50 Best Sandwich Shops in Brooklyn

“DeFontes is one of those Brooklyn institutions that instantly reminds you why some places never need a refresh.\n\nI went straight for the Signature Hot Roast Beef and, in a moment of well justified indulgence, added the Steak Pizzaiola. Zero regrets. These sandwiches are unapologetically stuffed. Meat, cheese, sauce, seasoning, all layered with confidence and generosity that feels almost defiant in today’s portion-controlled world.\n\nAnd the bread matters here. It’s fresh, warm, and crisp in all the right places, sturdy enough to carry the weight of the fillings without stealing the spotlight. It’s the perfect vehicle for the kind of sandwich that requires both hands and lots of napkins.\n\nOrdering at the counter may look intimidating at first, like there’s a secret rhythm you’re supposed to know and have rehearsed. Don’t stress it. The service is quick, efficient, and genuinely friendly. The staff are happy to guide you through it, even if it’s your first time staring at the menu trying to decide how hungry you actually are.\n\nJust keep in mind that there’s no seating beyond a stand-up counter along the wall, so plan accordingly. This is very much a grab-and-go or eat-it-immediately experience.\n\nDeFontes isn’t chasing trends. It doesn’t have to. This is classic, expertly executed deli cooking that delivers exactly what you want and then some.“

“I went here today and had the most delightful lunch with my boyfriend. The co-owner was very welcoming and gave us many suggestions. We split a French onion soup and the duck panini. The co-owner gave us a delicious roasted pepper dip and a mustard sauce that went great with the sandwich. He also ended up giving us a Nutella crepe on the house! The food was great and the co-owner was lovely.“

“Ok, maybe I shouldn’t have picked marathon Sunday to finally hit up Frankel’s—it was packed! But what a great spot. I love their creative breakfast sandwich options, and the vibe was pure NYC energy. I got the pastrami, egg, and cheese on a challah bun, and it was exceptional. Perfectly balanced, rich, and just messy enough in the best way. 10 out of 10. I’ll definitely be back.“

“Overall great place. Very simple, no frills, but the food is amazing. The Banh mis are thr best ive had and the pork, rice and salas is great as well.

My only wish is that they had some more vegeterian options since apart from the egg banh mi, there is nothing else. The other thing would be accepting card payments. But overall great food, service and prices.“

“Fantastic gluten-free bagels! Literally the best I've had. Great spreads: horseradish cream cheese and scallion cream cheese also the best I've even had. Ordered delivery and bagels arrived nice & hot & toasty.
Now I'm back home in Los Angeles after this work trip with my boss, and both of us crave these fine GF bagels.“

“This place is small with a big taste,no lie one of the best sandwich spots I've eaten at and the prices are very reasonable.Good thing I don't live in the area I'd be tired of eating here so it's always a treat when I'm near.“

“Their sandwiches are absolutely delicious. The sauce is literally magical but the flavor of the pork is also so, so tasty. My husband and I went a few days ago with our 10 month old daughter, she slept in the stroller the whole time so there is great atmosphere as well. I already can't wait to go back. Highly recommend!“

“Steep prices but the sandwiches are extraordinary and the owner is a kind soul. The turkey is roasted in house and the softest juiciest I've ever had in a sandwich. By far the best gluten free roll I've had a sandwich on and no reaction to any cross contamination. We came here from across the country on our honeymoon and have found a place we'll be sure to come back to.“

“the roast beef sandwiches are out of this world yummy“

“Great roast beef sandwich served on a bun soaked with the beef juices. You eat with a knife and fork. Not fancy. Paper cups for soft drinks. Great fries and onion rings. The place has been around since 1938. All cash. No credit cards.
We make the pilgrimage whenever we find ourselves in Brooklyn.“

“A little gem. This small spot with a beautiful back patio squeezed in a group of 10 or so. The mushroom pizza was all we had but was 5/5 and worth a trip. Their dough is so light and pillowy but with crisp edges and a fantastic bite. The toppings on the mushroom pizza were perfectly seasoned and a very nice ratio (not overpowering the cheese or dough). Honestly though, the dough was special and is worth the trip to explore their other pizzas. Next time we come we will absolutely get a few pies and take home whatever is left. But if everything is as good as that mushroom pizza, there's small chance of leftovers.“

“Classic Brooklyn joint serving one of the best roast beef sandwiches in town! But I would have to say the western burger also packs a solid punch. You can’t go wrong with any of the items here honestly. But our go to’s are always the roast beef sandwich, western beef burger, crown fritters, chicken wings, and orangeade drink! You also have the option to put cheese on anything! If you have a young one, ask one of the cashiers for a free ballon. If happens to be your birthday, you get to spin the giant wheel for a chance to win $5-$20 prize for next time use. Also, if you spend more than $45 per order, you can get a free pizza. The inside dining area seems like it’s still stuck in the 1990s, but I’m fine with that!“

“Excellent Sandwich!! Def check it out Over 100 to choose from“

“I have not had the chance to try the food yet but I just wanted to say R.I.P Lady Octopus they used to be located their their food is missed very much . But I'm glad Edith's took over the spot the food looks delicious looking forward to try the pastrami chopped cheese ☺️“

“Ive been coming to Jimmy's for as long as I can remember. I wish I went more often, but life gets in the way. The service is impeccable; everyone is friendly, and professional. The prices are fair and the food (all of the food) is phenomenal.“

“Great food! Had lunch catered to my business and everything was superb!! Thanks Guys!“

“This is an incredibly special place. The sandwiches are absolutely delicious, with good portions, very high quality ingredients and great execution.

Vibes are excellent and welcoming.

The food, for as incredible as it is, is so approachable. It was the type of meal I was inspired to wanna cook for myself. This is a must stop place if you’re around.

Sandwich pictured is La Bombolona.“

“I've been wanting to try this place for awhile since seeing IG posts showing the yummy food. I was in the area and stopped by around noon, after it just opened, so the line was short. I wanted to order everything, but was by myself, so i only got the chicken katsu sando and it was so good! The fried chicken was crispy and the milk bread was so soft and fresh. It was a very large portion, for me anyways, and I was full after just eating half. I also wanted to try the tamago egg salad sandwich too, but will save that for next time when my gf is here. They have a nice outdoor patio to sit and eat, but i took it to go.“

“Delicious fresh breakfast sandwich to order. Got eggs, spicy mayo, turkey bacon, cheddar, on ciabatta. Comes with sliced tomato and arugula, which is a perfect touch. Order include a hash brown fried to perfection and ketchup (thoughtful because I used it for my sandwich as well).“

“Vegan food that makes love to your mouth! My first time having Jerked Seitan. OMG! Definitely worth getting with the avocado.“

“sandwiches were delicious and so was the macaroni salad and the workers could not be nicer“

“Great food! Had lunch catered to my business and everything was superb!! Thanks Guys!“

“Omg the sandwiches are great and big 20$ it’s worth every penny!!!!“

“This place is incredible. It's peak Chicago in all the best ways. An absolutely immaculate vibe with an amazing array of Chicago memorabilia, a very lively and friendly staff, and delicious food. I would live here if not for the legality of it all.“

“Oh my Lordy it’s perfect! I got the Philly cheesesteak melt but on sourdough and it was soooooo fire.

Their house salad is dope, it has mandarins, red onion, carrot, and a light vinaigrette. Perfect.

You can tell it’s family owned and family vibes.

We had nice beer and played dominos while we waited for our food. Would definitely come back.“

“Tasty Burgers - Great host! Thanks for the nice evenings 😊“

“Food is always consistently good. Delivery is on time. Also, I called to try to get an extra added to my GrubHub order and the guy on the line figured it out for me even though grub hub wouldn’t let him add the order. Really cool staff 👍“

“The #7 CHE Si DICE is off Da Hook!! Now THIS SANDWICH is the real “HAYA DO’N”“

“Visiting my kid who is a member and stopped in. He goes every morning for his coffee to-go on the way to work. Great business model…love the membership. Coffee was yum, pastries are good too! Barista was friendly but seemed a tad overwhelmed and maybe could use a little help. The only other comment I would have is get to know the first names of your members and regulars. That’s what separates a Community focused restaurant from a Starbucks.“

“Great Jersey Mike's location. Staff was nice, sandwiches had perfect amount of toppings and spread. Not every location makes the sandwich the same and this location definitely was a top sandwich. Definitely will be returning to this location to get my JM fix“

“I’m salivating just thinking about their 🥪!!! They offer huge portions, fresh and high quality ingredients and now I’m hungry. 😋“

“The thoughtful decor makes dining here a feast for all senses. Every worker adds to the welcoming atmosphere. We chose multiple dishes for communal enjoyment. The service staff is friendly, food is satisfying, and amounts are generous. I'm already missing their food.“

“The food speaks for itself: stellar! This is the kind of spot that will soon have folks queuing up, I have no doubt. We got the Ashley’s 1 of 1 and the No Sleep Til Gravesend. The bread is super fresh and for me that’s a great start, you’d be surprised how places punk out on the bread. Next the flavors, for me the Gravesend tastes like a French dip with the au jus already in the sandwich- the roast beef is so flavorful! The Ashley is the perfect Italian sandwich if you love chicken but don’t really love cold cuts, and the dressing they use is the cherry on top! Try it before they get super famous and you have to stand on line to get one!!!“

“Delicious sandwiches and cute outside patio in the back for good weather days! Plus the owner is awesome and I love supporting good people launching great neighborhood/local businesses!“

“I’m salivating just thinking about their 🥪!!! They offer huge portions, fresh and high quality ingredients and now I’m hungry. 😋“

“food is delicious. chopped chicken grinder. sooooo good.“

“Best tuna in Williamsburg, with lot of mayonnaise!! (not like others that are putting little mayonnaise cuz it's expensive).And sandwiches are low priced (tuna sandwich is 6.50!), not like others that are charging for a tuna sandwich 9 or even 10 dollars..“

“There was a misunderstanding but it was dealt with in a cordial manner. I appreciate it ??

Vegetarian options: Veggie delight without cheese toasted and avocado ?

Dietary restrictions: I chose not to have cheese or any animal by product on my sandwich ? and was accommodated.“

“I come here often whenever I have a client in Clinton hill and this crew never misses, specifically one. I sit in here and always love the company of the same woman who always calls me ‘baby’. She truly makes my day every time I come in and see her! I just know she’ll let me enjoy my meal in silence but never failing to greet me and say thank you whenever I leave.“

“I’m leaving this review for my free cookie.
It’s an honest review though.
Buffalo chicken sub was delicious.
Customer service was top notch, bubbly bright personalities. I loved that.

Vegetarian options: I’m not sure“

“Fabulous shop and catering group! We have enjoyed several events catered by Campbell & Co. since their start up and they have always exceeded our expectations. It’s hard to say which we appreciate more, the fantastic food and cheese selection or their creative event displays. It is a pleasure to know that every detail will be attended to.“

“Mandy helped us host a virtual event with our clients. Absolutely incredible cheeses and she was perfect at hosting everyone on zoom. We’ve done a lot of virtual sessions and this was by far the best. Mandy is beyond knowledgeable without being pretentious, and strikes the right balance of leading the event while allowing everyone else to connect and ask questions. Thank you Mandy!!!“

“First time getting coffee here and it was great. So nice to have a new shop in Dyker where the coffee isn't burnt!! Inviting atmosphere, clean, bright, and beautiful friendly people. Welcome to the neighborhood!!!“

“I loved the breakfast sandwich that I got here! My go-to at any deli is a BEC with avocado and this is definitely one of the better ones I’ve had. Bacon was crisp, avocado was perfectly ripe and I got half of a large avocado, roll was chewy, and I added chipotle mayo for a little kick. It’s a good size BEC and this came out to $5. Can’t complain at all! And everyone who worked there was very kind. Will be back soon.“

“Great food. Fast service.“

“Great Jewish gut-filling, soul-warming, belly-filling healthy food. Very reasonably priced, and before you leave pick up a dozen extra-fresh Bagels from across the street, just tip the boy outside and he delivers to your car window, great food, great area, great neighborhood !“

“Attached to the Q Station, separate entrance. I love this place: Sign on door reades "No pets inside of store" AMAZING DELI Alot of fun to go in. Cute, funny young guys inside. Great coffee. Milk. Eggs. Mexican pastries. Stamps. Rolling papers. Hot & cold breakfast & lunch. Chips. Lucky Charms. Orange juice. Sanka ... Mind boggling assortment of items! NOT open late.“

“Came back to my husbands hometown to watch the NY GIANTS GAME, stopped here for lunch to visit with the owner ( friend we grew up with) to have a REAL HERO ON A SEEDED ITALIAN BREAD FROM BROOKLYN! MY HUSBAND WAS IN HEAVEN & SO WAS I LOL Definitely coming back when I revisit!!!!“

“The food and portions are fantastic also great daily specials. I always have a fun time at Pier 53!!!“

“Soon as I walked in I can tell that it would be a good place to get a sandwich because it smelled really good.I got the turkey cheddar onion lettuce tomato mayo salt and pepper on a roll and two Gingerales for $10 cashSandwich was bomb!! And it was huge. He sliced it all fresh when I requested the sandwich. ?“