17 Best Pizza Restaurants in Bay Shore

“I went to dinner with my son last and there was a bit of misunderstanding staff fixed the problem Food is great the atmosphere is great I’d like to think the management to straighten out the problem I’ve been eating there in Islip that pizza place for a while great food“

“TLDR; Incredible store, one terrible employee

Amazing blaze pizza! Lovely staff and great quality pizza, I enjoyed every part of my experience with blaze. Except Irfan, he was unprofessional, unhelpful and rude. I honestly turn around and go to Panera bread if I see he is on the line. He constantly messes up my pizzas, gives too little sauce and must be held accountable for the way he treats customers (especially women) but otherwise, lovely establishment.“

“I just had another amazing lunch at Zest. The portions are VERY generous and the food is always amazing. The chef is a culinary artist.“

“The pizza lunch special is $5.99 until 3pm for two plain slices and a fountain soda. I grabbed two specials for myself and a friend. We definitely enjoyed the slices which reminded us of old school pizzerias. Please do not try to improve, just keep the same recipe. Keep up the good job guys!“

“AMAZING thin crust pizza! it's time here. git the Supreme 🔥🔥🔥🔥🍕🍕🤤🤤“

“I grew up in a 100 percent Italian family and I have to say Nona’s lasagna was the best I’ve ever had in my life. At 58 years old I have had plenty of lasagna. This is my new go to spot for Italian fare.“

“The best food and most wonderful family!“

“the worker/owner was very chill made my day with a conversation 🤩🤩🤩🤩“

“2 👍🏼 👍🏼!s up. I saw a puppy in there while it’s owner was eating and nobody said anything 🐾🐾❤️.“

“This food was absolutely delectable. As the kids say, it was “busting!” On the brethren! My soul was lifted and my day was brightened from the exquisite cuisine I had the pleasure of tasting. I will be sure to tell the pastor about this wonderful place.“

“Okay, 25+ years eating pizza at Victorio's! Yes that's right... Victorio's has some of the best Pizza around!
Yes their pizza is awesome; perfect balance of cheese and sauce, the crust is browned nicely and just the right thickness, and spiced perfectly too.
You'll be pleasantly pleased when you take your first bite!
Enjoy their pizza and so much more, and some really good special's too.“

“Been eating here for years! Live in NH now, grab Bruno’s when I’m home in Brentwood!!“

“This pizzeria restaurant has delicious pies. Marconys has a nice restaurant side. The food is delicious. The owner is from Italy. We’ve been getting our pizza here and decided to cater a few dishes. Let me say , I am extremely picky with eggplant parmigiana. I usually make time consuming dish but I did not have the time. Marcony’s eggplant parm was the best ever. My kids keep raving about it. We also had the chicken franchise that was tender and delicious! We will be ordering here again very soon.“

“I personally have only been inside a handful of times, so I don’t really know how the atmosphere inside the place is nor how the people are. I usually order through the Domino’s app and it always arrives on time and is hot and fresh. They have never gotten my order wrong (it’s usually the same items anyway) and it always taste super good. I’ve been a long time customer and I honestly can’t complain. The service is always on time and the food is always made exactly to my order, never had any mix ups.“

“Great selection and great food“

“Ordered sausage/peppers/
Potatoes with angel hair pasta. It was the best I have had in a long time! Everything was perfect and the sauce was excellent. I live about 15-20 minutes away, but I will travel for food this good. Molto benne! Perfect!!!“

“La pachamama buenaza mmmm🍴😋👍💯🇵🇪“