20 Best American Restaurants in Mackinac Island

Kingston Kitchen at the Village Inn American • $$
1384 Hoban St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Mackinac Planked Whitefish
Jonkanoo Jerk Beef Tips
Boom Boom Cheese Balls
Jamaican Fried Chicken
Calypso Pork Sandwich
Jamaican Jerk Chicken
Coconut Curry Chicken
Jerk Chicken Sandwich
Westmoreland Risotto
Caribbean Calamari

“We have made Kingston Kitchen an annual dinner location while visiting Mackinac Island. The jerk chicken fettuccine alfredo is a must!! My husband had the bbq fried chicken and is still talking about how great it was! Great food plus a friendly atmosphere with a great waitstaff. Highly recommended.“

4.6 Superb205 Reviews
Village Inn Suites American • $$
1384 Hoban St, Mackinac Island

“We have made Kingston Kitchen an annual dinner location while visiting Mackinac Island. The jerk chicken fettuccine alfredo is a must!! My husband had the bbq fried chicken and is still talking about how great it was! Great food plus a friendly atmosphere with a great waitstaff. Highly recommended.“

4.8 Superb46 Reviews
Carriage House American • $$$
7485 Main St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Club Sandwich - Oven Roasted Turkey Neuske's Bacon and Cranberry Relish
Pan Seared Diver Scallops with Lemongrass Ginger Aioli Frizzled Leeks
Jumbo Lump Crab Tower with Fresh Salsa and Avocado
Smoked Whitefish Cakes with Mustard Vinaigrette
Berkshire Tomahawk Pork Chop with Wild Rice
Escargot with French Bread Toast Points
Peanut Butter Pie
French Onion Soup
Burger and Fries
Beet Salad

“It’s always a great experience at the Carriage House!!! Friendly staff, amazing food, stunning views, comfortable atmosphere! Love this place! ❤️“

4.3 Superb152 Reviews
Mary's Bistro Draught House American • $$
7463 Main St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Draught House Soft Pretzels with House-Made Horseradish-Beer Cheese
Mary's Famous Crispy Chicken Tendies
Pulled Pork Grilled Cheese
Homestyle Chicken Pot Pie
Lamb Burger and Fries
Whitefish and Chips
Whitefish & Chips
Mixed Green Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Mac and Cheese

“If you’re on Mackinac Island and skip Mary’s Bistro, that’s on you. The views? Gorgeous. The cocktails? Pure genius—like someone sprinkled creativity with a splash of sass right into the shaker.

Angel deserves a halo for the way she takes care of guests, and shout-out to all the rockstars whose names start with Ma—apparently that’s the secret ingredient around here. Service with personality, drinks with a twist, and scenery that makes you want to linger way too long.

Mary’s isn’t just a stop, it’s an experience.“

4.2 Good281 Reviews
Bistro On The Greens American • $$
One Lake Shore Dr, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Parmesan Truffle Fries
Oven Roasted Chicken
Whitefish Sandwich
Burger & Fries
Roasted Veggie
Charcuterie
Steak Frites

“Very cute area to grab cocktails or lunch. We stopped by with our dog and sat in the bar area and just got drinks. We ordered at the bar and the drinks were tasty, but there was a very long bar line due to the restaurant being packed and seemingly short staffed. Check it out for views if you’re looking for a spot to stop with your dog!“

4.2 Good106 Reviews
Winchester's Whiskey & Bourbon Room American • $$
7416 Main St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Chicken Bacon \u0026 Ranch Flatbread
Buffalo Chicken Bacon & Ranch Flatbread
Crispy Brussel Sprout Chips
Salted Maple Old Fashioned
Strawberry Rhubarb Lowball
Warm Soft Pretzel Bites
Smoked Brisket Poutine
Brussels Sprout Chips
White Fish and Chips
Pub Pretzel Sticks

“Great food and drinks !! Our waitress was amazing for the second year !!“

4.1 Good76 Reviews
Woods Restaurant American • $$$
8655 Cudahy Cir, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Herb Crusted Elk Chop Potato Pave Fall Vegetables
Pan Roasted Steelhead Trout
Pan-Roasted Duck Breast
Spiced Honey Duck Breast
Domestic Rack of Lamb
Bavarian Soft Pretzel
Grilled Filet Mignon
Great Wine Selection
Escargot En Croute
Hungarian Goulash

“Beautiful ride up and amazing dinner atmosphere“

4 Good91 Reviews
The Gate House American • $$
1547 Cadotte Ave, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Whitefish and Clam Chowder
Grilled Cheese and Fries
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Bacon-Cheddar Burger
Grilled Lamb Burger
Gate House Nachos
Mac Daddy Burger
Brisket Nachos
Grilled Cheese
Warm Crab Dip

“relaxing atmosphere.good food“

3.9 Good102 Reviews
1852 Grill Room Bar
Inside Island House Hotel, 6966 Main St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Planked Whitefish with Duchesse Potatoes and Asparagus
Broiled Kidneys Colbert Sauce
New England Clam Chowder
Classic Shrimp Cocktail
Classic Crème Brûlée
French Onion Gratinee
Maryland Crab Cakes
Artisan Bread Board
French Onion Soup
Peanut Butter Pie

“Great atmosphere, food and service!“

4.5 Superb388 Reviews
Pink Pony Bar & Grill • $$
7221 Main St #103, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Michigan Apple & Goat Cheese Salad
Beer Battered Whitefish & Chips
Chippewa Broiled Whitefish
Honey Brie Apple Flatbread
Honey Apple Brie Flatbread
BBQ Pulled Pork Sandwich
Whitefish Beurre Blanc
Wild Mushroom Risotto
Prime Rib French Dip
Smoked Whitefish Dip

“Love everything about Pink Pony!“

4.4 Superb391 Reviews
Yankee Rebel Tavern Bar • $$
1493 Astor St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp & Mussels Diablo
Whitefish and Chips
Pot Roast Sandwich
White Fish Dinner
Pot Roast Sliders
Whitefish Bites
Chicken Tenders
Prime Rib Melt
Cowboy Burger
Caesar Salad

“The whitefish was delicious service was great“

4.5 Superb124 Reviews
Millie's on Main Pubs • $$
7294 Main St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Fried Whitefish Basket
Truffle Blue Cheese Fries
Sweet Potato Veggie Burger
Classic Turkey Bacon Club
Grilled Chicken Alfredo
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Smoked Whitefish Dip
Unplanked Whitefish
Doc's Turkey Burger
Yooper Beef Pastie

“We live in Ohio and never get fresh fish. My wife and I decided to split the fish n chips and a cheeseburger meal. Both were outstanding! I like to save what tastes best for last and I couldn't decide. The burger meal comes with kettle chips and I thought about substituting them for fries, but the fish came with fries so we kept the chips and were very glad we did. If you make say what was the best thing I ate, it would be the fresh white fish. Delicious!!!! My wife and I don't eat out very often and this was the best meal we've had in years.“

4.5 Superb117 Reviews
Cannonball Oasis Fast Food • $
7641 British Landing Rd, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Hot Dogs Chili Dogs Cheese Dogs & Chili
Chicken Strips and Fries
Welcome Ice Cream Break
Chili Dog and Fries
Deep Fried Pickles
Chili Cheese Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
Cheeseburger
French Fries
Soft Pretzel

“The food is always awesome! My husband literally has talked about it since last year! He finally got his hamburger and fries he waited a year for and i got the pasta salad. We loved it!!!“

4.6 Superb61 Reviews
Mustang Lounge Lounges • $
1485 Astor St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Porky Mac and Cheese
Crispy Shrimp Basket
BBQ Brisket Burger
Jumbo Shrimp Basket
Boneless Wings
Mustang Burger
Fish and Chips
Pulled Pork
Tater Tots
Patty Melt

“One of the oldest buildings in Michigan dating back to the 1780’s. Food and apps are killer! Service is great food comes out quick and hot. The ambience of the building is really cool. Military and law-enforcement discount. Super veteran and law-enforcement friendly. This is a great American establishment in one of the oldest Michigan buildings! I truly look forward to coming here every single year we’re on vacation! This is a staple on our trip!“

4.4 Superb132 Reviews
Horn's Gaslight Bar & Restaurant American • $
7300 Main St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Spinach & Crab Quesadillas
Swiss Mushroom Burger
Chicken Fajita Wrap
Seafood Quesadillas
Fiesta Shrimp Salad
Islander Bean Dip
Chicken Tenders
Fresh Guacamole
Beyond Burger
Buffalo Wings

“Very good food and service. The French dip was really good. The chicken fajita wrap was amazing. My picky son loved the sliders with added cheese. Our server made sure our plates were correct and noticed a missing cookie. Our son was so excited to get Oreo cookies!“

3.6 Good147 Reviews
16

Chianti

Chianti Fine Dining
One Lake Shore Dr, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Prawn Carpaccio
Apple Dessert
PB&J

“We just got married at Mission Point on July 4, 2025 and had the best experience!! Julie Suddon and Charlotte Mills and the entire staff were incredible. Julie was super responsive and sweet from start to finish. Super easy to work with and just a nice person. She transitioned us to Charlotte Mills to do the actual planning and the transition was super smooth with tons of communication. Charlotte was equally impressive. Her communication was great from start to finish as well and fantastic for our rehearsal and the day of the wedding. Just super smooth from touring to actually getting married. We were so thankful for the wonderful and professional communication which eased any stress we could’ve otherwise had! We are so happy we decided to choose Mission Point and recommend anyone do the same if looking to get married on Mackinac Island!! Food was great, bartender was great, the vendors were chose were all on the suggested vendor list which made things super, super easy! Just so smooth, cannot say that enough! Thank you for making our wedding day perfect and for making the planning so fun and easy! Julia and Chris McAlpine❤️“

4.3 Superb29 Reviews
Great Turtle Brewery & Distillery Distilleries • $$
1359 Hoban St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Braised Short Rib Grilled Cheese
The Legendary Chicken Sandwich
Painted Turtle Cocktail Flight
Smoked Whitefish Hushpuppies
Pretzel and Beer Cheese Dip
Parmesan Brussels Sprouts
Brewery Fish and Chips
Giant Bavarian Pretzel
Cherry Gose Sour Beer
The Painted Turtle

“Riley Riley Riley! You are unforgettable. Thank you for a fun evening, great toast and BTW my son got all the messages to pause on overeating fudge. See you next year! Cheers!“

4.1 Good188 Reviews
The Straits American •
8593 Cudahy Cir, Mackinac Island

“Wonderful dinner! We tried everything. From the New York Strip, to the whitefish to the Wagyu burger, it was all amazing. The property itself is beautiful and we enjoyed the sunset over looking Lake Huron. Angus took the best care of us and we look forward to seeing him next year!“

3.2 Average5 Reviews
Pancake House Breakfast • $
7245 Main St, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Biscuits and Sausage Gravy
Scrambled Eggs and Toast
Chocolate Chip Pancakes
Ham and Cheese Omelette
Corned Beef Hash Eggs
Cinnamon French Toast
Red Velvet Pancakes
South of the Border
Buttermilk Pancakes
Blueberry Pancakes

“We had our dinner here and it was absolutely delicious. They had a very nice buffet.“

3.9 Good106 Reviews
The Jockey Club at the Grand Stand Seafood • $$
1 Grand Avenue, Mackinac Island

Customers` Favorites

Wood-Grilled Filet Mignon
Tomato Basil Soup

“Great dining location, very cozy and comfortable. Excellent food choices.“

3.6 Good66 Reviews

You May Also Like