39 Best Pizza Restaurants near Castleton

“This is great New York pizza! One of the best in Albany. And we are pizza obsessed. For a classic New York style pizza, the crust was crunchy and well done, sauce has a good balance of acidity and the right amount of cheese to sauce ratio.We did pickup for a large pie. 20 mins later from pick-up, crust is still crunchy without having to reheat the pizza“

“I don't know where to begin. I've wanted to try it and now I've been twice in one week. So far I've had the BBQ Chicken pizza which was amazing. Saucy and delicious. Today I had the veggie lovers.....it is absolutely perfect. Go, order, eat there in the cutest dining room or take “

“5 star pizza. Place is no frills, but clean and welcoming. Everybody was pleasant to deal with. And when I tell you the pizza is great…..THE PIZZA IS GREAT. It stands out in all categories, texture, taste, quality just fantastic. We had a margherita with prosciutto. Can’t say it enough times, it’s a spectacular pizza. Give them a shot!“

“I recently hosted an event at Villa di Como Ristorante through my job, and everything was absolute perfection -- the food, the drinks, their team, the atmosphere. Our guests complimented it all throughout the night. The staff was warm, welcoming, flexible, and collaborative. It was a memorable and enjoyable evening. Highly recommended!“

“Food and service were good. Only side comment is that were at a high top which we requested which allowed for little room when packaging up food. We had appetizer, entrees and desert. With a carafe of water and a bottle of wine on the table it would have been nice if our leftovers were packaged by the waitress away from the table. Other then that we had a pleasurable experience.“

“Love this little hidden gem! Stopped by for the first time yesterday and it definitely won’t be the last. Nonnas kitchen family vibes, absolutely delicious pizza, salads and subs, incredibly fair prices, you can’t go wrong! Can’t wait to go “

“As a first-time pizza customer, I found the thin crust pizza to be delicious, with a perfect balance of toppings and a crispy texture. The delivery was reasonably fast, and the driver was competent and courteous. However, the store-bought mass-produced cake slices offered as dessert were a bit underwhelming compared to the quality of the pizza.“

“First time for me and I loved it. I try and eat gluten free so Italian can be a bit boring. But La Bella did a great job. The space looks small from the outside but it is not cramped. I can't wait to go back. My spouse recommended it and I see why now.“

“This place is a gem. I know it’s not in the best part of downtown Albany. But the staff are amazing. Three waitresses are all great. The have ZERO attitude and just want to make sure you enjoy your drink and or food. There is no better place in the heart of downtown Albany serving drinks, food and smiles . This is a great atmosphere with even better people .“

“Alibaba is a gem hidden in the rocks. I can't express in words how delectable the butter chicken pizza is! The taste and texture just explode in your mouth leaving you both satisfied and yearning for more. I highly recommend their pizza!“

“Live in the neighborhood, wanted a cheese pizza for me and the kiddos. Called Zoya’s up and they had me a small order of garlic knots with marinara and an 8 cut cheese 40 minutes later. Great pizza, wonderful service!Vegetarian options: It’s pizza!“

“Easily the best $5 I’ve ever spent!! I moved to the area recently and am beyond thrilled June’s Farm is only 10 minutes away. I will be visiting often. It was a 50° February day the so I decided to finally visit and walk the trail. They have all these wonderful seating areas so I look forward to bringing a book when it gets warmer and reading next time these extremely happy and relaxed animals. The grounds are beautifully maintained and I can only imagine how pretty it must look in spring/summer. I look forward to doing the animal feedings too. The animals are so sweet and gentle. It was therapeutic just watching them rest in the fields without a worry in the world. They have wonderful homes, stables, coops, etc. Junes Farms is a must visit!“

“I was searching for places to eat in the local area and this place popped up. I don’t normally leave reviews but I feel compelled as the food was great, in large portions, and the pizza is something that I have not stopped thinking about. The waitress was incredibly friendly too and it added to the loving ambiance that comes the feeling of a family owned restaurant. It’s nice to see that a family business has been open for as long as it has! The salad’s were fresh, and thankfully they sell the dressing by the bottle because I kept wanting more. The decor could use some updating. The Grecian painting on the walls looks like it’s been there since the 80’s.“

“My dad used to work in downtown Albany and would bring home the most amazing rolls from Nino's Bakery when I was young. My husband and I recently went to find those same rolls that would stand up to meatball subs, Philly cheesesteaks, and such.. Found them and I will be going back every time I need a sturdy, chewy, soft, delicious roll! Oh and I have to go back because she mentioned they fill their cannolis fresh when you order!“

“Best pizza in Columbia county. Crust is amazing, ingredients are great, staff is excellent. The Bahama mama sounds weird buts it's delicious, rest of house pizzas are great. Try the Canadian bacon, pineapple, and banana peppers.Vegetarian options: They have a bunch. I like getting a pizza with olives, red onion, broccoli, artichokes and banana peppers“

“I ordered a gluten free dairy free vegetable pizza . It was a personnel size 12 inch pizza. It was very good I ate 1/2 of it. It’s so hard to find a really good pizza when you’re Gf & DF but this place Pizza My Love was fantastic. Also had the chicken wings. They were so very nice and crispy they way I like them. Thank you Pizza My Love. Love the name?❤️??“

“Had the double pepperoni Sicilian. It was so delicious!!! Best pizza I've had since I moved to NY 8 years ago. Can't wait till they open up the Voorheesville location. Then I'll only be 2 minutes away instead of 20.Parking: If you get there before the rush there's plenty of parking, otherwise you would have to park in the shopping center across the street.“

“Good pizza for a good price. I got 4 slices and 2 drinks for $16 (including tax). The pizza crust was really good (thin crust). The staff were very friendly. The restaurant itself is small but nice, it was clean and had some fun arcade games and a TV. Overall I would recommend it, I stopped here for lunch while I was in the area and I wasn't disappointed.“

“Won't go anywhere else for pizza on this side of the river, and I've tried them all. Best price and quality for pizza/wings, and their pasta dishes are excellent as well. Only complaint is the limited hours, I wish I could eat here everyday.Parking: 15 minute parking for about 5 cars in front of store if empty“

“This place almost has a neighborhood bar feel to it. Simple and classic bar food. The biggest positive is the prices for the food and drink. We had a burger, sandwich and a small pizza which were all fine plus a few drinks and the bill was $20 less than expected. Add in great golf cart views and we will be back.“

“I'll always have a soft spot for Navona. My dining experience is always great - food is spot on every time even when they're totally slammed. They stay busy but the service is timely and the servers check up frequently to ensure I have all I need. Regularly I dine alone but all friends I've brought with me have enjoyed it - especially the pizza. The inside is cute and the decorations are interesting. I enjoy the lighting as it's not too overpowering which I am sensitive to. The owner is friendly and can be seen chatting with people who are regulars which just goes to show it has the homey, family feel, very personalized. The servers know my order because I consistently get the same thing and dine there so often which is not necessary but sweet. You won't be disappointed - try the pizza and if that's not for you then the bruschetta or focaccia with ricotta, they're all delicious. For dessert I recommend the chocolate mousse - very sweet and rich but totally worth it!“

“Used to work in the area and got spoiled with having Route Four pizza close by. Would enjoy at least twice a week. Now work is farther away AND when I do get Route Four Pizza its only once in a great while. Consistent, super flavorful, always cooked/baked fresh, friendly, kind, courteous, and absolutely love the crust on the pizza! So over all from the first time I've eaten there up until recently ordering there again. The food is ALWAYS top notch! Thank you thank you thank you!!“

“Glad to have had the opportunity to visit this well known local spot while visiting the area. Unlike any pizza joint experience i’ve ever had. First we ordered at a counter before being escorted through the back of a narrow alley into a small garden seating area. nothing formal, all low key.The food came out quick and the service was friendly.the pizza itself was some of the best i’ve ever had. very doughy with unique flavor that almost melts in your mouth. there was a perfect amount of seasoning over fresh mozzarella cheese. I like the options of various doughs to try as well. We went with the standard dough to get the original flavor. Also tried the garlic bread and house made meatballs. The sauce for both was equally delicious. I hope to have the opportunity to re-visit this location to try some of the speciality pizza and pasta options. Very highly recommended ? ? ?“

“Another reviewer seems to have a personal crisis about Brooklyn and city people, so maybe she had it out for this place because of the "B" word in the name. And it's hard to say what "Brooklyn Style" is...that's a pretty big tent, and even if the people are from Brooklyn, it takes some cajones to name your joint "Brooklyn Style Pizza."Anyway, we were driving through the area and tried this joint. Thankfully, this place was quite good. Initially I thought the pizza was a little boring (very "friendly" sauce, bright, but not too herby, acidic, or sweet). The cheese was very mild in flavor, lacking the nutty bite you get in a typical good slice joint...I'm not sure what it was.But stay with me. Their pizza grew on me. Pizza is personal and I respect their take. Most importantly, points on their dough, which is the hardest part of a pizza to get right. It's hard to get dough airy, thin and toothsome. This one kept a foot in New York but was looking towards Naples with the lightness. Really good on reheat.Garlic knots were straight-up excellent the day we had them. They would be excellent in Brooklyn, too.One request: put your prices on your website, please.“

“Excellent calzone and Greek salad to go for dinner last night. My husband and I went to college in Brooklyn and used to eat calzone all the time. We finally found one that measures up!!! Got it with sausage and olives and it was sooooo good. Got two but we couldn't finish one. Salad was huge too, and just perfect. Lots of feta and olives and good dressing. Man at the counter could not be nicer. Even held the door for me.“

“We ordered XL Pizza and 20 Wings online. Our order was ready right on time. Pizza was great. It was thin and just cooked perfect. We requested our wings be extra crispy, and it was very crispy to perfection. I would recommend this place.“

“This place has all sorts of delicious food options. We generally get takeout pizza but the salads and sandwiches are also delicious. The place has a local and friendly vibe and is always full of happy people. Highly recommended!Parking: On busy nights, it's hard to find a spot.“

“As an Albany resident, I take no pleasure in giving such a good review to a restaurant outside of Albany. But good pizza is good pizza. It is what it is.This establishment understands the art of the sauce ratio. So many times you have a pizza and they barely put any sauce. It is the blend of the sweetness of sauce and sharpness of the cheese that makes the pizza.I will have to give up another one of my subscriptions, because I have to work Cugino’s into my budget.I was told the owner also ran PJs pizza, which was in Albany. it is a very short drive over the bridge from where we live so this is my spot moving forward.“

“Been going here for years and hope to make it decades! Great is an understatement! All I saw was smiling faces and great looking pizza pies! I ended up with two gigantic pepperoni slices— but my family ordered two other pizzas later for dinner, both of which were highly enjoyed during our movie night!Thank you for all the great food!“

“BEST STEAK AND CHEESE SUBS IN THE CAPITAL DISTRICT!!! They bake their own perfectly crisp yet soft sub rolls and the perfect seasoning on it!! I’ve tried steak n cheese subs in every popular sub restaurant around and I promise you , the best is made here!!!“

“Honestly, probably one of the best places I’ve eaten at, ever. The owner is super nice, and the food was even nicer. I watched the Mario movie while I ate the Stromboli, and for real, I’ve never felt more like a Pisano in my whole life.“

“It's a Friday night and yes they're busy. Did they mess up? Nope. Did they exceed my expectations? Yup. Craving a ceasar salad? Expect to get just that.. except 2x the quality of lightly crisped grilled chicken.. 3x the fresh greens.. and an amazing fluff and crunch to the croutons. 10/10 will order againAlso ordered my classic cheese pizza; it was fresh, warm and cheesy just the way you want it to be“

“Great location! Courteous and professional service! Pepperoni is beef! Great walk in deals! Budget friendly. Affordable for great food. Cook to order so always fresh! Dessert heaven for a great heartily slice of cake, baked cookies! Great drink selection. You can stay and eat or take out!! We did both!! FYI if you Google review the pizzeria you get a feee slice of pizza! Come on the journey and tell me what you like about Pizza ExpressParking: Limited spots to park! On bus line!“

“The pizza was excellent. I traveled from NC to NY with my boyfriend to see his family. He grew up eating pizza from this place and bragged about it endlessly. Well it didn't disappoint, the pizza is delicious and so is the pretzel bites. I was not a fan of the hot garlic parmesan wings. I thought they would be wet, but it was more of a dry rub. Overall, this is a great place to eat. Had a strawberry margarita and the bartender made a tasty drink“

“Recently had them provide food for a surprise party at a local bar. They were nice and went over how much food would be good for the party size which was perfect! I also expressed that delivery time was super important in order to not ruin the surprise and they made sure it was right on time!“

“No i don't have a favorite because everything I purchased has tasted good. I'm originally from Bronx NY and i moved up here 9 years ago and your pizza takes me back to the city pizza. This is why I always order from you guys and fast service never get my order wrong either friendly people. Ive tried the other local pizzerias but nope steak out is a perfect match to NYC pizza. Thank you guys keep up the great work.“

“I love this place. As a student many years ago, I had used D’Carlitos for my senior recital at Saint Rose. The food is excellent overall. Great owners!I went back to try the penne vodka chicken pizza, it is still delicious as always!One point off for the slices of pizza I had ordered. The pizza had been clearly sitting out in the restaurant. I noticed that they had pizza that had been sitting out when I came to pick up the order. Their pizza is usually very good, I was just disappointed in receiving cold pizza. I hope the next time I come back to Albany that the pizza will be fresh and hot.Parking: Parking is not the greatest because it is on a busy street however, you can park in the church parking lot or put your hazard lights on.“

“Best pizza in Ravena, hands down. We just had my daughter’s birthday party and fed 50 people with 13 pizzas. The pizzas were ready on time and all piping hot. People actually called me after the party asking where the pizza had come from and one person said the white broccoli pizza was the best she ever had. We love this place!“