“

“Breakfast paradise early morning before the beach. Lovely staff and not a bit of any fault to be found :) So glad to have discovered and rave about.“

“Enjoyed two evenings at CJ’s recently. Hope, our server, was engaging and very helpful. She recommended the steak tios and brussel sprouts appitizer. Both were delicious! Hope also makes a great french martini! We can’t wait to go back!“

“they're horrible at taking orders , in the past 5 months not sure if new owner new cooks, or just the lack of training but the food it trash ! I used to love this place but either they mess up on the pizza it's cardboard box nasty flat and the subs are so filled with meat ( turkey) it's falling out the sides breaking the whole roll itself barely any lettuce or pickles! last time I got a turkey sub the bread was hard as a rock and it had barley any turkey meat , what is going on with this place !?! they're rude when you order and it's a pickup waste of my gas for sure and money I won't be ordering again this place went room 5 star to zero lost a great customer get your crap together honestly why are you packing rhe sub with one much meat for it to just fall out that's such a lack of effort horrible service and they don't ever take accountability EVER!!“

“Our book club met at the Blackraspberry last night. First time at the restaurant for most of us. Excellent service (server was very patient with us - chatty book club) and the food was honestly fantastic. My hot-honey salmon bowl was so good, I will go back soon for it again! Atmosphere is fun and comfortable. Will definately make it a frequent place to go!“

“Went there for the 1st. Time on a weeknight. I had the grilled cheese sandwich with tomato soup. Never enjoyed a grilled cheese more! Only complaint was slow bartending. Otherwise, very nice.“

“Had a private function after a funeral and they were amazing to deal with. Made sure we had everything we needed and the food was amazing. great job!“

“We had Tara as a server and a great professional in Dev ( the manager on duty) all were so helpful and great with our kids!! Wish I could post pics of seared scallops over lobster corn risotto and amazing fresh seafood paella!!“

“Chowder was warm fries cold sent back none with meal. Kitchen help very loud and having a good time. We have been there before probably will not return.“

“From the moment we walked in the door we were greeted with a smile. Service was excellent Beet salad is soooo good. Delicious clam chowder. Food was very good“

“was great butt butt my was still hungry so we came back for seconds“

“Very good food and friendly staff!“

“The food is wonderful. I need to go back there again.“

“Amazing Father’s Day dinner. (I wish I took a photo of the bread, which was worth the trip alone!) wonderful service, beautiful view and outstanding meal.“

“Everything about this place is good: food, service, cocktails, prices, atmosphere. They basically hit on all cylinders just about every time. Everything the chef touches (possibly even looks at) is amazing. I’ve never had anything there that I didn’t like, and that includes things that I don’t like (not a fish fan, but he found a way to make me appreciate it). There are only so many compliments I can give before a review becomes unabashed, gushing adoration, so I will simply say: Try it.“

“The lobster roll was so good! Lots of lobster and the drawn butter was so good. The coconut shrimp was great. Nice and crispy, not greasy.“

“This was a really nice place with kind staff. I got the Jolly Pilgrim and recommend it if you like thanksgiving sandwiches!

They had a special drink of the month that was a banana split cold brew. It was tasty but too sweet for me personally.“

“My Honey and I enjoyed a fabulous EBG steak tips dinner. The tips and meal were amazing. Cooked to perfection. The Best tips I have had in a very long time! (Pls don't change them)! Service and atmosphere was wonderful. We will be back very soon! Thank you!“

“Love the burgers but today's food wasn't hot enough. And it wasn't crowded so not what sure what the problem was. And a couple of the 6 or so onion rings were burned. The music is too loud! You requested a review so here it is. But we'll still go there.“

“Quite easily the best clam chowda I've ever had. We had; clam chowda, fried shrimp, sea scallops, fish, hamburger (there were 4 of us). Everything was FANTASTIC! I will definitely return!!! YUMMY!!!“

“Excellent Environment, Superb Eats at a Fair Price, Highly Recommended“

“Your bartender Lisa and Manny & Barback Danny are AMAZING. Top NOTCH service. Amazing. I manage restaurants and resorts and these individuals. The way they work a crowd is amazing. You. Should be PROUD to have such a professional/Likeable “

“We had a large group of very tough customers and from the service, ambience and food it couldn't have been any better! Prob best restaurant on the south shore. Can't wait to sit outside with the waterviews this summer.“

“Teresa, our server, was awesome.

Food was as you'd expect from a Chili's. We go to various Chili's fairly regularly because my wife has a ton of food allergies but knows what she can get here. That said, if the food sucked, we wouldn't go.

Dietary restrictions: My wife has a bunch of food allergies, but every Chili's we go to (and this is one of the reasons we go), are super supportive and helpful.“

“Friendly, attentive wait staff. Best Eggplant parm sandwich. Very nice relaxing lunch.“

“We love going to the Pine hills mama mia's, staff is friendly and food and atmosphere are always great.“

“Awesome place good eats chicken was great“

“Love the Fribble. Friendly’s was a big part of my childhood and with no more and Cape Cod, it was a pleasant treat.“

“Great historical tavern, it was nice to be a part of this history. We didn’t eat, but every person that walked out the door talked about how delicious their food was. The Barmaid was very friendly and attentive. The cocktail menu was extensive and again the Barmaid said that if it wasn’t on the menu, she could probably make it if we asked. Very cute cottage like facility. We’d go back and recommend this tavern 100%.. cheers! ……Follow me and my travels on instagram if you like at #mylifemyterms55“

“Stopped in for drinks and live music, fun playful cocktails and wonderful desserts, plus excellent acoustic live music at just the right volume. Terrific service. Loved the menu, can't wait to return in the future and try some classic South Shore bar pizza.“

“I should preface I am a Wednesday regular due to my job.
But my job is changing and it won't be on my routine anymore.

So as a goodbye I wanted to leave a review of the wonderful time I have with my mother.

Every Wednesday for months now I've come to this IHOP with my mother after work, and it's always at the same time so the customer traffic and wait staff are always the same.

With that said, I always get the same thing and haven't mixed it up much, and the kitchen has done a great job with it.

I get cinnamon French toast every time, not really a menu item but you gotta try it, they can just put the cinnamon pancake frosting on the French toast, so good.

And our wait staff Laura has learned the order, so we're just regulars now, we don't even use menus anymore, just, "the regular?" "Yeah." And it's dope as hell to be that close to someone in your routine.

She's wonderful, I've actually really learned a lot about the point of sales machine just from her trying to put my order in over the months, and she always trys to get us the best deal because we're ordering something off menu.

And that's kinda it.

Aside from my experience though, it seems like the wait staff and the kitchen are at odds, but I always assumed the kitchen staff are also the managers, but maybe the manager isn't here on slow days.

It's hard to say goodbye to the place, we'll miss Laura.“