12 Best American Restaurants in Highlands

“Everything was great here. Starting with the service. No waiting for waitstaff; muliple vists by all the servers. Even the proprietor touched base several times. The drinks were well made with top shelf ingredients. The food was intriguing, chef used imaginative combinations. I had the 4th Street Burger and Street Corn (outstanding) and my wife had the 205 Wedge Salad (what a great surprise). The ambiance was just what my wife and i were looking for; and the setlist was killer too. We will be back. Awsome night. Thanks“

“The food is absolutely fantastic. I ordered the Chicken ala Frances. The chicken was tender, melt in your mouth. The rice had bits of craisins and nuts which went beautifully with the chicken. The veggie of the day was roasted brussel sprouts with a light sauce. I asked if they could please move to Maryland. The best food I've had in a restaurant in some time.“

“Everything was perfection 😀“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Exceptional Lunch Experience at Prime in Highlands! Our lunch at Primary in Highlands, NC, was simply outstanding. From the moment we walked in, we were warmly greeted by the host and restaurant manager, which set the tone for a wonderful meal. We started with perfectly cooked Oysters Rockefeller, followed by a fresh and flavorful green salad. My husband had the chimichurri marinated chicken sandwich, which was the special of the day, while I opted for the 14-ounce New York strip. Although I couldn’t finish the entire steak, it was perfect for sharing, and it was cooked to absolute perfection. The service was impeccable, attentive without being overbearing, and the atmosphere made for a lovely midday meal. We topped off the experience with a delicious slice of carrot cake, which was the perfect sweet ending. If you’re looking for an exceptional lunch in downtown Highlands, I highly recommend Primary for its fantastic food, atmosphere, and top-notch service“

“We had a Shame Dog, soup and a Rocket Cobb salad, all very tasty. The blu cheese dressing was especially good. Our server, Finley, was awesome. We were a little bummed as we couldn't watch the Tampa Bay Bucs game as they have a limited Directv subscription.“

“As a world traveler I have dined at some of the best restaurants in the world. Lakeside didn't disappoint. Steak, trout,, pear salad and spinach did not disappoint. Great wine list with fair prices. Reminded me of Mucky Duck on Sanibel.“

“Food and service were outstanding. Server was very attentive. The beet salad special was very good. Extensive wine list. As other reviews mentioned, it got very loud in the small dining room. There was a large group (~20) and they were literally shouting from one end of their table to the other. It was just annoying - thus the 3 stars for atmosphere. Next time, we’ll sit outside.“

“We enjoyed their salmon cakes immensely, that they make from their own poached salmon and then into patties. We served it with the aioli, on a bed of greens. It’s like getting a catered meal just for two. Love the people there. Rare breed.“

“We had an excellent dining experience, thanks to Casey’s outstanding service. He was incredibly attentive and made sure we felt well taken care of throughout the evening. For dinner, I enjoyed the pheasant, which was absolutely delicious, while my husband had the ribeye—perfectly cooked and full of flavor. Our son ordered the sirloin, but it wasn’t quite to our liking. Casey handled it with professionalism and care, ensuring it was promptly corrected. His warm and accommodating nature truly elevated our experience, making our evening both enjoyable and memorable.“

“We ate dinner on Wednesday, our first time. The service was Excellent! Kind, and very helpful! We definitely will be back!“

“Great food and atmosphere!“

“lot to choose from. fresh n hot grill, take n bake entrees, deli, NY style pizza.“