Sandwich Shops near New Milford

“This is one of my favorite local subways!! I live in Dumont. The staff is always attentive & friendly. Food fresh. Service quality. Salad bowls are excellent healthy. ? thank youVegetarian options: Always good to have non meat or non poultry items. I'm not 100% vegetarian or vegan. But I do order and cook that way a good percentage of the time while maintaining flexibility w chicken turkey etc. However I would order veg option“

“Nuru is very friendly and gives a good customer service. Every time I go there he knows what I want and how I want my sandwich. Quick service; the line move very fast with him. Also the Mexican man offer a very good customer service and he’s friendly too. Keep the good work!!! Thank you guys. ??????“

“I have lived around the area for many years, and never have I tried a better Itlian hero than at Nick's. You are paying for quality - you can tell by the second you take the first bite. A sandwich is as good as the bread, theirs is fresh and perfect. Nick's is a MUST TRY!“

“I've been coming here for many yrs, I'm a semi regular and it's always a pleasure coming in. From Felicia being amazing and always having a positive attitude to my service and food always being great, this is def the best Subway I've been to, especially after the renovations. The woman with the braided bun was the star of the show today for making an early release of the footlong sidekicks to me (thanks to management too) I got the churro and cookie one and it's so good, def recommend trying.“

“Came with 2 friends.Sandwiches and fries are great!Staff service is amazing. Guy gave us sanitizing wipes and extra napkins when he saw that we ran out.How would i describe the food? The fries r like mcdonalds fries but crispier and seasoned well. The no fork sandwich is like a largeeee costco hotdog with a toasted, really soft and light bun. Bread isnt too filling; perfect for a light lunch. The meat/cheese interior was supreme though“

“If you're looking for a speedy delicious sub, look no further! Ike's Big Mouth has a lot of sun options - I decided to get Casper's special because I love chicken cutlet. Note that you need to share this with someone or just need to have a big mouth and appetite. The place itself is small but they move quick!“

“good location with ample parking space.inside was neat and clean; and the staff were pretty good during our visit.we has the usual philly steak and it was hot and fresh just the way we like it. Add some chips and wewere quite satisfied with such simple butdelicious meal.“

“When Claudia is crafting your sandwiches, you can rest assured that they'll be absolutely delightful. This place offers great value, reliability, and speed. Despite their efficiency, the food still retains that comforting homemade taste and feel. I wholeheartedly recommend it with a perfect score of 10/10!“

“Exceptional experience at Jersey Mike's! The customer service was outstanding, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The staff's friendliness and efficiency stood out. Moreover, the food was consistently fresh and delicious. A great place for a satisfying meal with top-notch service.“

“Every single thing is delicious. Honestly, Agamie never disappoints. The food is super fresh & the service is exceptional. The staff was so nice to my 6 year old too.“

“I don't remember the person's name but he was Asian and was really good. He messed the order but it was really nice to go change it. Even the other lady who was taking the order was also really good and recognized the order being wrong. Great customer service.I am sorry I am bad with remembering name.“

“Love this place! Talk about comfort food. Their deli subs and chicken parm is off the hook. Makes you want to try the other sammies but aside from great tasting fresh food you're going to get that 1 on 1 small family experience who take absolute pride in what they do. Support your local small businesses! Almost forgot, best chilli in northeast NJ, mind blowing.“

“Food and service is always great. Right off a main road so it can get pretty busy. Establishment is always very generous with their servings and usually pretty quick. The only thing I dislike about this place is that their bread is very soft. I usually like my subs on a crispy roll. This is my go-to option when Cappelluti's Deli in Kearny is closed“

“This location has friendly, engaged, and quick working staff. They were upfront on how busy it was so we knew exactly what time the food was going to be ready at. Great location, efficient production time, and food came out great, classic Mike style. Jersey Mike's never disappoints and this location is no exception.“

“Never disappoints. I get the club with turkey and pepperoni. The pepper relish is awesome. I really like their cheesesteaks it's pretty good probably one of the best cheesesteaks around. if you know of a better cheese steak around please comment back on this post, i love cheese steak. The stubborn brand cream soda is some of the best cream soda I've ever had. The kids in there are pretty friendly. All in all they make a good sandwich their meat is good quality not cheap stuff.“

“I disagree with all the bad reviews there are no cockroaches crawling in the walls ? in my opinion this is better than subway, good customer service I’ve gone like 7 times already and I’ve never had a complaint. I recommend it very much.“

“This store is my go-to after a day of driving and shopping. It is on my way home. I always look forward to seeing the workers with their smiles and pleasantness. Prices are reasonable and the store is clean. Plenty of seating. There is a large parking lot, but sometimes I'm not able to get a spot near the store and have to go to another part of the strip mall. Great location for this store and has been there for a long time.“

“yum yum....nom nom.... two tries. two salads. both awesome. i'll be back again and again :)))“

“I came here today with my 4 year old for a daddy/daughter lunch, we loved it! The service is fast, the food is fresh, and the staff is friendly. The seating area is clean and comfortable and spacious. But I already knew all of that… I live around the corner and frequent often. I’m posting today because Noel suggested I try the chipotle cheesesteak, with his recommended preparation. It was phenomenal! I ended up eating 3/4 of a giant and I am sitting here stuffed ready for a nap haha. Thanks for making it fun and extra delicious today, Noel! Thank you to Chris and Patty for the great service as well :)Kid-friendliness: It’s quick, fun, and relaxed, with healthy options. Great for bringing small kids out for a quick bite without the stress.“

“Nice and friendly atmosphere and I recommend The Jibarito with Steak on fried Plantain..it’s my Fav!“

“My best friend of over 30 years introduced me to this spot. She passed away in Dec. Of 2022 But I continue to go to Montclair DeliIt's become my favorite place to eat. Their food is amazingly delicious and the service is great. They make you feel like family.“

“Muy buen servicio y el desayuno muy bueno ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Excellent sandwich, very courteous and knowledgeable staff. I was there to get a sandwich but I also picked up nice reasonably priced greeting cards and balloons too for my nephew. The place is bright and clean. This will be my go to stop when I am in the area making deliveries. Huge parking lot to park my truck, easy in and out.Also I saw they had a sign that say Buy 2 get 1 Free pizza. Next time I should try the Subway pizza too.“

“I was in the mood for Blimpie and stopped here. When I arrived I parked on the street nearby. I walked in, and the nice man took my order. I ordered the breaded chicken on wheat and paid and left. When I ate, it was really good and hit the spot. Had a good experience.“

“What's not to love about Denaro's? Consistency is key here. Aside from their low prices, the bread hasn't change and nor has the friendly service. Sandwiches are made with a generous amount of freshly sliced cold cuts and they have just the right selection of toppings. Simplicity and quality are key here. A Denaro's sandwich never disappoints. Cash only!“

“So I just started working in Fort Lee, so close to Jersey Mikes I had to go try it, of course I know the food is good but when I tell you THIS LOCATION is the best Jersey Mikes I’ve ever had idk what they’re doing here that other places don’t but I don’t even wanna eat Jersey Mikes unless I’m getting it from this location.New lunch obsession.“

“I had a small Chicken Diablo sandwich with raw onions and lettuce. It was a pricey meal at $10.99 for a small although it tasted very good. The chicken had a nice heat to it which was nice.The atmosphere was nice and very clean and the staff was friendly and attentive to our questions. The service was also quick.Vegetarian options: Veggie Diablo Sandwich“

“It's Blimpie's! The BB still a classic NJ favorite that I'll take over any Subway sub. I tried a few others as well. It's always slamming. I also recommend the Hoboken. So glad there's still one Blimpie's near my house.“

“We came from Brazil and this place was amazing! Amazing service , food , atmosphere etc. A very nice cook and hostess she was very helpful and patient! Helped with concerns and questions. Very much recommend this place if ur visiting nyc or even live here.“

“I wanted a quick bite so stopped in. I walked in and there was a small line. When I got to the front the nice lady took my order. I got the veggie patty on whole wheat bread. They made it just like I liked. I had a coupon and it was about $3.50. When I got to the car I ate and it was good. All in all I had a good experience.“

“Their Parisienne sandwich is the best way be had outside of Paris, and everyone is so nice! The bread is perfection. I love this place so much.“

“This was the cleanest subway I have ever seen! The kindness staff I've ever met. I feel horrible that they have to deal with uneducated ghetto ppl that disrespect, abuse & take advantage of the staff. I witnessed it first hand, and I could see the fear in their faces by some kids being rude and threatening & also a customer defending the kids that were in the wrong. I was ready to jump into action, but you never know in this neighborhood. But Def was ready to call 911. Bravo to you all, and I wish they had some sort of security.“

“Today I went to mood ‘wishes and didn’t know what to choose, they have so many options and everything looks soo good, but I went with the hot and dirty bowl w/ chicken… it was such a good choice!! Soo delicious! I’m definitely coming back can’t wait to try the rest of the menu items“

“After a long day of waiting for our car to be fixed, these employees really delivered great service. The guy and girl on today were so kind informative and enthusiastic about their services that we enjoyed our stop so much more. First time to this joint and glad we came. Perfect in every way.“

“Great place! The guy behind the counter was very chill and made a pretty good Mr. Beast Burger for me and my friend. Burger was 7.5/10 in my opinion - definitely something I would buy again. Their entire menu looks delicious and plan on heading back to try more. Their fries are definitely 9.5/10 - some of the best fries I've had in a while. Highly recommend you stop by and try a burger from this place ?“

“I came here and Kevin, the guy making the sandwich, Jaury, the grill guy, and Jeremiah the expo guy were all exceptionally great with service, Kindness and professionalism. Everything was done meticulously and carefully and they made my friend and I feel welcome. We will definitely return and this might be the best JM in this area, also my girls sandwich was made first and they They brought it out to me when it was done. I am so thankful for this teamParking: There’s enough parking, It’s a strip mall so everything is close“

“Great customer service! Tell Missy we said Hi.“

“This location is a solid Jersey Mike's in Edgewater!I love this chain restaurant. I think their sandwiches are higher quality than most of their competitors that have similar offerings. The bread is always delicious, soft on the inside with slightly crusty edges. You can tell the meat they use is freshly sliced and hasn't been sitting out all day. My go to sandwich is the Original Italian Mike's Way. Loaded with Italian meats and packed with flavor, this sub will always be one of my favorites! For this specific location, I usually order online from the website and pick up. I haven't had any issues, the orders have been correct and ready on time. I will keep coming back for my bi-weekly sandwich!“

“The variety of sandwiches offered was impressive, each bursting with fresh and flavorful ingredients. The bread was perfectly toasted, and the portions were generous. The service was prompt and friendly. A delightful experience that I can't wait to repeat!“

“So goood..the food!!! Seating ares may be smaller than normal and may have to park across the street but food and service will pack a punch. So goood. Thsnk you Eggty 8.Parking: Small but can,also park across the street in next parking lot“

“Easy to think 3 stars is horrid but the man working was INSANELY nice and asked me politely what I wanted even though I couldn't hear him a few times oops. Fast and cheap. Sandwich was typical subway nothing fancy. Would go there if I was in a hurry and needed something. Great spot.“