50 Best Sandwich Shops near New Milford

“Clean restaurant. Stopped by yesterday for lunch. Owner was there and he was a kind gentleman who conversed well while making my Spicy Italian 6-in sandwich. Funny guy. This location does not participate in any discount promotions/coupons. Best of luck to this franchise owner!“

“I've been ordering Wonder near the office I work at downtown and have always enjoyed their food. It's nice to have access to it by my home now!
Their food always arrives hot and fresh. I like the Detroit deep dish pizza a lot.“

“I Love this place because the food is Really Good Here I Like the Workers At This Restaurant And I make a new friend at This Restaurant his Name is Mohammed And it's A Very Nice Place and The People and Everybody is great here and it's very clean and yhr place is Nice“

“Everything was so fresh and delicious“

“Great lunches very accommodating for small lunch gatherings. Friendly atmosphere and staff. Delicious home cooked food and Italian specialties“

“Always a great experience at the deli. The owner is very personable and accommodating.“

“Took the kids to Jersey Mike’s after soccer practice today and it was a total win! They loved the turkey sub and I went with the Italian Mike’s way. The staff was super nice and fast, which is a lifesaver when you’ve got hungry little ones. Way better than typical fast food feels like a real sandwich shop. Highly recommend for busy moms and families! We’ll be back soon. 😊“

“I highly recommend this place! The brunch was fantastic. I tried the Nova Omelette special, and it was absolutely amazing. The staff was incredibly friendly and attentive. My kids are already planning to return and order the blueberry and orange pancakes.“

“yum yum....nom nom.... two tries. two salads. both awesome. i'll be back again and again :)))“

“desayunos deliciosos los batidos son frescos“

“They have the most beautiful chip display of any Subway I’ve ever been to - it’s just so perfect & organized & it made my OCD brain happy when I walked in. My boyfriend always gets the nachos and they’re (surprisingly) really good.“

“Best sandwich shop in North Jersey area hands down! Never disappoints!

I constantly order from this place and try new things—even though I don't always like to switch it up—and honestly everything on the menu is beyond amazing!“

“My wife and I are visiting from Tampa, Florida. It was just a short walk to the sandwich shop (1/4 mile) or so. I can't rant and rave about this place enough. My experience was amazing and the food was better. 100% recommend anything meatball 🤤. The cheese steak 😋. I need to eat every sandwich 🥹.
Ate to fast to take a Pic of the food, I'll try next time to snap one but don't count on it.“

“The staff is SUPER helpful and patient. I am handicapped and they really took their time to help me with the menu, accessibility, and securing my food 😋
I would definitely recommend to anyone whose unsure of what to eat, family with different eating habits, and those with munchies too🤩
Family friendly as well.“

“A kind young lady by the name of Ruby attended my mother and I at the start of her shift today. She was very helpful, offered great suggestions and was diligent. Thank you sweetheart for the great customer service :) never let anyone dim your sparkle“

“I`ve tasted in a couple years ago, and I just can say that is the most delicious sandwich in NJ 😉👌“

“I work in the mall where this Charlie’s location is and I always set my order with one of their employees named Dulce. She’s extremely polite and nice. She always greets me with a smile and remembers my order. Kudos to her she deserves a raise“

“Thank you to our local Fair Lawn Jersey Mike’s! After supporting our Girl Scout troop while selling cookies, they donated lunch to our girls. Smiles all around!“

“Delicious sandwiches! The kind you’d travel from afar for just one more taste. All Boar’s Head Products. Fresh toppings and the Best Submarine Bread all combine for that taste of perfection. Best subs I’ve had in all of Jersey.“

“If you love to spoil yourself for breakfast well then look no further Bocadillo, has all the sweet and savory you crave.
My favorite the Salmon Toast with a Cafe Horchata. Looking to not cook for lunch because life’s too short? Order a Tuna Bowl, you won’t regret it. If the day gets away from you and it’s dinner time and you have nothing to cook, make it a tapas night in. My favorites are the manchego bites, shrimp and garlic, croquettes de jamon, and calamar. Something awesome is that they have a mini market where all my favorite items are available to purchase to make at home!“

“It had been a little bit since we've been in (life gets in the way sometimes) but as soon as my husband & I walked in the door we were hit with that heavenly Blimpies scent of fresh ingredients that is indicative of Blimpies & Blimpies alone. It just smells like delicious subs. We realized, after speaking to the wonderful owner, that we've been getting the BEST subs in the world at this location for over 40 years! My pick is a "Blimpies Best" (extra oil & vinegar) honestly it was perfect. My husband gets a turkey & provolone which was terrific (he gave me puppy dog eyes & got a huge chunk of mine too)
Eateries come & go but the best stay, this is worthy of place in your rotation.
I should also say that I live in Nutley with quite a few Italian delis & pizzerias so if I'm saying the Italian sub (Blimpies Best) is terrific that's saying a lot.“

“Friendly crew behind the counter, fast service too. Oh, and pretty good sandwiches too. 👍🏻“

“Local around the area and will always love this place to my core. I’ve been coming here since I was young and I watched the place change interior looks and saw the upgrade they had; proud of them! My family and I would have this place for Dinner time to time and it would never disappoint. Food is wonderful as always.“

“We really enjoy Sandwiches“

“Gerardo and Amelia have been serving the North Bergen community for over 6 years andhave been nothing but welcoming and an amazing addition to the community.

Me and my mom, Maria Villatoro love the sandwiches here and I have meltdowns at home if I can’t have them for real!

Thank
H & M“

“Cars is a Ramsey staple that every high schooler knows. The people here are always ready for the lunch rushes and constantly give back to the community, from simple posters on their windows to directly supporting the Ramsey district, they have played their part in uplifting our community. Additionally, the highschool lunch rushes to get here are no joke, with some running to make sure they are first to get here.“

“3/23 another delicious dinner from Ikes! chicken parm sandwich. plenty for the two of us. Everything from salads, wings, sandwiches are delicious! service is fast and friendly. recently I have had delivery and the food arrived fast and hot. The hot roast beef sandwich is sooooo good!“

“As I walked in, I greeted the wonderful counterperson, that was there at the moment. It happened to be a wonderful lady
With great spirits and an excellent smile. She built my sandwich to my specifications. And even helped me with a 2 part payment
I gotta say that kudos. To this location and to Jersey Mike's for having this wonderful employee.“

“Ordered twice, one is pastrami turkey and roasted beef, the other is meatball w/ mozzarella. I think the ingredients are pretty simple but the flavor is sooo good. It is absolutely a go-to place when u don’t want to cook, affordable and quick.“

“Thank you for your generous support of Eastbrook’s class of 2021! Amazing spread of sandwiches, fixings & even gluten free options!“

“Good good best chicken cheese steak“

“😀 hey serving sarges now“

“Absolutely love this place! We really needed something like this where you can order from different restaurants all in one spot. My food was perfectly packed, incredibly delicious, and super fast. I’m so glad one opened nearby. I used to go to the one near my job on 23rd Street, so this is super convenient!“

“To whom it may concern, I am a student at Cresskill Middle School and a member of the Aerospace Engineering Club. We are in need of a sponsor for the American Rocketry Challenge to provide us funds. If you side with us, your club will be presented with publicity at the challenge, increasing your funds and fame. The entire nation will be aware that this little shop made it to the finals of a big time competiton, and whenever someone walks into your store, they will be aware of the success you made. Additionally, once we win the challenge, rocketry challenges across the globe will discover you and the fame you felt once, will be amplified throughout your entire life, increasing funds forevermore, and increasing your partnership with the rocketry field. Lastly, you are also helping out your local school, meaning the entire town will be in your debt and they will continue to buy sandwiches forevermore. Also, we can add fundraisers, if needed, and since Jersey Mike's is very popular, the amount of funds are sure to increase. Please side with the Aerospace team!“

“I like this subway sandwich because it’s a clean place and I like how the customers are very nice to you and they give you extra napkins if you need some other subway customers they just don’t care and don’t give you any napkins or just forget your order that what I don’t like but this subway sandwich is more better I rate it at 5 stars.“

“Great customer service! Tell Missy we said Hi.“

“I've been craving blimpies 10 out of 10 been there 2 times every time it hit just like i remember I hope this forgotten place stays they don't make them like this anymore 😔 very friendly 💯❤😋 ifi ever have to a party or event definitely catering with this place 100 out 100 💯 🔥 delicious 😋“

“Mr Jarmar R Williams an employee there excellent customer service to us.My partner & myself frequent Jersey Mikes in Fort Lee NJ & Mr.Jamar addressed our issues immediatey.My personal opinion he def needs to manage that particular store his customer service is ova the top..💪“

“I had a wonderful experience at this local subway the customer service was truly excellent i was served by Shravya who made my meal with such care also Peter at check out was fast friendly and courteous!! Excellent customer service at this “

“I had the Steak & Cheese sandwich, and it was amazing! The steak was tender and flavorful, the cheese was perfectly melted, and the fresh veggies added a nice crunch. The toasted bread made it even better.

Great service, fresh ingredients, and a satisfying meal. Definitely a 5-star experience—I’ll be back for another one soon!“

“Muy buen servicio y el desayuno muy bueno ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Nice and friendly atmosphere and I recommend The Jibarito with Steak on fried Plantain..it’s my Fav!“

“Got the lemon pepper wings and fries and it did not disappoint! Wings were crispy juicy and the lemon pepper was a rub, not a sauce. It was seasoned just right, not too much, not too little. Fries were golden and hit the spot too. The service was quick, everything hot and fresh. Definitely coming back!“

“The presentation transforms good food into something special. Their kitchen delivers excellence and their team always shows care. The staff displays sincere hospitality. The positive facial expressions create a pleasant environment. I've stated the essentials.“

“*Editted my review to 5 stars:
Been here a bunch of times now. Overal the service is 10/10. And I have been going to the point pleasant original place for the last 25+ years, so it's solid at this location. I eat here specifically because the sub service is such good quality the majority of the time. Another comment said he felt discrimination because he was white. Well, it's never a skin thing but a sin thing, and don't ever forget, it was an African man that helped the Lord Jesus carry his cross.“

“Im so happy I chose to go here on a random laundry morning. They make my day every time I go. They have the BEST sandwiches and the BEST brown sugar iced coffee, it's soooooooo good 🤤. The owner is so kind and has great music or movies playing, and the deli is ALWAYS clean. 💚 Beautiful energy to start your day.“

“great service. awesome chicken cheese steak 😊😊😊😊“

“Guys am telling you that this Subway location consistently provides excellent service, and the staff is nice. In particular, there is a young woman who works on Saturday mornings who prepares exceptional sandwiches. Whenever she is on shift, everything looks fresh, and the quality of the sandwich is outstanding. I usually see her only on Saturday mornings, but she always delivers a perfectly made sandwich.“

“Had a great experience at Munchies Deli & Grill in Guttenberg. I really like that they offer halal food, which makes this a great option for anyone looking for halal deli and grill favorites in the area. The food was fresh, flavorful, and satisfying, with that classic comfort-food feel.

The menu has a nice variety of options, and everything feels like it’s prepared with care. It’s the kind of neighborhood spot where you can stop in for a quick meal or grab something to take with you.

The owner was a pleasure to speak to and made the visit even more enjoyable. You can tell there is genuine pride in the business and a real focus on taking care of customers.

Overall, I had a great experience at Munchies Deli & Grill and would definitely come back. Great halal food, friendly service, and a welcoming local atmosphere“