49 Best Seafood Restaurants near New Castle

“Fantastic Food, outstanding service, great dining room.“

“I love Portsmouth for its shops and vibe, but honestly haven’t really loved a lot of the restaurants. Came here and I think it will be by new favorite spot. Food was really good and they have something for everyone. Some of the seating was a little awkward.“

“Kudos to the kitchen… best meal we’ve had in a long time!! Will be back soon!“

“We are here from out of town and stumbled upon this incredibly amazing spot! The seafood chowder is killer, THE BEST!!! Do yourself a favor stop in!“

“The BEST place to get a lobster roll or fish tacos. I don’t think anything on the menu could disappoint 🥹 my new favorite restaurant. The staff is also incredible! Hard working and friendly.“

“oh wow... what a find! We were looking for a seafood restaurant when passing thru the area and the name caught our attention. We had an amazing dinner! We both chose the seafood fettuccine, which was heavenly - incredible pasta and sauce topped with succulent seafood. Desserts were lavender creme brulee and white chocolate cake...Holy cow! Dinner and service were both top-notch.. and we can't wait to return!“

“It is always a pleasure to dine in here. The staff were pleasant and the food is awesome. We are from New Jersey and whenever we come up here we always come to Robert's.“

“The BEST roast beef I've ever had at a sub shoppe. I just wish that they delivered!!!“

“My family and I love Cape Neddick Lobster pound. We always have 3-5 children with us everytime we go, the kids love getting their kids meals in a cute boat and at the end of the meal the children can pick a prize out of their treasure chest!!! The high ceilings and large windows make for the best views with Super cozy vibes in the winter! Always super clean, staff is always so nice and very attentive! Every meal we had our food comes out perfectly with 0 complaints! Some of our favorites are the warm pretzels, the mussels, Caesar salad with steak, and my absolute favorite is the seafood pasta! 10/10 !!“

“great service amazing food“

“I have been eating there for years. I went the other night because I was craving scallops. I got my usual scallops and tried to substitute o-rings for fries. The girl told me it wasn't allowed. No substitutions. I was willing to pay for the upgrade. No go. I live in the area and there are a lot of other options which I'll be trying.“

“We booked the private dining area and had a great experience. Service was great and we were not rushed at all. Food and drinks were good and the overall booking process with Zoey was easy and transparent.“

“Just got back!!!! We Had both a cold and a hot lobster roll…and there was absolutely no skimping on the lobster!!! And 2 fluff chowders!!! Everything was so good and reasonably priced!!! We will be back!!“

“Great food and always very friendly helpful staff.“

“good place to work company has a talent for gettimg amazing quality lobsters“

“Everything- wonderful rooms, public areas, fantastic staff, and a chef whose food is TO DIE FOR! We just got home from 2 wonderful nights there a Christmas present from our daughter and her husband). We've been going there for 35 years and this stay was one of our very best! Bravi, SNI!“

“We looked at a lot of different restaurant options for dinner. I’m so glad we decided on Old Ferry Landing!!!! The food was fantastic!!! Drinks were summery and unique 🧉🍹 The lobster bisque was the best I’ve ever had!!!! And there was a great amount of lobster meat in it. I tried a bite of my boyfriend’s clam chowder as well which was also delicious but the bisque was 🤤😍 We will definitely be back!!!! Our waitress was very attentive and so sweet!!! It was so nice to dine at a place that’s been around for 50 years. I hope Old Ferry Landing is around for 50 more!!! 🦞“

“My fiancé and I had to return for a second night, making it two nights in a row for the great seafood, service, and atmosphere! Cathy was phenomenal in the main dining room Thursday night & Michelle on the deck Friday night was delightful!! Lobster, scallops, clams, and everything were spectacular!!! We WILL be back!!!“

“Always great food and amazing friendly staff.“

“Awesome place to see a band with the family“

“great food at reasonable prices. excellent service.“

“Great view when sitting outside. The food was tasty but not to die for. My fries had good seasoning, but they were a tad cold. The crab cake sandwich had bacon on it and a great texture. Also, the waitress was friendly and prompt at serving us.“

“Just a quick note from someone who never writes reviews. Sitting at The Beach Plum with my three kiddos and so impressed and grateful for the wonderful service we’ve received here. We had a tiny issue with one meal which was immediately acknowledged and fixed tenfold. Two members of the team checked on us several times after to make sure we were doing okay and then sent us home with an extra meal for later on the house. My kids learned a great lesson on wonderful and kind customer service and The Beach Plum will continue to be a favorite spot for us! Thank you!!“

“My 10-year-old wanted to go for dinner and he asked the host if we could sit by the window. We were told no even though there were several tables open. Asked for a manager and the manager told us no that's not how they do it. We left“

“I work at the Moffatt-Ladd House across the street and have been meaning to come over and experience their menu, as we often have overlapping customers. Our host sat us right away, drinks were fabulous, and all the meals were absolutely amazing! (I had the caribbean grilled swordfish.) My mom had been here with her parents in college in the early 80s and clearly Casey is carrying the mantle well. Thank you especially to our server, Rachel!“

“Best lobster roll and lobster bisque I have ever had!“

“We stopped here for an early dinner and were very impressed with both the authentic flavours and friendly staff!! It’s a beautiful restaurant too. We loved the crab fried rice which was overflowing with large pieces of crab and also the lemongrass chicken was delicious!! We will be back any time we visit Portsmouth.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Comfort food meets fine dining. Great atmosphere, service was great. The food was amazing. Will definitely be back !!!“

“Dropped by Santiago’s for a quick Cinco de Mayo bite and margarita! Had one of the freshest, most delicious salads I’ve ever tasted. The margarita was top-notch, and bartender Victoria was fantastic!“

“The food is amazing, always super fresh and the flavors are incredible. We visit here twice a yearr and this is always a regular must stop for dinner while we are in town. I have found nothing compares to the quality, freshness, and flavor of the food they serve here. I have never been disappointed with anything I have ordered here. Highly recommended“

“Have been many times over the years, both to hotel and restaurant. Highly recommend and love that they empower their employees to support the communities they live and work in.“

“Amazing food, great service and beautiful restaurant! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“My family recently booked a private function in the Eisenhower room at Lamies. Everything was truly exceptional. Michelle and her team went out of their way to guarantee that our extra large party was perfectly cared for. I highly recommend considering the Old Salt for your private functions. You won’t find better service.“

“Michael was wonderful at the bar. Extremely knowledgeable and a fun person to talk to while he is mixing drinks and teaching others.“

“The food is delicious, I have had the smash burger, the jambalaya and lasagna. The portions are big and the staff is so very friendly. I love going there.“

“We have been coming to Bamboo for over 10 years. We meet as many family and friends here because it’s always a hit. Great food and a really friendly staff, the restaurant is beautiful and clean. Love it all.“

“Tino's is our go to place when we want a great meal, lively atmosphere and extremely nice staff. We love that you can actually have a conversation and not have to scream above loud noise. It's a pretty spot and i like that they have a semi outdoor space that they keep warm and cozy even in the winter months. It's overall one of our favorite spots to eat.“

“We were very impressed the locals seemed to know each other and the staff knew them,despite that we felt comfortable welcomed waited on quickly the food was great. Looking forward to return than,s“

“Looking at the outside my husband and I thought we were underdressed, but once inside it was cozy. We were sat near the bar and fire place. The food was incredible, staff was super friendly and the place was clean. I highly recommend stopping!“

“Traveled out to Portsmouth from Wisconsin. Sick of seafood, best burger I have ever had on the east coast. Lots of tv’s to watch the games. Friendly people. Highly recommend you give it a try. Will try their lobster roll though before leaving. Had some delicious apple crisp for desert.“

“They have the best food and very generous portions. Chicken parmigiana is the very very best. Can’t wait to go again and have the steak and cheese“

“Very belated review - I was in Maine with friends for a wedding in Oct of 2024. None of us are from coastal areas, so we were excited to try some seafood that would be fresh and this little place was one of our stops!

I don't remember what everyone else ordered, nor can I speak for them - but I got their coconut shrimp and was AMAZED! They were by far, the most delicious shrimp I have ever eaten. Cooked to perfection, breaded just right, and melted in my mouth. If you have the chance to try them - please do! I live across the country and still think about them and wish I could get more.“

“The food is delicious, I have had the smash burger, the jambalaya and lasagna. The portions are big and the staff is so very friendly. I love going there.“

“Loved our lunch yesterday (in the inviting and spacious bar room) of salmon burgers with side and bloody Mary's! Festive atmosphere and friendly staff. Will return for sure!“

“Best lobsta rolls eva!!🦞🦞“

“First time ever and had the most AMAZING meals, drinks and experience. Staff A+! Food, chicken, broccoli Alfredo. 10/10. Creamed lemon Haddock. 10/10!!! Drinks and bartender, Brittany A+. Chef came out to us to see how our meal was. Told him we left NOTHING on the plate, neither one of us. Not a CRUMB! I usually leave a little something to take home. I couldn’t stop eating. DELICIOUS. Found out new spot! Thank you so much. See you soon!“

“14 members of my family were in on Wednesday September 10th to celebrate my last chemo treatment and 3 family birthdays….our waitperson was Samantha, she was wonderful, very friendly, never missed a step when serving this loud talkative group. We want to make sure she is given a nice job….she’s an asset to your team….food was delicious….4 of us came back on Saturday for salmon….excellent again… Thanks to the staff, cooks and food we will be in many times again.“

“Such a great night! The food is fabulous, and the staff is amazing! Definitely a go to.“

“We ate dinner at The Rooftop at The Envio, on Thursday, September 18th. Met your wonderful hostess, Deb. She was extremely friendly and sweet. Deb even wished my daughter a happy birthday. She was a breath of fresh air. ❤️“