29 Best Seafood Restaurants in Cape May

PRIMAL By Mia Seafood • $$$
406 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Aged Ribeye Charred to Perfection
Chocolate Covered Strawberries
South African Lobster Tail
Cheesecake with Raspberry
Dry Aged Bone in Ribeye
Yellowing Tuna Tartare
Garlic Peppercorn
Mushrooms Onions
Shrimp Cocktail
Steak Surf&Turf

“Great food and great service!! Will definitely be back. My wife loved the strawberry burrata!!“

4.6 Superb219 Reviews
Iccara Italian Bistro Italian • $$
315 Ocean St #4, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti GF by Request
Pappardelle Della Nonna GF by Request
Homemade Mousse and Whipped Cream
Seafood Scampi GF by Request
Lobster and Squid Ink Pasta
Crab Bisque Market Price
Grilled Octopus Salad GF
Squid Ink Lobster Pasta
Sicilian Calamari
Caprese Salad GF

“Excellent service from Athena. Really good food. Still BYOB but now have Meadowcroft wines. Very nice wine very reasonably priced.“

4.4 Superb495 Reviews
Grana BYOB Salad • $$$
413 S Broadway, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Braised Beef Short Ribs Herbed Potato Puree Broccolini Baby Carrots Bordelaise
Pan Roasted Muscovy Duck Breast
Scallops with Mixed Vegetables
Radiatori Lobster Fradiavolo
Chargrilled Spanish Octopus
Rigatoni Bolognese Bianco
Local Day Boat Scallops
Butternut Squash Bisque
Seared Alaskan Halibut
Artisanal Cheese Board

“We had an absolute perfect dining experience. Each course was outstanding. Peach & Burrata salad, delicious. Scallops perfectly done and chocolate panna cotta so good. Loved every thing about Grana BYOB.“

4.7 Superb130 Reviews
Lucky Bones Backwater Grille American • $$
1200 NJ-109, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Margarita Pizza Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes Delivery: No Curbside pickup: Yes
Famous Lucky Bones Mussels & Pasta
Manhattan Style Local Clam Chowder
House-Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich
Backwater Grille Super Nachos
Great Selection of Craft Beer
Crab and Shrimp Cake Sandwich
Steamed Local Cape May Clams
Crab & Shrimp Cake Sandwich
Brick Oven French Onion Soup

“I went to Lucky Bones on New Year’s Day, for lunch!! They did not disappoint!! Wed’s are Oyster day specials!! Had the best Ousters Rocketfellers!! Then I had the BOLT sandwich!’it was soo good!! Highly recommend Lucky Bones! Plus, I added point to my rewards card!!“

4.4 Superb292 Reviews
The Cove Restaurant & Seaside Deck Seafood • $
405 S, Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

French Toast Topped With
Cheese Burger and Fries
Crab Cake Sandwich
Cheese Omelette
Club Cakes
Pancakes
Sausage

“Great casual restaurant at the beach. Nice view, good food and friendly efficient servers. Don't forget your wallet, as cash only, but there they do have an ATM.“

3 Average74 Reviews
PRIMAL By Mia Seafood • $$
406 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Aged Ribeye Charred to Perfection
South African Lobster Tail
Cheesecake with Raspberry
Dry Aged Bone in Ribeye
Garlic Peppercorn
Mushrooms Onions
Creamed Spinach
Shrimp Cocktail
Steak Surf&Turf
Tomahawk Steak

“PRIMAL in Cape May offers an exceptional dining experience! . As a first-time visitor during the off-season, I was truly impressed by both the outstanding service and the remarkable food. Chef Mia and her team deliver on quality, quantity, and value.

The meal started with complimentary fresh-made bread, followed by a delightful house salad. The main courses—filet, halibut, and a lobster/scallop appetizer in the shallot cream sauce—were all flavorful and cooked to perfection. And the Truffle Yukon mashed potatoes? Simply the best I’ve ever had. Dessert was a tower of homemade cookies surrounded by fresh fruit and decadent vanilla icing.

PRIMAL is a standout gem in Cape May, offering an unforgettable dining experience that combines exceptional service, expertly crafted dishes, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're a local or visiting during the off-season, this restaurant is a must-try. Chef Mia and her team have truly set the bar high—an experience worth savoring from start to finish!“

4.7 Superb124 Reviews
La La Lobster Cape May Seafood • $$
732 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

La La Shrimp Roll with Chips & a Pickle
Lobster Roll with Extra Lobster Meat
La La Shrimp Bowl Gluten Free
4 Pack of Lobster Friendly
6 Pack of Lobster Family
Lobster Boardwalk Fries
New England Clam Chowdah
Lobster Grilled Cheese
La La Bowl Gluten Free
Lobster Mac N Cheese

“I went in tonight a little after closing and the guys were cleaning up. I asked if they wer3 closed and was told yes. When I asked if anyplace else sold lobster roll Will politely said he didnt know of any place. And was kind enough to make is 2 lobster rolls after closing. Delicious and generous portions. Thanks Will. We had a long day and this was the perfect ending after getting everyone settled in for the night.“

4.6 Superb91 Reviews
The Lobster House Seafood • $$
906 Schellengers Landing Rd, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Broiled Fishermans Wharf Platter Dine in: Yes
Fresh Jersey Clams on the Half Shell
Fishermans Wharf Clam Chowder
Alaskan King Crab Legs
Broiled Lobster Tail
Oysters Rockefeller
Chicken Francaise
French Onion Soup
Fried Calamari
Lobster Bisque

“It's been about 5 years since the last time I was here. I was worried the prices might have sky rocketed and made it unaffordable, but I was pleased to see that there were many affordable options. We took our number and waited to be called to order.
We ordered a pitcher of Iced Tea at the bar and sipped it as we sat out by the docks till our number was called. The food came out quickly and was very tasty. We enjoyed a beautiful atmosphere watching the boats go in and out as the cool breeze cooled out skin as we sat by the shaded docks.
I definitely recommend the broiled seafood platters!
The lobster house does not disappoint.“

4.2 Good787 Reviews
Cape May Fish Market Seafood • $$
408 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Cape May Salt Oysters & Top Neck Clams
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake Sandwich
1½ lb Whole Steamed Lobster
Connecticut Lobster Roll
New England Clam Chowder
Flounder Sandwich
Caesar Salad
Seafood Roll
French Fries
Fish & Chips

“Freshly made, quality food. Fried oysters were huge and cooked to perfection. Great choice!“

4.2 Good209 Reviews
Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls Seafood • $$
320 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Classic Lobster Roll Shrimp Rolls and French Fries
Lobster Mac and Cheese
Chicken Tenders
Fresh Coleslaw
Lobster Rolls
Mac N Cheese
Crab Roll

“The wife and I were out and about and decided to try the Waterside location in Lakewood Ranch Fl. I have to say im a bit of a critic because we have family in Maine and have tasted all ends of the spectrum of lobster rolls from amazing to terrible and this place makes a great Lobster rolls with a spot on price comparable to Maine and other restaurants in the area. The staff member we dealt with was super nice I wish I would have got his name, but I do know he was from Jersey and had great knowledge knew the product well. We had 2 Connecticut rolls and they were great. I would say this place is worth checking out. Theres only outdoor seating, but you can easily walk around waterside and find a spot to kick back and enjoy or walk out enjoy their outdoor seating and it will complement their lobster rolls very well. They also have nice little selection of beers/beverages and a whole N/A fridge too.“

4.2 Good92 Reviews
Port Marina and Restaurant Seafood • $$
954 Ocean Dr, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll and Potato Salad
Black Truffle Meatballs
Cheese Steak Flatbread
Grilled Mahi Sandwich
Grilled Shrimp Tacos
Crab Cake Sandwich
Shrimp Cocktail
Fish and Chips
Conch Fritters
She Crab Soup

“We love Port. Always a great breeze and view at the outdoor bar. Drinks, salads, seafood, oysters, and sushi are just perfect. And, Luke is one of the nicest and friendliest bartenders in the CM area. We will be back.“

4.1 Good277 Reviews
Quincy's Original Lobster Rolls Seafood • $
709 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Classic Lobster Roll with blt
Lobster Grilled Cheese
Lobster Mac'n Cheese
Jumbo Lobster Roll
Lobster Salad Roll
Lobster Bisque
Quincy's Fries
Lobster Meat
French Fries
Shrimp Roll

“The wife and I were out and about and decided to try the Waterside location in Lakewood Ranch Fl. I have to say im a bit of a critic because we have family in Maine and have tasted all ends of the spectrum of lobster rolls from amazing to terrible and this place makes a great Lobster rolls with a spot on price comparable to Maine and other restaurants in the area. The staff member we dealt with was super nice I wish I would have got his name, but I do know he was from Jersey and had great knowledge knew the product well. We had 2 Connecticut rolls and they were great. I would say this place is worth checking out. Theres only outdoor seating, but you can easily walk around waterside and find a spot to kick back and enjoy or walk out enjoy their outdoor seating and it will complement their lobster rolls very well. They also have nice little selection of beers/beverages and a whole N/A fridge too.“

4.1 Good88 Reviews
Atlantic Capes Fisheries Seafood • $$$
985 Ocean Dr, Cape May
5 Superb1 Reviews
Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar Seafood • $$$
615 Lafayette St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Oyster Bay's Famous Crab Cakes
Cheesecake Bananas Foster
Bananas Foster Cheesecake
Oysters on Half Shell
Spinach & Brie Salad
Oyster Bay Jambalaya
Oysters Rockefeller
Crispy Duck Breast
Charbroiled Oysters
Bang Bang Shrimp

“My husband and I have been visiting Cape May for years now, and we cannot understand how we waited this long to stop in the Oyster Bay Bar & Restaurant for dinner. We spent a few weeks in the area this year and had meals at the Oyster Bay Bar three times!! From our first visit, we felt so incredibly welcomed beginning with a nice chat with the hostess as we waited for our table. Just from that brief chat during our first visit, the same hostess greeted me by my name on our 2nd visit. I’m embarrassed to say that I cannot remember her name, but I will say that she was incredibly lovely and personable. Our server, Bobby, who took care of us on both our first and last visits, had a wonderful personality, sharing some tidbits with us of the history of the restaurant and with being local to the area, answered some of our questions about the holiday season in Cape May. Now, about the food…with each visit we tried something new and found each meal to be delicious and satisfying. Our favorite appetizer, which we had on all three visits, was the charbroiled oysters. Absolutely delightful!! The mix of the Parmesan cheese in the garlic butter….so very good!! My husband and I always like to do something special on our last night of vacation…and you guessed it, the Oyster Bay Bar was our choice for dinner! The lovely hostess greeted us once again and mentioned to the owner, Gary, that this was our third visit and that we chose this restaurant as our last dinner on vacation. Gary stopped by our table, after sending a complementary round of drinks to us, and spent time speaking with us. Knowing we were tossing the idea of a return visit during the holidays, he gave us his personal cell phone number to reach out to him for not only restaurant reservations but also if we had any other questions regarding the holiday visit. Never before, have I encountered such genuine kindness and graciousness in a visit to a restaurant establishment. I cannot stress to all who take the time to read this review that you most definitely must stop in the Oyster Bay Bar & Restaurant for a meal. You will not be disappointed. Thank you, Gary, Bobby and the most loveliest hostess for adding to our vacation memories and experiences.“

4 Good110 Reviews
Mermaids Restaurant Mediterranean • $
702 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Mediterranean Calamari
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Mozzarella Sticks
Fish and Chips
French Fries
Cheese Steak
Shrimp Kabab
Greek Salad
Lobster Roll

“Great Food and Awesome Location. Love it!“

4.7 Superb370 Reviews
Louisa's Cafe Seafood • $$
104 Jackson St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Caesar Salad with Hard Boiled Farm Egg Homemade Croutons Parmigiano
Chocolate Mint Pot Decreme
Vanilla Bread Pudding
Grilled Fish
Crab Cake

“Fresh and interesting menu. Everything we had was perfect. Smoked salmon and noodle aps were both great starters to share. Scallops, crab cakes, swordfish entrees were delicious. The desserts were lovely and generous portions. Not surprised to hear that this is a perennial favorite for many regulars.“

4 Good128 Reviews
Stowaways Seafood • $$
1200 Lincoln Blvd, Cape May

“We had a great time at Stowaways. Pat was the best!“

3.8 Good32 Reviews
Tisha's Fine Dining American • $$
322 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Cape May Scallops with Risotto
New England Clam Chowder
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Cheeseburger and Fries
Cajun Fried Oysters
Seafood Pescatore
Mushroom Risotto
Scallops Risotto
Chicken Pasquale
Scallop Risotto

“Always go when in Cape May…fabulous food“

4.5 Superb980 Reviews
Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant American • $$$
1301 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Prime Beef

“I absolutely recommend Peter Shields Inn for a wedding venue. We had a small wedding on the beach and our wedding dinner was handled by Peter Shields. We worked with Amy (their event coordinator) and she was so helpful in every way. She went above and beyond to make everything so easy for us. I literally handed them a box of our wedding decorations and the tables and everything was set up perfectly! I didn’t have to lift a finger. Their bartender served up our signature drinks with a smile. Our guitarist serenaded guests on the porch while they enjoyed cocktails and wonderful hors doeurves. Dinner was seriously some of the best food I’ve ever had. Perfection hands down!“

4.5 Superb831 Reviews
SeaSalt Restaurant Seafood • $$
SeaSalt Restaurant, 1035 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Herb Roasted Spanish Octopus
Ceviche

“Not sure why this place has a 3.9 rating - we had a wonderful time! Our server, Agnieszka, was great. Oysters were solid. Branzino was superb. Shrimp bruschetta was perfectly balanced with a lot of flavor. Our 2.5 year old daughter was treated great, and thoroughly enjoyed her hot dog and french fries. The Malbec was good, as was the St. Germain Spritz. It was a bit pricy but that’s to be expected for the location. Would go again!“

3.7 Good117 Reviews
Fins Bar & Grille Seafood • $$
142 Decatur St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Fins Seafood Chowder
Lobster Cobb Salad
Crab Cake Sandwich
Thai Shrimp Tacos
Crispy Calamari
Tuna Tartare
Lobster Roll
Crab Cakes
Fish Tanks
Fins Pie

“Fins is amazing. Hope you’re lucky enough to be there on a day Kenny is. He’s an amazing bartender with a great spirit and can help fill you in on all things Cape May. He makes the best drinks and will find exactly what you’re looking for menu wise (everything is great!) Fins is a must do!!“

3.8 Good214 Reviews
Maison Bleue Bistro French • $$$
653 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Local Pan Seared Scallops
Surf and Turf Special
Wagyu Cheeseburger
Oysters Rockefeller
Local Harvest Salad
Fresh Oysters
Creme Brulee
Steak Tartare
Vichyssoise
Duck Confit

“We absolutely adore this place! The decor is top-notch, creating a romantic ambiance. The service is excellent, and the food, though not extensive in its selections, is all delicious. I ordered the roast chicken, and my husband opted for the Wagyu burger. Both dishes were tender and juicy, exactly as we had hoped. If you haven’t tried this place yet, I highly recommend it.

By the way, if you do get there early, the outdoor porch is a great spot to sit and enjoy your wait time in style, and don’t let me forget to mention this place is BYOB.“

4.5 Superb142 Reviews
Union Park Dining Room Fine Dining • $$$
Hotel Macomber, 727 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Short Rib Mashed Potatoes and Carrots
Basque Burnt Cheesecake
Twin Lobster Tails
Scallop Appetizer
Lobster Risotto
Brownie Dessert
Chocolate Tart
Burrata Salad
Bay Scallops
Crème Brulee

“EXCELLENT FROM SOUP TO NUTS !!!!“

4.3 Superb490 Reviews
410 Bank Street Restaurant Seafood • $$$
410 Bank St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Atlantic Cape Yellow Fin Tuna
Mesquite Grilled Lobster Tail
Shrimp and Crawfish Beignets
Blackened Scallops Appetizer
Cajun Shellfish Gumbo File
New Orleans Voodoo Shrimp
Gulf Stream Crab Terrine
Chilean Sea Bass Creole
Blackened Sea Scallops
Blackened Prime Rib

“Food and service fabulous!“

4.4 Superb134 Reviews
Oceanview Restaurant Breakfast • $$
235 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Pork Roll Egg and Cheese
Two Eggs French Toast
Eggs Bacon and Toast
French Fries
Cheesesteak
Home Fries
Tater Tots
Crab Cakes
Fish Tacos
Sandwich

“Very friendly staff, bright open atmosphere across from the beach. Food was good, quick service.“

4.5 Superb77 Reviews
Backstreet Simply Delicious American • $$
600 Park Blvd, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Second Course Pan-Fried Fish Cheddar Grouper Carbonara or Chicken Francaise
First Course Warm Goat Cheese Salad or Spinach Salad
Pan-Fried Crab Cake
Blueberry Cobbler
Pan Fried Fish
Fried Tomatoes
Banana Foster
Tiramisu

“Always delicious at Backstreet!“

4.5 Superb34 Reviews
Ugly Mug Bar & Restaurant Bar & Grill • $$
426 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Buffalo Wings with Blue Cheese and Celery
Manhattan Clam Chowder
Ugly Mug Lobster Roll
1½ lb Whole Lobster
Crab Cake Sandwich
Fish and Chips
French Fries
Onion Rings
Roast Beef
And Fries

“Just landed in Cape May looking for a place to grab a quick bite we stopped at the ugly mug in Cape May. The service was excellent. The crabcakes had so much crab in them that I could not finish them. Their coleslaw is excellent out of a 10 I would give this old-time Kate Bay Restaurant 10 out of 10.“

3.9 Good214 Reviews
Delaney's Irish Pub And Grill Irish Pub • $$
400 Washington St, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

1 ½ lb Whole Lobster
French Onion Soup
Bangers and Mash
Shepherd's Pie
Reuben Eggrolls
Salad Sandwich
Blackened Tuna
Chicken Salad
Caesar Salad
Lobster Roll

“Pretty good pub fare with decent prices. Sometimes a little too crowded & loud for my liking,but most won't mind that.

They know how to make two of my fave casual meals: a Reuben and Fish & Chips, both of which in other places manage to be soggy rather than toasted or fried to crispy perfection.“

3.7 Good206 Reviews
Hemingway's Steaks & Seafood Restaurant American • $$
in the Grand Hotel, 1045 Beach Ave, Cape May

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Mac and Cheese
Seafood Combination
Braised Short Ribs
French Onion Soup
Crispy Calamari
Stuffed Flounder
Caesar Salad
Creme Brulee
Hanger Steak
Fish Tacos

“We celebrated our 53rd anniversary there tonight. They could not have been nicer to us. They treated us to a very special evening. Balloons at the table and complimentary champagne. They also treated us to a dessert of our choice. The food was delicious. I think we found our new favorite restaurant.“

3.4 Good179 Reviews

You May Also Like