33 Best Italian Restaurants near Cottleville

“Great, family style Italian food.“

“DELICIOUS 🤤 we will be back in town next month and SO excited to dine here again!!“

“Everything!!!Great dinner, drinks and atmosphere! Bartenders are on point!“

“Family fav for years!! Best pizza and salad around“

“My grown sons and I had dinner there tonight and everything was fantastic. Staff were very polite and helpful and the food came to the table promptly, fresh and hot! Restaurant and restrooms were very clean. I ordered pizza takeout at the end of dinner for another family member who said the pizza was excellent! We look forward to coming back again soon.“

“Always a delicious experience! Love the happy hour availability. The owner always makes sure everything is going well for you!! 10/10 would recommend.“

“LOVE Mia Sorellas. Amazing dinner, delicious cocktails and A+ atmosphere! Added to my favorite spots list.“

“Tony and family always make you feel like family. From his table side presence and his beautiful mother leading an amazing team in the kitchen. Anthony our server was great and knowledgeable of all the dishes. We started with the calamari and fried spinach and a perfectly spiced marinara sauce. We each had the separate salads I had the Italian chop salad, and my girl had the Caprese salad both were absolutely amazing. I had the Benedetto's Farfalle with spicy pink sauce and added shrimp 🤌we also had the perfectly cooked and breaded Chicken Spiedini served over risotto. Timing is everything when you have multiple dishes everything was perfectly prepared.. 🤌🤌🤌🍷“

“Service was excellent. Portions were huge. Food was very average. Chef salad basically had lunch meat thrown on it. Shrimp dinner was boring. Pictured here is seafood pasta, which was *okay*. Large enough to share. But, again, the service was great!“

“I had the best experience ordering 4/1/26.
I ordered a gluten free calzone on DoorDash and added steak to it. They called me and said hey just letting you know the steak marinade has soy and we wanted to make sure that’s okay. I told them it was not and I asked if they had another protein, they did and I added that and all is well“

“Great food all the way around. Pizza is delicious. Dominic knows how to run a restaurant. I watched this crew worked their tails off while we were sitting there waiting for our food. This place runs like a smooth machine. Everybody works together there.“

“Amazing pizza! Best lasagna! Great staff! 5 Stars!“

“me and my boyfriend came here for our anniversary dinner and absolutely loved it!! our server was very kind and helpful. our food was served quickly and was delicious. we loved everything about our experience! special shoutout to the worker that was happy to take our picture before we left!“

“We’ve been here twice and both times service and food were excellent. May be my new favorite restaurant in this area. Highly recommend!“

“Great food, great waitress Jamie!“

“The food is phenomenal!!!!“

“We are extremely pleased with Ami’s Catering of our family wedding. Ami’s Catering was the best decision! Consider their catering for your parties, showers, banquets, holidays, a weekend meal or weekday lunch or dinner. Planning the wedding reception with Shabi, Ami and their staff was enjoyable, delicious as we sampled the menu and they worked with us on details. PROS: Communication, tasting appointment, menu choices, customization, pricing, service, set-up, delivery, hot-food, delicious, savory, and everything about this family restaurant!! We have eaten at both locations, yet we are usually closer to O’fallon location. Carry-out at O’fallon is a favorite. Pizza variety, famous salad, their house dressing, hot rolls, garlic bread, chicken meals are savory and pastas are all top notch!! Check out their menu, so many choices!!“

“I was very impressed with this Olive Garden location. The service was very good, we were seated quickly. Our waitress took great care of us, we never had to wait on anything and it appeared she was taking care of multiple large tables. The atmosphere was very fun and bright with very comfortable seating. The cocktails were amazing and they offered a very nice variety of alcohol and non-alcoholic drinks. The menu was your regular Olive Garden menu but did seem to offer items I had not seen before. I ordered the 6oz sirloin with alfredo and I have to say, the steak was probably one of the better steaks I have eaten. It was perfectly seasoned and even better it was a perfect medium - rare which I have had problems getting in a lot of restaurants in the past unfortunately. I would definitely recommend this Olive Garden to everyone. Everything was exactly as we had hoped.“

“Fantastic food, great as always“

“I generally tend to steer clear of major chain restaurants, favoring local spots instead. However, my niece had her heart set on Olive Garden for lunch, so I decided to put my preferences aside—and I am so glad I did. This visit exceeded my expectations and my neice was happy, too.
The Service
The highlight of our meal was undoubtedly our waitress, Tina. From the moment we were seated, she was attentive and kind. It is rare to find service that is both remarkably efficient and genuinely warm, but Tina managed both perfectly. She wasn’t overbearing, ensuring our drinks were never empty and that we had everything we needed before we even had to ask. Her kindness really made the lunch feel special for my niece, which I truly appreciated.
The Food
While the breadsticks and salad are the classics everyone knows, the real standout for me was the Steak Gorgonzola-Alfredo.
Final Verdict
If you are like me and usually avoid the big names, let this be your sign to give this location a chance every once in a while. We left happy, full, and relaxed.“

“Pizza is great and they support of course local music. I was in a few nights ago and the owner stops at my table to check on things. He said the pizza looks a little overdone, I can take that off your bill, but actually I like it a littel well done and crispy, so no problem but nice that the owner himself offered to make it right.“

“We went because I remember going to a restaurant they had many years ago on St Charles Rock Rd. The food was as good as I remember. Everyone loved what they had. We will definitely be going back.“

“We came and Darryl assisted us with our party we were planning, he was amazing! He answered any questions I had about the menu and catering. He was very patient and polite. Thanks for making our party amazing. We recommend 10/10 every time! Food was PHONOMINAL! Can't wait til our next event! Thanks Candicci's“

“10/10 would recommend! Especially for hosting an event! We had a pretty decent sized (35) celebration here a few weekends ago & it was perfect. We ordered food ahead of time, brought in some decorations and the staff was incredibly kind (shout out to Matt, Chelsea, Ali & Todd!) throughout the entire process. The food & drinks were great & affordable. The heated patio was amazing. Will definitely be hosting here again in the future and visiting for dinner until then. Food recommendations: Toasted Ravioli, Chicken Bacon Salad & Fettuccine Alfredo. So good!“

“Best lunch special pizza & salad I have ever eaten. Pizza was excellent! Young man behind the counter was very helpful & friendly. Stef's pizza has become our go to pizza effective today, 9/18/23.“

“The absolute BEST NY style pizza in the county.“

“Probably the best experience at a restaurant we’ve ever had. Ethan, the waiter, was personable, accommodating, and friendly! Food was exceptional as well!“

“Excellent quality of food. Great service and nice ambiance.“

“Absolutely delicious!! Love the focaccia bread“

“Great pizza typically. We’re regulars. The sauce tasted a little different than usual. But pizza was still good. Provel bites were not edible this time, went in the trash. Tasted really salty. Not sure will be getting those anymore, definitely not the same ones we’ve been getting for the past 7 years.“

“We were having trouble ordering through the website so we tried to call the Imo’s closest to our branch and were on hold forever. When calling this location, someone answered right away and was VERY pleasant and helpful. We were technically outside their delivery area but they made an exception for us and delivered to us anyway. The woman who took our very large order was so friendly & patient. Our delivery driver was also very friendly & helpful. Our food was hot and fresh and packaged well. We were very satisfied with our experience & would highly recommend!“

“Great Gluten Free Pizza and loved the salads . Why did you guys remove yourself from Doordash??? We ordered from there all the time because we live in st Peter’s .“

“Finally got got to try the legendary Pirrone's Pizzeria Florissant while playing a great gig at Bunkers Tavern yesterday! 😊🍕💥 Awesome pizza with thin crispy crust and they use provel cheese! 💚 RECOMMENDED! 👍“