50 Best Sandwich Shops near Lyndhurst

“I`ve tasted in a couple years ago, and I just can say that is the most delicious sandwich in NJ 😉👌“

“Always awesome stopping by Jersey Mike’s in Lyndhurst for a sandwich. Food is great but the staff is even better, lotta big smiles and super helpful. One of the few places where it seems like actually they care about the customer enjoying their meal, and their day as well. Damaris and the crew are the best. I highly recommend a visit for those who haven’t.“

“Good food - good people. Every dish is fresh and tasty.“

“This place is great! Atmosphere is chill and cool but the staff is also really friendly. They know what they're doing and what they're talking about, and you can tell making the customers happy is their main priority. Food is stunning!! Some italian classics and some twists, amazing wines and for their prices it's 100% worth it. Love this place and I can't wait to return and wouldn't hesitate to recommend to anyone looking for somewhere to eat in NYC.“

“DeFontes is one of those Brooklyn institutions that instantly reminds you why some places never need a refresh.\n\nI went straight for the Signature Hot Roast Beef and, in a moment of well justified indulgence, added the Steak Pizzaiola. Zero regrets. These sandwiches are unapologetically stuffed. Meat, cheese, sauce, seasoning, all layered with confidence and generosity that feels almost defiant in today’s portion-controlled world.\n\nAnd the bread matters here. It’s fresh, warm, and crisp in all the right places, sturdy enough to carry the weight of the fillings without stealing the spotlight. It’s the perfect vehicle for the kind of sandwich that requires both hands and lots of napkins.\n\nOrdering at the counter may look intimidating at first, like there’s a secret rhythm you’re supposed to know and have rehearsed. Don’t stress it. The service is quick, efficient, and genuinely friendly. The staff are happy to guide you through it, even if it’s your first time staring at the menu trying to decide how hungry you actually are.\n\nJust keep in mind that there’s no seating beyond a stand-up counter along the wall, so plan accordingly. This is very much a grab-and-go or eat-it-immediately experience.\n\nDeFontes isn’t chasing trends. It doesn’t have to. This is classic, expertly executed deli cooking that delivers exactly what you want and then some.“

“The Sandwiches just like in Florence !!“

“I taked to there "my kids" (im a babysitter) to have a açai bowl with a lot of tops. they loved so much and they tried the pao de queijo too, The Best.“

“Been going to Faiccos for over 45 years now and nothing has changed thank goodness. The absolute best Italian cold cuts sandwiches,cheese and other specialities served by clean professional knowledgeable staff. The wrapping of the meats is a work of art in it self. Quality is amazing fresh and you can taste each item if you desire. The employees ability to cut tge meats so thin you can read the paper thru them still amazes me. Store is always very clean and workers are clean and well groomed important when they are touching your food. In 45 years never a problem never an issue
Always perfect just perfect.
Try tge home made sopresota or Italian from Italy mortadell or 8 different salami or a sandwich. Tge house made mottsorella is also amazing. Well worth the wait“

“Dopo una settimana in giro per NY, l'ultimo giorno, ahimé, ho scoperto il bar/gastronomia/shopping Best Sicily. Il miglior caffè!“

“Everything on the menu is delicious! The service is fast and staff is amazing. My children love their empanadas! It’s cozy, welcoming and relaxing ambiance…“

“I cherish every visit here. Workers at La sandwicherie chelsea welcomed our family with open arms. Great ambiance with a nice vibe, friendly staff, and a clean & simple decor. Their meals maintain quality while costs stay reasonable. This place delivers a pleasurable experience.“

“From service to food, everything shows attention to detail. As usual, I found the sweet offerings most satisfying. Workers here enhance your meal with their service. Accommodating, unpretentious, and sincere. I haven't discovered a place this excellent in years.“

“Travels great for any tailgate!! 10/10“

“Absolutely great experience every time!
My local Subway never disappoints. The place is always clean, the ingredients are fresh, and the staff moves fast even when it’s busy. Everyone is friendly and they actually listen to how you want your sandwich made. You can tell they take pride in their work. My order is always right, and the bread is always soft and fresh. Definitely one of the best Subways I’ve been to — highly recommend!“

“We had a takeaway of those pastrami sandwiches and tuna salad which were awesome, so we ordered more after we finished the first batch.

We waited like 15-20 minutes in lunch time.

Madison Square park is 2 minutes away with some public chairs and tables.“

“Fantastic gluten-free bagels! Literally the best I've had. Great spreads: horseradish cream cheese and scallion cream cheese also the best I've even had. Ordered delivery and bagels arrived nice & hot & toasty.
Now I'm back home in Los Angeles after this work trip with my boss, and both of us crave these fine GF bagels.“

“Everything was so fresh and delicious“

“This is by far my favorite restaurant. Every item on their menu is amazing. The owners and staff are friendly and welcoming as well. I make the excuse to visit the restaurant once a week from Manhattan“

“Their sandwiches are absolutely delicious. The sauce is literally magical but the flavor of the pork is also so, so tasty. My husband and I went a few days ago with our 10 month old daughter, she slept in the stroller the whole time so there is great atmosphere as well. I already can't wait to go back. Highly recommend!“

“Sandwich was delicious. Loved the 70’s & 80’s movie posters on the wall. And the staff was helpful and had great vibes!“

“Holy crap the sandwich was good it was bursting with flavor and everything in between. The guy helping me gave me 70 free bags of chips and free cookies, of course. My life has been changed forever. The sandwich was so good, for a second I thought my dad returned.“

“Everyone go check out Dutch’s sandwich shop. They have great breakfast sandwiches and much more. The service is wonderful makes you feel welcome. The owner is a great guy and cares about his customers. He makes sure the experience is wonderful. I’ll definitely come back.“

“Great food! Had lunch catered to my business and everything was superb!! Thanks Guys!“

“we loved it!“

“This was our first time trying this famous sandwich place. Thus, we were not sure what were the options. Unfortunately, they do not have a list of menu. However, they were very patient with us and told us what the special sandwiches of the day were. We got that day's special which was roastbeef. It was quite delicious. Next time, I would like to try a sandwich with bresaola (if they have).“

“I came today and tried Pietro sandwich and it was amazing! Tasteful and huge! It’s definitely one of the best sandwiches I ever had and I totally reccomend it! I live in Greece but I visit often NY and from now on I will visit Capone’s every time I will be in the city!“

“Always a great experience at the deli. The owner is very personable and accommodating.“

“The team makes even first-time visitors feel like regulars. Heaven on 7th Marketplace combines great cooking with excellent presentation. The staff maintained superior attention. All my selections demonstrate good flavor. The restaurant functions well and I'm glad I gave it a try.“

“Great lunches very accommodating for small lunch gatherings. Friendly atmosphere and staff. Delicious home cooked food and Italian specialties“

“The Picnic Basket NYC is always a fantastic experience. The kale salad is fresh, flavorful and perfectly balanced, and the chicken melt is my husband’s absolute favorite — warm, generous and delicious every time. Friendly service, great quality and consistently excellent food. Highly recommend.“

“I enjoyed the chicken pesto burrata, what a delicious sandwich! The person i was with got the lunchbox special, not a bite was left of either sandwich. I also recommend the ginger lemonade, it packs a little kick because of the ginger. I'll definitely come here again when I am back in NYC“

“Great food! Had lunch catered to my business and everything was superb!! Thanks Guys!“

“This is an incredibly special place. The sandwiches are absolutely delicious, with good portions, very high quality ingredients and great execution.

Vibes are excellent and welcoming.

The food, for as incredible as it is, is so approachable. It was the type of meal I was inspired to wanna cook for myself. This is a must stop place if you’re around.

Sandwich pictured is La Bombolona.“

“so i ordered pancakes from here and while the pancakes themselves were quite good, they charged an outrageous amount for strawberries that were soggy and bland. if they used fresh strawberries then it would maybe be a 5/5 but if you like strawberries then perhaps you should go elsewhere. otherwise im sure you’ll have a great time with the pancakes. i also had a peach mango smoothie and that was pretty good.“

“Based on my experience there, I loved it but I’m hesitant to give five stars cause I only had the ribeye cheesesteak which may be one of the best cheesesteaks I’ve had out in NJ in all seriousness. Felt a little pricey but so does everything else these days. Even then, the cheesesteak was worth every cent. Highly recommended.“

“My favorite place in Hoboken! The owner is one of the kindest people I have ever met, and every delicious dish is made with love. Great coffee, omelettes and breakfast sandwiches! Cozy ambiance, good music and cool local artwork on the walls. Definitely give this place a try!“

“If you miss this place, then you are missing out on life! By far the best Italian sub shop, I've ever had the experience to try. Their subs are slammin!!! Highly recommended and such wonderful staff too!! It's definitely a must go to, and now my favorite sub shop around!!“

“Decided to stop in and see what the hype is and they did not disappoint! Line was coming out of the door but the staff working got everyone out as soon as they could quickly as possible!! I tried the chicken Cesar salad sandwich it is a 10/10 must try with an extra side of dressing!! Everything was fresh and flavorful!! Staff there were very friendly and the whole vibe was amazing!! Will def be stopping by when in the area, go try it if you haven’t yet!!!“

“Thank you for your generous support of Eastbrook’s class of 2021! Amazing spread of sandwiches, fixings & even gluten free options!“

“Delicious fresh breakfast sandwich to order. Got eggs, spicy mayo, turkey bacon, cheddar, on ciabatta. Comes with sliced tomato and arugula, which is a perfect touch. Order include a hash brown fried to perfection and ketchup (thoughtful because I used it for my sandwich as well).“

“Deliriously delicious shop in the East Village! The sandwich rolls were the best I've tasted in NYC and perfectly toasted. My love and I enjoyed The Hog, a vermicelli and meat salad with the best fish sauce, and a lamb taco. I especially was impressed with the cleanliness and food handling. Go to "about us" to read the interesting story of the two friends/owners who we were so fortunate too meet at Wheelers in Sheepshead Bay.“

“Awesome food and even greater customer service!! 🫶🏽👏🏽🙌🏽❤️🎯🎯“

“Good local sandwich place. The owners are honest people.
My recommendation: consider selling half sandwiches on the menu and charge little more than half price. You'll attract more customers that way, and the half sandwich is already filling. Thank me later bros.“

“OMG OMG THIS IS ABSOLUTELY THE BEST HERO IN THE WORLD!!! IT TOOK ME BACK TO 80'S WHEN I WOULD VISIT JERSEY CITY. THE SMELL WHEN I WALKED IN MADE TOOK ME BACK TO LINCOLN HIGH SCHOOL DAYS. THE AMOUNT OF MEAT ON THE 10 WAS UNEXPECTED AND I GOT A WHOLE FOR MYSELF WHEN I PICKED THE BAG UP I WAS LIKE NO WAY. THE AMOUNT OF MEAT WAS CRAZY IT TOOK ME 3 DAYS TO EAT IT. IM TAKING 1 BACK WITH ME. THANKS FOR THIS AWESOME EXPERIENCE“

“I asked for a Pastrami Hero but needed help on what to put on it, hot or cold. The gentleman working to make my samdwich was extremely helpful in helping decide how to make it (haven't had one before) and the result was incredible.

Every time I come to NYC, I love the hospitality of these local shops. I could tell he cared about making a high quality sandwich that I would like and he succeeded.

Bravo. Thank you. I will make it a point to come back next time I am here.

My wife for the Big Chicken and said it was fantastic as well.“

“This place is incredible. It's peak Chicago in all the best ways. An absolutely immaculate vibe with an amazing array of Chicago memorabilia, a very lively and friendly staff, and delicious food. I would live here if not for the legality of it all.“

““I’ve known this place for 26 years and hadn’t been back in 18. It hasn’t changed a bit — even the same owner and staff are still here. The decor is simple, the service is friendly, and they only serve one thing: Cuban steak sandwiches. Still as delicious as ever! It makes me so happy to come back and enjoy the same great taste. This place proves that having one great product is enough to last for decades“

“We visited this place for breakfast during our recent stay in Times Square. Overall, it’s a decent spot for breakfast or lunch. They offer a wide variety of dishes on their menu. We opted for a veggie wrap and an egg sandwich with cheese. The coffee, however, was quite ordinary. Not much seating available inside.“

“Love this sandwich shop, happen to be around Lincoln park. Togo the sandwiches buffalo chicken and turkey sandwich. Both of them were so good! And also plus chip!!

The owner was really nice and welcoming too
Price is good and sandwich is big“

“If you were looking for a cup of coffee and a sandwich at 4:30 a.m. this is your spot! I've been in here several times, and the place is spotless. They only have one small table to sit at, so you shouldn't plan on eating there. There's a big menu and the coffee is always fresh. I always see the same guy working there, and you can tell he knows what he's doing. If you are in the area and need something quick and easy and reasonably priced this is the place to go.“