50 Best American Restaurants near Elma

“I have come here several times since places reopened after covid. Alton's has always had great food, a clean and friendly restaurant, and great service. I would highly recommend this location for any meal. It is a relaxed atmosphere and even when busy you won't be rushed.Parking: Sometimes parking is a little tricky if the restaurant is full, but there is always a spot to be found. Sometimes there is a bit of a walk through the parking lot.“

“First time at the Elma Towne Grille. Decided to try the Lenten fish fry. Waited not even 5 minutes before 6PM and was sat in the bat area. The atmosphere was great as it was not loud and the conversation was easily heard. Ordered quickly and received the food within 10 minutes! The beer batter was a golden crisp color, the fries were just the perfect amount of crisp, and the cole slaw and mac salads were delicious! The lemon.pepper broiled was ordered as well and was cooked to perfection! So much food and will come.back for sure!“

“Mel was awesome! She went above and beyond to make it a fun date night for my wife and I. We HIGHLY recommend the ahi tuna. The Wasabi sauce is a must try with it! The homemade blue cheese is also incredible!Drinks A++. Nothing bad about this experience at all and we will be back very soon!“

“We waited 2 hours to get a seat for 2, but dang those traditional wings are soooooo fire, like nothing compares. Even the other wings there are not in the same league. If you asked me which I'd rather have, I prefer eating these wings for the rest of my life over my left foot. The wing quality too is just super up there, wew“

“We are so glad we found this place. If you have never had a beer in weck (or like us, hadn't even heard of them) this place is a must for a quintessential Buffalo meal! We felt really lucky that our first was on prime rib day (Thursday). Their fries were delicious. Loved the open kitchen concept. Definitely felt like we found a local gem!“

“We are the self-professed BIGGEST FANS of Smokin' Little Diner in Lancaster NY. But I am sure that we are not alone in our devotion! This place lures us in like a Siren! It's a very unassuming little steel railway diner on Broadway near Transit Road. There's lots of parking in the rear parking lot of this adorable diner, and you smell the meat smoker when you step out of your vehicle. On this day, we stopped in at 11:30 am after a doctor's visit. If it weren't for appointments, we'd never get a meal "out". I try to get something different each time I stop in. Today I selected the Oink Moo Burger with Fire Berry BBQ and a heap of kettle chips. It arrived at our table like Mount Rushmore with a steak knife holding the monumental stack together. Oh boy! It was visually pleasing and I rushed to take my photo before I drooled all over the table. The brioche bun glistened in the sunshine coming in the window, and it barely covered two giant breaded onion rings! Next layer was a pile of pulled pork over a perfectly cooked beef patty and a slice of American cheese! The bbq sauce is one that I've enjoyed before: Fiery Berry Bbq. So delicious. I'm one happy person, but I know that I am consuming my entire day's worth in calories and carbs at this meal. My husband ordered the Meatloaf Stacker. It is a pile of tender, exquisitely seasoned homemade-style meatloaf over a pile of mashed potatoes, all balanced on a slab of sourdough and enrobed in ultra flavorful brown gravy. I had to sneak my fork across the table to sample that alluring plate. As with most dishes here, this menu choice also comes in a pulled pork or pulled chicken as well. Topped off with a cup of coffee, we're two well satisfied diners today! There is a very nice Kids menu for the little guys. The wait staff is ultra friendly and efficient! Don't delay! Come on down!“

“First time I went here I would have ranked this a 5. Unfortunately after a couple more Doordash Orders and some in person visits I have found it can be inconsistent. Don't be dissuaded by the full parking lot. The service is very quick.“

“This place has an amazing veggie wrap. Delish!! My walking mate had the veggie burger, and she said it was outstanding. Very pleased walkers we were that day. The only reason the service is a 4 is because you have to wait. This is a busy place!!!“

“I arrived at duffs and entered through the mall entrance, passed by the trophy case and was told to wait 25 minutes for a table.There was many games for you to play while waiting. After 35 minutes I was seated at a booth. I ordered a Mountain Dew and it arrived pretty quickly, it was a pretty good soda. I then ordered 10 boneless wings with medium sauce on them and a medium hot flavored sauce on the side. After 25 minutes my food arrived, I tried the fries, it was good but crunchy. I then ate my wings, they were good but way too spicy. I then tried the Medium hot on plain wings, not as hot as the last one which made me think they put the wrong sauce on the wings and when I asked they would not swap them. I also tried the barbecue Dr pepper wings, they were the best wing I had, I highly recommend. The atmosphere is like a sports bar. I recommend this place but not at prime dinner time!Parking: Plenty of free parking.Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly, kids menu and plenty of good food for kids“

“Clean, worn but cared for. CASH ONLY, atm on site.Highlight- consistent high quality simple food with a rotating special menu at more than fair pricing, easily have a drink, and meal for $20-25 with a tip.Bar is cozy, restaurant roomy on the simple side.Parking: In front, and to the left of building NOT TO THE RIGHT, that is private parking for the business next door and may be ticketed or towed.“

“This is a great reason to support local businesses. Pizza is very good and priced right, $5-8 less than the other guys. And it's a solid pie. Wings are another strong point: great sauces, cooked perfectly and a good size.Service is as warm and inviting as it gets, one person nicer than the next. Love taking the kids on the weekends because it's not going to cost you an arm and a leg. This is what a neighborhood local should be.“

“Overall, food is pretty good. I always get the chicken pot pie...it could use more gravy and chicken cut into smaller pieces. French onion soup is great! They took off the pork chop which hubby really liked, so now he gets ribs or something else. We usually go a couple times a year.“

“I just read the review about an elderly man that frequents the restaurant and the staff taking advantage of him. That is completely FALSE! That is a terrible way to express your opinion! I am also a longtime customer, I know Jim and he gives money to the staff. I have witnessed the staff refuse this money and he threw an absolute fit! Caused a scene in the restaurant and yelled its HIS money and he will do what he pleases with it. He comes in almost daily AND the girls have called his daughter to make her aware of this.As far as his dementia, why would you all let him drive to the restaurant twice a day? I myself am here almost everyday and sometimes sit with him. He is a funny and wonderful man. He loves the staff and hugs all of them before he leaves. And myself.So your review is distasteful and wrong. Gets your facts straight before you try and ruin a business!“

“It was our monthly gathering of the TreeNuts. I ordered the mild chicken fingers and fries. Whooaaa! It was a lot of food. The food was delivered hot, fresh and it was delicious. I took a to go box and a finger for lunch and dinner and it was just as good as the first bite!So glad we chose this cute little bar and grill.The only down side was parking but there is plenty on street parking.I'll definitely be back. Thanks so much for your prompt, friendly serviceParking: Small on lot parking but there is off street parking.“

“All of our food was delicious. my seafood fra di avlo was super good & I had the eggplant stack appetizer it came on a salad with capers & olives with fresh mozzarella & the dressing was excellent. My Wife's food was also delicious. we can't wait to go back to try the rest of the menu!!“

“Food was absolutely amazing. The mashed potatoes are great. The portion size was impressive. Comfortable setting and nice waiter we had. He was very friendly and professional. We went on 3/16/24. First time there and can't wait to go back. I got the pork chop on the bone. It was amazing.“

“Their service and food continues to be one of the best in WNY! We happily drive about 30 minutes away for their fish fry. Small wait on Fridays of course. Same everywhere for Lent. Cajun fries were a good choice with the fishParking: Very irregular size lot around the outside of the restaurant, tough to park when it's busy“

“New location, different vibe, but still a great atmosphere with delicious food. It's a pig place, but don't be fooled by the name. Vegetarians can eat very happily alongside their meat-loving family and friends. The Masala cauliflower risotto was lovely and satisfying. There is no rush and the staff are wonderful. Highly recommend for upscale dining. Definitely need to go back. Looking forward to getting through their menu.Parking: Crowded, but available.“

“My son and I love 99 Brick Oven. He always gets the margarita pizza and cheesy garlic bread. I try to try some different menu items. Food is always amazing. Staff is always amazing. When they first opened I called to ask about the pizza because my son if very picky. They told me if he didn't like the pizza it would be free. He LOVED the pizza!! We love sitting outside on the patio regardless of weather.“

“Missed out on the kitchen but stayed to enjoy a couple brews. The bartender was attentive and made sure my beer selections were in alignment with my preferences. I like to start with a light blonde, enjoy the taste of a nice red, and end with a thick & sweet stout or lager.“

“Highly recommend Grezi on Main! We came from out of town to visit with family and had the pleasure of dining at this local restaurant. We enjoyed starting out with a cocktail (The Oliver), Autumn Salad, Pan Seared Scallops, Jumbo Chicken Wings and Brussels Sprout Bruschetta. We enjoyed the Grezi Smash Burger as our entree. Then ended the night with 3 different desserts. Food was phenomenal, staff were friendly and decor was elegant!! This Buffalo restaurant is outstanding!“

“Wow. My coworker knew about my love of French onion soup and insisted I make the trek from the north towns to this place. I can say, there wasn’t much reason for our family to travel to East Aurora after one of fav kids museums moved, but now I have a reason to make the haul! We stopped by here after taking our kid’s to a gym in the area and I’m glad we did. I’d say that this might be my favorite French onion soup on the basis of the rich flavors alone. My wife and I went back and forth comparing it to our number one. I felt this is a little less cheesy than my typical favorite (or maybe it was slightly more cooked than I’m used to) but the flavor of the broth and ingredients are the best. We weren’t ready for dinner so we just ordered the soups and got fries for the kids. My daughter was raving about the fries and the service. She kept saying “we have to come back.” I agree!“

“I am from the New England area. And, I am a tough customer in regards to seafood. Hayes is the best! At the restaurant. To pack it up raw. And cook for yourself! Simply put. The freshest and best in the buffalo and surrounding areas!!!!“

“Childhood favorite and always stop when I’m back in town. Can’t decide between the creamy custard and the tart lemon ice? Get the artic swirl - custard and lemon ice mixed together, and of course whipped cream!!!Mom got her favorite hot fudge sundae with lots of whipped cream!“

“There were 10 of us tonight 7 who have never been here and they all loved it and said this should be our new hang out! Our server was absolutely fantastic, and it was very busy and She never had a attitude and had a smile on her face at all times!! I’m sorry I forgot her name! Marybeth will know who I’m talking about!! Thank you for giving us a nice night out!“

“What a great dinner I just shared with a friend! The whole idea of this restaurant is based on Anthony Bourdain's quote about sharing food with friends. And share we did! We split the oysters, parmesan truffle fries, the Tuscan flatbread, and the impossible sliders. We also each got a glass of wine. (No sharing that lol) The food was delicious, and the wine was fantastic, the service was best of all! We got lots of recommendations and suggestions, and we were well taken care of. I was delighted to see that almost everything was able to be gluten free! I had a lot of tasty options to choose from. Overall, we had a great time, and I plan to go back with my fiancé. The experience we shared would have been great for a date.“

“During a very difficult time for our family, Tracy and Jess went above and beyond to provide a beautiful breakfast tray of sandwiches with both regular and gluten free bread, bagels, cream cheese and more. The recipients all commented on how delicious everything was and how much they appreciated breakfast. More than anything, their care and compassion will not be forgotten. Thank you so much!“

“Another stop on our wing trail trip. These were my least favorite. The buffalo wings were a bit on the dry side. The parmesan wings were well coated with cheese but still a bit dry. The size of the wings was good, but they were severely overpriced. The other food on the menu seemed more reasonable and the plates coming out of the kitchen looked and smelled good. The bartenders were extremely nice and helpful. The place in general had a good vibe. If we were local this would be somewhere we would go back to, just not for the wings.“

“This food was incredible!! You get so much food for what you pay for. I got the small Greek salad and that could easily feed two people as a starter salad or one person (plus potentially leftovers) for dinner. All of the ingredients were so fresh and tasty. The gyro I ordered was also amazing and I even ate it a day old (don't tell the owners - I'm sure they would be disappointed ;) ) because I was in a rush and it was still absolutely incredible. I need to find my way back to town to have this again!!“

“Really enjoyed the fried pickles(great batter) and cheese fries. Good American Menu. The band was WAY too loud and the sounds were very unbalanced, couldn't hear or understand anything. We had to wear ear plugs.Vegetarian options: Really good veggie wrap.“

“So — firstly I have to say — this is one of the few cash-only places remaining in the area. If you’re local & use KeyBank, there is an ATM in the Tops Plaza up the street. Make sure you know that going in so you don’t have to pay ATM fees (although they have one in the restaurant!).Honestly, this place has more “diner” vibes that a typical hot dog place in Buffalo — it reminds me of the old Louie’s that used to be on Transit in Depew. Above average but not jaw-dropping good, decent prices, and a wide variety of choices. For what it is, this place is a gem. If you’re going and expecting something high-class, fancy, etc, then don’t go!But in my opinion it’s a great local place & also should be considered somewhat of a diner — good diners are few and far between especially in the suburbs of Buffalo, so give it a try!“

“Was looking for a casual & unique brewery on a road trip. What a winner! Very attentive and friendly staff. Awesome assortment of craft beers. Best of all NO KIDS during this visit. Yes, I’m an adult who goes to breweries for an ADULT experience. Not keen to be surrounded by wee ones when trying to relax and enjoy an adult beverage. Will be back for sureParking: Limited spots near the brewery.“

“Is it strange that my favorite restaurant is in a gas station? Charlie the butchers, located within the Marathon gas station on Main Street in East Aurora is spectacular. Not only do they have what you would expect, delicious roast beef on weck, they have delicious sides and daily specials like baked ham, meatloaf, corned beef, and prime rib. The service is fast and friendly - and the prices are very reasonable for what you get. It's just lovely.“

“My brother and I eat here every Saturday. We just love the French dip sandwich. I get the sweet potato fries with it. I eat half while there, and take the rest home for another meal during the week. I've had a few of their other menu options - which are very good... however, Mike and I are addicted to the French Dip (appropriate... French Road, French Pub, French Dip!) He goes there 2 or 3 times during the week all by himself (he's a widower.) He enjoys an alcoholic beverage with his meal. We discovered this place about a year ago - now it is on our regular rotation. The waitresses are always efficient and friendly, the bus boys are even attentive and on the ball. Atmosphere is casual, but clean and welcoming. I can recommend this place without any reservations... ok, bad pun... Try it! Hope you enjoy it as much as we do!“

“I can't believe what I'm reading on some of these reviews and think it must be a Buffalo problem. Blaine, Joella and all the folks in the Tempe location are first rate. They treat me right every time I come in, and the hot dogs are the best anywhere. Love the rings. My daughter loves the shakes. And even the fountain drinks are spot on with carbonation, which these days is saying something. Big hat tip to Tempe Ted's.“

“I can't believe what I'm reading on some of these reviews and think it must be a Buffalo problem. Blaine, Joella and all the folks in the Tempe location are first rate. They treat me right every time I come in, and the hot dogs are the best anywhere. Love the rings. My daughter loves the shakes. And even the fountain drinks are spot on with carbonation, which these days is saying something. Big hat tip to Tempe Ted's.“

“We had the Derby Day Special - Hot Brown Open Face Sandwich. Didn’t know at the time it had a culinary history. It was delicious with thick tasty slices of turkey, not deli. Fresh sliced tomatoes, and a rich cheddar cheese sauce with crispy bacon on top popped under the broiler for a unifying effect landing onto our placemat for a photo finish - delectable. Inspired cooking!“

“My wife and I go here any chance we get. The atmosphere is comfortable. Either in the warmer months out back or inside when it is snowing looking out. Nicer than home with the ambiance. Food is always great. Drinks are to die for and desserts are sinfully good... A++++“

“An institution and just a wonderful hole in the wall. Great wings and prime rib. Just go. You probably need a reservation as it is a very popular local spot. But such warm people very glad we went. They didn't realize we weren't local.“

“Place was packed but we were seated rite away, few minutes for waiter to come over, super busy so whev, he was super friendly and attentive, food came out in a timely manor and was excellent, was offered coffee refills many times by multiple servers which is almost unheard of any more. Super experience! Will definately be back!!!“

“My new favorite burger spot! Everything about the food is perfect! The burger was super juicy and fresh, the fries and onion rings were fantastic! And best part was it was all very reasonably priced! More people need to know about this great spot! Next time I'm trying the chicken!“

“Our first time. We're "locals". We will DEFINITELY be frequenting! Had the Shep' Pie. Let me just say, mmm mmm MMM! The beef just melted and the sauce was exquisite! The veggies were perfectly cooked and everything was seasoned JUST RIGHT! No extra salt OR pepper needed!!! Other party members ENJOYED the thinger tenders, and thinger sandwich. (* explanation below)Their list of sauces is just WOW! It can be found on the chalkboard on the wall. ;) The fries, fresh cut of course (delightfully, a common theme of the menu!) Soups were PIPING hot! Also very, VERY good! We will definitely return and sample other items. * - Thinger - the are fresh made and not prepackaged. Party members indicated it was dark meat (thighs) or maybe a 50/50? I can not personally attest to that.“

“I was just there yesterday and my experience was like no other. She was very attentive and quick not just with me and my family but other tables as well. I hope i got her name correct, Cindy she is very friendly, small in stature with blonde hair.“

“I used to live near there and ate there regularly. Moved away 10 years ago, but was back in the area and had to stop in. The food is as good as it always was. Hubby had to have the fried chicken, his favorite! The food was good, the service friendly and attentive...we'll have to go back again!“

“Good food see people cook it in front of you tell them how you want it always got footling hot dog from there and fries another places that uses vinegar you choose put on your French friesKid-friendliness: They have kids food hereWheelchair accessibility: There is room wheel chairs“

“Ordered a large pizza from there today. I have previously ordered chicken finger subs (which were delicious) and today brought home a pizza for lunch. The girl taking the order was super helpful with the questions I had and very nice when I came in to pick it up. The sauce isn't overly sweet like other places and you get plenty on the pizza. It's dough-y enough for my liking - one of the best little spots I have found so far.“

“We were in the area for a 2 night concert at Bills Stadium. We had purchased the tickets last fall as a wedding gift to one another so we decided to book at a B&B vs a tradtional hotel as sort of a "half year" anniversary gift.We arrived and were greeted by the very pleasant Innkeeper who was also the chef. He showed us to our room which was beautiful and had a deck off the bedroom suite. My husband is a huge animal lover so seeing a red fox as soon in the distance as he opened the door was a bonus.The entire Inn is beautifully set up and decorated with a cozy atmosphere. The room was large with old world charm met with modern day amenities as well.The breakfast was served daily in their adorable dining room and each meal was very well prepared.The Inn was close enough to dining locally with easy access to Buffalo. We also enjoyed the large flea market just down the road. We will definitely be coming back to the area and will be booking here again.Nearby activities: there is a very large indoor/outdoor flea market nearby with LOTS of vendors.Food & drinks: The Inn is closely located near an Italian restaurant and a Mexican restaurant. We did notice many other small eateries nearby also“

“The gluten-free pizza was very good. The crust was the thinner type so I'm not sure they make it but it was actually very tasty. It wasn't a thick fluffy pan pizza Detroit style crust but it did taste very good. My partner got regular pizza and he loved it. I like their sauce it wasn't too sweet but it still had some sweetness. The wings or meaty. We got extra sauce and it definitely was very saucy what you really like. Definitely will be going back! The only sad thing I am one of those weirdos who likes ham pineapple and mild pepper rings on my pizza. They don't have pineapple and mild pepper rings.“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐The Lion and Eagle Pub is an absolute gem! From the moment you step inside, you're transported to a cozy, welcoming haven filled with character and charm. The ambiance is unbeatable, with warm lighting, comfortable seating, and an inviting atmosphere that's perfect for unwinding after a long day. The staff is incredibly friendly and attentive, always ready with a smile and a recommendation from their impressive selection of drinks and dishes. Speaking of which, the food is absolutely delicious – each dish is prepared with care and bursting with flavor. Whether you're craving classic pub fare or something more adventurous, The Lion and Eagle Pub has something to satisfy every palate. Add in live music nights and special events, and you've got the recipe for an unforgettable experience. I can't recommend this place highly enough – it's truly a five-star establishment in every sense of the word!“

“I have made it to order Cubans wherever I go, it's one of my favorite sandwiches. The Cuban Melt at Rookies today was among the best I've ever had. If not the best, a close 2nd. I wasn't even planning on stopping this afternoon for food, but as we were walking by decided to stop in. So glad we did. The server was great. I will definitely be back the next time I'm in the area!“