39 Best Italian Restaurants near Cottleville

“Great, family style Italian food.“

“Outstanding. Little Pricey for pasta. We will definitely return. Food was amazing pizza was delicious“

“DELICIOUS 🤤 we will be back in town next month and SO excited to dine here again!!“

“Everything!!!Great dinner, drinks and atmosphere! Bartenders are on point!“

“Family fav for years!! Best pizza and salad around“

“Just left Fazolis tonight around 9pm and the customer service was awesome the service was fast and the Food was fresh. I had to give acknowledgement and show gratitude because most spots get lazy at night but this was not the case so thank you Rex.H and the young lady who made my order with a smile. Yall rock😎🤘“

“This restaurant was fabulous! The staff is warm and friendly! We felt like we were back in Italy. Everything we had from cocktails, wine, appetizers, entrees and dessert was impeccable! We love this place and recommend it to everyone, it's a hidden gem. This is one of our favorite restaurants. WE WILL BE BACK!“

“First time diners! We were welcomed immediately by a friendly staff. The atmosphere was quaint and inviting. The food was flawless and the service exemplary. Joe and Diane were extremely good to us. We will be back! Thank you for an amazing meal!“

“Tony and family always make you feel like family. From his table side presence and his beautiful mother leading an amazing team in the kitchen. Anthony our server was great and knowledgeable of all the dishes. We started with the calamari and fried spinach and a perfectly spiced marinara sauce. We each had the separate salads I had the Italian chop salad, and my girl had the Caprese salad both were absolutely amazing. I had the Benedetto's Farfalle with spicy pink sauce and added shrimp 🤌we also had the perfectly cooked and breaded Chicken Spiedini served over risotto. Timing is everything when you have multiple dishes everything was perfectly prepared.. 🤌🤌🤌🍷“

“LOVE Mia Sorellas. Amazing dinner, delicious cocktails and A+ atmosphere! Added to my favorite spots list.“

“The pizza was delicious, but what really stood out to me was the staff. While I was waiting for takeout after a long day at work, I got to see how genuinely kind and caring they were toward one another. One employee had finished his shift and was waiting for a ride, and the way everyone interacted with him—including one of the younger hosts helping his dad encourage him to head home—was just so sweet and genuine.

It honestly brightened my evening. Great pizza, great staff, and clearly a really wonderful group of people. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Stopped in this place because it was near Trader Joe’s and the kids were hungry. Holy Smoke was it good! I got the Meat me In St Louis Calzone. It was HUGE. Only ate half of it. The place was very clean, staff was friendly, had good beer, and the food kicked butt.“

“Always love going to the Massa’s New Town location. Beautiful, elegant yet cozy atmosphere. I always enjoy the food and feel like its good value. I went for lunch for the first time and was very excited about how many lunch specials they offer. At $12.99 w a salad included it was a great deal. Service as always was friendly
and prompt. Will def. go back.“

“We’ve been here twice and both times service and food were excellent. May be my new favorite restaurant in this area. Highly recommend!“

“Amazing pizza! Best lasagna! Great staff! 5 Stars!“

“We were traveling and staying at a near by hotel so we had our pizza delivered. lt was really good! If we didn’t live so far away we’d definitely become regulars. My husband usually only eats the top, but their crust was so thin and crispy he loved it. The young many who delivered the pizza was extremely polite and helpful.“

“me and my boyfriend came here for our anniversary dinner and absolutely loved it!! our server was very kind and helpful. our food was served quickly and was delicious. we loved everything about our experience! special shoutout to the worker that was happy to take our picture before we left!“

“Had a large party reserved and had some of the best service from our waiter Freddy than we have in years anywhere else. He was incredibly attentive, thorough and kind.“

“Great food, great waitress Jamie!“

“Fantastic food, great as always“

“Amazing pizza! Best lasagna! Great staff! 5 Stars!“

“We are extremely pleased with Ami’s Catering of our family wedding. Ami’s Catering was the best decision! Consider their catering for your parties, showers, banquets, holidays, a weekend meal or weekday lunch or dinner. Planning the wedding reception with Shabi, Ami and their staff was enjoyable, delicious as we sampled the menu and they worked with us on details. PROS: Communication, tasting appointment, menu choices, customization, pricing, service, set-up, delivery, hot-food, delicious, savory, and everything about this family restaurant!! We have eaten at both locations, yet we are usually closer to O’fallon location. Carry-out at O’fallon is a favorite. Pizza variety, famous salad, their house dressing, hot rolls, garlic bread, chicken meals are savory and pastas are all top notch!! Check out their menu, so many choices!!“

“Pizza is great and they support of course local music. I was in a few nights ago and the owner stops at my table to check on things. He said the pizza looks a little overdone, I can take that off your bill, but actually I like it a littel well done and crispy, so no problem but nice that the owner himself offered to make it right.“

“We came and Darryl assisted us with our party we were planning, he was amazing! He answered any questions I had about the menu and catering. He was very patient and polite. Thanks for making our party amazing. We recommend 10/10 every time! Food was PHONOMINAL! Can't wait til our next event! Thanks Candicci's“

“Excellent quality of food. Great service and nice ambiance.“

“Aiden was our server and he picked us up right at shift change. He did an amazing job was very accommodating. He took marvelous care of all four kids and two adults with a smile even took care of one kids food allergy, beautifully. Great job Aiden!“

“Went with my parents for a celebration lunch today. By the looks of the parking lot, they were pretty busy but we didnt have to wait to be seated. We had a wonderful server named Aris. She was very friendly and polite. She was very helpful when my dad had menu questions. One of the Doctors I work at my hospital knew I was having a double mastectomy surgery and knew we'd be back and forth with appointments and not always feel like cooking and dishes at home when they were taking care of me while I was recuperating, so he bought us a gift card to use. I wish more servers were like Aris, she's top notch with customer service and being bubbly and friendly. I dont live in the area, but when I'm back in town for my next surgery/ recovery I would be happy to come back. It wasn't just Aris, the hostess was super friendly too, as well as another worker taking a to go order out and she held the door for us. All around top notch, and food was delicious.“

“We went because I remember going to a restaurant they had many years ago on St Charles Rock Rd. The food was as good as I remember. Everyone loved what they had. We will definitely be going back.“

“Absolutely delicious!! Love the focaccia bread“

“I absolutely adore my Imos location here. They are always courteous and very professional. Nick and Mike are absolutely great at making the Original Imos pizza that so many of us crave and long for. My mom passed away a couple of months ago. Whenever she would visit, her ONLY craving desire was always for Imos On Jungermann. She absolutely adores them all and they loved her too. They were all saddened to hear of my mom's recent passing & as I enjoy Imos on today, I do it in my mothers honor. Thank you Imos Jungermann for loving my mother and treating her with a tremendous amount of love and respect which goes a long way. You will always be not only the best pizza ever but you're like family to me. The memories go all the way back to the mid 80s when my dad would take us to the Imos which stood in an old white building near Forest Park. Jungermann Imos gives me that same vibe and awesome flavor from so long ago. Bless you Nick, Mike and your awesome team for always going above the call of duty. Im eternally grateful 🙏“

“Probably the best experience at a restaurant we’ve ever had. Ethan, the waiter, was personable, accommodating, and friendly! Food was exceptional as well!“

“10/10 would recommend! Especially for hosting an event! We had a pretty decent sized (35) celebration here a few weekends ago & it was perfect. We ordered food ahead of time, brought in some decorations and the staff was incredibly kind (shout out to Matt, Chelsea, Ali & Todd!) throughout the entire process. The food & drinks were great & affordable. The heated patio was amazing. Will definitely be hosting here again in the future and visiting for dinner until then. Food recommendations: Toasted Ravioli, Chicken Bacon Salad & Fettuccine Alfredo. So good!“

“Our waiter, Mike, was personable and quick. The food was good and hot. Loved the cream the chef added to the Manhattan clam chowder.“

“The absolute BEST NY style pizza in the county.“

“Best lunch special pizza & salad I have ever eaten. Pizza was excellent! Young man behind the counter was very helpful & friendly. Stef's pizza has become our go to pizza effective today, 9/18/23.“

“We were having trouble ordering through the website so we tried to call the Imo’s closest to our branch and were on hold forever. When calling this location, someone answered right away and was VERY pleasant and helpful. We were technically outside their delivery area but they made an exception for us and delivered to us anyway. The woman who took our very large order was so friendly & patient. Our delivery driver was also very friendly & helpful. Our food was hot and fresh and packaged well. We were very satisfied with our experience & would highly recommend!“

“Great Gluten Free Pizza and loved the salads . Why did you guys remove yourself from Doordash??? We ordered from there all the time because we live in st Peter’s .“

“We were in St Peter’s Mo. and were going to go to Olive Garden for my Wife’s birthday, when I told our clerk at the hotel she said she would recommend the Pasta House over the Olive Garden. We went and had supper. Everything we had was great better than the other place. We took desert back to the room and it was great. I would recommend to anybody.“

“Finally got got to try the legendary Pirrone's Pizzeria Florissant while playing a great gig at Bunkers Tavern yesterday! 😊🍕💥 Awesome pizza with thin crispy crust and they use provel cheese! 💚 RECOMMENDED! 👍“