50 Best Sandwich Shops near West Caldwell

“My office has been ordering lunch from here periodically over the past year, and today we placed a larger order for the entire office. Before placing it, I called the store twice to make sure we had enough food and sides for everyone.

Tommy was not only incredibly knowledgeable and helpful, but also one of the friendliest people I've ever dealt with. By the time I arrived to pick up the order, he made me feel like family!

The entire staff was wonderful, the food was delicious, and everything was ready as promised. I can't thank them enough for making our office lunch such a great experience.“

“I've only ever gotten whole bagels here but WOW they're perfect. Slight crunch to the outside, pillowy inside. They're even amazing plain untoasted with butter and obviously great toasted and all the way dressed up as a sandwich.“

“The Great Wazu is the reason small businesses are the HEART of a community. I am a soon-to-be small business owner myself. I walked in this place tonight like I do every 1-2 weeks to get dinner. Sara behind the counter has gotten to know me and ALWAYS remembers my order. Tonight, she asked me what was new, and I told her I had been upset all day worrying about all the stuff I have on my plate right now getting my business ready to open. She was the sweetest. When I reached for my credit card, she told me my order was on her and gave me a hug and said, "You got this." It was one of the most human experiences I've ever had, and I just want everyone to know how special this place is. It's not just the sandwiches. It's the kindness.“

“YES 👍🏼 my favorite local sandwich shop hands down!“

“Everything on the menu is delicious! The service is fast and staff is amazing. My children love their empanadas! It’s cozy, welcoming and relaxing ambiance…“

“OMG! I enjoyed such a fresh sandwich! So excited this sandwich cafe has been created in my area!“

“Holy crap the sandwich was good it was bursting with flavor and everything in between. The guy helping me gave me 70 free bags of chips and free cookies, of course. My life has been changed forever. The sandwich was so good, for a second I thought my dad returned.“

“Ok first off I was born n raised in East Orange so I was familiar with the area and atmosphere. Fast paced..This store is everything. I was greeted and got help ordering by the a very nice female employee. She came from behind the register. Next payment a d waiting for the food... It took a minute but such courtesy 👍🏼. It was a little busy but controlled. Everything looked clean and neat. Now the food was excellent. I ordered a NY chopped cheese with everything and a pastrami and swiss with everything on wheat toast for hubby. Sandwiches were top chef. Very filling. I was so hungry lol forgot to take a pic. Next time and it will definitely be a next time. I suggest pre ordering to save time. But this will be my new sandwich spot 💯💯💯“

“The pastrami is really good“

“Subway, Is truly the best place to come in and gets a snack or sandwich. I love it and the Service is even better I would definitely recommend coming here and get yourself something to eat come stop by and get yourself something yummy to fill your stomach“

“Truly the best Eggplant sandwich I have ever had. SO tasty and SO filling.“

“I’ve been here several times. Each visit did not disappoint. I’ve ordered soup and sandwich each time. Each time I ordered a different sandwich. All of them were quite tasty. It’s always the same nice lady working here by herself. I definitely recommend if you’re out for a quick lunch.“

“Always a great experience at the deli. The owner is very personable and accommodating.“

“Great subs!!! Ribeye was fantastic!!!“

“great food and the people are usually pretty respectful but no matter how many times i tell them im just a man with long hair they still call me a woman
like just give me my sandwich i don’t care that you’ve never seen a man with long hair jesus christ
show me one woman named marshall im actually begging you at this point“

“Great experience! Ordered through grub hub and grub hub kept delaying my order so Jersey Mikes took it upon themselves to deliver my sandwich personally to the hospital that I work! Great customer service! Thanks again!“

“Everything they make is amazing. The sandwiches are bountiful. Fresh ingredients. My fav place“

“I moved into the area recently and have gone to this location multiple times over the last year two years. Honestly, I’m not sure what it is, not sure who is doing what, but everybody who works behind the counter are some of the friendliest people in food service I’ve ever met! They are genuinely sweet people. Seriously, when you go in there, just strike up a little light conversation. They’re so nice! A pleasure! Every single one I’ve ever encountered behind the counter! Good job!! ☺️“

“Tony Boys in Montclair has the best sandwich in all of Jersey. I highly recommend the Goldmill — so delicious, and the portions are huge. The owner Mike is one of the best humans you will ever meet. If you’re anywhere near Bloomfield Ave, it’s worth the stop.“

“First time here and new to the area. I had no wait time. Smoke turkey and provolone sub was perfection. Soft fresh roll and all the veggies and meat was freshly sliced. I asked for specific items and they made it exactly like I asked.

Now the guy working that day can use some people skills (greet people, smile, saying thank you) but he did make an amazing hoagie. Someone just please tell him it’s ok to smile at paying customers 😁

The establishment has street parking, wide sidewalks and easy to see awning. Inside needs some cleaning, paint and new tiles. Nothing much to look more welcoming but the food is amazing, still.

No inside dining or bathroom. Some seats while you wait.

I also love the clear glass to see your sandwich being made. That’s so classic!

Will be back because summer is definitely for nice chilled subs.

They have hot food too!“

“Everything they make is amazing. The sandwiches are bountiful. Fresh ingredients. My fav place“

“BIG SHOUT OUT TO PARSIPPANY JERSEY MIKES!!!! Can’t thank you enough for feeding 100 healthcare workers (at your own expense!) during these uncertain times..... YOU GUYS ARE AMAZING 😊😊♥️👍🏻🙏🏻 #peoplehelpingpeoplehelpingpeople #covid19wontwin“

“Local around the area and will always love this place to my core. I’ve been coming here since I was young and I watched the place change interior looks and saw the upgrade they had; proud of them! My family and I would have this place for Dinner time to time and it would never disappoint. Food is wonderful as always.“

“Not up to Jersey Mike’s standards. Did not have chicken salad, got tuna sub that was poorly made. Over stuffed with tuna, mushy bread. Only ate half.

Update March 2026: Been back 3 times since bad experience. They must have had a bad day then. Each time now food is good, well prepared, and staff is friendly and efficient. Thank you 🙏 for improvements!“

“One of my favorite places to order better than Blimpie sandwiches, Roberto’s, nice and clean. The owner is the worker and the greatest sandwich maker ever I don’t say this about most places but if you’re looking for a great and tasty sandwich, this is the place to go.“

“Tony Boys has amazing sandwiches but also generous and kind owners who give back to the community and schools. Their salads are good too but their hot sandwiches are phenomenal!“

“This was a go to place for me when I worked in the area. The MTB and the Jeter are delicious and the salads are great too. Charles is very organized and makes great food. I would highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a quick bite.“

“5 STARS First time there . Ate half of a half & very large portions Tuna w/Swiss let tom, onions peppers oil & vinegar. Best in a long time. Very friendly staff & place very clean. Would deffinitly recommend.Jersey Mikes. I think they also deliver!“

“This is the best sandwich place in Nutley. I highly recommend the hot italian lover. We order/pick up from here frequently- too frequently-and I love it. It's a small shop, the kids there are hardworking and kind. Endless support for this business.“

“By FAR the best place to get a sub. Freshly sliced cold cuts, awesome service, and one of the friendliest places around !!“

“I’ve been coming to Troops since I was a teenager, and no matter how much time passes even after moving to Florida this spot NEVER misses. I still make it a priority every time I’m back. The #7? Still flawless. Same flavor, same quality, straight nostalgia in every bite.
This time I brought my wife and daughter with me, and they get it now. This place is part of my story took me right back to my Clifton Speed Center days… #IYKYK.“

“BEST FOOD AROUND! A++++++“

“One of my favorite places!! The chicken cheesesteak and fries are delicious“

“Let’s start by saying hands down the best coffee in town ! The staff are very efficient in what they do there’s nothing to not love about this place they have amazing sandwiches hot/cold dinner/ breakfast they have it all ! There’s a huge selection of different drinks, snacks, house hold items, ect if you need it in your home there’s a very good chance you can find it here they have great hours to accommodate all and the owner and staff are super friendly ! If I can give this place a 100 star ⭐️ rating I would ! I hope you all find the time in your schedules to swing by here a nice lunch or even a cup of hot coffee.“

“First time here. Great experience. We got there right at 5 pm when they opened on a Saturday. Got table right away. 20 mins later place was packed with long wait. Wait staff was awesome. Annette stopped by our table numerous times and was fun to talk too and welcoming. Shrimp beeps were our favorite. Eggplant was awesome. Garlic pasta and savoy chicken were so tasty. Could not have been more pleased. Great prices too. Old school atmosphere that is fun to experience. But it’s not a place you can linger, you eat and go. Highly recommend for good simple Italian food.“

“Nice place to get u coffee Sandwich and u gas 😍“

“it's a great thing that people could rent from newark legends6“

“This is the BEST place ever! The sandwiches are super meaty and toasty! I LOVE the meat! When they warm up the meat, it makes the sandwich perfect! A certain hunk, Bob or Rob, helped me out today... and speaking of meat... WOW! 😉“

“I come here almost everyday and truly enjoy it. The food and smoothies I buy I adore since I have many options. As a person who enjoys food I would encourage others to try the food. The employees brighten the atmosphere and bring more value to the establishment. Every employee who works here is nice, kind and considerate. They all have a wonderful work ethic and try their best to get you food that you can enjoy.“

“This sandwich shop takes you back to a time when a real Italian Deli could make a hero. For me it's not just the cold cuts, but the bread that make these heros special. Starting with the mild Italian hero with the works. You won't be disappointed.“

“This was such a nostalgic trip. I was so happy they were open and available. If you are looking for a good sandwich, head over to this Blimpie. The team that was working on Sunday November 3, 2024 mid day was excellent. There was so much love in my sandwich. It smiled at me when I opened it. That is what food is supposed to do when made appropriately. Will definitely be back sooner rather than later. I recommend the Blimp sandwich.“

“Outstanding group of workers there! Greeted as soon as we walked into the door, and even though there was a long line - the crew were quick, accurate and did a fantastic job making sure our wait wasn’t too long. Even went as far to ask each customer their name, introducing themselves and asking how their day was going! Stellar crew and are happy to have them in the community! And did I mention the sandwiches are delicious and prepared perfectly?!! Five stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Just want to thank Angel for being so helpful. Ordered from doordash and the store unfortunately put wrong ingredients on bowls. Angel was very helpful with fixing the issue even tho doordash was taking for ever. Everyone loved there bowls. Thank you !!! Will continue ordering from this location with service like this“

“Their subs are sooo good. The bread is always fresh and soft and so are the meats and other ingredients. You may not always find parking, but if you're getting your sandwich to go, this shouldn't be an issue.

Parking: You may not always find parking, but if you're getting your sandwich to go, this shouldn't be an issue.“

“If you are going to shop at Whole Foods, an Amazon Prime card is very useful. The card and Amazon app. while allow you to receive discounts and keep you informed of sales items. I shop at Whole Foodsfor specialty items and some fruits and vegetable. Mainly organic fruits that you do not peel like apples, strawberries, blueberries and pears to name a few. My other main reason for shopping here are the specialty especially in the cheese and bakery departments. They carry a lot of Keto/Paleo items which I am not interested in, as well as, an oat-milk/almond milk machine that makes them fresh. Next to the bakery they have a Naan bread display. The naan bread is made their on premise Tandoori oven. The store and parking area is never crowded when I shop. They usually have only one or two cashiers working during slow periods and a self check-out area. I never tried their deli, pizza station or acai bowel so I have no comment. If you do not have your own shoppin bags which I do, It will cost you 10 cents per bag.“

“I’m so excited to finally have a Jimmy John’s close to me! I’ve been so homesick for Illinois and my favorite sandwich shop. If you haven’t tried a Jimmy John’s sandwich yet, then you must! You won’t be disappointed! The bread is *chef’s kiss* one-of-a-kind. It’s also a great choice for catering a party. You can also order ahead of time for pickup via the app. The staff were friendly and made a great sandwich 10/10“

“If you are going to shop at Whole Foods, an Amazon Prime card is very useful. The card and Amazon app. while allow you to receive discounts and keep you informed of sales items. I shop at Whole Foodsfor specialty items and some fruits and vegetable. Mainly organic fruits that you do not peel like apples, strawberries, blueberries and pears to name a few. My other main reason for shopping here are the specialty especially in the cheese and bakery departments. They carry a lot of Keto/Paleo items which I am not interested in, as well as, an oat-milk/almond milk machine that makes them fresh. Next to the bakery they have a Naan bread display. The naan bread is made their on premise Tandoori oven. The store and parking area is never crowded when I shop. They usually have only one or two cashiers working during slow periods and a self check-out area. I never tried their deli, pizza station or acai bowel so I have no comment. If you do not have your own shoppin bags which I do, It will cost you 10 cents per bag.“

“I came here with my best friend and we enjoyed their submarine sandwiches. The food is fresh and very very good. I bought my kids submarine sandwiches here and they are the bomb, baby. My kids loves this place. I will continue get my sandwiches here for life! Thank you Sandwiches Unlimited! ❤️💋“

“Great sandwiches! Always fresh. Management and staff always friendly. The store is always clean when I go there. They really got it together there. I highly recommend!“