11 Best Sandwich Shops in Rochester

“J.R. and Omar today had to handle an upset customer today around 12:45 during a lunch rush. They handled it with kindness and in a calmed manor. I was able to get my order that was correct as they had to deal with her at the same time. I applaud them for being professionals while she was not. Everything I ordered was perfect. Good job!“

“The subs are always amazing here. We had placed a order online on January 13th. Took a bit longer than usual to get our food which I was told the reason why it took longer to get our food was told our ticket was misplaced so I was given four coupons to make up for it. I’m glad I looked at the coupons before using them. The coupons expired in November of 2020. So the coupons can’t even be used.“

“First time there . Wasn't sure what to do. But didn't see sign either that says start here. Took a bit to order. Very busy online orders. Everything was good.. didn't know they don't put the lettuce tomatoes and onions on unless you ask.. only had 3 tables to sit at.. but most people just ordered and left. Everything was clean.. but did have to ask someone to clean a table for us. But like I said it was busy. Next time I'll remember to ask for lettice“

“Visiting from out of town and this place was the only place that was opened for breakfast that wasn't serving breakfast food. The service was fantastic, the sandwich artist was very polite and patient with my indicision. We didn't eat in but the dining area was clean and spotless.“

“Delicious subs (they're huge!) and the potato soup was incredible too :) We will definitely keep coming back.“

“Stopped for lunch after getting haircut next door. We didn’t have to wait to order- no one ahead of us. Ordered basic sand which- all are served cold- which was fine in 96- heat. Other days I wouldn’t be a fan.

It was made quickly. Accurate to how described, but the bread isn’t too soft. Seemed day old or worse, quite dry and super crumbly in the car. It made my black pants look like it was attached by a bun. Not great, just okay.

Store is clean, however drink machine is out of order.“

“Tasty sandwiches that are reasonably priced and very friendly staff..... what's not to like??“

“I stopped at Jimmy John’s and had a good experience. The staff was friendly, and the service was quick just like you’d expect. My sandwich was made correctly, and everything tasted fresh.

The location was clean and well kept, and the whole process was fast and easy. It’s a reliable spot when you need a quick meal, and I would come back again.“

“Employees working on August 8th, 2025, around noon, were extremely efficient, friendly and professional. Ive had many mixed experiences with subway so im always pleased when I find a good one. Between the fast service and perfect sub, I was highly impressed 👌“

“Always have great service whether ordering online or picking up...staff are always fun, last online order for fun entered the name BIG DADDY and they came back with SMALL DADDY ♥️ on the sandwich wrap, definitely made our day! 😂😂“

“Kurt and Matt were the best gentlemen behind the counter anyone could ask for. They worked as a team, listened, were kind, and showed compassion. The sandwiches they made were top notch fresh, tasty, and for a good price. Thank you, guys. I'll be back.“