50 Best Bakeries near Old Tappan

“Great selection of breakfast and lunch options in addition to some hard-to-get grocery items. Friendly staff and they also have a text option allowing you to place your order ahead of time.“

“The best macaroons. The crème brûlée and Ferrero rocher were my favs!“

““Life is tough sometimes. This experience always gives me JOY. The people are amazing and the treats are the best I have ever had.”“

“My sisters and I were there in October 2022, and we had a beautiful experience! The pastries were delicious (lemon ginger tart was our favorite) and the atmosphere and customer service were divine! The shop is gorgeous and the lady behind the counter was so very nice and welcoming ☺️! We live in PA but we'll definitely be back in the spring“

“Great caterer !!!! Deserves 10 stars! Fabulous four foot Charcuterie Board that served over 30 people. Salmon -Chicken- Shrimp and Cold Cuts with vegetables, cheeses, fruits and cheeses. Professional servers are top rated. Great to work with from the start of planning to day of. They did a Summer non alcoholic drink bar and an iced tea and iced coffee bar. Tasty ice cream chipwiches to top off a great party catered by La Promenade. Would recommend for your next party! Thank you to Cynthia, Jenny and Sam and the rest of you at La Promenade for making our party the best ever! Great value! Highly recommend!!!“

“Delicious empanadas, and desserts! More than just cakes, stop in for a delicious treat like I did!!“

“Came here for the first time today with my mom and the food was delicious, esp the coco bread, I was overwhelmed by the options and will be coming back to try the other foods that are offered such as the bread pudding which I regret not getting today :( but the patties also tasted delicious I got the chicken and beef and they tasted perfect!!

Also remember to bring cash only!!! And be respectful.

Vegetarian options: They do have a veggie base Pattie unsure if the Pattie breading is vegetarian safe tho!“

“Amazing staff, our cakes were so yummy, just simply the best !!“

“My friend picked up an assortment of treats for my birthday, everything was so delicious✨Red velvet cupcake and The pistachio thingy were my favorites❣️Have to go soon & try more treats🥰“

“The fresh off the rack help yourself bakery was a cool experience but the eating of the huge everything bagels, pretzels and pastries was heavenly 🥯🙏🥰“

“A hidden gem on 46! So unexpected as it’s a great cookie focused bakery on the highway. Great cookies but the Ruggies are like my grandmother made and that woman could bake some rugelach! Great pecan sandies too. Gotta try more varieties next time! And a super nice owner and staff.“

“Excellent sitting inside,A/C very comfortable.Excellent food as well.Love this place.“

“Excellent place!!! Everything is top- notch!!! Highly recommended!“

“In 2024, the Monsey area is filled with catering establishments, take-out store, and bakeries, and yet Glaubers, which has been here forever, is still the best. They have catered kiddushin and a wedding for us and we were always greatly satisfied. When you go to the store you will find fresh and delicious food, and the people serving you are even more delicious! If you haven't been to Glaubers yet, go tomorrow.“

“What a wonderful place! My family and I often have breakfast/brunch at Guzzo’s and we are always pleasantly satisfied with the food and service. The staff is amazing and provide you with a warm welcome. We just celebrated my daughter’s 10th birthday here with her friends. I booked the tea party package that Guzzo’s has and it was such a great experience. The girls couldn’t stop talking about how much fun they had & how tasty everything was. Thanks again for making this a memorable birthday!“

“Their granola is the best we’ve ever eaten. It’s so yummy.“

“Such helpful and wonderful staff . Picked up a valentines cookie cake for my daughter’s class and they decorated it wonderfully. I was given a free sample of the caramel crumb cookie and it was divine. Did I mention they were super friendly and kind ???? 100/10

They have many treats and I saw some gorgeously decorated chocolate strawberries and I thought the price was amazing for the presentation. I think a dozen strawberries were $36 which is a bargain compared to other places who make subpar looking strawberries . I would have loved to receive them as a gift myself !

Can’t wait to try the banana pudding next time !“

“Everything was absolutely perfect, from the service to the deliciousness of the food (Chilean sea bass was outstanding, the lamb chops special was superb and the grilled octupus was perfectly tender). The only mention I have and it's seriously not a big deal was the dining room that we were seated in was a bit too dark I actually had to turn my flashlight on my phone to see. On a scale of 1-10 I give it an 11 !!“

“This place is just amazing! There were 5 of us and we all ordered something different. Everything we got was delicious- we all tried each other's dishes. There's a little bit of everything to satisfy even the pickiest eater. I would just drive her (over a 2 hour drive for me) just to come eat here. I need this place closer to home, lol.“

“Used to go the Mount Vernon shop when I was a kid, then after the fire and they moved to the Bronx..followed them down there- EVEN when the current owner bought from the gentile older man from MV... "Paul" has kept up standards. The Coco Breads are THE BOMB - I'd know, I was taught to make them at the bakery my Granny worked in Mo'bay every summer! A MUST HAVE !!!! Go out of your way. Brave the parking situation. DO IT, you will not regret it!“

“As charming as the bakery is, it pales in comparison to Miss Eleanor, the owner. Over the past several years I developed a sensitivity to wheat, so I wanted a gluten-free snack. She had a wide selection of sweets (cupcakes, cookies, brownies) but I saw the picture of biscuits and quickly decided to enjoy them with my coffee.

I took Ms Eleanor up on her offer to warm them up and chatted while waiting for my order to be complete. We had a lovely conversation about so many things - food, travel, career changes.

The biscuits were delicious and very reasonably priced so I’ll have to make my way back soon.

Dietary restrictions: gluten-free. dairy-free. egg-free. keto/sugar-free.“

“Excellent quiche and delicious cappuccino“

“Best mochinuts I’ve had!! Great place, super friendly staff and amazing food and drinks!! I love this place!!“

“How much do I love their bakery? I drove from Orange County, NY to pick up 3 dozen Black and white cookies to bring to a party in Massachussets. That is how yummy this bakery is!!!! The staff is just as sweet as the desserts.“

“Randy did an amazing job with our son's custom camper-themed cake. Our kid was beyond thrilled. Thank you for being so accommodating and wonderful! You really made his birthday special.“

“"Blend the most delicious freshly baked pastries, cakes, and their signature rugelach with a touch of Geshmak. Add a dash of excellent service, infused with the irresistible aroma of Sander's Bakery, and you’ve got a recipe for pure indulgence."

Dietary restrictions: Kosher to the strictest standard.

Kid-friendliness: Everything little kids (and the kid in you) would enjoy.“

“I have been going to the official cake lady now for 10-11 years and about 3-4 times in a year. Kim never ever disappoints. She makes our vision come to life. The cake is so good we drive over an hour to pick it. Kim is always professional and listens to every detail needed for the cake.
The cakes are always moist and delicious . We will continue to drive to get our cakes.
Thank you“

“Hmmm I'm not sure about the hype on this place. The service is slow (maybe to create a line outside?) and everything was pretty expensive. I got a few donuts and a baguette and it was good but not really anything amazing. Not sure if I would wait in line again for this place when there are so many bakeries in the area.“

“My son was recently diagnosed with EOE and is dairy, nut and egg free. Someone recommended AltEats so I contacted Laurie and she worked her magic! My son was able to enjoy an amazingly delicious birthday cake for the first time! She also created the most delicious cannoli filled cake for my guests! I can’t say enough about how easy Laurie was to work with and how lucky I feel blessed I feel to have found this establishment!“

“Everything in Rispoli is delicious! Can't beat their lobster tails! We drive 90min each way every time we have a Rispoli craving and bring their cookies and pastries to our friends in central jersey. Next week we're shipping cookies to Oregon! I have a feeling it will become a regular occurrence. Thanks for never disappointing us!“

“Petal Dust Cakery is first rate from making my vision come to life through cake design to the easy ordering process and friendly assistance. Look at all these cakes below!! Each one was SPECTACULAR! All within the past month too. Amazing work and sooo delicious💖💖💖“

“Every thing I’ve ever tasted from this bakery elicits a reflexive “mmmmm!”. Can’t wait to go back!!!“

“I come here atleast once a week and my boyfriend comes here 2-3 times a week. All of their croissants are amazing. I love the apple and the almonds croissant. My boyfriend is obsessed with the chocolate croissants. I believe all of them are under $4 which is pretty good considering how large they are. They also have coffee, juice, cake, cookies, arepas and breakfast platers. Great for a quick bite before work. Been coming here for a little over a year.“

“The best homemade pasta, mozzarella and ricotta in town. I even worked there, when I was a teenager. Steven continues to run the family business with such dedication to his customers.“

“Excellent service, taste and decorations. LOVE LOVE-LOVE THEM Thank you“

“This bakery is outstanding!! They have phenomenal products that are beyond description!! You will not be disappointed with your purchase here!!“

“Athens Bakery has the BEST spanakopita I've had in the U.S. or Greece!!! Amazing food and very kind staff. You will never be disappointed :)“

“Chip City is a must-visit! The cookies are delicious, they're soft and packed with flavor. The staff here are incredibly friendly and welcoming, making the experience even better. They’re always happy to help and make great recommendations if you’re not sure which flavor to try. Definitely a spot I’ll keep coming back to!“

“The bread is so delicious I get it sliced and their pound cake, the croissants and apple turnovers and big donuts yummy. And you go there early get a hot butter bagel! 😋
I also had them do 4 dozen dinner rolls for my Christmas party, They were so delicious they were hit of the party.“

“Let me start with I am not one to write reviews however this one is worth the occasion. It was an absolute pleasure working with Wildly Cakes to get a cake for my bridal shower. We had a traveling themed bridal shower and Wildly Cakes was able to make this beautiful world map on the side. But it doesn’t just end there the cake itself tasted delicious. We got a vanilla cake with cookie butter filling and all my guests ranted and raved on how good it was. We actually have our wedding cake being made by them too and we cannot wait to see and taste it especially after this great first impression.“

“Tried the USR location this morning as it's located around the corner from my office. Front staff was friendly, attentive, and helpful with assisting me to navigate options as a first time visitor. There was no line and I quickly received my to-go order. The ham, egg, and cheese croissant was delicious- fluffy and flaky, not at all greasy, and the perfect cheese pull. Can't wait to return to try desserts and coffee!“

“I recently visited this charming French bakery, and everything was absolutely delicious! The pastries were fresh, flaky, and full of authentic flavors. You can taste the quality in every bite, from the buttery croissants to the perfectly balanced tarts. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making it a perfect spot to relax and enjoy a treat. Highly recommend this bakery for anyone craving a true taste of France!“

“Everything ive tried has been delicious. The foccacia bread, monkey bread, brownie edges, and oreo truffles are all great. The cakes look amazing too. Despina truly puts out great products and if youre in the area i highly recommend you give this new bakery a chance.“

“Wow this lady can bake! I have know her for a few years now but didn't really know about her baking till recently. I thought I would be nice and supportive and buy a cake. BAM! Best cake I ever eat! Now I am trying to think up excuses to buy another.“

“Amazing omelettes and great service“

“Best baklava we ever had!“

“The owner Erika was a pleasure to work with. Super helpful with choosing the right size cake. Designed the cake better than the picture I sent. The cross and rosary were so realistic it’s hard to believe it’s sugar. Not only was it a gorgeous cake but so fresh and delicious!“

“We miss you at Green Dragon Farmers Market in Ephrata Pa. Your bread, rolls, bagels, raviolis were the best. Wish we could order online. While we understand your reason for leaving, Lancaster County is known for food, the bread and rolls is lacking locally. Sooo sorry you had to go. All the best, your Friday regulars“

“First time trying Joe’s pie and WOW! The pumpkin praline pie was amazingly delicious, the best combo of pumpkin and pecan that we have ever had in a pie! We would love to return and try another flavor in the near future. The shop has really cute bird-themed decorations and display cases selling some interesting costume jewelry too.“